Takeaway
Yes
Comments (199)
Stopped here for late night snacks and beer around 10pm. The Mac and cheese was delicious and the service was great.
Place was pretty packed Thursday night around 7pm. Honestly, wings are greattttttttttttt! I like to ask for the sauce on the side so I can enjoy these wings with different dipping sauces. They have a great selection of beers on tap (founders all day ipa is my favorite) and staff is very friendly and fast. I will come back again with some friends.
Simply a Must to add to your pub crawl in New York city, Very friendly staff, and the best food bar none. We had the Steak sandwich, 3 layers of steak, cooked to your preference, melted cheese, and some sort of house sauce with a portion of Fries, Just Mouth watering and Full of taste, all washed down with an Ice Cold Miller Lite, Gorgeous. The pics you see were the next days lite bit sliders, a small snack not long after breakfast. So Treat yourself and visit PJCs for a great experience, Hey dont take my word for it, Go find out for yourself. Colin and Nicola, BELFAST.xx
Great food. We had the nachos.. burgers... shepherds pie..and the bomb.com wings.. out waitress was excellent
NYC take on a neighborhood Irish pub. Good menu of wings, burgers, apps, etc. I would drive across town for it, but great for midtown west.
Staff were friendly and food was good. Happy hour sangria was great.
I arrived here alittle after 11am. The bartender James was very helpful and eventhough I was too early for lunch the cosmopolitan was a good starter. I came back after my appointment and the wings, cheeseburger, and second cosmopolitan didnt disappoint
It was a great experience! 💓 It was nice and cozy, especially in the rain. I had a burger with fries, they tasted heavenly! It was loud, yet as much as I hate loud noise, I found that it brought character to the place. 5 🌟s
A nice mix of locals and tourists with amazing chicken wings. I like to get the plain because they give you bbq and buffalo dipping sauce.
Just stopped for a beer. Super friendly service. Typical Irish pub.
Hot day, cold beer. Pj Harney’s has a great vibe and the staff has great recommendations for NYC activities and dining! I will be back when I’m back in NYC.
Nice pub thats close to Central Park, Columbus Circle & NQRW subway lines. Meaning peeps from UWS & Queens can easily get to and from if looking for a meeting spot thats convenient. Staff was very friendly and hospitable.
Better than average food and in ample quantities. Lots of alcoholic drink choices.
Great place to drink with friends, bartenders are great guys and girls o enjoy it every time o go there
I found the food just ok. Shepherds pie missing veggies. Not browned enough. Waitress was too knotch. We had a big group and they did fit us in. Which was appreciated
There is not much to say about this place. Standard Irish pub in upper Midtown. Beers are a bit pricy. Standard bar fare. Sandwiches are better than expected. 2 beers, app and 2 meals will be around 60.
Service was good even though it was packed to the walls. We needed a quick late night bite after flying in and this really hit the spot.
Heres the deal with PJ Carney’s Pub - it is small and cozy and super friendly and it has nice pub food and good beer and drinks and tons of regulars. Id argue THE WINGS (shown in picture) with sauce on side are worth the visit alone. When you need a beer or just a place to space out or get a decent fish and chips PJs is the place. Also soccer on the TVs awwww yeah. Zero strikes against this place. Its not fine dining but its perfect at what it is.
This place overcharged my credit card, I have one amount on the bill but charge was little more. So, they charged other amount than it was on my bill.Be carefull with credit card.Avoid this place
Great pub food. Great service!
I and my wifw went there after walked through central park. The food is good and the have a lot of choice of beer. the guy at the bar was very friendly, he offered me a beer for a little delay with my orders. Recommended!!!
Your average bar and food great if you work or hangout the area. The staff is attentive.
Actually 4.5...Had the grilled vegetable chicken salad. Excellent. My lady had the Cali Turkey Club. Very good. Not bad for NYC prices. Great locale right across from Central Park. Staff could have been friendlier. Will be back.
Delicious Irish breakfast.So good. Fresh ingredients. Must visit for St. Patricks day and just any day really.
Their kitchen is surprisingly yummy. quesadilla, burgers, chichen nuggets are awesome. good service. call if you want to order takeout. not a typical tourist pub, local people are coming here. 5 starts
Cheap drinks and quick service, everything you want in an Irish pub!
Phenomenal hole in the wall pub, had the burger and fries with Irish bacon and mushrooms.
Great atmosphere (especially after the Marathon) and a good selection of offerings for some quick fare. I recommend the pitchers of beer! House special is pretty good
Always have a good time, excellent service, the cosmopolitan are very good and the best chicken wings, in town.
Good beer and food. Great late night spot
If you go to New York City go here. Burgers, fries, great cocktails and great service!
Food here was incredibly delicious and calling the prices reasonable might be an understatement. Considering the location and the quality of the food, this may be one of the best deals in NYC. Lots of similar Irish pubs will charge way more than this place.Will definitely go back.
What a sweet lady served us, very honest. Thank you so much.
The server was great, good was blah, was too crowded and table wasnt cleaned. That sums it up.
Cute little bar. Service was good. Bathroom was heated. Creepy customer guy staring though.
Friendly service. Kind of small inside, but theres also outside seating.
Excellent bar for a beer before touring Central Park.
Bartender was great. The burger was very juicey and my wife loved the BLT. It was a very unassuming place from the street and were both very glad we found it
Fabulous pub! Amazing bar tender shout out to John. Must go place, plus open late! Hospitality 10/10
Everything is great but we come here for the wings.
I cannot believe that a tequila shot is more expensive than a regular shot. Crazy! The service is not a good service according to the price sorry for the servers, but you can do it better.
Advertise brunch…cold coffee and no French toast. Sent coffee back and was served another cup of cold coffee. Ordered a $11.00 potatoewithcheeseand broccoli. Served a tiny ice cold potato with a small sprig of broccoli. Complained and meal was taken off my bill.
Unfortunately they dont have fried calamari any more....
My husband and I discovered this place by accident on our way to the train after dinner almost 6 years ago. Was our first date! 😁 Staff were friendly and attentive, fast service, and chicken wings were amazing!We still go here regularly once or twice a month for happy hour, and its our go to place to hang out with friends, like today. They have been consistent in terms of atmosphere and quality of service, and I believe the chicken wings even gotten better! Casual, fun and friendly neighborhood bar. Love this place!
I will come again when I am in the area. Very nice layout and great food. Service was great too considering the challenges
Taxi Burger excellent,pitchers of ale & a warm friendly welcome! 👍
Great place to have a drink, very friendly bartenders! You wanna have a Great time go to Pjs
Good beer selection, loads of TVs, good wait staff. Crowded, but still a great spot on 7th just south of C Park
Recommend the dark and stormy drink with classic fish and chips. Great pub in the middle of the city!
If in the midtown 57th street area, a good place to grab a cocktail, cold beer, or bar snacks. Established in 1927, a no frills, no nonsense, bar across from Carnegie Hall.
Had a very good burger. Chose to eat on the street. Not good idea. Subway is super noisy and the busses run by frequently so it was hard to hear.
Its your average bar. Nothing exceptional nor is it disappointing. Good spot for a quick drink or two but thats about it. Would I visit again? If Im in the area I would stop by. Although, I only had drinks and the patrons there seem to enjoy their food orders as well. Then again, its my opinion. I prefer cocktail bars were old fashions are done to the tee and delicious.
Love this place!! The shepherds pie is delicious, also the burger is a great choice. By night the place is happily crowded with great people and great ambience, an authentic Irish/American pub with great beer options. The staff is always friendly, fast and professional. One of my favorites in the area :)
Pretty classic New York crowd for a Friday afternoon. Waitress was super nice, specials were on point, and its a great location between Carnegie Hall and Central Park. You can sneak in as a tourist and immerse yourself in Daily Midtown life. Note - go easy on the happy hour beer specials as its a one-person bathroom right off of the bar. Enjoy!
Service was good and the menu was pretty decent for a late nite spot. Small venue but not crowded.
WHAT IS THE POINT OF GOOGLE MAPS IF IT ISNT ACCURATE?!!!!!! I am planning my travel around it and it’s so off that it’s completely worthless to use. Please edit and revise whatever system you’re using because all it causes is problems. I’d rather have you not mention a time if it’s not even close to being accurate. Would have ubered. I will jump over th w turn style at least 5 times to make up for this ridiculous experience of
Perfect pub for a drink with friends. The snacks are quite tasty as well, we tried the nachos. The wait staff was quick and courteous and never let our glasses go empty. One thing, it isnt a large space, so unless you get a table you may feel crowded.
Pretty good Irish pub right off of southern Central Park. Perfect location to grab some simple, tasty food after a day walking around midtown.The staff is nice, food is standard wings, nachos, Shepards Pie youll see around NYC but it was still done well.Only issue is the restaurant is a bit small and wraps around the bar. its very likely that tables are filled making it hard to fit a decently sized party but if you are looking for dinner for 1-4 its a great choice.
This site is my first choice place. Of all restaurants I know I prefere it most. I always suggests to my friends to go to visit this restaurant. when I I need a special dinner, this place comes first to my mind. fresh and food and a rich cuisine.helpful staff, and agreeable mood. In addition to that, the bill is reasonable. I tell about this spot with great pleasure.
Cozy place, little selection of beers.
Ive been here several times both for meals and drinks. Everyone on the staff had always been friendly and the service is great no matter how busy they are. All of the food had been good. They have your basic pub fair, so dont look for something healthy of fancy. The prices are also reasonable, which is hard to find in this part of the city.
Food and drinks aren’t great! Excellent happy hour as well
Simple but tasty bar food. Friendly staff and excellent service. Perfect small pub in midtown with TVs all around and several drink options. 😁 Highly recommend of you need to kill some time before a show.
Cozy Irish pub, good eats, good beer, good vibe
A friendly place and staff. Basic pub food, but excellent and plentiful. You likely will not be able to clean your plate. Lots of tv sports and vintage pop music. Fish & chips is superb. Lots of draught. I stuck with Coors Light, $5 for honest pint. You will love this place.
Not a big place, so get there before 6 PM or after 9 PM or you will standing up around the bar. Other than that, good place for a quick bite and a drink. Not a loud place, so you can actually have a conversation
This restaurant is my preferable site. Of all restaurants I know I prefere it most. I always suggests to my friends to go to visit this place. when I want to go to a good meal, this restaurant comes straight to my mind. superb and food and a rich menu.trained crew, and good atmosphere. Not less important, the bill is affordable. I sent my friends to this restaurant with great pleasure.
The last time I was here over 2 years ago I really enjoyed it bar my last night where I was charged double which left me bitter.This time around the staff where different and......lovely. I like the look and feel of this bar and I find the food to be very good.Rush hour and lunchtime the bar can be very busy but it is a most when in New York
I have been here several times over the years. The reason I like it is because its great place to drink and watch people watching one another. The whole place is seating around a bar which is in the middle of the square room. Sitting at the bar, youre across other people so looking at one another is inevitable.
Great loverly day. Chilling and people watching
Nice place with good price wings. Come during happy hour.
I sent my friends to this place with my warmest recommendations. I go their often. This recommendation is always successful. The the cooking is delicious and the stuff is very friendly and cooperative. Whenever we eat in this place we enjoy a delightful evening. I recommend this place with pleasure.
Its was very chill not but a few people there enjoying a cold beverage an other peoples company. Waitress was very nice an helpful with the questions we had about New York. Drink prices are crazy high but hey it is in New York times square.
Stopped in here for a drink before an event after work. Decent sized bar that wasnt too packed when we got there, but every seat at the bar was taken.They make their Moscow Mules with the Crabbies ginger beer! AKA.. the drink is all alcohol. Great prices and even better location right in Midtown. Will be back
I remember taking someone on a date there a few months ago. Although the place is a bit busy, man the food is amazing. I forgot the name of the sandwich but it had steak and some cheese but wow, it was so amazing. (Order it medium rare btw) Anyways, the flavor just came to me with the first bite.
Went for a quick lunch during work. Basic bar food choices, and I only eat turkey and fish for meat, so got the turkey sandwich. They forgot to take the bacon off, but didnt care, and gave to coworkers. It was ok. Not bad for lunch, but looks better for drinks.
The food and atmosphere was brilliant. We were never left waiting with an empty pint and the staff were really welcoming. One of my best experiences on our trip to NYC!
Found this great Irish pub on my recent visit to NYC. Just went in for a Guinness and quick bite. Pleasantly surprised by the excellent food. I recommend you treat yourself to this place when you are in Manhattan.
Today afternoon I went to PJ Carneys to have lunch and drinks. Its a great place with great food and drinks. It was not my first time there today. I have had only good experience until today. The waitress was very rude and grumpy. She was the younger one of the two working today. She ruined my lunch with her mood killing skills. It was this bad that made me leave a review here...
This was a totally happening Irish pub before a show at Carnegie. I think every table and chair was taken. The environment was nice and pleasant for the most part. It felt Irish-ey. It was service to the point. I think the food looked good by the looks of the menu and other peoples plates/desire to come to such a hustling place. It looked like authentic Irish fare along with authentic Irish service most likely. Wine was a little pricey too and limited. Probably a beer and burger type of place with some Irish spin.
Outdoor seating is right next to subway grating so is a bit loud. Solid beer selection and bar food.
I’ve been here during lunch, dinner, happy hours (There are two a day!), and late nights. I think the late nights have been the most packed, at least when I’ve been there. The menu is simple, basic bar fare and the food is pretty good. Food and drinks are average price for the area.
Waitress is useless. I was here with a party of 10. The waitress was waiting us with a couple of other tables. We wanted separate bills but she said it was too busy to take care of. She had a total of maybe 20 people to take care of. Bad customer service
Good food and drinks. Touchy with happy hour drinks 5 hours walking sightseeing etc. Asked for double round, really thirsty and tired .IT DOESENT WORK THAT WAY we were told, silly. Customer always right Got one drink ordered another immediately . Why all the sillyness.music too high. Would still recommend . Just stop the silly stuff. Ps. Dont serve drinks by handling the glasses by the top. Hygiene. It is the little things
The pub was small and quaint. The atmosphere was what you would expect from a pub, lively and loud. But,I cant say the service was the same. Waited a while for a drink and a refil and treated like a number and on to the next.
Very small space. Good service. Fish and chips is on point, but the shepherds pie taste like taco meat with mashed potatoes on it and very few peas and carrots inside.
Delightful Irish interlude in Manhattan. Fiona and Phil are so cordial and funny you dont want to leave. Thanks!
Great pub in Manhattan, but doesnt feel Manhattan (lacks the pretentiousness). Great pours, Smithwicks on tap, and a great Irish whiskey selection make this a great choice for someone wanting to catch a football match, or just unwind.
Fantastic little place. The waitresses were friendly, the food was excellent, and the music was great. Wonderful atmosphere in this bar. Highly recommend for a bite to eat and some drinks if you are in the area!
Its your standard Irish Pub, but made to NYCs tastes, which is mildly understaffed, and the service is pretty rushed. That being said, Id happily come back here. It filled my craving for chicken wings after walking around the Met for a few hours, and the prices they have are pretty reasonable for NYC.
First excursion to the city in a long time. Randomly popped in here for food and a drink. Great little place with warm atmosphere. Food was really good. Reasonable prices for the area. Would come back.
Really nice place for a beer on the go. Friendly staff.
A cute little pub, conveniently close to central park. Its a bit cramped inside, but thats part of the charm. Good selection of beers on tap, and the wings were good too.
Stoped in for wings and drinks during happy hour. Everything was delicious. Place is very tiny but thats what gives it that authentic pub feel.
Fine here several times.Too noisy to talk normal with friends, pricey drinks that keep going up & food is getting more expensive as well!Will have to find a better alternative, which is very likely to find in that area.
Amazing irish pub. We had dinner and drinks just like home. However we left our hoody there and flew back to ireland emailed them and within 24 hours they had it kept ina safe place for us. Still trying to figure out a good postal method.. all in all very kind caring and friendly pub. Have a pint for me in it. 😁
They thought that I could drink 15 drinks in 6 hours and still query the bill. Basically because I had 7 pints of Guinness, they took advantage and added an extra 3 pints to my bill. When I asked about the bill, instead of talking to me, I got a huge emotional reaction. Which is a pretty sure sign that something is wrong. In the end I paid with zero tip, never to return.
Awesome food and great service. Also didnt cost an arm and a leg
It has a classic old New York charm that just feels like home every time no matter who I am with. A place with no pretentious hype... where you can just have a few drinks and be yourself... as Anthony Bourdain would say.
Great old school nyc Irish pub. Cozy, great food, fantastic bartenders.
Great pub food and service, friendly crowd numerous televisions for sporting activities, juck box with fabulous songs. A fantastic neighborhood place to meet nice people, eat good food have great drinks and an all around fun time.
A nice place to take a break at a hot day in August. Airco works well. We went here 2 days in a row. First day it was quit in the pub and the staff was friendly. The 2nd day it was very crowded and noisy and the staff was a little grumpy.
Small pub atmosphere. Great service! Delicious monsterous burger! All the food was 100%. And a decent beer menu
Best Fish n chips Ive found in NYC. The batter is thick, and the oil permeates gloriously through it, so it has a crispy, fried, layered texture on the outer part- reminiscent of of the crystallization in the caramel of creme brûlée. Delicious tartar sauce. The fish breeding reminds me of the tastes in a Krispy creme doughnut, without the sweetness. Good pub environment.
Same as the Diner great place
A straightforward, laidback spot that’s a good choice for drinking a beer and small appetizers.
I used to go there in the late 80s, all through the 90s and up until 2004 until I came home to Ireland, I worked in Desmonds/Kennedys up on 57st, PJs is possibly the best bar in the neighborhood, friendly staff, good food served quite fast on even a busy day, one of the few bars I miss in New York.
Great food, service and facility. Across from Carnegie Hall. Lots of variety on the menu, all four of us were quite impressed with quality and quantity of food. An excellent lunch choice
Great fish and chips, the homemade tartar sauce is phenomenal, I couldn’t get enough of it! The service here is also pretty attentive and quick.
A cut above the typical NYC Irish pub. Good selection of beers and quality of bar food better than expected. The place always feels lively.
A really friendly stop to get out of the rain.
Food and drinks are good and reasonably priced
A great pint of G. Great staff. A home from home.
Good food great drinks and wonderful staff who left two friends alone to catch up. Very friendly atmosphere
Service is attentive but not intrusive.There is a wide variety of beers on tap and best of all TWO happy hours per day
I certainly loved the food and customer service, excellent location close to my house. The workers are always very nice. Will come back again.
Gggggrrrrreeeeaaaattttt!! Good service, amazing (strong) drinks, fun time. If you need to get blitzed before ice skating in the cold i highly recommned.
Great food. Only one waitress so service was a little slow. But she was great and did a great job
Stopped in for a pint or two before, last night had dinner and drinks. Excellent, friendly service and the food was very good. Will definitely be back.
The sever was awesome but when I ask the bartender to plug in my phone so it can charge so that I can stay and keep drinking she just put it behind the bar and did not plug it in and when I ask why she gave me an attitude and said that she was busy but the customers where still out side and she was just standing around so I asked for my phone back and when back to my hotel while I was still able to get a uber before my phone was to die
This place is historic and wonderful. The staff members are actually Irish, and the beer selection is amazing. Try the Mac n cheese with Irish bacon.
Service - Very Good to excellentFood - Very Good (Shepards Pie was excellent)Excellent choice of beverages :)Small but a very good atmosphereClose to Central Park and handy for resting your tired feet!I would go back
A very cool bar with reasonable prices, and decent food. Wasnt too crowded when I went so the atmosphere was pleasant and its a nice looking pub.
Good food, good beers. I went in for dinner by myself and stayed for a couple extra drinks because the bartenders and patrons were so fun to be around.
Just had a few beverages while waiting for a friend to get out of work. Staff was super friendly and efficient. Will imbibe again when in the neighborhood.
Probably the best Guiness in town, thats from local people and it is very good. Very popular and nice atmosphere, staff are very friendly. Dont have crisps tho..... but nice bar.
Good food, bartenders can make a nice drink and on a cold night, when the wind is howling down 57th, this is a great little place to settle into a booth, order something hot and good and enjoy the warmth. :)
Good for pumpkin beer after walk through CP.
Been going here for last 5 years before concerts at Carnegie Hall. Nice cozy space, good happy hour.
Great drinks, food and meeting place to enjoy time with your company. Overall, its a lovely experience.
Great location, very good food & beer!
Great for a quick drink before going to Carnegie Hall. Very expensive, however. They do have a great beer list, and the service was quick.
Nice place. Good food. Wings was delicious. Cold beer. Ill come back soon.
I went to PJ Carneys before a show at Carnegie Hall. It was kind of dive bar with typical expensively priced drinks. I had a margarita and it was decent.
Get the burger. Tends to be pretty crowded here but the bar seats are a good option. Right across from Carnegie hall so expected it to be especially crowded before and after shows.
Nice cozy place to grab a mid day drink and snack.
One of a kind place. Not necessarily you will like it but I love it. I like to stop by for one or two super cold beers.
We absolutely LOVED this place and frequently went while we were in New York. Such A Fun Place with outstanding Bar Service
Great food amazing service
Its calm and chilled
Went there twice in one day because it was so great! Service is awesome, beer and food was great too!
I was there on St. Patrick’s Day and had Fish and Chips. OMG, it did taste amazing, I ate my whole dish and even ate some of my boyfriends fish. 😂
Nice chill bar tucked away in the corner. Very nice and competent staff, expertly crafted drinks, and the fries are pretty good too.
An after-softball game bar for us, I havent been impressed with PJ Carneys. Their food is bar food, the bathroom is always filthy and the beer is just OK - not frosty.
Had a few drinks there last Wednesday evening staff were excellent would definitely return next time I’m in New York.
Nastiest shepherds pie ive ever had, which i was later accompanied with projectile vomit. Never again, i cant say much about the rest of the menu but dont eat the shepherds pie.
Good, small pub. Decent prices for the area.
Great service and tasty food, what more could you want? Happy hour specials are great, amazing Pastrami!
Solid classic pub. Food is alright, and the beers are plentiful. Service is quick and nice.
Love the bar food here. Delicious!
Great place, local atmosphere
Good little pub in a great location near Central Park. Beer selection is great, food is good, and our waitress was ok.
The aesthetic and vibe of this place is fantastic. Best experience Ive ever had in a NYC bar
Beautiful Pub. My first time when I drank American beer in USA. Beer was delicates.Nice staff.
Fried Brussel sprouts were an interesting idea but mushy inside... Not good execution. Otherwise, a pretty standard Irish pub.
Love getting a beer after hiking the park. Cozy, sports on, bartenders are great. Reliable fun place.
Good collections of beers and quality of food is awesome
Best fish and chips in town. The real deal and a generous helping! Great staff!! Buzzy bar.
Great staff. Small pub, louder like a college place. Limited beer selection.
Great bar, great food and service. One of my faves on the Upper West Side!
Great service, well located and good beer.
Fun, friendly relaxing atmosphere. Good food, had a burger and beer and they were good
I went there after work with two friends. Drinks were good and the service was excellent.
Good food + good service + good prices = great find in NYC !Kudos to the waitress for running out on the street to return wifes phone !
Great location right by the N R trains. Nice decor with a city pub vibe. But kinda pricey even for that area.
Excellent place. Bartender is awesome. Very friendly environment standard Irish bar
Best pub food I have ever eaten. Fish and Chips or the Shepherds Pie, you cant go wrong.
It was an outstanding find as we walked up from Battery Park to the Financial District. Huge portions great atmosphere!
Long day of walking the city and needed something to wet our whistle. Miller High Life on draft. Hit the spot. Nice staff.
Great beers and a wonderfully Long Island Ice Tea. Food was fabulous and staff very nice.
Great chicken wings. Fiona was wonderful as our server. Would definitely go again.
Great service! Small place with Excellent service, good food, nice atmosphere and great drinks!
I love the chicken wings, and the burgers are juicy and delicious 😋😋
Great drinks. Good vibes. Close to my job for a quick after work drink.
Its not bad here, the chicken wings were good but on the salty side. Otherwise, no other complaints.
A nice pub with delicious food. Serving staff are amazing and seem happy to help.
Good stop. This feels like a locals place... classic rock, kinda loud, not too pricey. Definitely a good stop after a day at MoMA.
Good selection of beer. Music was very loud. Great staff.
Great happy hour deals on drink and food. Nice bar atmosphere
Great food for a bar, nice service. Good beer selection.
Decent pub food in a small pub at a great location. The Irish staff was great!
So fun and great people! Your ny nostalgia!
Good food, good prices. VERY friendly and nice staff. 2 minutes from Carnegie.
Happy hour is a great deal and our waitress, Fiona, was sweet as can be.
Good food good service. Have pumpkin bear with cinnamon sugar around cup top!
Great food, good service, reasonable prices. Just a tad drafty.
Cool place really close to the Central Park
Really great Irish pub. Fantastic service, fantastic food, fantastic drinks!
Delicious fish and chips, fantastic service, cider on tap - everything you could ask for.
Total reviews rating 4.4
199 Reviews for P.J. Carneys Pub 2023:
Review №1
2022-06-10What a great place & what a great bartender. John is a wonderful & attentive host behind this legendary establishments bar. Fantastic food, service & crazy awesome libations. We had so much fun we’re already planning our next visit ! Highly Recommend !
Review №2
2021-08-29My wife and one year old son went here the other day. I got the french onion soup which tasted different than normal but was still amazing. I also got the Taxi burger. It was cooked exellently but there was 2 eggs on it which was a little too much. My wife got the avacado and BLT which had plenty of bacon and avacado. The service was amazing and we loved tge experience.
Review №3
2022-04-18The weather was hot, the streets were crowded and we just wanted to get out of both. We dropped into PJ Carneys pub and received a warm welcome. The friendly staff brought over a jug of water and we ordered some food. I can highly recommend the Gaelic burger, it was cooked perfectly and tasted delicious.
Review №4
2022-07-16Really cool Irish pub in the centr of NY.Good beer, ale, food.
Review №5
2022-07-01Cool par in midtown, totally unexpected but pleasant find on a hot summer night in New York
Review №6
2020-02-03Fantastic bar with cozy vibes & friendly bartenders. Drinks are reasonable prices for Midtown and they they have an awesome bar menu. Highly suggest getting the Buffalo Wings! Grab a seat at the bar & youll find it hard to leave this Midtown gem. 👏
Review №7
2019-01-10We have been fortunate to make it to NYC a few times. The first time there we happened upon this place by accident. We have made sure that we return each time. It is crowded but that is the beauty of it. It is definitely up beat and there food is great. The prices are reasonable and it is so close to Central Park.
Review №8
2022-03-165 star service, 3 star food. Go if you want simple pub food, but this is not a dining destination by any means. Cozy and good music and the proximity to Central Park is quite convenient. I recommend the BLT.
Review №9
2021-11-15Best wings in the city. I have been coming here for 8 years and it’s never disappointed. Food is always top notch and service is always friendly.
Review №10
2022-03-19I paid 30 bucks for 2 Jameson and cokes. I live in Hells Kitchen and find much cheaper options in the area. Felt completely ripped off. Other Irish bars offer cheaper prices so try avoid.