In-store pick-up
Yes
Poppys Bagel in Amityville
Categories
Location on the map
Amityville, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
In-store shopping
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Delivery
No
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Dining options
Breakfast
Yes
Planning
Quick visit
Yes
Phone: +1 631-532-6529
Opening hours
- Monday:6AM–3PM
- Tuesday:6AM–3PM
- Wednesday:6AM–3PM
- Thursday:6AM–3PM
- Friday:6AM–3PM
- Saturday:6AM–2PM
- Sunday:7AM–1PM
Poppys Bagel in other cities:
Comments (94)
Great bagels...amazing breakfast sandwiches. The staff is very professional & good.
Honestly can’t go anywhere else for a bagel, so good!
Bagel shop and deli. Good lunches but breakfast is their true strength. All the standards are there, bagels and egg sandwiches. Staff is super friendly and nice, the wait is never very long, and the prices are very fair.
Without question the best egg sandwiches in the area. Truly a hidden gem. The staff is super friendly. If you want a tasty sandwich, give the Big Bird a try. You wont be disappointed!
It was my first time here and I loved it! The food order was correct and the wait wasnt long. Cute place and I will definitely be back.
Tried to give his place the benefit of the doubt but was disappointed each time. Was served old deli meat and expired rice pudding and bad cream cheese with what tasted like sugar in it to mask the expired taste ! This was all on separate occasions by the way always very kind service tho
This is my go to place every morning, they always have fresh and hot bagels ready to go and although any popular place will have lines they get customers out quickly and make my morning that much better, if you want a nice bagel shop that won’t delay you an hour in the morning rush I suggest you go here
Placed a detailed order on the phone, which they repeated back to me to confirm. Upon arrival they needed me to repeat my entire order. Once I got home I realized the order was completely wrong. Returned for my money back. They didnt even offer it on the house or any type of compensation. Others were having similar issues. Dont know if it was a bad day but wouldnt return to find out
Super friendly crowd. Their multigrain bagels have raisins in them and it didnt go well with an egg and cheese, so they made us a new one.
Great place for early breakfast, fresh bagels, and coffee. Very friendly staff.
They make me like Im family when I come in the door.. I eat breakfast there every morning... best bagel shop in amityville
The place is very very very clean and neat inside. Extremely nice and fast. The bagels are very fresh and hot all the time. Gotta try the mini bagels
Best bagel store around, i travel from 3 towns over just to get the best egg sandwiches in suffolk county. Worth every penny
Is it that hard to post intelligible prices or have decent coffee
When I come to visit this is the first place I come!
Awesome service and great food.
Very friendly place with good food! One suggestion: Add flavors to WHOLE bagel, not just on the top!
The food and service is great at Poppys, I was very happy they delivered. This place is the jewel in the village. Highly Recommended .
Very nice, employees good coffee fast and easy in and out.
Decent prices. No one was at the counter when we walked in... Slow service. But nice place. Good selection!
Good bagels and service
They have the BEST bagels in Amityville!!! The service is excellent!! And the prices are reasonable!!
A really good bagel store with great friendly service good prices and good food. A must in Amityville
Very good Bagels excellent service
Clean, variety of bagels & toppings, friendly staff and very affordable
Best bagels & cream cheese varieties I have ever had!
Great bagels, always fast. Cashier is super nice.
Very good food. SO FRESH AND CLEAN. FOOD IS REALLY GOOD.
Great service, good bagels.
Allways good! (Except when its near to closing and they use that smelly ol mop-lol)
Great egg sandwich made to order!! Fast service.
Very clean, very good begels and great service!
OK not to thrilled with the bagel I chose which is a locks scallion cream cheese toasted bagel it wasnt the best like bagel boss which gives you salad for free with it of your choice.
Friendly environment and good breakfast and really good coffee
Great Bagel store. Family owned and run. Great service!
I love poppys. Please get uber eats or doordash!!!
Really good Toasted Egg Everything Bagel breakfast sandwiches .
Very nice people work here. Definitely will be coming back.
Hands down best quality you can get from anywhere in Amityville, Copiague, or Lindenhurst.
Excellent
Good food. Good selection. Very good service.
Good, fresh bagels with great service.
The bagels are fresh and the egg sandwiches are delicious.
The food is excellent and staff is so professional!!!
Best bagels and one of my favs
Family owned amazing service great food
Good bagles n Good coffee
Friendly staff and good bagels
Love the bagels and the people who work there
Clean, good service, good food.
The people were nice and the Bagel were fresh.
Bagels are good and staff is great
Service is slow, very limited selection and too pricey
Good bagel. Service was fast .
Excellent food and service
Love this place,very nice people
Makes nice breakfast sandwiches
Great food and service.
Love it always a great experience
Good service , Good food
Nice food
The homefries here are superb.
Favorite place to eat breakfast
Excellent every time!
Decent service
The best place ever
Love it
Good bagel shop.
Excellent 100/100 thanks
Great sandwiches!
Food is great!
Staff is very friendly
Good buttered bagel
Good local spot
The best coffee!!!
Great Service
Good breakfast.
Good place for Amityville
Yummy
Best bagels
Rude staff
Great place
Most delicious Bagels 🥰🥰🥰 The people who work here are super friendly ☺️☺️ So that the best bagel spot in Nassau for me !!!
Good place
Total reviews rating 4.4
94 Reviews for Poppys Bagel 2023:
Review №1
2022-05-09Service is fantastic. The bagels are good. The sandwiches are great! They use Boars Head cold cuts too. A+ establishment.
Review №2
2022-05-14Depends on what you are looking for. Just an average bagel place nothing to extra or special about this one. Its not my first place to go if I want a great bagel.
Review №3
2021-12-25Santa Claus sent me here to get breakfast Christmas morning. Hard to find good food when so far from the North Pole. Poppys Bagel is the place to go on Christmas Day. Truly recommended by all the Elves in Santas Workshop. Merry Christmas!
Review №4
2022-02-12Always come here to get my breakfast! Great way to start the morning with great food
Review №5
2021-07-09I ordered a sausage egg and cheese on a toasted egg bagel. The sausage was under cooked the egg was thin like they only put 1 egg. That’s not the issue , the issue is the sand which was 6 dollars. I recommend taking the extra 6 mins drive to stuff a bagel in massapequa. Don’t eat here over priced and under cooked trust me . Imma get another sandwich just to add photos so yah can see and imma get the receipt
Review №6
2019-05-22Love this place I have breakfast here all the time. I always get a bacon egg and cheese toasted with coleslaw. Theyre chicken sandwiches are also great fresh cold cuts and sides. Bagels here are also really good and fresh. Definitely would recommend this place to someone looking for a new favorite place to have breakfast. I promise you wont be disappointed.
Review №7
2021-05-18Always s good food and friendly people, i Have heen going for breakfast there since they opened years ago. Fresh food, awesome egg sandwiches and the owner is a sweatheart.
Review №8
2020-10-26Eat Breakfast Special, Price was Good. Ingredients Fresh, tasty. Yum ! I would return in a Heartbeat, they were extra friendly and very nice to me super early in the morning. Must try once. I eat breakfast. Yum !
Review №9
2019-08-11Great bagels and sandwiches and warm friendly staff. Service is quick and the quality is exactly what you need from a New York bagel joint. My personal suggestion, salt bagel with scallion cream cheese. You wont be disappointed.
Review №10
2021-07-19Very clean and friendly place to grab a cup of coffee and a fresh bagel. Best cup of coffee Ive had in awhile.