Delivery
Yes
Premier Diner Commack in Commack
Categories
Location on the map
Commack, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Great coffee
Yes
Great dessert
Yes
Great tea selection
Yes
Popular for
Breakfast
Yes
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Healthy options
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Dining options
Breakfast
Yes
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Phone: +1 631-462-1432
Site: http://www.premier-diner.com/
Site: http://www.premier-diner.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:7AM–11PM
- Tuesday:7AM–11PM
- Wednesday:7AM–11PM
- Thursday:7AM–11PM
- Friday:7AM–11PM
- Saturday:7AM–11PM
- Sunday:7AM–11PM
Comments (199)
In my opinion, Premier diner embodies the phrase “You get what you pay for”. Great quality food but definitely on the pricier side. Service is good and owners are always around to assist. Always a great experience enjoying a meal at Premier.
The BEST diner you ever ate in. We had the most delicious breakfast that day, but all the food on the menu and the large list of daily specials have been worth a special trip. Go enjoy 😊
Ok, so the 3 stars are solely based on pricing... Since COVID pricing everywhere has gone through the roof.The service was good, the burger was excellent but no coleslaw or pickles with it. This is a big mistake, in NY we have to have some slaw and pick with our burgers.Other than that, I highly recommend stopping in if your in the neighborhood.
I forgot to take pictures of our food!! 😬 But, OMG!!!...EVERYTHING WAS SOOOOOOOO GOOD!! 😋 The food was served in a timely manner. It was hot and cooked to perfection! The entire dine in experience, was lovely! We ABSOLUTELY LOVE our waiter, Orlando! He was so courteous and attentive to our wants and needs. We will definitely be coming back. I believe this will be our new date night spot!! Thanks, Premier Diner for your excellent service!!! See you soon!!
We always liked this diner! Food is always good and they have remodeled. Added an entire section open doors and fireplace. The atmosphere is so modern and relaxing . Give it a try.
This place has always been close to my house, but it took a while for me to go. Went for the first time today and I have mixed feelings. The tuna melt and egg and cheese on a roll were perfect. Good portion and delicious. The omlettes were also good with good portion sizes. The home fries... Were def not good. A weird combo of mashed/smashed potatoes. Maybe its their style, but I def did not like them. The chocolate pancakes were also really good. They did forget my hot chocolate in my to go order, even after they told me its in the bag. So its not bad, but not amazing either.
I used to like this place a lot more Im not sure what it was the atmosphere the food was good but it wasnt great I remember being very good at one point it was still good I would still go again but it wasnt as good. They remodeled and the atmosphere and the food much better this time. Our waitress was also very nice and took very good care of us
I couldnt believe the wait staff. Our waiter took out drink order and then went sat at the bar and played on his phone until someone else told him to finish waiting on us. The prices are way over kill. $20+ for a sandwich? There better be gold in it because damn my sandwich was soggy and not appealing at all. And the toilet seat in the ladies room was broken I almost fell off. And instead of checking the bathrooms they hung toilet paper on the coat hanger because they were obviously to last to do their job. I wont be returning.
50 dollars for 2 frozen burgers they should be ashamed of them selves i dont know how they have great ratings maybe their breakfast is great we orderd to burgers medium and they came out like hockey pucks with heavy char fully cooked the meat was tough not tender at all... tell-tale signs of ripping off customers with frozen food
Great food and friendly staff. Wish they stayed open later. Easy to see right off of Commack Road close to the Long Island Expressway. Plenty of parking and a wheel chair accessible entrance. Clean facilities. Public Restrooms. Daily food and drink specials. Not open 24 hours. Credit cards accepted. We will definitely be going back..
Excellent! Large variety like a NY diner should. Generous portions and real good service.
Nice diner, friendly staff. Good and large portion food.
Great Food Great Service! Definitely recommend checking this place out. Located right off the highway too. One of my go to spots when I’m in the area!
Great omelettes,breakfast,good burgers good dinners. Salads are good service is good too! If Im in Commack thats where we go!!Update! Went for breakfast! As good as ever! Dividers between the booths...
Came on a Saturday at 10am and had a short wait as we had a large party. We got had two servers who were both great. The food was fair priced and large portions.
Free Chickpea salad as a starter! Both the cream of turkey soup and manhatten clam chowder were winners. Great food, great value and service is fast and professional.
Fast & friendly service & delicious food! If I have to critique, its a little pricey for a diner, but its in Commack, so cant blame them either. Lol. Will definitely come back.
Food here is ridiculously expensive. $25 for a Cobb salad?? I got the french dip. It was bland and boring. Even the dip had very little flavor. The dessert was pretty good.
My wife, daughters and myself were in Commack for my father in law’s funeral. We had just gotten to the hotel from the airport and decided to get dinner at the Premier. The food as many others have said is excellent but this really a major call out for our server, Stephanie (hope I spelled it right 😊). She was flat out amazing. A sweet and caring person. I doubt we will ever be back but I had to let Stephanie know how much we appreciated her. Thank you, Thank you, Thank you.
Good food, great service. Though a bit expensive for 2 sandwich platters, 2 coffees and 1 cup of soup. With tip $80.
Beautiful Art Deco styled diner. They even had a fireplace inside. The French toast was delicious and expertly prepared.
Excellent food, huge portions, and very friendly service. My wife says that their beef sandwich haunts her dreams, while Im partial to their breakfast fare.
Ordered a late night pastrami platter...ate everything...fries were crispy good...tasty pickles.... pastrami was on point...would Def order this again when the craving calls! 😋
This is still our go to. Nice and friendly. Clean and good hot food. They are expensive tho. When we first started to come here it was about $20 for breakfast for the 2 of us. We went this weekend and it was up to $32! Very expensive considering I ordered just scrabbled eggs and my husband corned beef hash. I had a tea and he had an orange juice. That was it. Not including the tip we left! Sweet Mamas down the road is good and half the price. Currently if you get here after 8am you will be waiting for a seat. I have seen this all to much with businesses. They get popular, raise prices, people go someplace else, they keep prices high but then lower quality to make up. It happens like a cycle. I hope they fix the prices to get continued business. I would wait for a table knowing the food was good.My basic scrabled eggs were good but can get anywhere. 2 eggs scrambled with some homefries and white toast. Definately not worth the price they charge. The corned beef hash was good. Not out of the can. But it never was from here. You used to get large chunks of corned beef but now it is little shredded pieces that look like it was placed in a food processor. Almost like a ham salad size. It came with two eggs, home fries, and toast. Our visit definately warranted concern over price and quality. It was ordinary. Nothing special like it used to be.
French dip meat was well done, not even close to rare, lemon meringue whipped cream was disgusting and just tasted like congealed charcoal, they managed to run out of apple pie, the pizza burger was okay.
Ive never had a bad meal here. Great service, a variety of food on the menu. Plenty of parking, handicapped spots in the front, close to the front door. Clean bathrooms. But, does get very busy.
Fantastic, great food And the service is even better. My coffee cup never got empty
First time at the dinner for lunch. I had a cheeseburger deluxe. The burger was ok and fries also. Nothing out of this world and especially not for over $20.00. I guess it is what it is.
Best burger Ive had in a long time! Really enjoy their breakfasts too.
Another delicious luncheon and a great return after this Covid blah blah. My wife head the spinach greek salad, I ordered the gyro deluxe....so excited, I didnt take pics, sorry.Carla our waitress was excited to have customers and showed great appreciation. Her service was excellent!
Must always get to this place when I come into town. As a transplanted NYer, I grew up on diners and this is simply one of the best!!
I only had the pleasure of having their French toast and some tea. But the staff was friendly and kind, quick to serve and the food came reasonably fast and was very good.I came on a relatively slow day it seemed but from what I saw, they were good. I hope they do the same on busier nights.
Working in the area and decided to try this diner. First impression was not cheap. Ordered the Brooklyn Burger comes with beef, pastrami and Swiss on a large, non seeded bun. Second impression...Best burger ever! You can taste the quality of the beef and the pastrami is not fatty but not dry. Definitely will be going back!
First time here and this place is great! Our waitress was very attentive and the food was great
The best diner I have been to on Long Island..Portions are always more than you can think of eating, everything always nis.cooked to perfection!!Forget the rest this is my one and only go to..Should be yours too..
Excellent food and excellent service. The portions are very big for the price. Excellent id eat here again.
Food was great. I had breakfast there. Their sausage and bacon were very delicious.
Food quality was excellent. Taste was lacking. Hollandaise sauce tasted like it was from a store bought packet. Disappointed in the Benedict. Prices are on the higher end from what I expect from diners. Recently my wife and I decided to try every diner on the island again. I cannot even put this in the top 10. Service is top notch from every employee. Will return to try a different dish one day.
Very large portions. One meal is good for 2 people! Occasionally the french fries are too greasy (they need to change the oil)..
Classic Diner with classic food. I ordered a breakfast and it was great! For those curious about normal dining standards it was a clean nostalgic atmosphere. It seemed like a good spot for families. The dishes were surprisingly large and I stuffed in about 2500 calories worth of omelet before I left.
Great food. Big portions. A classic Diner
Pete the owner and his family are always friendly and accommodating to all their guests. The servers and other employees always have a pleasant disposition. They always work to ensure your visit is a memorable one. There is a large variety of selections on the menu, and their Greek specialties on the dinner menu are some of the best we have ever tasted. Their stuffed French toast on the breakfast menu is so delicious and filling we dont consider having breakfast anywhere else. The facility is always kept clean and we always feel safe eating at Premier.
Asked for gravy fries with baconFries were half rawGot lumpy nasty TURKEY gravy with a red oily ring on sidebacon was on sideAsked for grilled cheese on rye with baconno bacon and had one slice of cheeseDISGRACEFUL
Our waitress was attentive and kind and the food was delicious! Portion sizes are no joke but quality is not sacrificed! The corned beef hash was fantastic and my daughters loved the silver dollar pancakes and chicken fingers.
Great food..Came late and excellent service
The food was good BUT it cost 60$ for a salad and a buger..
Was just my daughter and I this year for thanksgiving and we didn’t feel like cooking so we picked up thanksgiving dinner the night before at the last minute before closing. This was the most delicious t giving dinner we both ever had ! Thank you soo much for being part of our community! This is my kiddos fav place to eat since we moved to Dix hills in 2003! You guys are soo sweet and accommodating and just keep getting better over the decades ! Thank you soo much for making our thanksgiving day meal soo special delish and carefree. Was the best ever! We vote you for the bestest diner on Long Island ever! Bravo !! Apple pie for dessert was divine. 100 stars for you guys. Love Marge and Lara ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ see u real soon. Bravo !!!!!!!
Food was excellent, service was great. If you are complaining the prices are too high eat at home. The cost of everything is up which is passed on to the diner then passed on too you. I didn’t think it was too expensive at all.
Outstanding food. Quality is a top priority in this establishment.
Portions are generous and service is really fast. Burgers and fries are good, so it the dessert. Wide variety of food.
Was my first time here, chosen by a band mate. Place is clean, nice decor wonderful staff. Kept my coffee mug full...my omelet wasnt the best, but the home fries made up for it
Stopped here for to go orders after the outlets. This place is super clean and the food was amazing. The waitress we had was super accommodating and really friendly! Will come back here again!
Best diner ever!! The food is warm and great. It is a very clean diner with wonderful servers. I already know what I want to order on my next visit!
This review is not reflected of the food but rather the managers poor customer service. My husband is blind we usually share a dinner which is easy for him. I was surprised there was a $7 share charge. I have never experienced this at other diners. The manager didn’t acknowledge my feelings and was short, curt, and without empathy. He needs Customer service 101!
They are rude! Food..fair at best. Not top quality! Grizzle in meat & cheap low end bread. The waitress the long time one..RUDE! They raised their prices twice this year 2021. Their Jewish clientele pay any price..thats why they can afford their new addition to bldg. They INSULT me & wont give this. USAF VETERAN a discount? What...a S1 off my order? Audacity! Yet you have an Icon of the Blessed Mother on your shelf & deny me a good Catholic & veteran? I boycott you & so do my friends! Youre welcome I served my country for your freedom! Not that you care! 🇺🇸I RECOMMEND THE OLYMPIC DINER. DEER PARK, ON DEER PARK AVE! 10 STARS FOR THEM!
Food was great, staff was very nice and right on. See you again.
The food was delicious
Prices went up a lot since the addition. The food was good but expensive.
I cant say enough about this diner...(my first time going)... The food was absolutely amazing! Even my toast was delish! The service was great and super quick!! Cant wait to go back when Im in the area again.
A little on the pricey side but the food and service was excellent.
Premier is my goto diner never disappointed. Great place for a buisness lunch meeting.
Good food and service just a little pricey.
Very good diner with very good food enjoy
Food was decent, but VERY expensive for Diner quality food.
This diner is by far the best I’ve been to! The food is so good that we came two days in a row. The French toast is thick and fluffy, the home fries are actual potatoes and not the frozen premade potatoes and the breakfast sandwich on a Kaiser roll are one of a kind. Such good food. Can’t wait to come back.
My wife picked me up a plate. I ordered the cheeseburger with bacon, mushrooms and sweet potato fries on the side . Love the presentation of the food all very delicious , cant wait to try breakfast.
Went on today - 11/07/20 and they have open space area with a canopy and tables spaced out - Big Plus.Athena our server is friendly and top service with coffee and getting our order correctly and in prompt fashion.Coffee was very good and the food - various omelettes and an order of waffles were tasty & delicious.A very good place for a return visit
Very beautiful and the staff was very helpful 👌 and keep up the great work 👍
Not what it used to be. Old salad, cheap ingredients, but expensive bill. One star is too many. Never again.
Our first post-COVID indoor meal and Premier Diner delivered as it always does. Fast, friendly and professional service, extensive menu, excellent food, ridiculously large portions, clean environment, fantastic martini! I was afraid that with the problems one hears about hiring I’d see a strain in their ability to deliver, but no. No wonder this place is always full.
Not sure if we will be back to eat on Sundays, wait to busy, service was really bad, our waitress never brought our drinks, on top of that she added to our bill, of course I complain about. I was not happy !!!!
The first second I walked in it was great! A lovely waitress held the door open and greeted us and a man was waiting with menus and immediately sat us. But that was it for the good experience. We saw our waiter a total of 3 times in the hour we were there. I took maybe 6 bites of my food and didnt like it, our waiter came back 20 minutes later and at that point I didnt want to wait for anymore food so we just asked for the check to leave and I still had to pay $18 for something I didnt even eat. I saw the nice waitress pass my booth more times than I saw our waiter. Mozzarella sticks were amazing though. Just wish the service was better and that I couldve gotten something to actually eat, rather than throw away $18 on a wrap I didnt eat.
Met friends from out of state . Server was wonderful to work with ... she remembered who had each meal at our table of 5+ ... Gracious staff all around during our visit there ... Easy to find off the 495 in Commack .
Charged you a fee for using a credit card, food was good and big portions but the fee for the credit card usage is a no go for me.
The premier diner is an excellent establishment. The staff there is incredibly kind and considerate towards their customers. Everyone provides a warm welcome and feeling on inclusion. On top of that the food is amazing. From their well known pancakes to their gyro wraps you will leave full and pleased with lots of leftovers. On your way out don’t forget to check their desserts the layered cakes are to die for.
Good food but terrible service. They never see you when u walk in. You wait long and then start looking for them to sit you. Then you wait long for waiter to serve you. Waiters never offer you neither appetizers nor bread basket. On top of it they take away your plate without asking if you are still working on it. They never smile and talk to you like police which makes you feel extremely uncomfortable. Food was great first day I went there. Next time I brought my friends and recommended to order same food. What a shame same food didnt have half of same things I had on my plate last time. The plate was half empty for the same price. My friends didnt understand what I was crazy about. Food can be God at times but sevice is stably terrible. They get annoyed when u ask for desert thay comes with your order which they never mention. I always feel like they are doing me a favor. Hate the attitude!
The food is ok, however the prices are now extraordinarily expensive. It is definitely cost prohibitive to go here.....a recent lunch for 2 people cost 50 dollars. Will not be returning at all.
Went for breakfast with wife and friends . Food nicely presented , hot , all very fresh . Portions much larger than we expected . Server was very attentive w/out being overbearing . Easily gotten to just off the Long Island Expressway in Commack .
Portions were huge. Waitress was clueless! Overall experience was good. Best pies ever!!!
Very big portions and good service. Food was ok, not great.
Perfect place for a hearty breakfast!
Great food! Large varied menu. Wait staff are the best! Very comfortable seating.. Well be back soon.
Classic diner, fast and friendly service, big portions, able to accommodate substitutions, quick to refill coffee and water. Place was packed on a sunday early afternoon.
Great place. Great food for great prices. My only problem is their hours say they close at 12 I call the restaurant to place a pickup order and they say they can’t take my order because they are closed at 11. Please fix your hours or don’t answer the phone when you’re closed lol
Avocado toast not the best Ive ever had. Omelette was a little too oily for my taste not the best breakfast Ive ever had. Service was good though.
This is one of if not the best Diner in the area, I have come here multiple times and the food is always great and the service is too. They are also open later on Sundays which is very convenient.
$24 for 2 eggs, corned beef hash, a cup of coffee and side of bacon?? This isnt Montauk! Guess Ill be going back to Candelight since thats just ridiculous. Food was just okay as well... nothing special.
Absolutely delicious 😋 breakfast was spot on
Good food...!!! Attentive owner, manager and/or staff as one enters. The person assigned to our table of 8 was a bit slow or distracted. My older son and daughter and their children asked several times for refills of their soft drinks and my wife and I asked for the same with water; and we never received either...??? Otherwise, I would eat here again just not after five hours of pumpkin picking, corn mazes and hay rides with the family; we were thirsty as well as hungry.
Every time we went there, they excelled their service. Very good food
Started going here when Candelight Diner prices increased. Some people complain about the prices here but I think they’re more fair, plus the food and service are great.
Food was good and the service was friendly and quick, server made sure we were ok throughout the meal, great place for a quick bite
Great service, good food.
Food was amazing my Girl friend and I add the eggs Benedict it was absolutely amazing service was top notch coffee was great price was reasonable going back for dinner Saturday before we leave to go home to Florida
Classic diner. Good food fast and hot.
Food was ok but kinda pricey for a diner. The dessert cake tasted old, it wasnt fresh. The server was nice.
Had a great experience here at the dinner. Came here with my wife, her mom and our 1 year old. They were baby friendly and provided us with a high chair for the little one. The prices were amazing for the amount of food we received. The service was quick and the coffee kept coming. Overall really enjoyed the food, the service and the accommodation. Will def be coming back.
Best diner period.Corn beef hash for breakfast is a absolute.Diner specials can feed an army and never disappoint.Wait staff is top notch, cant say enough about how pleasant everyone is, been coming here for at least five years and nothing positive has ever wavered.
I meet 20 of my family members here on a Sunday. The manager Archie couldnt have been more helpful (we called a head). The food was great service was good even though every seat was filled.Close to LIE and Northern State. Great food and location! Will definitely go back
Great food. A little pricey but Im from out of town. They have a wide selection of food and great service too. Our waitress was attentive and our cups were always filled. If youre looking for breakfast items or late night cravings this is the place to go. Also, dont forget to get some dessert. They have many choices in cakes, pies, and other baked goods. We were staying at the hotel nearby and came here for brunch and a late night snack. Hope you enjoy!
Went for lunch with a friend. Decent experience; food was good, service just OK. Im not in the area often but Id go back if I find myself there.
Beautiful diner and great plentiful food
Friendly staff and great food......always! Good place to eat and have fun.
Great pancakes • Awesome chicken sandwich • efficient service • Clean dining area and bathrooms • friendly team • spacious •good pricesI updated my review, they earned five stars as far as Im concerned. I love supporting local family businesses. One of the brothers which I believe is also the owner has such a high vibing personality. Great attitude!!! He accommodated my friend who had a damaged debit card. The waitress was very attentive and hard working lady. Wish I had gotten her name. Great job everyone. Ill be returning soon!!!
Just came from dinner. Portion we’re good size. Coffee terrific, even the tap water was good. Staff very friendly and attentive from the host at the front door to our waiter Harry. Extensive menu as you would expect! Clean, comfortable!
Always friendly staff. My favorite waiter is Nico. Food delicious and huge portions , go hungry and you wont be disappointed
We went in for a light lunch. Just French onion soup an French fries with brown gravy. The soup was great. We were disappointed with the gravy. It was more like flour with some gravy flavor. They did bring us turkey gravy, when we said something. It was ok.
One of the best diners on long island
The Boston Burger was very tasty. The steak fries were very tastyService was friendly and quick. Place was packed but we really didnt have to wait long. It was a pleasant expierience. If Im in the area again we definitely will ear there again.
Great food again. Had the turkey burger. Wow.
Food was presented well, hefty portions. However, my wife ordered Salmon, and within 30 minutes she became ill with GI symptoms. The manager on the phone said he would do nothing about the fish dish.
The presentation of the breakfast received was pretty. The eggs and bacon had the perfect color and flavor. The grits were nice and creamy. The service was a little slow although it was not yet that busy. Would not come here during the busy hours.
This gets a 5 on my diner scale. I think there are no threes in diners. Theyre either quite good or quite bad in my experience. This place falls on the quite good end. Not perfect by any means, but its clean, well lit, lots of friendly staff, it gets very busy, but the food comes quick and fresh, with large portions. Ive never had a bad meal there.
Very good and typical diner ambiance with a huge menu and tasty food. I went here for lunch with a co-worker and enjoyed a very tasty 1/2 pound burger with mazzerella , bacon and Jack Daniels sauce. My friend had the crab cake salad that was huge. The prices are a bit steep for a diner, but the food and service was very nice.
This is one of my favorite omlettes
Big portions and not bad diner food selections. Some selections are better than others. There are waitresses and front desk staff here however that are not friendly. I am unsure if theyre not used to new faces/race or its just their demeanor. If you can shrug the attitude, then its worth a try.
Good food wait staff was helpful
I live in Michigan. I have to come to Long Island for work on occasion. I make it priority to stop here every time because everything they make is very tasty. Service is great. I recommend The chicken Panini. Its actually made with fresh mozzarella not cheese slices. I also recommend the Banana-Walnut Pancakes. Also very good. Cost is low and the portions are huge. Its Certainly worth a try!
Delicious diner food, extensive menu and everything was very well made. However, the service was not good. The servers were inattentive and the person bussing tables and running food ended up doing more for us than our server. That said, the food we got was very good and we will definitely give them another try.
Always the best!! The food is ALWAYS delicious, and fresh. The wait staff is always friendly and professional. The dining rooms are ALWAYS clean. There is no other diner like this one!! I have been coming here for years and I will continue with pleasure. A MUST VISIT IF YOU WANT A TASTE OF THE BEST LONG ISLAND HAS TO OFFER!
This is the best diner Ive ever been to. The breakfast is spectacular. I had lemon blueberry pancakes that tasted made from scratch. Delicious. My husband loved his farmers omlette. Service was attentive and friendly. Plenty of parking. Place was packed on Sunday morning, but we didnt have to wait for a table. Bathrooms super clean
Decent food, super friendly waitress but way overpriced. 1 pancake meal and a western omlette 2 waters 1 chocolate milk $44
So glad to be able to come in, sit down and enjoy a Premier Sampler again! The people are great here, and so is the food. I love when its not busy and they put your hamburger bun in the Panini press.
Premier Diner is always busy but certainly worth the wait!!My favorite go to Diner. The food menu is large. The food is exceptionally good. The portions are generous. The service is very good. The staff are attentive.My only complaint would be that its pricey.Today I had a Mexican salad and the price is $17.95. But again, the portion was so big I only ate about a quarter of the salad and the rest will be for another meal.Easily located right off the LIE.
Best Diner Right Off The Expressway
Food and service is good. Painfully over priced. Rediculously so. 3.25 for a cup of coffee yeah, NO!
Prices seemed expensive, until our meals were served. Portions are More than generous! Goat cheese salad was enough to bring home leftovers. We added chicken and one order was More than enough for 2 of us to share. Waitress was extremely helpful, courteous & knowledgeable about menu items. Refills were brought before we even had to ask. Definitely would recommend this diner!
Im a big fan of Diners. Whenever I see one that Ive not been at, i have an irresistible urge to go. With this diner I should have resisted that urge.The menu needs some work as there isnt much variety beyond sandwiches.I ordered a very simple cheeseburger and fries. I asked that the cheeseburger be cooked medium well. The middle of the burger was almost raw. I had to cut around the raw burger to actually eat it. If I werent in a rush I would have complained.Now on to the french fries. They werent even completely cooked. Making both portions of my meal undercooked.Its pretty hard to mess up a cheeseburger and fries folks This Diner achieved both.The pricing also is an issue. Almost $16 for a cheeseburger and fries. Ouch!
We went there for lunch. It has inside and outside eating since it was raining we opted for inside. My husband and I ordered soup and a sandwich. We each had a bowl of soup and grilled cheese sandwich, soup was good but the grilled cheese was not melted and the bread was lightly toasted and the bill was $32.00 not including tip.
The Premier Diner is the place to go if you want delicious, fresh, oversized meals & fabulous service. Peter, Helen Gus, Archie & staff all make sure youre dining experience is all you want it to be. Order anything on the menu including dessert & youll be amazed. Thanks Premier for a fantastic meal from beginning to end. Well be back real soon.
The food was good all the way around. The service wasnt. We felt rushed and because of that it was hard to enjoy our dinner. My friends and I hadnt seen each other in quite some time. We know to choose a different place next time we get together.
I can’t believe the way we were treated at this diner The owner said it’s very stressful with the COVID-19 it should be stressful for us then you should close your diner they’re all stressful there I would pick a different Diner like the owner said their lots diners on Long Island he saidwe went there our food was cold hamburger was raw waitress yelling at us I never experienced that there sticking up for themselves and their waitress they shouldn’t do that we paid good money gave the waitress $10 tip even though the way she treated us we will never go back there and I don’t recommend itThe waitress YELLING if you’re not ready I have other people I have to serve yelling it out for everyone to hear and she did that to the other customersVery disappointed with the owners not having respect for us all we did was ask if we could sit on the left side and it was not ready so we took the right side no problem which was the worst thing we ever did thank God there’s other diners hopefully this won’t happen to someone elseMy daughters on the on the front line worked all day to have something to eat and you get a raw hamburger and they get angry at us?I got cold food we didn’t argue with them As they saidThe Waitress brought it back and it’s burnt we’ve been there before never got served like this very disappointing especially in times like we’re having nowVery stressful place!!!!!!!
We had a family gathering here.I didnt realize that our oldest daughter,my son-in-law and grandson were going to be there.We all enjoyed ourselves.The staff there is great!Very friendly and helpful.The food was awesome!I had no leftovers!!
The prices are high for a diner. But you do get a lot of food. I had the salmon it was really good. Came with soup or salad and dessert. Would definitely go back. Waitress we had was also very good.
Please do not give these people your business.The management is downright nasty. The food is mediocre and very overpriced.There are at least two other diners nearby that are SO MUCH BETTER in every way. (Dix Hills Diner and Candlelight Diner).We were rushed out on an early Sunday morning before it got busy. The owner rudely said if we wanted somewhere to talk, we should go to the public library. Thats after a $30 breakfast bill for 2 (not including tip) and $40 of pastries to go.Ill never step foot in this diner again.
This is a true NY diner. Excellent choices and huge selection of all types of food. Parking was a bit of a problem and it took a while to get a spot at lunchtime in a Friday. The quality of the food we had was excellent. They did not rush us, and the waitress was extremely nice. This is a Long Island food spot that I would definitely return to again.
My son absolutely loved the Oreo pancakes. Too much cheese in the omelette. The steak fries would have been better if they were cut a bit smaller. Please get normal hot sauce. Please get rid of the old fashioned glass ketchup bottles. Please use a better tea bag, not Lipton. Ive never seen milk already on the table. I have to admit that this was a place where things were done very differently as when I asked for disposable spoon and fork someone had to go in the kitchen to get it.
They have a very large outdoor tent with enclosures in the parking lot and it looked like they had 2 heaters but it was so warm today they werent needed. The food was good and so was the service.
They had a great ham steak. Eggs Benedict was great. Amazing hollendes sauce. Adriana was a great waitress will ask for her station again. Adriana told us about there French toast bits. Fantastic all I can say.
Good service good prices lots of choices
Food was good, but quite expensive. Wanted a gyro but not for 14.00, with Greek salad and fries wouldve been 21.95. Hot open Turkey sandwich also would have been 21.95... got a jack daniels chicken sandwich with cheddar and bacon for 14.00 - came with Cole slaw and a pickle. It was okay.
To expensive for my taste .Orange juice 6 dollars. Not even that goodFresh orange not worth the prize.
The food and service are great. Because of Covid, we chose to eat outside. Eating outside at this location is not so serene due to the truck traffic and pollution on Commack Road.
Very nice diner serving quality food. Large portions means youll be full or bringing some home. Prices are higher than other diners in the are, but are justified by the quality and quantity of the food.
Loved the food. Service was good and they really took care of our needs.
Dined here with the wife on a Monday night. Sat right away. Cobb salad with grilled chicken was good. My only criticism is they skimped on the bacon. Portion size was enormous. Took half of it home. Service was very good.
The waitress we had was rude and nasty Refused to write down order and everyone of the four dinners were incorrect and when corrected the waitresses response was what do you want me to do she was rushing and slammed salt and pepper om the table. The diner was not full at the time
Ate there several times while in the area. Delicious food, generous portions, desserts to die for. Although very busy, still best service and food quality. Servers the greatest
A little pricey and just kinda ok.....
Excellent salads! Im sure the rest of the menu is good as well but unfortunately we are on diets and chose the salads. My daughter and I shared a Greek salad with grilled chicken and my wife had an avocado salad. It was plenty of food and it was all delicious. I did sneak a look at the burgers and onion rings and they look good too ;-)
Best diner in the area. Good food. Decent prices and the service is good. Prime time dinner hours expect some waiting. Entrees are big. Love the Greek salad, burgers, fries, gyros, onion rings. Its all good
Typical diner...just as it should be and the way you expect a diner to be. Ive been going here for over ten years and the quality of the food has been consistently fresh, good, generous and tasty. The staff is always friendly and professional. So far its my favorite diner on the Island.
First thing I noticed was the sharp new decor in there. It is diner style but with flair. I have been there twice for breakfast and once for dinner. The menu is both creative for a diner and has more than average choices. Food was good. Last time I went the service could have been a tad better but not a deal breaker. I recommend a visit, especially for breakfast.
Great food, but unfortunately we got the short straw with a waiter. We had to ask multiple times for everything, only to watch our waiter examine his pen instead of doing his job. Also, our table was cleared before we were done eating, and the bus boy actually threw away a dessert we purchased and didnt replace it. After asking three times for our check, we tipped according to the service we received. Apparently it wasnt enough for our sorry excuse of a waiter. He came back to the table with the change, which was his tip, and told us we should be tipping him way more. Never in my life have I ever heard anything like this. Im sorry, but a tip isnt mandatory. If he wanted a good tip, he should have provided good service.
Premier Diner is a great place for quick bite. It is Right off the I495, with a large parking lot. Burgers are excellent here. The breakfast items are always spot on no matter what time of the day. Staff is super friendly and welcoming
Went there as a change of pace from the Candlelight diner in Commack. It was OK. Went on a Sunday around breakfast time and was able to get seated pretty quickly. Waiters were attentive and courteous.The food was just ok, nobody was blown away by their meal. It was edible. Candlelight Diner is much better in terms of the food.
Prices are insane! $20 “handhelds”?! Service was fine. My guests lasagna was cold in the middle , they microwaved for a bit and brought it back. I got a gyro, it was pretty good. I won’t be back
I eat in this great restaurant quite a bit! This is my favorite restaurant to dine. I visit this place at least once a month. The cooking is of high quality, the crew is polite and the rates are reasonable. I like going in this restaurant over a rich lunch.
Outdoor seating today and a perfect day for it. Very busy with an adequate staff. We had an excellent server. Diner quality food.
Second time in a row that I had terrible food and poor service. The prices they charge are high, its a diner not a fine dining restaurant. At least with those prices, you would expect the food and service to be exceptional. Do not waste your time and money here.
Very good food. We always go here for breakfast.
Waitress was Awesome and breakfast delicious.
Great food & staff. I have been here several times and my experience has always been exceptional. The staff is very accommodating and friendly and food is always great and plenty.
Premier is always good. Breakfast is outstanding. Also great with salads and fish dishes. Was disappointed with the pot roast and brisket dinners. Would not order them again.
Outstanding LI diner, fast and gracious service, extensive menu. Best CORNED BEEF hash Ive ever had: huge chunks of perfect corned beef and potatoes with just the right amount of onion and seasonings. Belgian waffle was light and crispy and hot!
Went for lunch with a co-worker today and ordered a chef salad. I did not look at the price, shame on me! The salad was $21!! Was it big? It was ginormous. But why??? So you could overcharge your customer? Not only was it way too big, they rolled the thickly sliced cold cuts into one giant roll with a diameter of 4” and the full length of the bowl. It was a horrible way to present the salad and their thousand island dressing was very thin. It could easily feed 3 people but that certainly isn’t what I wanted.
Food great, service not so good. Went for dinner. Waiter barely spoke English. Food was good. No followup from waiter, wanted another glass of wine, ordered it, no one showed up after 10 minutes.. Paid my bill and left, no tip, no one seemed concerned, even after I told them at the till. I also thought that for a diner, the entrees were very costly, 25-30$ range. May be good for breakfast and lunch, but a disappointment for dinner.
The Diner is immaculately clean, i was at counter and the Stainless steel was shinning and cups and glasses. I. Could see into kitchen same thing. I ordered a Turkey sandwich and it was at least 3 inches thick and melted in your mouth. The waitress was Eliane and was just fabulous .I have friends that go there for breakfast on Sundays and its a ritual for them.
Breakfast, lunch or dinner, this is the finest diner I have ever been to..The food is outstanding, service is always great and the atmosphere and decor tastefully done.The menu is second to none, try it...
The food here was really good and the service staff here are very nice too. Ive been coming here for years and looking forward to many more.
Family operated ,the owner ,his wife or 1 of the two sons are always there. And they watch everything , make sure everything is clean, your beverage is full, . My wife and I go there at least once a week, after a movie, breakfast, dinner, even for coffee and desert have been the hundreds of times over the years and Have never been served a bad meal. (Best turkey burger around) And the portions are huge usually end up bring half home to take to work. And there staff is great very accommodating . Go there you will be pleases
In a word disgusting !!!. Been here twice . Last time there will be my last time. The burger meat was low quality - dry and had a frozen taste to it. The gravy was so salty and terrible. ....And Overpriced!!! Do yourself a favor go to Dix Hills diner instead.
Exceptional service and food! I’m picky with diners, and I can honestly say this is one of the best ones I’ve been to. Clean, friendly service, and food was great. Will be coming back!
Let me start off by saying, the place has a great atmosphere. 👍🏼The food was good however the Omelets could be made a little better. 👎🏽My wife ordered the Brocolli and Cheese omelet with spinach added. The cooks or the waiter, not sure which one forgot to put the cheese in the omelet. Who has an omelet with out cheese!?! Lol So we had them take it back to make it right, thinking they would remake the omelet. No, to our surprise they opened it up put to pieces of American cheese and placed it under the salamander for about 10 sec. The cheese wasent even melted. Needless to say, we had them strike that from the bill.My wife ordered the Challah (a thick sweet Jewish bread)French Toast and it was amazing!I ordered the breakfast burger with steak fries. The fires taste good. You can tell they change thier fry oil regularly. The yoke on the egg was hot and still runny. Asked for a true-med and got a med well.Oh well...(pun intended lol)🤣OVERALL the experience was OK. Waitstaff are friendly and place is clean. Food is average. Lil on th expensive side. TOTAL STARS ⭐⭐⭐
The food was good- service was excellent but its very expensive sure for a diner. Dinnrr for 2 was $75 without a tip!
I ordered a burger well done and got it rare. Sent it back and then got the same burger medium rare. The fries were soaked with oil and soggy. My wifes eggs were cold. Overall a satisfactory waste of time and money with intestinal discomfort to look foward to!
This Diner is amazing! The best corned beef hash ever! Always have a great visit never a disappointment. Our server Niko was wonderful even on a very busy day. Highly recommend this place
Great food great service 👍
Will be going again soon. My server was Mandy and she was excellent!! Food amazing.
Excellent food and service, as always. My wife loves the Santorini omelette.
Food is way above diner grade. Generous portions. Service is great. You will have something to take home. Excellent for breakfast. Friday and Saturday nights there can be a wait. Worth the time. Best coffee that I Have had in a while.
This one of the best diners on Long Island. They never disappoint. Food is always fresh and tasty. Great portions. Definitely worth coming to, especially for simple comfort food.
I could have stayed here all day! It was like I had found a home. The food was fabulous. The people were friendly and made you feel like part of the family. If you get a chance of come out this way, put it on your definitely go to places!
Service is always excellent. I prefer Amanda(Mandy), Larry and Harry as servers. They know how exactly you like your food preparedHelen and Pete along with Gus run a top notch establishmentThe diner is spotlessThe portions are enormous, usually enough for two meals. You will be taking home food, for later, with youThey offer a ten percent discount to seniors, cinema arts members and veterans if you ask The key here is you have to identify yourself as belonging in one of the above categorizes. Tell them!You cant miss at The Premier
Last time I reviewed this diner they hiked the prices up to rediculous prices. Seems they werent done. Todays visit for 2 burger deluxes and plate of turkey dinner equaled over $53. As a person who travels often, compared to the tri-state area those prices are insane. Granted the food is tasty, but no tastier than any other decent food establishment. I guess if the locals are willing to pay, then why not. I will definitely not be eating here again.
This always crowded diner has huge portions of excellent fair with great staff and service. Ive eaten there more times than I can count, and its always consistently great. Just be ready to take home half of your meal!
Great variety, service and food. Good food & experience anytime
They but the dinner in diner.I do not know why I have not reviewed this place before. Ive been here with my family around 100 times since they opened about 10 years ago.The food is restaurant quality. Forget finger foods and burgers. The fish and chops are superior. Tons of pasta and chicken dishes. Order items that you would not ordinarily think to at a diner and you will be very pleased.
Food was not to par, service the worst. Waitress was extremely nasty.
Total reviews rating 4.3
199 Reviews for Premier Diner Commack 2023:
Review №1
2022-04-29My family had such a great experience here with the service and the food, so they decided to take me here for my birthday dinner. We met with Tonia, who is the sweetest, chillest waitress of all time; she was down to earth and sooo relaxed, she created a relaxed environment for us to enjoy our time.Food: Um, we literally closed our eyes and picked random stuff on the menu and they were all on point. This diner is no joke, the food is great. See for yourself (see photos).Price: Price is about 20~40 a person, depending on how you dine, buffet or per plate? The dishes on the menu averaged about 20-35. The portions are equally great.Ambiance: Casual, comfortable, but can be intimate and romantic in a certain way. Restaurant itself is well lit and well designed. I liked that the kitchen itself is in the middle and the tables surround the kitchen. Cool layout!Another thing to remember is that the parking lot surrounds the building so if you are planning a surprise, make sure the table is not visible to where you park.. or they will sit there and watch you bring the balloons,.. cakes.. gifts.. you get the idea.Anyways, shout out to Tonia for making our time at Premier Diner so awesome!
Review №2
2022-04-27Relatively dissatisfied and disappointed. First off my waitress was absolutely fantastic, she was very attentive, quick and helpful. This is my second visit to this establishment. My first was before the renovation. My first visit about 7 months ago was absolutely fantastic. This visit was sketchy for a number of reasons.I believe the owner was the one seating people on my most recent visit. He was watching the tables and wait staff like a hawk the entire time I ate. It was unsettling. I’m assuming a big part of this is because the tips seem to go to the house and not the waitress’s and waiter’s which I find terrible.I really wanted to like this place, I travel for work so every 3-4 months I stay at the Hilton behind the restaurant which makes it convenient to walk to. The Vodka on the rocks that I was served had to be about 90% water unlike the first time I dined. I probably won’t be back and I REALLY hope the support staff here is being paid what they’re worth, though I doubt it.TLDR; Waitress and support staff are great, food is meh, house tips are shameful, drinks are weak.
Review №3
2022-04-01LOVEEEE THIS DINER!! Food is FRESH and LOVEEEEE their Greek salads with grill chicken that comes on the side!! My hunnnnies got an omelette that he loved!!
Review №4
2022-04-15It was my first visit to this establishment and upon entering I was greeted and sat immediately, service was good, food was decent though could of used some more seasoning. Alittle pricey but understandable during the times we are facing.
Review №5
2022-03-01First time visiting this diner. It seemed newly renovated. Very nice and clean. I went for brunch on a Sunday around 10am. It was super busy, but I was able to get a seat right away. Staff were okay, most seemed to be long time employees.Their dessert options were great. A whole lot of things to choose from. We had their Oreo cake. It was super delicious!
Review №6
2022-03-16This rating is not because the food isnt good or the service is bad. I live close by, and have been eating in this diner since they opened. We ordered out from here throughout the whole pandemic supporting them every week when it was very quiet. In recent months, their prices have skyrocketed. I went there for lunch today. Had a tuna salad sandwich and orange juice. You will see the bill is close to $22.00. I think thats outrageous. Diners beware of their incredibly high prices.
Review №7
2022-07-08I have been going to this diner for years. Always a great dinning experience and the food is always frsh and delicious. The portions are huge from a breakfast meal to a dinner meal always delicious. The new renovations make it like going to a 5 star restaurant versus a diner. This is definitely a must.
Review №8
2021-08-21After seeing a comedy show we needed something to eat . And at 10:30pm why not breakfast at a diner. At first glance of the menu I noticed above average prices. After I got my food, I was happy to pay the prices. Food was delicious!!
Review №9
2022-05-23Amazing staff and service! Go there every time with my family. Usually get the breakfast (2 eggs with bacon and home fries). I would also recommend any of their omelettes or they are pancakes theyre amazing! And as far as burgers go based on my experience my favorite is the breakfast burger with the egg.
Review №10
2022-06-06Great service and the food was even better. I ordered the croissant French toast and thought Id gone to heaven.