Outdoor seating
Yes
Primo Piatto Ristorante & Pizzeria in Huntington
Categories
Location on the map
Huntington, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Kerbside pickup
Yes
No-contact delivery
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Highlights
Great coffee
Yes
Great dessert
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Cocktails
Yes
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Happy-hour drinks
Yes
Happy-hour food
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Bar on site
Yes
Good for kids
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Romantic
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Groups
Yes
Planning
Accepts reservations
Yes
Phone: +1 631-935-1391
Site: http://www.primopiattorestaurant...
Site: http://www.primopiattorestaurant...
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–9PM
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–10PM
- Saturday:11AM–10PM
- Sunday:11AM–9PM
Comments (109)
Its a shame. After new management took over its been awful. Meatballs are different and pretty lame. Sauce is bland. Garlic knots are now very doughy and greasy, and I could go on and on. Its hard to believe that every phone or online order (every one-no exaggeration) is wrong in some way OR I show up and they never even put in the order. After six years of living up the road and having it be our favorite restaurant we are never going back. Also, I think its great that they employ so many young kids, but some responsibilities are just too important for them to handle. We gave them about ten chances but we are done. What a shame. Just go to Portofino in the village and youll be taken care of.
I had stopped by for a meeting but let me tell you the owner and his family are amazing people and when I was ready to eat I was blown away how good the food was. I live in the city and I expect my Italian food to be good but this restaurant really surpasses my expectations and for my birthday I want to have my dinner there. Their menu, wines and service spoiled me rotten. There prices are affordable and the restaurant has such a beautiful interior and exteriors. It’s like they brought Little Italy to Long Island!!!
Got here at 3 pm today for Happy Hour with my wife and another couple. $3 bottled beers including Peroni. Personal pizzas were great and the service was outstanding. Waiter was attentive and very friendly. We will be back for certain.
Unfortunately the rating is due to the service alone. Our server, Erika, was unfriendly the moment we walked in the door. Im not sure if she was having a bad day, but it made our experience uncomfortable. There were 2 other servers as well and they were constantly checking on their tables and seeing if the customers wanted or needed anything. We didnt see her until we were done with the meal. Also on the website, there was an offer for 10% discount for 1st responders. I was told that it is not valid during happy hour. It would be nice put this on the website. This was not the way I wanted to celebrate an anniversary.
We had a fundraiser here last night.The owner John and his staff were amazing and incredibly attentive, and only outdone by the food!! The pizza, the pasta, the chicken parm sliders…..all excellent.And last week we ordered a few pies from here for Poker Night, and the Buffalo Chicken pie was amazing!!!Whether looking for an Italian night out, or just a few slices, you need to try Primo Piatto!!!
What has happened here? This is the second and last time I will order a Margarita Pizza to go. It was cold, crust was burnt, no basil. This was the pizza, the staff is rude, unfriendly, and most seem like they dont want to be there. Much better places in Huntington for Pizza- I wont even post about having Dinner inside anymore, that is very inconsistent.
Super convenient, out door service, great pizza and dinner, excellent service.
This restaurant sits on a hill in a spacious corner and decorated nicely. Outside sits potted vegetables and herbs that smell delish. The service is impeccable with efficiency and warm smiles from every employee. The food is magnificent. Good fresh quality food. This place brings back good memories for me and my husband as we are both homegrown Italians. If you love to eat, it’s a must to come here. Four stars!!!!!! Pam and Rich Signorelli
I celebrated my 21st birthday at Primo and it was such a great experience! The owner Joseph was so attentive and truly cared about my guests and I having a great experience. The food was amazing and the service was great! One of my favorite places!! My guests were raving about the special cavatelli short ribs and pork chops!!! Will be back!!
Stay away from this place!This is the first time in our lifes myself and my wife had such horrible Italian food. Considering we do love Italian food and did try it around the world including Rome, Venice and Milan.Meatballs in this place are mostly consist of bread and Veal Parm Dinner was cooked on rancid MSG oil, leaving disgusting aftertaste in the mouth you could never forget!If you want good Italian food look somewhere else.
I am so upset to be writing this but I am hoping that it fosters improvement in some way because we love the location and were SO bummed after our first visit.We got there on a Saturday evening around 6 and it was still quiet so we were seated nicely outside. We waited about 10 minutes to be acknowledged and finally got some water....menus after that. There were a bunch of young waitstaff helping other tables, including people who were seated after us. Maybe there was training going on because sometimes there were two at one table, but none for us. After about 20 minutes, a waitress took our drink order and then after another ten minutes, a guy took our food order. Pizza bread was good so we held out.My boyfriend got spaghetti with meatballs which were very spongy and not hot. The sauce saved the day but he really only ate the pasta. I ordered the shaved brussels sprout salad with almonds and pecorino cheese. I was served a huge bowl of raw shredded brussels, a glob of goat cheese, and a handful of whole almond tossed onto the top. There were some pickled onions...or something, but there was no sense to this massive bowl of belly pain, and no finesse...No one came by during the whole meal to see if we wanted more wine...or anything. We asked the fourth person who waited on our table (dont know what happened to our original waitress...or the others that brought stuff) to bring the check and was asked if we wanted to take the bitten meatballs home.Not a good experience...food was NOT well prepared or thought out. Bummer - really wanted to like this place.
A bit pricey but the new interior renovation looks very nice
This is a beautiful little Italian restaurant. Great atmosphere. Hard working staff. And an attentive owner. I highly recommend this establishment for a date night or just a night out with family.
The food here is uniformly and ridiculously good. The caesar and beet salads, ALL of the pizzas, and the ravioli are my favorites. Best Italian in town.
My family and I enjoyed a wonderful dinner experience here. Great staff, the food was top notch. Hats off and best wishes to the new owners; we could use a high quality Italian restaurant here. Keep up the good work.
Enjoyed Saturday I dinner there. The food was very good. I did have music which was nice. My husband had the chicken Marsala said it was very good I had chicken parmesan chicken was cooked just right. Will be back soon
I cannot understand the generally positive reviews for this place after giving it multiple tries (convenient location). The food is decent, hence the star, but unremarkable and overpriced. I have yet to encounter a minimally courteous employee, most of whom have been dismissive at best. Ordering takeout is a hassle, as apparently none of the posted menus are accurate. It is intolerably loud during popular mealtimes. Would strongly suggest avoiding, as there are many similar spots nearby that far surpass the food, service, and ambiance. Very disappointed.
An Italian restaurant at its finest in Huntington, NY!Beautifully decorated, relaxed atmosphere, and when the weathers nice the tables extend outside in front. The menu is simple authentic Italian with a modern touch. Everything tastes like it was just made for you; each serving is more than you can eat at once. In particular try the fried zucchini appetizer!The waitress was always there when you needed her, and the manager, Zach, went around checking with every table to make sure all was on point.Advise reservations, especially on weekends. It gets busy.
We were there for our friends bridal shower. It was a beautiful event and the food was excellent. There is an outdoor patio where we sat and it has a large parking lot.
Ordered lunch a few minutes after they opened, orders were ready in a very reasonable amount of time. Fried zucchini and mozz were great. Penne alla Vodka w grilled chicken was 2/5. Chicken was good, pasta was cooked well, sauce was the downfall. Maybe because it was still early.
My dinner experience would describe your restaurant as casa de incompetence. My wife and I came with two of our grandchildren, five and four years old. They were very well behaved but you would be smarter to move tables with young children that age.After 45 minutes, we asked that we could have the children’s meals as they were quite hungry and it seems silly to have them wait while my wife ate salad. Their meals came out, thank goodness. An hour later, I gave up and asked, in fact begged, our waitress to bring our two pastas to go. I’ve made orrechietti with broccoli Robe and sausage at home, if it can’t take me an hour and a half at home how can you possibly take a restaurant that long! You made a lovely night out with grandchildren frustrating and disappointing. Many things are Covid related and understandable to a civilized public,but a partially full restaurant With a complement of staff has no excuse. You just performed poorly
Delicious home-made old style Italian comfort foods with a marinara sauce reminiscent of nanas Sunday best!Very friendly and quick service with indoor and outdoor seating overlooking E. Main St.Plenty of off-street parking, great menu and a nice tasty slice of pretty much anything you like.
Great pizza and chix parm cool vibe
Food always delicious. Friendly staff.
Went there for dinner. Baked Clams were terrible. Clams whole but flat as a dime (and the size of a dime). Breading burnt on top, soggy underneath. Not a good flavor. Orecchiette Baresi - pasta was overcooked, sausage was undercooked (pink tint) and minimal broccoli rabe (3 pieces). Roughy Annerito was not good. Garlic knots were excellent. Pizza looked great, should have tried that.
Massive portion sizes, amazing service, and a wonderful homey atmosphere. The meatballs are one of the best items on the menu! Also, check out the cannolis!
Never order Spegheti Vingalo. The spegheti was soggy, the chicken had bad smell, and the presentation was really poor. Never coming again and telling my friends as well. Horrible experience. Plus we had to wait for 30 minutes.
Friendly staff & good food. Outdoor dining area was great.
Friendly staff and the Pizza is not to be missed. Among the best on Long Island In my opinion.
I have never gotten a bad meal... everything is delicious!!! We are lucky to have such a great choice in the area. Thanks for being awesome.
Great food & friendly service in a cozy, casual dining room. I think Ive gotten the orange roughy fish over a couple dozen times now. Plenty of parking.
Delicious italian food right on main street. The specials are amazing and the food and service is excellent.
The food is delicious and the staff are great.The place has a very nice bar. Will be going back.
Average in every way. Take out menus at the table. Rubbery calamari. Tiny wine selection. Just meh.
Quick pizzas taste amazing, personal pizzas are phenomenal, and dining there is an above average experience. Its good for everything.
Great Italian food with warm and friendly owners and staff. I eat there for lunch and/or dinner at least once a week and I especially enjoy the Orecchiette Baresi!
My Ravioli with creamy pesto sauce was probably the best Ive ever had. Everyone at our table was raving about their dishes.
Our go to pizza joint. Best slice around and a good gluten free pie. Best meatballs too!
We have been several times and it has always been good. The menu consists of pastas, pizza, appetizers and some main dishes.
Love this place great food
I have been coming here sinow it has opened. The staff, the food, the service is head above any Italian restaurant. Recommend to come in, and once you do.... youll be hooked!!
The menu consists of pastas, pizza, appetizers and some main dishes.
Great meal in the restaurant. Chicken Sorentino was delicious. Service was good
Good Italian food. We go there about once a month. Seems to be our go to place in a pinch.
This may have been the best food but more importantly the best service i’ve had in a long time especially from the two busboys joseph and jake
Love this place 💕💕 the pasta is amazing! I felt like I was in Italy enjoying great Italian food and wine.
Liked the pizza. Ive had only 1 dinner there, and I wasnt very impressed with service or food.
Excellent experience ....wonderful staff and delicious food .....if your ever in Patchogue go to their sister restaurant Locale ...just as wonderful
Love this place. Food is excellent, THANKS JESSE, service is outstanding and all in a nice, cozy atmosphere.
Always the best food with great servers
They are good and amazing food also drinks to
Kids love the alla vodka w chicken ... awesome garlic knots
Everything was great. Servers were very efficient and very pleasant.
The food is outstanding and the price is just right. Great customer service!
Absolutely love it!!! Great food and atmosphere!!
Pizza is standard but still good, havent had anything else
Absolutely delicious! The new owners are excellent!!
Family environment, great food, and large portions. What more could you ask for!
Great food. Great service. A real Italian experience.
Always wonderful. Since full time employed and on a swing shift hard to get out. I cant wait to go back
Great service, great staff and even greater food.
Great food and fantastic service!
Very friendly, good food and a nice group of people.
Very good service, our meals were great
Had a great meal. Service was excellent.
Delicious panini. Great service, especially helpful Christina.
Good pizza,great on a hot day sitting outside
The staff, the food, the service is head above any Italian restaurant.
Great food good prices excellent service
Good food good service. Reasonable price
Very very slow service. Good food.
Didnt really care for the place and the pizza was bleh
The food is excellent and the hospitality is second to none.
Great food great staff BEST ORANGE ROUGHY!!
Great atmosphere to match the food.
Food and service are always outstanding
Great meeting place with awesome food..
Great Italian food ...family owned
Long wait , customer service was average and the food was average
Everyone, good food, good service, good prices.
Food and staff were superb!!
Awesome garlic bread and Gamberi Scampi
Margherita Pizza is very tasty
Thought the lasagna was terribleVery ordinary
Good food, good prices.
Great food and nice intererior
Great food and atmosphere.
Always great food!
Best personal pizzas !!
Good food
Excellent grandma pizza.
That chicken parm hero tho.
Not good.flies
Great place!
Just good stuff....
Really good!
Spaghetti is supreme
Very good
Pasta pasta
Total reviews rating 4.3
109 Reviews for Primo Piatto Ristorante & Pizzeria 2023:
Review №1
2022-05-31I’ve read great reviews hence was curious to come. I liked the vibe, pretty relaxed. Great drinks and wine menu. We ordered Burrata, Beets Salad and Filet Mignon. Salads were ok and filet mignon was not very tasty. Service was great. We had to come back to taste the pastas and pizza that perhaps is a better option here.
Review №2
2022-06-20We just had our daughter’s wedding shower at Primo Piatto and could not be happier. All of our guests raved about the wonderful staff and fantastic food. The staff was polite and very attentive to everyone there. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone having an event or if you just want to go out for a meal. Great atmosphere also.
Review №3
2022-05-29Crispy Calamari a bit greasy though.Great SalmonGreat sausage and peppers hero Parmigiano.Also took out Shrimp Parmigiano hero.Got good remarks.Service friendly and polite though I think staff should dress more like waiters and waitresses.
Review №4
2022-07-02These people own intermezzo and this restaurant. We have been to intermezzo and had the worst service ever and bad food and been so disappointed, we vowed to never go there again. We went to Primo piatto not realizing that they also owned this restaurant. We sat and asked for a bottle of Pellegrino 10 minutes later a waiter came to our table and I asked again and he said yeah it’s coming and we ordered another drink another 10 minutes later still no drinks at all we walked out. This place doesn’t seem to be run by anybody there’s no manager headwaiter, nobody seems to care and the food is mediocre at best. So spend your money somewhere better.
Review №5
2021-04-26This past weekend we had Primo Piatto cater for our sons first birthday party. Spoke to John who took the order and assured us that the food will arrive on time. The day of the event the food arrived on time and HOT! Everyone was raving about the food. One issue, wish we order a bigger tray of the eggplant rolitini, IT WAS DELICIOUS!!!!!
Review №6
2021-05-21Delicious Italian food and pizza in a lovely Huntington restaurant.The new owners are doing it right! Their new Food Specials and Brunch Specials are amazing deals! Food and service are top-notch. Their free on-site parking is an added bonus!
Review №7
2021-12-19Im giving 3 stars. The pasta was great, but I asked I asked for a Pepperoni slice and they gave me this in a box without even heating it up. Good food, but poor service effort.
Review №8
2022-05-15I have noticed a serious decline in the quality of the food that is being served. They have all these young people in the kitchen that don’t know what they’re doing. I called to share my feedback and the manager ended the call because he didn’t like what I was telling him. What a shame!
Review №9
2022-05-29Quality, cleanliness, polite wait staff, and most of all a vast and delicious menu to choose from.We visited from out of state and were pleasantly surprised!
Review №10
2022-08-30Excellent food and service! Ive been getting eggplant parmesan, chicken parmesan and the salad. All delicious!!