Kerbside pickup
Yes
Pudgies Pizza Pasta & Subs in Waverly
Categories
Location on the map
Waverly, Tioga County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Phone: +1 607-565-2004
Site: http://www.pudgiespizza.com/
Site: http://www.pudgiespizza.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:10AM–10PM
- Tuesday:10AM–10PM
- Wednesday:10AM–10PM
- Thursday:10AM–10PM
- Friday:10AM–12AM
- Saturday:10AM–11PM
- Sunday:10AM–10PM
Pudgies Pizza Pasta & Subs in other cities:
Comments (193)
Food is always delicious. Its more expensive than other food joints (idk why) and they have messed up our pizza the last time we ordered (didnt tell them. Ordered a deep dish and it was flat 😆. Wasnt correct at all! And low sauce). We love pudgies pizza none thr less.
I always spend between $60-$80 each time I order from these guys just to make it worth the 15 min delivery and give a $10-$20 tip to the driver. To now be told that after ordering 5-7 times from them that they dont deliver to where I am. And pizza places complain about drivers not getting ripped smh
Friendly place to eat orderd a large truckey and medium chease steak there menu said 799 for the cheese steak and truckey didnt give me a price when called the said 13 99 for the truckey and 999 for the chease steak 🤔
Same as other post, great pizza which is all I ever get. Only complaint is their special costs a $1 more for the same thing I get at other locations. But the dinning area is always clean and I have never had to look for a place to sit as their is ample room and tables that can accommodate at least a party of 6.
Always hot 🔥 and juicy pizza 🍕
Just like all the other Pudgies, its pretty good food! I think a little on the expensive side though. The 2 slice special which comes with a drink, I had 2 slices of chicken wing pizza, a small fountain soda drink, and 2 things of ranch dipping sauce and it was $9 and change! Thats a bit crazy to me!This is a nice place for kids and family though. They have games and machines for kids to play!Something I like about all the Pudgies is they have clean, stocked restrooms and napkins on each table as well as salt and pepper.This location is in a good spot too.
I go here every week and their pepperoni pizza is beautiful (+2 stars)Their pizza specials are a miracle cure for both a hangover, and the munchies (+2 stars)They have a friendly staff that makes you feel welcome, every. single. time. (+2 stars)If youre looking for something worth eating, COME HERE!!
Pizza is always pretty fresh. Subs are very good with nice rolls. Big wings with good sauce. A little bit pricey though for a pizza joint. 2 can easily go over $20 for a couple subs and drinks. Other than this a good choice.
I think that this location is the best. Hands down the best turkey sub you can get in the area. Everything else is good too. I have never been let down by the service. If other Pudgies have turned you off. You need to give this place a try.
Surprisingly amazing pizza. I will definitely be back.If you place an online order, definitely calk and confirm it went to the correct store. Happened to us, the manager was great and took care of it immediately.
Dont recommend the Italian sub. For some reason, they put the oil on the roll before the put the meat, cheese, etc on the sub. This causes the sub to be soggy by the time you get them home. Everyplace else I know puts the meat, cheese, etc on the sub..and then puts the oil on. Other than that, love their subs(especially the roll/bread).
Been going to Pudgies since I was a child. Always been a fan of Pudgies pizza and mac and cheese. Ill always recommend this place if they keep things how they are. Never been to a location that disappointed, so quality control is on point.
Food was okay. Worker who I spoke to was rude.. also rather than telling me my food order did not meet the minimum delivery fee they just added a charge. I would have ordered a side if I had known.
Up until recently I wouldve given 4 or 5 stars but today I discovered they charge $.75 cents (with tax) for a cup of water!!?!?And while they have wi-fi they dont allow customers to use it!!Back in the day they were about good food and a decent atmosphere, now its more like a $10 burger!
Service slow, subs amazing
Pizza was perfect! Fast and friendly staff Customer service was a TEN plus! If you havent had a good pizza in a while you need to stop In at Pudgies! Best pizza around. 👍
I love the wings the sauce on them is so good as is the sauce on the pizza. Its kinda greasy but still is a good place to eat. Also have great subs and stromboli.
Way to much pizza sauce. An the price was outrageous. At the time I ordered the pizza they werent even that busy. So no need for all the extra sauce.
Havent had Pudgies pizzas in over 6 years due to living in Texas. I am still hooked on Pudgies and have been for 20+ years. The Waverly Pudgies was immaculate and the customer service was perfection at its best.
Very fast service, fair prices and unnecessarily accommodating employee which was an amazing surprise! Great business
The employees seemed to be in total confusion as to what they were supposed to be doingWe ordered a fish fry and got only fish and fr, when we asked about our Cole slaw the young girl at the register told us that we have to pay extra to have cole slaw..EVERYWHERE I have ever had a fish fry there is always cole slaw..including pudgies..and ive ordered fish fry there several times..this time they tell us it doesnt come with the meal..smh I wont recommend anyone to go there again
They have pretty good pizza just not always the best cheese.
Have loved pudgies since i was a kid.. im 43 now and i still tastes the same as bak then..
Love there subs and calzones n buffalo chicken pizza pasta is good 2
They over charged us. They dont honor their online menu prices wich are less than what they will charge. I would consider this a well placed scam. Too many bad experiences with this place wont be ordering from here anymore.
Over priced, cold, little ceasars quality pizza. Never take advice on whats good pizza from a New Yorker. Will not be back.
Love their pizza!! Always stop on my way into Western New York!
Good food good service a little pricey for a pizza place but ok
Pretty good slices of pizza. Plenty of seating but a lot of people takeout. I love stoppimg there for a nice hot slice of pizza pie
Food is good but the prices are high.
Best one in the area.Definitely aint worth going the extra mile.
There prices are to high but food is good the people are rude will not order there again
This one is in Waverly NY. & It is my opinion that they are by far the best! The service the food quality everything about the place is above the rest!
Prices for wings and pizza are outrageous
My family and I have a Pudgies 5 minutes away and chose to drive to this one and hour away because its a more welcoming environment and tastes great.
We get takeout here often. Orders are a litte slow on a busy night, but the food is always good and reasonably priced.
We ordered subs! We were on our way back to NJ from the Finger Lakes and stopped in for a quick lunch!!
Tasty sandwiches, calzones, breadsticks, and stromboli, but the pizza seems a bit plain.UNCLE GERRY’S TIP: For better pizza, try Coaches down the street.
Ok pizza, this is just my opinion but I think they put to much sauce in their pizza, but its still pretty good
The absolutle BEST pizza i ever had! Worth the 3 hour ride to get it!!
Water was on the floor and I slipped and fell never even asked if I was OK just replaced the pice slices that went on the floor n rushed to clean up the water
Pizza was overpriced and undersized. My slices where basically two giant bubbles with almost no sauce our cheese. Will not be coming back
Been pretty much the same for 60 years, thats why I go back.
Was not very good,first i ordered our sub asked for light lettuce i like 2 pieces of lettuce on sub ordered fries tasted like their frier oil needed to be changed
Use to be a favorite place to go but after poorly cooked food one day and having to wait for a hour for a salad that I ordered for pick up and I was on time no more for me.
My guys have always love your pizza but it is so unhealthy okay at best.
Pizza is very good, especially veggie, meat sauce, pepperoni, plain, honey mustard chicken, and garlic cheese.
Amazing pizza and very friendly staff. Pizza is well worth the price.
Good pizza, good cheesy garlic bread sticks, open in a pinch in case dinner escaped you
Hubby and I visited from Long Island and they delivered the food was excellent !
As a New Jerseyan, Pizza is sacred to me. Probably the best chain pizza that I have ever had.
One of our must stops when my son came to town from Texas. Stromboli is the best ever.
Thos was one of those cant drive anymore and Im hungry kinda stop but im really glad it happened had the calzone and it was fantastic
Pizza crust was over done and the place was a bit over priced.
Very clean pizza joint. Good subs. Good customers. Not Uber pricey.😎👍
Ive been eating at Pudgies since I was a child. Good food then now!
The sub was great
Just love their pizza
Good food. Ordered was correct. A little pricey.
Grew up in pudgies. They rarely disappoint. Pizza with meat sauce and saucy medium wings. Yum 😋
Great food! The Buffalo chicken pizza is killer.
Tasty food and helpful workers who were able to direct us to the place we needed to go when we were lost!
Great pizza, polite service, easy to order online or by phone.
A Valley tradition! Best pizza & wings around!!!!
The food was very greasy, not to mention over priced for the amount of food that was ordered. Will not suggest this to anyone or be reordering in the future.
Love this place. Everything Ive tried is delicious and good quality.
Its always great! Best pizza EVER!
Fantastic food, people, and atmosphere! Great place for any meal!
Great pizza and fast service.
Very polite staff and really delicious pizza.
Great food, excellent portions and awesome staff!!!
It was alright nothing to brag about
Has one of the Cleary family as manager. Good tasting pizza
A hometown favorite, Pudgies is delicious pizza, friendly employees, and reasonable prices.
Love the sauce on the pizza. Always a go to with chicken wing pizza
Yummy!!! Have loved their pizza my whole life!!
It was alright... stromboli was delicious, but cheese on pizza, a little over done.
Of all the Pudgies throughout the lands (Ive been from Wellsboro PA to Syracuse NY) this branch is my favorite.
This is my spouses favorite pizza. I think the peperoni is too greasy.
Good pizza and subs. A few old arcade games makes it fun too.
Favorite pizza place around. Prices are average for the area.
Service good but food not so much!
Great pizza and subs excellent service!!
Spiedie sub was to hot,had red pepper flakes on it,no way to marinate meat!
Great vibe, cool people, good food A+
The wings were good
Its not real pizza. A foamy, cakey. Sugared sauce imposter.
Best pizza in the north PA 😋💕
Good food and lovely customer service.
Great customer service and the food is fantastic!
My favoriate pizza. Great service!
Great pizza and good prices
Awesome, fantastic.....great food and service.
Fresh delicious food and excellent service
Has very good food and very clean
Always a nice place for their stromboli
Well it was the most expensive sheet pizza I ever bought.
Best pizza around. Enough said!!!
Decent food. Employees always friendly
You have to be there at the right time. Otherwise pizza special is old
Great location and good prices quick service.
Its ok.. not a real new York style pizza
The new dips are great! Really worth a try.
Would you like some pizza with the grease? Worst pizza EVER!
My son loves going here..have arcade race car..
Ordered a sheet and received a blonde hair under the cheese. Disgusting.👎
Food is ok, very high priced though
My stuff be cut all wrong
Not the Pudgies of 50 years ago.
Cheap pizza and very amiable employees.
Very poor service. I would never eat there again.
Love the pizza and the cheesy bread!!
Quick service, delicious pizza!
Very good pizza and wings
Very good wings
One word about their food....Awesome!
Pizza frete remember this? Um...yummmmm
Disgustang!!! i hait this plaice it iz vary bed
Friendly fast service and awesome food !!!
Little bit expensive 😬 but good food
Ok pizza sauce can be a bit spicy
Best Pizza and subs ever!
Love their pizza!!
Very good food..friendly setvice.
Who doesnt love Pudgies its like as American as apple pie
Its just average. Nothing special
Pudgies is the best!
Great food all the time!
Friendly service and quality food
Good place for family dinner
Good but kinda slow
Best pizza in town.
Good food they deliver
Very nice clean
Pizza a little undercooked, so common today
Good food
The best pizza ever
Very good food and service
Quick service & Tasty Food
Nice subs..taste
Best subs in town.
Amazing pizza and wings!
Good pizza, good location
Great food and service
Great pizza and wings.
No pizza price
Not bad
Best pizza around
Best pizza around
Very good
Good Stromboli
Best pizza ever
Home town favorite
LOVE IT
Good food and service
It was so good
Love the Pizza!!
Its ok
Great tuna hoagirs
Best stromboli ever!!!!!
Good food and service
Pleasant thru and thru
Always friendly
Good pizza :)
Love there food
Best pizza!
Always great!!
Yummy pizza!!
Great food
A favorite for sure .
Great pizza
Love pudgies!
Great as always.!!!
Great pizza
Nice
Not like it use to be
Very good!!
Good pizza
Great food
Great food
Good pizza
Stromblies
Great food
Total reviews rating 4.2
193 Reviews for Pudgies Pizza Pasta & Subs 2023:
Review №1
2022-06-02I placed my order at the counter and waited in the car. The Pepperoni & Sausage pizza we received seemed like it was a pizza that had been sitting around for a while. It was dry and did not look appealing at all. My husband ate 1 piece of it and I didnt eat it at all. I had also ordered wings and they were perfect. Plus I got two of the fresh chicken bacon ranch slices and they were super good. If I ever go back Im going to ask to see the pizza before I leave.
Review №2
2022-01-30A large pudgie burger and mushrooms cost 27 dollars!. Canceled order and got the same order for 10 dollars cheaper and a bigger sandwich at Sapranos Italian market. Lol
Review №3
2022-02-16Good food, when they can actually get my order right so far its been wrong majority of the time unfortunately, alot of the workers are rude and could really care less about you as a customer which is sad honestly, manager is good for fixing issues and seems to care its just the regular workers.
Review №4
2021-08-13The food was delicious and the employees were very nice. My only complaint is that My food came out too early. I ordered a few pizza slices while the other members of my party ordered things that had to be cooked and assembled, so I had my food about 10 minutes before everyone else. Next time if I do this Ill be sure to ask for them to bring everything at the same time, so my food doesnt get cold before all is served. Overall the place was very clean and tidy.
Review №5
2022-02-11Always love pudgies but this one is one of the best Ive eaten at. Highly recommend!
Review №6
2022-02-26Love there pizza always ask extra crispy wings
Review №7
2021-12-14Still making good food like back years ago way back when I was only 13 years old there was Alot of great times back in those days but this pudgies Still makes great food and has friendly people
Review №8
2021-01-24Pizza is pudgies so its always good. Employees are nice but last time I was there to pick up a pizza am employee that had been obviously fired wanted his last check and instead of telling him to leave or go outside the store to discuss issue with him the (assuming) manager stood right at counter arguing with him. If my kids would of been with me I would of been upset about language used and the lack of professionalism. An elderly lady was behind me in line.
Review №9
2022-01-13Excellent pizza and wings, reasonable prices, convenient location, courteous staff.
Review №10
2019-11-11I do like the facility. The pizza is good. I/we usually get individual slices - sometimes I think they could look a little fresher, but the taste is still good. Prices could be less expensive and I would like to see better specials.