Delivery
Yes
Renzos in East Islip
Categories
Location on the map
East Islip, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Payments
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Phone: +1 631-277-1593
Site: http://www.renzospizzali.com/
Site: http://www.renzospizzali.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–9PM
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–9PM
- Saturday:11AM–9PM
- Sunday:11AM–9PM
Renzos in other cities:
Comments (59)
BEST chicken ala vodka slice!!! The chicken is perfect and so is the sauce , also love love love the crust. Can’t wait to try their other food.
These guys are great. Always smiling and making you feel welcome. Pizza is consistently good which is why I visit this place about twice a week for lunch.
We love renzos! The people are amazing there is always something awesome to try. They are always trying new combos along with the classics. The best specialty slices are penne ala vodka, white with broccoli, eggplant parmesan and buffalo chicken with a side of ranch!! They also have this roll thing if you can get one they only make a few a day its grilled chicken lettuce onion or no onion a combo of fresh mozzarella and shredded mozzarella with a ceasar dressing rolled up in thin pizza dough! It is to die for! I pass at least six other pizza places to go here. Highly recommend.
Been going here since I was in Little League baseball. In my 30s now and bring my kids. Great pie selection and pasta dishes. Clean tables and friendly staff.
Great Pizza but also other Italian Pizza like foods , plenty of parking, open till past 8pm so grab supper and enjoy yourself either as take out or eating there.
To put it very simply;Renzos makes the absolute best pizza that I have ever tasted.Regular pizza or sicilian is simply a slice of heaven!
Have ordered 3 times. Pizza is great. Staff is always greeting people with a friendly smile.
Best pizza ever!! Free delivery and very friendly workers and owner. I would recommend this place. Amazing!!
I live in central islip and I drive to get the pizza from them they are nice and the pizza is soooooo good
I have been going here for years and have always had good service and is one of the best pizza parlor in east islip
One of my favorite spots to eat. fantastic location, neat, and good customer service. A must try!
On multiple occasions, this place has been awful. For some reason, they never get the order right. The staff and owner are not friendly at all. Never again will I spend my money or time here. Much rather go down the road to Fargiannos. NO, I DO NOT RECOMMEND!
The garlic knots are my favorite at Renzos pizza and my fav slice is The buffalo chicken pizza
Very friendly owners,Love ,love , their buffalo pizza.Highly recommend
Delicious!!! Ive had the pizza and chicken wings. Tried the chicken parmigiana and the chicken Marsala and they were excellent!
Best pizza in East Islip. They have added a lot of new & delicious new items to the menu.
This place is great. I only go here and one other pizza restaurant(honestly I cheat on my regular place to go here)
Love Renzos. My favorite is the Shrimp Francese. Friendly family place.
Great food. Wonderful staff. They allow you to use credit cards for delivery.
Very good in house pizza. Small local pizza joint with friendly staff and quick delivery.
Theyve been around since I was a kid and are still here for a reason. Because theyre the best around!
I just left this wonderful establishment.. and this place has THEEE BEST PIZZA IN LONG ISLAND!!!
Great pizzas, and warm and friendly people.
Im a sad panda. I ordered a delicious pizza and half of it is on one side of the box. 😟🐼
Great food, fantastic service. They never disappoint.
These guys have the best Chicken Franchaise. The best.
Best Pizza in East Islip, always served with a warm smile.
There food is really great and customer service is very well too
Very polite staff, delicious pizza!
Been going there for years. Great place to order great food.
Never disappointed our go-to pizza place.👍
Theyre open when you walk out of the bars at 3am
Place is great, Christine Martinez must have caught a bad day or something...
Delicious food and excellent attention.
Best pizza in east Islip
Best Pizza in East Islip
Great Local Pizzeria!
Best bufalo chicken roll
Fast and friendly people
Delicious buffalo slice 😍
Renzos food is great
Really good pizza
Very good and nice service
Love the pizza.
Awesome
Good food!
Excellent food and service
Very good 🍕
👍🏻
Total reviews rating 4.6
59 Reviews for Renzos 2023:
Review №1
2021-07-14Absolutely delicious. The spinach wheel was one of the best Ive had. Looking forward to stop by again. Great local spot.
Review №2
2019-08-18Stopped before a show down the block. Pizza was fresh and tasty. Service was very friendly.
Review №3
2022-01-15We have tried every Italian place in The Islip area and this place is by far the best!!! The pizza, meals, and sauce are amazing!!! Old school Italian!!!! Fantastic!!!!Very nice people as well!!!
Review №4
2022-02-15Pizza is good but the worker literally scammed me! the worker didn’t put my order in the machine and charged us a strange exact amount of money.
Review №5
2020-05-31Very good pizza. You can tell they use high quality ingredients. There food is alwaysVery good and consistent. They have been thereForever, they must be doing something right.Also a plus the owner is always there andPleasant along with the staff. Another plusIs the place always looks very clean.I highly recommend you give them a try.
Review №6
2021-02-28Renzos pizza is one of the many local pizza spots in East Islip. They offer a full contingent of the standard Italian menu items found in most pizza shops on Long Island.I can only speak to their pizza so far, and its good. They actually cook the pie, unlike so many others that have a soft undercooked Wonder Bread type crust.
Review №7
2018-06-26It took 2 days to eat the pie :). It was delicious and the amount you get for the price is amazing. My family came from Florida and wanted real NY pizza. The best pizza out here in East Islip area. The staff was also very friendly. Im glad we found this hidden jewel.
Review №8
2015-11-22If you want excellent pizza with competitive pricing this is your pizzeria for the Town of East Islip and surrounding areas. The owner always greets me promptly by name with a smile. Customer experience is excellent here. They have many different types of pizza to choose from and can always make custom pizzas per request. The food is always delivered warm and delicious right to my door free of charge. I would highly suggest this pizzeria if you are looking for a nice atmosphere, good price and great quality tasting food.
Review №9
2019-09-02They catered a party at my in-laws today and the food was fantastic. We usually get pizza from Renzos when we are in the area so we know the food is great. Their penne ala vodka and chicken francaise was the best Ive ever had. I cant say enough about this place. Thank you for delicious food!
Review №10
2014-03-11The prices and family atmosphere is excellent when considering a pizzeria, They offered free delivery which was prompt and quick. The price was within range of most local pizzerias and the quality was great. They have a nice selection of pizza to choose from ranging from, pepperoni to meat slices to chicken/bacon/ranch slices. This is my favorite local pizzeria in my town BY FAR. They also offer catering if that suites your needs, as well as appetizers and calzones.