Delivery
Yes
Salvatores in Port Washington
Categories
Location on the map
Port Washington, Nassau County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Offerings
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Payments
Cash only
Yes
Phone: +1 516-883-8457
Site: http://salvatorescoalovenpizzeri...
Site: http://salvatorescoalovenpizzeri...
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:11:30AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11:30AM–9PM
- Thursday:11:30AM–9PM
- Friday:11:30AM–10PM
- Saturday:11:30AM–10PM
- Sunday:1–9PM
Salvatores in other cities:
Comments (185)
Excellent coal fired pizza thats just as good as any of the top named ones in NYC. The service was friendly. Ill be back. Its worth the 30 minute drive.
❤ the pizza here..We ordered a large pie with roasted red peppers and fresh mushrooms.
Delicious pizza and fast service. Everything is clean and so simple, servers are helpful and friendly
Some of the best pizza you can get in new york, only downsides are you have to order by the pie and its cash only
Drove 20 minutes here for no reason. They failed to update the google hours. They are closed for “winter break” until 2/24. Do better.
For us, this is a great pizza restaurant. Everything they sell is very good to excellent. A hair on the pricey side, a smaller menu, pick-up onliy, and cash only make this place for us less than 5-stars. Highly recommended if you can handle the negatives we described. We still and always get food from them.
My girlfriend and I came here for the first time today after seeing a positive food review on YouTube. We arrived around 4:30 but weren’t aware that indoor dining doesn’t begin until 5. We were understanding and told the lady “no worries at all, we’ll take it to go than.” Once she heard we were first time customers she immediately insisted that we take a seat now since the pizza won’t be the same if we take it to go. I know this to be very true with brick and coal fired pizza especially being Italian myself, best way to eat it is fresh out the oven. Customer service was 5/5 and so was the pizza! We will be back...
Absolutely delicious thin crust pizza. Staff is extremely friendly. A great local restaurant. Very happy to be part of community.
Absolutely one of the best restaurants in town! A local favorite that never disappoints! The only flaw about this place is that I wish they were open on Mondays or delivered, because I would do anything to be able to eat their food more! The pizza is always absolutely perfect and crispy on the bottom, and I love it when I get fresh garlic on top, it really adds a nice kick. The garlic bread too, is always a great addition to a meal there. I would eat their pizza every day if it were possible!
Really great pizza shop. Everything tasted very fresh. We got a regular pizza and Greek salad both were delicious. They allow dine in service now which is great. Just a heads up it is cash only though and they dont let you order by the slice
Thats really great place! So tasty that you wanna get back again and again. Naturally cooked on coal oven, it does the trick. Highly recommend for pizza lovers!
The pizza is amazing. It tastes fabulous every time we go.
Very disappointing. Sauce is overly sweetened and crust is not salted enough. Probably made the dough with too much water. Very boring and lacking in flavor. Toppings were a waste of time. Its cash only as well.
Friendly & fast service, excellent pizza. Crispy, thin crust. Generous toppings. Ample parking. Highly recommended.
Its bizarre to say this about pizza, but it wasnt salty enough. The fresh mozzarella is a nice touch and lends well to the thinness of the crust. But the tomato sauce is too sweet. If they salted the sauce properly and didnt add sugar, it would balance the pizza far better.I have to say, Im basically a pizza connoisseur, Im like Mona the Mechanic from My Cousin Vinny but for pizza.This pizza was a let down for Long Islands caliber. For the in-your-face audacity of the sign that reads Cash Only. No Credit Cards. No Cry Babies. as you walk in, I hoped that their food would stand up to that rudeness and willingness to turn people away hoping to pay with credit. But it did not. I would not recommend. There are better coal-fired joints on LI and with the bountifulness of pizzerias on LI, its worth it to take a drive.
Fav place in port, i’ve been going there since i was younger and the food is devine
Salvatore’s pizza is amazing. Amazing and I’m from Brooklyn. Calzones also rock. This place is a must to try. My mouth waters just thinking of the white pizza. Cash only and they don’t deliver for a reason. Because Brick oven pizza should be eaten fresh out of the oven. It’s still awesome when you take it home.
I went for the first time because Ive heard good things, but was not prepared for one of the best pizza experiences of my entire life. Easily in the top 5 pizzas Ive eaten in my 36 years on this planet eating pizza regularly.
Hands down the best pizza on Long Island, and its even better than some of the famous NYC spots like Grimaldis. Just as good as the pizza are the rolls, which come in a handful of options, my personal favorite being the sausage role. Seating is on the limited side and it can get packed during lunch and dinner hours so beat the rush or expect a wait. This is a cash only spot, and a whole pie only spot, no slices. Salvatores will not disappoint.
Best pizza in town, if not all of Long Island. The crust is perfect every time: crispy on the bottom and springy on top. Lots of sauce, the perfect amount of mozzarella; the Mona Lisa of brick oven pizzas.
The food is just fabulous. If you want pizza this quality, you’d have to go to BK or Manhattan. Well, you’re in luck . you can’t go wring with anything you order here. I wish they would take credit cards , but it’s worth stopping by and getting cash if you’re coming here. Believe me when I tell you it’s worth the trip to Port Washington . Besides Difaras in BK this is my second favorite place . And then Spumoni Gardens . Come with an appetite portions are huge . If you eat a calzone by yourself . You’re the man !!
Life-changing pizza. As a lifelong New Yorker, I have tried hundreds of different pizzerias. This one is without a doubt the best. Their sauce is something truly special that can’t be described in words. Their mozzarella cheese and bread are fresh, and the coal oven cooks the pizza to perfection. It literally is just the best pizza anywhere. Best of all, it’s a nice, hidden gem in Port Washington, NY.Cons:-Closed on Monday :(-They’re so good that they get away with only accepting cash
There are many pizza places on long island however this one is perhaps the best. Offering classic New York Style Pizza in a real coal oven with a vintage setting and menu that probably hasnt changed in 30 years. To its immense benefit. Every menu item you offered here is genuine Italian American flair to it and worth exploring.But the Pizza! Their pizza is unapologetic as this place is for how Italian-Americana they are. And the result is a fantastic flaky delicious piece of melted goodness. You never order by the slice here, you get a whole pie, of about 4 choices. But that whole pie is going to disappear, even if you are by yourself.
I ordered my pizza. They asked for my name, told me it would be done about 6:30 and that they would call my name when it was ready. I waited outside their door for them to call my name. It was close to 6:30 when I went inside to find out if my pizza would soon be ready. Turned out it was ready and sitting on the side. What’s the point of waiting for the pizza if they never tell you that’s it’s ready? If I wanted cold pizza, I could have had it delivered.
Hands down this is probably one of the top 3 places to get pizza on Long Island. The ingredients are fresh, the service is great, and the coal oven pizza is absolutely outstanding. Bring your appetite, you won’t be disappointed.
Best pizza Ive ever had, anywhere. Toppings are all fresh, not canned. Great crust, cheese, and sauce. I generally dont like eggplant, but their eggplant parmesan is outstanding, and so tender.
Very good pizza, nice restaurant, on the smaller side but can accommodate large groups. Pasta was good, meatballs were soso, bland for kids that is good, as it was for my son, for adults Id suggest skipping.Just one thing that was a problem, we ordered a pasta with marinara to go for our daughter who is dairy allergic, my wife and I both separately confirmed that just pasta and sauce would be dairy free. When we got home we found cheese in the marinara. Fortunately my daughter did not eat it.PS cash only, but theres a bank across the street.
Their regular pies are fantastic and a nice change from normal pizza. The stromboli is also worth a try. Cash only so come prepared.
This site is my favorite place. Of all restaurants I know I prefere it most. I always suggests to my friends to go to that place. everytime I want to go to a superb lunch, this place comes immediately to my mind. fresh and all kinds of food and a large menu.trained staff members, and good ambience. In addition to that, the charge is reasonable. I tell about this place with great pleasure.
A great old fashioned coal oven pizza. He oven is so hot that the pizza gets those delightful burned areas on the crust. Service is fast and efficient but sometimes the wait can be long... but its worth it. Enjoy this place, as I do regularly, you will it be disappointed.
Amazing pizza. They make their own mozzarella and the crust is expertly charred. Listed in Ed Levines book on Pizza. The coal oven is historical. The rolls are also outstanding. Worth a trip.
Ive been coming here since Im little the food has always been the same its absolutely delicious best coal oven pizza on long island hands down
The best. For take out order way in advance ok busy nights it can be over an hr wait. Pepperoni and mushroom is my favorite. The zitis, either eggplant or sausage, are great also. The wine is not so tippy top but who cares when your pizza is literally the best around. No slices, get a pie and save it for later. Love yourself, eat here more.
It was ok. I guess there was a lot of hype about it from others while we waited to be seated. Didnt live up to expectations. Good service and good food. Nothing exceptional about the pizza.
12/16/13. A Californian here. Best pizza of my life. Ive eaten pizza around NYC and Long Island, including Lombardis. Nothing compares to Salvatores. Will go every time Im near Port Washington. Thanks!
Surprised to find this gem in a strip mall? I loved the pizza, the coal fired oven is unique and it was fun to watch the team kick out pizzas 🍕 will stop for pizza next time I’m in the area!
I didnt want to post how great the food and staff were , I wanted to keep it to myself so I would never have to share our little secret. But the truth of the matter is that my wife wouldnt let me. Awesome restaurant, best pizza in the solar system.
Some of the best pizza I have ever had. Lovely family-run business. You can watch them make and cook your food while you wait.
This is hands down the best pizzeria in Port Washington! I would even say all of Long Island. The pizza isn’t the only delicious thing a fab of mine is also the chicken roll. Must try pizza.
Their Sausage Pizza is award winning and delicious. In 2019, Newsday gave it the best pizza on Long Island.
Salvatores is without a doubt, the best pizza in the world. And Ive lived in Italy, and tried the best Brooklyn had to offer (even Spumoni Garden).
Im lactose intolerant but I will pay the price every time for Salvatores.
Salvatore’s is famous for their coal oven thin pizza. The food is good as well but pizza and strombolli’s are best. Always consistent!
Best pizza on North shore! Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil. We drive 30 minutes to eat there. Sounds crazy, but its worth it!
Best Pizza on LI. Period.
Best pizza in Port Washington and one of the best in Long Island.
The staff are very rude and disrespectful. The pizza is good but its hard to go back there because of how the staff approach you.
These guys have some of the best pizza Ive ever had. Their coal oven stuff ranks up there with the very best. I hear their mozzarella is buffalo? Maybe thats the secret!
Great pizza! Not oily like most pizzerias make. Fresh toppings. 👌
Best pizza I ever had. And that’s saying something, trust me.
Im a life long NYC resident and I consider pizza to be the food of the Gods. Salvators must be where they dine when they visit the Earth. Truly great pizza.
Great thin crust pizza... only 14 tables and crowded on weekends... but well worth the wait... oh... also.. CASH ONLY.
WOW one of the best pizza ever 😋
Overpriced and food was just okay.
Typical pizza parlor but the best pizza and sausage calzones on Long Island. Calzone comes with a side of very fresh tomato sause. Brick oven
Their pizza is the best. Enjoy it in the restaurant when its fresh out the oven. Cash only though.
Excellent food with quality ingredients! Top notch and a must try. Its worth a drive even if you dont live in the area.
Food was delicious! I would definitely recommend this place. Location is small, but if you are in the area, I highly recommend.
Incredibly fresh ingredients, large portions and attentive customer service.Only inconvenience is that its CASH ONLY.
Great thin crust pizza, would give 4 stars were it not for parking being very difficult in that area
So lucky I live near this place! 😭
Best Pizza ever. Better than Grimaldis or the original families place next door to Grimaldis in Brooklyn
Decent thin crust pizza. Had both pizza Bianco and red sauce. OK. Not wonderful.
Excellent thin pizza. Perfect crust. Delicious roasted pepper salad. Going back tonight!
Love this place! The staff was so helpful and kind. Our waitress was polite and helpful. This place was a really amazing.
Pizza great. Garlic flat bread too. Wish place was kept up more
The coal fire pizza 🍕 was top notch a 👍 for Port Washington I drove 40 minutes to get there!!!!
Best Coal Fired Pizza on Long Island and great Eggplant Parm., salads too!
Best pizza in Long Island. Thin crispy crust High quality ingredients
We ate a really teasty pizza with fresh motzarella, a bit basil and artichoke harts.
Best Pizza around. Cash only and no deliverybwhich is a slight pain but its worth the hassle.
Very good pizza, you should only dine in. Always a line and 30 min wait. Cash only.
Quaint, excellent pizza, meatballs, Greek salad. Great service. Loved it!
Good Pizza. Far from the best on Long Island but definitely in the top 10.
Food consistently Delicious. Staff consistently Wonderful.
Pizza was excellent. We had the Meatballs pie. Delicious!
Best pizza in town. Period.
This is authentic pizza place they serve you very large pizzas made in the coal oven
Their pizza is the best in the area. Theyre cash only.
Great pizza - super quick! We have been twice and will go back again.
Friendly service... delicious pizza and stromboli...mozzarella was amazing as well.
Best pizza on li. In my opinion only Johns of bleaker is better.
Great pizza plus other Italian foods
Amazing pizza, and dont skip the garlic bread.
Consistently perfect pizza. Arguably the best pizza on Long Island.
I have been eating NY style pizza for over 50 years and this is one of the WORST pizza Ive ever had.
Absolutely delicious tried a couple of different pies and a calzone
Literally drove an hour, you guys arnt open, change your times on google 8:30 on friday night.
Great pizzas at affordable prices. Recommended!
Great oldschool pizza and sauce is fuggetaboutit.Delish.good eats.
Ordered macaroni and side of meatballs. Very bland and average. Stick with pizza, their specialty.
Cash only fyi
Awesome coal oven pizza! No credit cards and no ATM, so be prepared.
Havent been here in a long time, finally made it back and the food was just subpar, I was completely disappointed.
Fantastic food, great service and a pretty nice place!
Great pizza. Friendly, cozy atmosphere.
Best pizza and sausage rolls on Long Island
Amazing italian style pizza with natural and fresh ingredients!
Pizza in a bag instead of a box? Idk and by the way I would like a slice before committing to a pie!! Samples maybe?
Best pizza around, and Kayanne is an amazing manager.
Best pizza in town, cash only.
One of the best coal oven pizza parlor you can find.
Good unique pizza.
Best pizza i’ve ever eaten,and i have eaten alot of pizza..
Highest quality pizza along with good prices
Nothing like a spectacular pie with my two best friends (the Sams)
Always enjoyable. Great Pizza. ☺
Fresh toppings. Nice crust. Tables are tight.
Not your usual pizza. No slices Excellent pizza
Wow that is some really good pizza.
The pizza is really crispy and the pizza is so fresh.
You have to have the giant pizza slices and add your toppings
Good place but its a shame that still antiquated and dont take cards cash only
Small place but delicious pizza
Amazing - definitely one of the best - really nice & quick service
Salvatores had the best pizza in Port.
Absolutely awesome brick oven pizza!!!!!!!! Try the white pie......
The most delicious pizza in the country
One word. YES.
Best pizza I have ever had
Best pizzaAuthentic italian style
You wait a lot you pay a lot and then you love it even more.
Didnt really taste like much to us.
Great tasting pizza and tasty salad
Great pizza in a basic setting.
The pizza is the best I have ever tried
Quality food for a good price
Best pizza on long island!
Great place, great food. Closed on Mondays.
Good staff! Okay food, nothing special.
Best pizza on Long Island!
Arguably the best pizza in Port Washington
Great food. Friendly service.
Best pizza on the island.
Best pizza in Port Washington area
The best pizza in NY!
Not kid friendly in a neighborhood like Port Washington.
Best pizza on Long Island
Great pizza and eggplant!
Wonderful pizza and service
Very good pizza.
Best pizza in NY!!!😍
THE.BEST..PIZZAIN.MY.LIFE.BRAVO.
Amazing brick oven!
Best pizza in the area.
Best calzones ever
Best pizza on planet
Best pizza in town.
Good food
Very good
True Italian crust
Great brick oven pizza
Amazing pizza!
Best Pizza Ever!
Good stuff, good people!
The best pizza. The best pizza...
Good puzza, fast service
Amazing stuff, guaranteed!!
Great pizza!
Great place for a pie...
Pretty great pizza
Ok
Amazing pizza!
Great pizza
Great pizza
Excellent pizza
My favorite !
Fantastic!
Worth the trip
The Best!!!!
Love it!!!!!!!
When I serialize the day I go back to that. People that bring me many memories when I was very young
Italian style Margherita Faja Wonderful ~~
Best sauce sauce
Good food
Total reviews rating 4.6
185 Reviews for Salvatores 2023:
Review №1
2022-06-20Been coming for years and consistently top notch coal fired pizza. Light sauce balanced with fresh mozzarella and lightly charred crust. Every pie made to order, no single slice and cash only establishment.Located in a strip mall off Shore Road and parking tends to be difficult especially during weekend dinner service.
Review №2
2022-04-09The pizza here is consistently great since I first ate here 25 years ago. Just brought home a large pie, garlic bread, chicken roll and eggplant roll and everyone loved it. The eggplant is prepared fantastically! Will be back again more often.
Review №3
2022-04-04I love coal fired pizza, and this place makes a great one.
Review №4
2022-03-06I asked the waitress if they had the condiments for my salad before I ordered, and she told me yes. When my salad came and I asked for the oil, red wine vinegar & balsamic vinegar, she tells me they DONT have it❓Save yourself the time and find another Italian restaurant that carries the basic ingredients.And enjoy your meal.
Review №5
2022-05-03I have been reading about Salvatores for several years, and finally decided to pay a visit. The pizza is otherworldly, The chicken roll spectacular & the meatballs were spot on! Salvatores definitely did not disappoint.
Review №6
2022-06-29Horrible customer service that ended with me having to explain to my crying kid why this large male had forced me to give him the pizza back. I didn’t bring cash, so they asked me to use the website to purchase a pie. I did and paid through credit card. I got an alert with the receipt for my order. I showed it to the manager. But he said he hadn’t received payment. We waited.ñ for it to process. Mind you, I had a crying baby and a whining 4 year old wondering what was taking so long. Time passed and I asked to check again. Nothing. He called “the company” (I’m assuming the credit card merchant company). And they said they haven’t gotten paid. But I had the alert and receipt from Slice Life. I said we’d be leaving in 5 minutes without the pizza and would just call Amex to cancel/ so in 3 minutes he gave me the pizza and collected my number and name in case there was an issue. I walked out. But at this point the baby was hysterical, so I had to feed him outside the car. He then came over to my car and accosted me to give him the pizza. But I said I had a receipt that I paid for it. It was so upsetting to my four year old and the baby was crying that I finally did just give it to him. So I called Amex. And the issue (as I told him) was on their end. It’s the merchant’s responsibility to close out their transactions. When they do it will go through. Mind you, it says it went through already just an hour later. I’ll be reporting the merchant and Salvatore’s to Amex for this. I could not for the life of me understand why we got treated so horribly. I hope the owner sees this and changes their practices and manager.
Review №7
2018-04-05A hidden gem in the Soundview Section of Port Washington, New York. Great coal oven pizza and pasta dishes. Greek salad is awesome. Sausage Pie is a must. No slices, you can only purchase a whole pie. CASH ONLY!!! Easy to see right off of Shore Road. Small parking lot that fills up fast especially on the weekends and at night. Clean facilities with a wheelchair accessible entrance. Public Restrooms. Moderately priced. We will definitely be going back.
Review №8
2019-08-13Fire coal burning pizza, one of the best that Ive had its way better than the bigger names like girmaldis... Super crispy and comes out piping hot. Service is on point really friendly staff. Cash only place though...
Review №9
2021-07-27By far the best pizza on long Island, hands down! Would recommend 11/10
Review №10
2018-05-01This place is a hidden LI gem. How did I not find this place sooner? After 2 years of living in LI, I finally found amazing pizza, on the level of Patsys and Grimaldis. The pizza tastes outstanding, just perfect. Crispy bottom, mozzarella is delicious and the sauce is out of this world. You wont even notice how you will eat 4 slices in minutes. We will prob come here every week now..... So calories, watch out! The best pizza on LI so far. The location is great too as it has parking outside. All other entrées also tastex great, like ziti, French fries, and eggplant parmesan.