No-contact delivery
Yes
Sergimmo Salumeria in New York
Categories
Location on the map
New York, New York County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Highlights
Great coffee
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible car park
No
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Tourists
Yes
Phone: +1 212-967-4212
Site: https://www.sergimmo.com/
Site: https://www.sergimmo.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–7PM
- Tuesday:11AM–7PM
- Wednesday:11AM–7PM
- Thursday:11AM–7PM
- Friday:11AM–7PM
- Saturday:11AM–7PM
- Sunday:11AM–7PM
Sergimmo Salumeria in other cities:
Comments (199)
Great sandwiches with a hometown neighborhood feel. Fast service. Delicious sandwiches and great calamari... And I dont really like calamari! There are a few tables that are nice and cozy. Definitely stop by!
Got to the hotel and checked out for what was the closest Italian joint. Not expecting anything except for great food we went here for a late dinner. Typical hole in the wall. But awseome food and bottle of wine. I am sure partly just the fact it was our first meal in NYC on this trip....but seriously the pasta was awesome. The paninis were awesome. Would be a regular place to go if I lived here.
We randomly found this very nice Italian Restaurant, off-side the crowded main streets and only touristic oriented other restaurants.The stuff is very friendly and helpful.We needed Pasta for carbo-loading for the NYC Marathon 😉We got our Pasta very fast and they cook it fresh. It tastes very delicious and fresh.We can absolutely recommend this fine restaurant!
Authentic and delicious. Inventive sandwich combos.
This spot slays. This is their vegetable panini and it was simple, focused and super tasty. Eggplant, zucchini, marinated mushrooms and broccolini dressed with really nice olive oil. As a meat eater I love trying veg options at new places — if they can make this stuff sing I’m psyched to see what they can do with meat. So bummed I only found out about Sergimmo after working in the neighborhood for 10 years but I’ll be making up for that lost time by eating there regularly from now on.
Excellent place and amazing real Italian food... Best paninis ever! Great staff and good prices. This time I got the special for the day, chicken parmigiana and prosciutto panini. Long time without enjoying a bread like the one they have here. 100% recommended
We only tried two sandwiches (the #3 Emelia Romagnia with prosciutto, mozzarella, spring mix and pesto and the #24 Di Francesca with chicken cutlet, mozzarella, sweet peppers and artichokes) but unfortunately we were not impressed. The bread was tough and the chicken sandwich lacked flavor and had only a single, thin cutlet.I wouldnt write this place off completely but there were other items on the menu that sounded appetizing which I would recommend trying instead.
Everything is great about this place. Delicious food, very fresh and at an affordable price. In addition to having lunch, I ordered a sandwich to take with me and it was amazing.
A legit Italian deli, like I grew up eating at. I had turkey, prosciutto, and fresh mozzarella on a baguette. It was delicious! Everything was fresh and you could taste that theyre using good quality meats. The bread was chewy and crusty, although not my favorite. I liked that it was thin and it had a nice flavor, but I dont like when the breads are super dusty with flour on the outside. Either way, it was a great sandwich! If we werent taking it to go, Id love to have tried a panini. Maybe next time.
Wow - I was in search for some great tasting pasta, and I found some amazing tasting pasta! The sauce was so rich and creamy, the tortellini tasted freshly made - my only regret is finding this restaurant on my last day in New York. The restuarant itself is very clean and the staff is great!
Fresh and delicious Italian sandwiches and homemade mozzarella - what’s not to like?They also have excellent chicken soup.
This feels like the place you’re gonna get whacked. Like you go in, ask for a sandwich and WHACK. You’re swimming with the fishes. Lol I’m just playing. Sergimmo salumeria is great 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 very delicious Sammie’s and it has a ton of other stuff. Place has seating room for your butt.
I had the lasagna was the best tasting I ever had cant wait to go back
Fast and friendly customer service. Excellent selection of paninis made with high quality ingredients. The eating area is kept clean. Easy location to get to from Port Authority. All in all great place with good food presentation at a reasonably price.
The Godfather sandwich was just like my grandma would make... Only better! Fine cuts of beautiful Italian meats, created by hand individually. Think Subway, but a million times better! Fyi, on Sunday it was cash-only when I went
Small shop near Hudson Yards with really good food and good portions. Cant wait to try it again!
Best sandwiches in town!!!High prices though, like everywhere else in NYC!
Fantastic place for Italian food lovers. Sandwiches were very tasty and that bread!!! Ate there twice during our four day stay and will be back when we visit NYC again!
Took 10 min to make one cappuccino and one espresso, and we were the only ones there. When it came the espresso cup was full of coffee grains inside and out. When I politely pointed it out, all they could say way yeah. Also, poor ambiance with the radio blasting. I would not come here again.
Delicious! Friendly staff. Big sandwiches. You do wait a bit for the food, but its worth it. I had the 4. Spouse had the 19.
Authentic and delicious!! I got the number 7 “veneto”. Amazing!!!! Italian subs 😍
Tried it out with my wife and it was great! I then catered with them for work and had glowing reviews! I plan to frequent more often
Although the sandwich filling was generous and ingredients tasty, the panini bread was way too hard, dry, tough and unpalatable. Overall not worth it.
I had the #14 Abruzzo and it was just ok. I should have gotten something with warm soft bread. I was not a fan of chewing hard cold bread. But the meats and cheese were tasty.
I went for panini after reading the review however I am not very impressed
The chicken parm with vodka sauce sandwich is incredible. Everything was fresh and delicious. Cant wait to grab lunch here again.
Amazing food. My go to place when nearby!
Brilliant food, very cheap and friendly waiters - located in the best city in the world!!
My fiancé and I came here 3/13/21 and we enjoyed our food, I had the special of the day which was a chicken parm and my fiancé had a veggie sandwich. We both enjoyed our meals the place was pretty empty he and I and one other person sat in to eat & others came in ordered and left. I’d definitely recommend stopping by if in the area.
Great place to grab a quick bite. Awesome sandwiches! Love coming here!
(December 2020)This is an unassuming place on 9th Avenue, squashed in between a smoke shop and something else. Its very easy to miss and we certainly would have passed by if it hadnt been for a friend stopping in to purchase a salad.The menu is written on the chalkboard wall and seems to cover all sorts of Italian sandwiches under the sun. I was immediately drawn to the fig and prosciutto sandwich - which sounds like an odd pairing-- but worked wonderfully. My partner- although he now cant remember what he ordered-- absolutely loved it as well.We also bought a 1.5 liter San Benedetto ice tea. At $5, it seems pricey, but when we returned to the hotel room to eat, it was an amazing drink! We would actually return to this location to pick up more tea for the trip home.I feel my review doesnt really doesnt really do justice to how great this place is, but I would certainly return in a heartbeat.
Yummy! Extensive menu. Wonderful Italian sodas
Their sandwiches are authentic and creative. I always get the V.I.P sandwich. Their seating area is kind of small but I usually get it to go anyways. Definitely one of the better Italian eateries in the neighborhood. Took my friends from out of town and they loved it.
Luckily, my NYC friend knew this place existed. Fabulous sandwiches. Meat,lettuce,cheese all fresh. Homemade bread. So much to chose from. Recommend highly. Wish it was near me!
Placed an order through GrubHub, never showed up. Can’t speak to the quality of the food since I never received any, but did appreciate the follow up from ownership.
Great filling sandwiches with fresh quality ingredients. If you have time they also serve full meals like pasta dishes. A great spot to go pick up a bite or have a chat and an espresso with the cute owners! Must try!
Had a Sergimmo Speciale Sandwich. Really good and freshGrilled chicken, Gorgonzola and greens on a ciabatta breadThere are 26 sandwiches in the menuAlso, yummy salads and pasta dishes
One of the best Italian delis, and a personal favorite, every time Im in the city.
Simply put, this is one of the best Italian sandwich shops in the city. You can get overwhelmed by the selection of items handwritten in chalk on the wall. Fret not -- just order whatever you want and theyll whip it up. Give serious consideration to keeping it simply with a prosciutto, mozzarella, hot peppers sandwich -- super fresh and reasonably priced. I have also had the lasagna, which is excellent.Although this is primarily a take-out place, there are a few seats available (though at the lunch rush you may have folks waiting in line hovering over you). Credit cards are accepted but cash allows for a slight discount.
Loved the godfather sandwich we got here
Best salads! So big so fresh so tasty and reasonably priced. Authentic Italian! Like people speak Italian there... everyone is so friendly. id eat lunch there every day and not get bored, but will just have to do with twice a week :)
A friend took me here for lunch. The choices were amazing. I decided on a sandwich which was devine right down to the homemade bread. Such a little secret in NYC. Highly recommend.
It was okay. Staff seemed more interested in continuing their conversation In back, rather than taking our order. Up front, the Mozzarella sticks seemed like generic pre-made. The side of sauce saved it from 1 star. The Italian Wedding Soup had some very good ingredients, but it was so heavily salted i couldnt finish it. The selection looks great and Id go back to try something different.
Sergimmo continues to deliver the best traditional Italian foods in Midtown. The bread, sandwiches, fillings, cured meats, and hot dishes are all absolutely delicious. A go-to for all sorts of neighborhood folks, regularly drawing customers from 40 blocks away. Oh man, now Im going to have to go get another sandwich tomorrow 😊
Expensive for what you get. Pasta with ragu at $19 seems to be made with bowtie pasta from a box. Size is regular and the sauce was better than average. The paninis actually appear to be sandwiches on baguettes. The Emilia Romagna had prosciutto and homemade mozzarella at $12. It was decently good, but pricey. Theres a sign saying they dont take credit cards on weekends, which is puzzling considering there wasnt another dine-in patron there on a Saturday night. Theres also a credit card surcharge fee of 4%, which seems like a bad business decision to me because it almost deterred me from trying their food since I almost never carry cash.
Great Italian deli with amazing mozzarella! Had the number 4 Lombardia which was lovely grilled chicken with cheese and all the trimmings. Will definitely be back to try more. A little more expensive than your average sandwich spot but worth it as the ingredients are fresh. Careful at lunch time as it gets busy so know what you want to order! Staff were friendly and the lunch specials sounded great too. Some of the regular customers were on hand with recommendations.
Very good sandwich options. Good service
My rating is a 4.5* because the last time I went there it was a little worse than usual. In general, though, this place has delicious (if expensive) sandwiches with high quality meats and cheese and a fig spread that is so delicious that it makes every other sandwich shop seem inferior. I also like that its always open and it gets extra credit for being so good in a block that largely has forgettable food. Dont worry about the lines during lunch hour, as the service moves fast.
Fast service, sandwich was phenomenal, all ingredients from the bread to the meats, vegetables, and cheese were top notch. Pricing on the higher end, but in my opinion, worth it. Eat in or to go, cash only on weekends. Will return for lunch when working in the area.
I only wish there was a place this magical in the city i live in. With their artisan made meats, cheeses, and their to die for pastas, you wont regret coming here! The great food is matched with quick and friendly service even during a busy lunch time. In the event I get another opportunity to go back to New York, Ill definitely be making a stop here ;)
$14 sandwich. After tax and tip its $20. Good but not great.
Took my Italian uncle (RIP UnclePete) here—he is VERY picky about what’s “truly Italian”—and this place made the list. He loved it (as did I). Super fresh ingredients, nice staff. Couldn’t ask for more.
They got the best sandwiches in western midtown. Watch out for the lunch rush!
Got to the hotel and checked out for what was the closest Italian joint. Not expecting anything except for great food we went here for a late dinner. Typical hole in the wall. But awseome food and bottle of wine. I am sure partly just the fact it was our first meal in NYC on this trip....but seriously the pasta was awesome. The paninis were awesome. Would be a regular place to go if I lived here.
Amazing service the staff members were so kind, and the VIP panini was to die for! So fresh and the flavours were perfectly matched. I was only in town from Toronto for a day but I will definitely make my way back there the next time Im in NYC.
Fantastic low key Italian with good food, decent mid priced wine - lovely rustic atmosphere, great & reasonably priced option if doing theater in the mid-30s & its better than most of the fine dining Italian spots in theater district. Get a meat & cheese plate, get a salad, most definitely get a cannoli (very fresh cream)
Nice place good food and the owner was extremely nice very pleasant place. I just wish they had bread that was not as hard more soft as an option. Other than that I highly recommend this joint for a delicious sub sandwich.
Very good sandwiches in a new, clean upscale deli. The sandwiches and side items are a solid 4.5 stars. The service is fast and the prices are reasonable. Expect to pay about $12/pp for lunch.
Excellent sandwiches in quality bread - this was our first stop for a meal in NYC, and it was exactly as Id hoped.
I was in the city on business and found this deli and tried it out. It was close to closing when I ordered my meal to go but all in all it was very good. I guess I expected more of the Italian experience but it was close to closing so I understand. The meal tasted very good and the staff very friendly. I will be definitely try again. Thanks.
Fantastic paninis. The bread is delicious and the mozzarella cheese is as fresh as it gets. Service is very fast. Great lunch spot if you want to stay or youre on the go.
Excellent sandwiches in Hells Kitchen. A popular lunch time spot. Always busy. Not much sitting room. I usually get a sandwich to go because Im not interested in fighting for a table. Highly recommended.
We have been impatiently waiting for Sergio and Mossimo to reopen this Deli in Queens since Strawberry Farms caught fire.Great location, Family hospitality, AMAZING quality meats, breads, and cheeses. There is none who makes a better tasting homemade mozzarella around the neighborhood... Prices are not or out this world for what you get... BUT DONT FORGET YOUR CASH, NO CREDIT.
The chicken pesto panini + balsamic vinegar was amazing here. It was definitely filling enough and the mozz was so so so fresh and delicious. What a refreshing lunch that didnt boggle down me too much into a slump. If I worked near here, I totally would get this for lunch almost everyday, theres so much to choose from - next time I should try their pastas. It was a bit confusing when coming in for a lunch rush - youre supposed to line up at the place opposite the fridges and then pay at the register on the right upon the entrance. They should probably invest in some signs so that Im not like a crazy person in a crowd..They call your name when they get to your receipt and you pay at the register. They also have a discount if you use cash!
My boyfriend and I LOVE this place. We rarely visit places twice, but Sergimmo Salumeria has us coming back time and time again! Their meats and veggies are always fresh and delicious! Friendly and quick service, and the place is always so clean!
We were looking for an Italian restaurant within walking distance of Penn Station. So glad we decided on this location. My Panini (#7) was amazing (soppressata, fresh mozzarella, hot peppers, arugula). My wife and our friend both had Pasta Al Pomodoro with an added meatball and were both equally enthusiastic about this restaurant. Add to that a reasonably priced bottle of wine and a relaxing unpretentious environment and this place is an easy 5 star rating.
Really good little deli. The vodka sauce and the meat, cheese, etc. are top-knotch. I got the chicken parm sandwich and it had some kind of prosciutto on it with mozz and a vodka sauce (daily special). I was full for hours! Please be aware that on weekends, they dont take cards. Thats really inconvenient and I think they should change their policies because its turning away customers.
Love Sergimmos. Real Italian sandwiches. Havent had much else on menu but antipasti and pastas always look delicious too. Sometimes busy in lunch rush but well worth the short waits!
Recommended by someone I know from work; fantastic! Im sorry I didnt discover this place years ago. Large sandwiches, high quality, absolutely delicious. Ill be back.
I seriously want to buy this place and bring it to DC with me. Simply fantastic. I wish i could rate this place 6 stars.I had read many excellent reviews on this place and decided to give it a shot. The better part was that I decided to buy food for 5 people from here and bring it 200 miles back to DC with me. The staff was great and packed everything well. They even had the courtesy to separate the cream from the cannolis so they would not get soggy (which worked out great). Needless to say, the comments were:The regular lasagna - amazingThe vegetarian lasagna - Unlike other vegetarian lasagnas Ive had. This is the best ever madeThe cannolis - these are the best cannolis Ive ever had in my life! The cream IS PERFECT!!!!Baked ziti - ExcellentThe Il Vip - excellent chicken, fresh pesto! :)Uber bonus: It is 3 blocks from Penn station. This means you can grab a few plates of food to go and bring it with you.
Everything here is so fresh and delicious. I think the best day of my life involved the freshly made mozzarella from Sergimmos. Definitely my favorite lunch spot in midtown - it feels like an oasis!
If you ask me, I would say this is one of the best Italian sandwich restaurant there is in NYC, literally! The moment you step foot through those doors, you automatically feel like you are transported to Italy, but in midtown. The place may be a bit tight and packed, but I can assure you that their sandwiches are way better than supreme, its beyond supreme! To order is quite simple: look through their GIANT chalked-wall menu, head to one of the counters to place your order, pay from the other counter, step aside and wait until your name is called, pick up and enjoy! I ordered the Di Franchesca (#24), which consists of fried chicken cutlet, mozz, sweet peppers, artichokes, EVOO on their signature bread, and crema di balsamic. There is no doubt that I downed it all, but its just that good even though it might seem like it can be a two person meal. You can taste the freshness of each layer and best of all, most of the ingredients are made in house, or imported directly from Italy. You are not limited to only sandwiches since they serve other Italian dishes, but to go for the full experience, you might as well get the sandwiches instead! Definitely heading back there even if the wait can be long!
Located near many of NYs theatre rehearsal studios, as well as near Penn Station, this is one of my very favorite lunch spots. I usually pick up one of their panini, which are sizable, but not grossly overstuffed: fresh, chewy bread, with fresh meats and delicious homemade mozzarella.My go-to is the Veneto, #7: the sopressata is thinly-sliced and nearly melts in the mouth, and comes dressed with the aforementioned mozzarella, sliced hot Italian red peppers, and a drizzle of balsamic vinaigrette.If you have a companion, try splitting the antipasto plate. Everything is fresh and full-flavored.Even though there is usually a line, service is very quick and efficient, and you wont wait longer than a minute or two to order. Once you do, the order is filled very quickly.The interior is neatly and rustically decorated. Seating can be hard to come by. I usually get my order to go: there are some outdoor tables diagonally opposite the place, at 36th and 9th, overlooking the scenic on-ramp to the Lincoln Tunnel (in good weather, its actually quite pleasant). Or walk a few more blocks to Hudson Yards and the river.
Having come to from Texas, I greatly appreciated that showing proof of vaccination was required in order to dine-in. I felt very safe. Thank you.
My wife and I ordered the vongole pasta and penne a la vodka. The pasta was really delicious but we wish the portions were just a bit bigger but I definitely understand that this is normal size for restaurants in the city~
Great Italian deli sandwiches!
My favorite sandwiches on the planet, hands down. Really good, fresh pasta dishes as well. Its out of the way for me, but worth the time to go.
Good spot for classic Italian sandwiches and pasta dishes.
One of the best sandwiches Ive ever eaten. Period. Unbelievably good meats, rustic bread, and cheese. Good Italian pasta dishes too. Try the arincini.
This place is the real deal. Great bread and meat. I always get the VIP. It might be the obvious choice on the menu but I always get a craving for it. Fast service and good selection.
One of the fun things about moving to a new neighborhood is that you get to go on a food rampage and try out all the restaurants around you. I was looking around Yelp for a legitimate sandwich spot in the area, and Sergimmo Salumeria popped up. This place had some pretty solid reviews, so I figured I might as well check this place out.Sergimmo Salumeria is a straight up Italian spot. If youre looking for something like Subway, then you might as well go to the corner deli instead. Prices here arent cheap either. A sandwich will run you anywhere from $12-15, depending on the sandwich that you get. The spot itself is pretty small, but does have enough seating since most people either get it delivered or to go.The first time I came here, I went with the Massimo il Grande. For $10.50, my sandwich was loaded with grilled chicken, mozzarella, sun dried tomatoes, and Arcadian mix. To top it off, all their sandwiches are sprinkled with balsamic vinegar and olive oil. This sandwich, I must say, was pretty damn good. The chicken did not taste like it just came out of a plastic bag, and everything tasted incredibly fresh. For lunch, this is a perfect portion. Juicy chicken, fresh veggies, and flavorful spices. What more can you ask for?Well, if you want something a little more unique, order the Il VIP. This is a little more expensive, at $14, but this is their specialty sandwich. Inside, youll find: Prosciutto Di Parma, mozzarella, Arcadian mix, EV olive oil and fig spread. Pretty unique mix for a sandwich, and yes, it does taste amazing. If youre looking for a sweeter sandwich, then definitely go with this, because the fig spread gives it that kick. If youre looking for something a little more savory, or with more substance, then Id recommend going with a sandwich with more meat, or even their regular pasta entrees.Say you want to make your own sandwich at home. Well, at Sergimmo Salumeria, you can buy meat by the pound, and even bread. The best part? The also have home made mozzarella. This place fires on all cylinders. The sandwiches are solid, the meats and cheese that they sell taste amazing, and all of that justifies the price that they charge. Lunch on a budget? Go somewhere else. Otherwise, this place is an amazing choice for getting a meal.
Tried the Veneto sandwhich... wow! This was a well portioned sandwhich, made with fresh slices of meat and cheese. I would recommend sharing or saving a half if you dont have a large appetite. The rainbow cookie was also delicious, a nice balance of chocolate, jam and cake.
Dont go to Italy. No money spend need to be involved for a trip. Just visit this place to eat a REAL Italian food )))) no regret at all. Small, cozy, family-owned.
Get the #1 Proscuitto w fresh mozzarella and fig spread. Its $14 but you wont be disappointed. Pricey but so worth it. I couldve eaten the whole thing but frankly i liked it so much i took the other half home to eat later. This is probably the best deli sandwich ive had in nyc.
Huge, brick-like sandwiches, made-to-order with fresh ingredients! The Il VIP is a fantastic sandwich that could almost feed two people. Their parmigiana sandwiches are also fantastic!
The Food is always fantastic there. If you like fresh non processed food this place is for you.
Outstanding rustic Italian pasta and paninis in a no-frills, casual environment. The bologenese is outstanding, and the pasta is perfectly cooked. The sizes are generous, and youll need a nap (or espresso) after lunch.
The Best sandwich in New York! You want to go somewhere else... forget about it; this place is amazing. You wont regret it. The Umbria is highly recommended :)
Food was good I would recommend this place
I had heard about this place from my colleagues, but never believed it could be real. Delicious italian sandwiches, high quality meat, and fresh cheese all in a little, obscure Italian deli? Oh, its real. I indulged in #15, the Lazio, with Chorizo, provolone, Arcadian mix, olive spread. This sandwich was unlike anything Ive had before. I may even say its the best Ive had in the city. I also ordered an arancini ball, which was so creamy and cheesy. The side of marinara was clearly fresh and homemade.I will be back, again and again. I only wish I had discovered it sooner.
Chicken parm with prosciutto special was delishhhhhhh
Fast, courteous, service and EXCELLENT quality food. Chicken parm sandwich was on amazing bread and my significant others salad was made to order and very fresh.
I love the paninis here!! Haven’t tried the pastas yet, but if you’re looking for a crispy panini with great tasting and quality meats this is the place.
If you love mozzarella, this is the place to go. $16 for a sandwich. WORTH IT. All the ingredients are made in house and you can taste it.
Really great sandwiches, year after year. Quality ingredients and a bit of old-world charm in a neighborhood with few outstanding eateries.
What a #midtownlunch gold mind just blocks from the office. The old world charm of meat hung about and a chalkboard menu are enough to make anyone a believer that this place is for real! The Veneto w/ Soppresetto is off the charts amazing and can be enhanced with Prosciuto and sweet peppers to balance out the hot and tangy. The best sandwich in the lot however is the Massimo il Grande! Trust me its a stand out among gold stars! Everything in here is fresh to a fault. The lines get very long at lunch and even a call ahead order isnt completed until you show up. That can be a bit annoying but I assure you the wait is well worth it. Youll forgive any wait after the 1st bite! One of my @NewForkCityNY top picks for westside eateries in Midtown!
This place has great sandwiches, great bread and great meat. I have had a bunch of different one and on my last visit had a chicken parm, if it had more sauce it would had been great.
Amazing italian food. Located in the working area of Manhattan. I absolutely recommend their lasagna and panini of the day (the hot one).
I got a Veneto Panini for lunch; it is $9 but it is HUGE!There was plenty of mozzarella cheese, red peppers and Sopressata. I just finished half of it and I am stuffed!The mozzarella is really fresh and the Sopressata was spicy and flavorful.I want to try all different sandwiches on their menu :)
Delicious Italian paninis, with exceptionally fresh bread, meats, and cheeses. Maybe the best little restaurant near Javits.Post script: try the multi colored rainbow cookies. So good!
BestSandwichesEverThe veggies are covered in amazing sauces and everything is freshHave gone many times
Tomato sauce is too sweet; pasta is otherwise homestyle comfort food. Meat and cheese plates are probably the way to go. Credit cards oddly not accepted over the weekend.
Great lunch spot. Authentic, delicious Italian eats and some of the best sandwiches in the city. Whatever you get, have your mozz smoked and get the sundried tomato spread.
The food is great, but pricey. Expect to easily pay $12 for a take-out sandwich. The interior is cozy, but the seating is very limited.
Some of the best Italian authentic sandwiches and paninis in this part of the city
Place is dope, all the fixins. Even have Italian radio playing inside
My favorite sandwich shop, I’ve been here over 50 times. Each sandwich on the menu is delicious. One of NYC’s gems!
What a tremendous selection of great food! We found this through Yelp and were exceptionally surprised at the value. The food was tasty, the service quick and the place was very clean. Well be back!
VIP sandwich had nice ingredients but the rather tough bread and chewy proscuitto resulted in a sandwich requiring a bit of effort to eat. Flavors were great though.
Paid 15 dollars for a salad literally thrown together that I could have made at home. It was not worth it at all
Had Penne a la matriciana - the pasta was well done and the sauce good, but not particularly memorable - a decent grinding of fresh black pepper would have helped.
Food is awesome here... Be it the legendary meat lasagna or one of the awesome sandwiches (especially il vip)... or the canoli... You will enjoy food here. The staff is super friendly too...
Great food and good portions. Fills up fast, so get there early (or later) for a seat. Take out is always an option.
Great service authentic recipes for real Italian deli food and good coffee to boot pun intendedPricing reasonable as well
Very good lunch spot. Only had the sandwiches but they are big and great. Never had a bad experience
I love this place! The food is delicious and authentic. Weekends are cash only, but they charge less all week if you pay cash
Order was wrong. Could care less. Girl behind the counter was rude and didnt want to give us silverware because they gave us paninis instead of platters. Never will go back for these reasons.
Definitely not your Italian - American deli but rather something that is truly Italian. Excellent ingredients, portions that can be split and mouth-watering looking entrees.
Favorite sandwiches in NYC. My company has been ordering for here for groups for years. Everyone loves them!
Gimme gimme a good panini. Great sandwiches and the specials are usually the best choice. Truly one of the best.
Mouthwatering Italian sandwiches – our favorites are the Il VIP, The Trentino, Marche and Abruzzo. Make sure to browse their various bars as well.
A cozy place with real Italian options. Highly recommended for a small group looking for good pasta and sandwiches!
Nice sandwiches, mine was a bit dry but overall good sandwiches!
Probably the best sandwich I have had .. the VIP... prosciutto, fig spread, fresh mozz, etc !!! very very good !
Very tasty Italian paninis... Fast service and nice seating area! Great for a quick lunch break!
Great panini. They came around with fresh warm mozzarella to taste.Cash only on the weekend.
Awesome! Had the Veneto and added capicola
This place is the real deal! Great pastas, divine cannolis and yummy sandwiches. Everyone is friendly with excellent service.
First rate Italian sandwiches.
The best sandwiches Ive ever tried! The service is always great too.
Sandwich contents are spectacular and the service is ultra friendly, but some bread variation would be great
Superb Italian sandwiches made on the spot from fresh ingredients - fair prices considering the quality and size
Lovely quality. everything was good. the bread, the soup. everything
My first time eating there had the best Chicken Parmigiana sandwich! This is the real deal!
Excellent! Nicely portioned
Delicious italian paninis!!! Small cafe setting. Cant go wrong.
This place made our trip! Last night of our stay. Definitely the best food we ate on the trip.
The food is excellent anf the staff is friendly. The Paninis are deliscious as well as the pasta dishes.
Great sandwich amazing quality meats..only gripe was a little too much balsamic.
Amazing sandwiches!
Was good one. Works in weekend
Good quality ingredients, but I dont understand how they can sell bread this hard and people keep coming back. Im missing something. Pricey too.
Great sandwiches 🥪 and amazing expresso
Great spot for quick sandwiches or pasta!
Recommended for visit if you miss the Italian home food.Nice prosciutto and wine.
Only one in the store and didn’t acknowledge me for 5 min. Called ahead and when I got there he hasn’t even started making the sandwich.
Superb! The food brought me back to Europe! Ordered bolognese and matrichiana and they’re both delicious!
Damn, that was amazing and popular. If you get a chance you should not miss this one. I will definitely be back and willing to walk out of the way for the great food.
%100 recommended!
Delicious homemade pasta. Great panini. Italian radio station playing in the background. Friendly, casual.
Great sandwich, long line at lunch
Best paninis. A fresh quality sandwich. Good customer service.
One of the best sandwiches you can get in midtown. Worth the wait.
Excellent Italian bistro. Large choice of panini, good salads
Nice little deli close to Penn Station. Nice place to sit and have a glass of wine killing time.
Great lunch spot - Authentic Italian food simple place and fair prices.
Prices are higher than listed here. Pasta bolognese 20$ Food good.
The cherry peppers with mozzarella were excellent. Great service and great food.
ViP is one of the best Italian heros in Hells Kitchen period
Excellent, quality food! One of the best lattes Ive ever had!
Quick/ fresh and best Italian deli shop with great sandwiches and pasta
Try a plate from their deli, amazing fresh food. We had one to share.
Best coffee in NYC.... by a long way.... Excellent panini, pizza and pasta.
The pan fried mozzarella sandwich with truffle oil was out of this world. Ill never diet again.
Great sandwichs, bread was covered in too much flour though
Ive tried their chicken salad and lambardia - both are super delish😋
Great paninis, good pasta, fulfilling salads, excellent cold cuts.
Awesome paninis! Tasty salted meats and fresh mozzarella
Paninis were $13 each, but very good.
The best Tortellini Ive had in a very, very long time!
Amazing food, great service and wonderful staff, very friendly
Tasty sandwiches!
This place has the best sandwiches.
Im from Wisconsin and hit this place when in town. Awesome food.
Amazing panini
Great food.great place to eat and resanable price s
Excellent sandwiches! Felt like I was back in Italy!
Great sandwich, loved the fig spread.
Best Italian sandwich shop in Manhattan.
Very good sandwiches and excellent service
Excellent food, very reasonably priced, stuffed silly...
Awesome selection!! Great taste, and service!!
Phenomenal sandwiches! Expensive, but some of the best, anywhere.
Good paninis, kinda small and crammed
Great place...I visit NYC yearly and will add this to my favorite places to visit while here.
Great food, small cozy atmosphere.
This place is amazing! Worth going out of your way to try!!
One of the best Spaghetti Bolognese Ive had..
Great food, great service and a great place to have a conversation
Total reviews rating 4.6
199 Reviews for Sergimmo Salumeria 2023:
Review №1
2022-05-31I had the most delicious sandwich here. The Panini of the Day was chicken with vodka sauce and prosciutto. I hope this restaurant puts this sandwich on the regular menu. I will hope to stop by this place again soon and experience this shop’s amazing food. The prices are very reasonable and the seating area is small but inviting.
Review №2
2022-04-19Omg!! I love this place. I just popped in for lunch today as we got take out quickly and met the owner - Massimo. He was so kind to tell us about his wonderful store, he’s been there for about 15 years and has done a lot to make sure he did not close thru the pandemic. And man… I’m so glad he didn’t!!!Everything is so beautiful and handmade… and omg… DELICIOUS!! We will definitely be back here in a regular basis when in town. I’m so glad we stopped in today. He has handwritten his menu on the walls and handmade the bread and cannolis… and they were OUT OF THIS WORLD.A must stop in for a reasonably priced and very delicious treat. DEFINITELY GET THR CANOLLI….
Review №3
2022-04-17Great spot for a light lunch.Just a quick walk from Penn, this Italian sandwich shop is a must try. I had the IL VIP (number 1) and was very satisfied.The sliced prosciutto di Parma, mozzarella, and fresh bread were a great combo but were only made better with the crown jewel of the sandwiche... fig spread! The contrast between the salty of the prosciutto and the sweetness of the fig spread was strong and made the sandwhich have real flavor.With so much on the menu, and such quality ingredients; I know ill be back soon. Thanks for the great food!
Review №4
2021-08-18I ordered the godfather which comes with three deli meats: sopressata, prosciutto, cappiocolla. the meat was of a very high quality. the flavors were perfectly balanced with the fresh mozzarella, bell peppers, and mixed greens. all of their ingredients are fresh. the only qualm i had was that bread was a little bit stiff/hard to bite through (but i’m no sandwich expert so maybe that’s how it should be?).
Review №5
2022-08-12The sandwiches are really overpriced for what you get. The bread is dry and the cured meats are normal without being exceptional.The staff is really nice but not the owner, who is quite scary and rough.All in all, this feels more than a tourist trap than a good sandwich restaurant.
Review №6
2022-09-01The most phenomenal italian food youll find in NYC. Best vodka pasta Ive ever had! The place was so warm and inviting! Would recommend it to anyone!
Review №7
2022-06-07Oh man, its been too long since I have been here. But a short walk from Penn Station to incredible paninis. The VIP has excellent prosciutto, delicious mozzarella, and a perfect spritz of fig spread on not too hard/not too soft panini. Simplicity and perfection.
Review №8
2022-06-29Just ok in my opinion. The ziti and meatballs was dry and barely warm.
Review №9
2022-05-29Nice little spot for an Italian sandwich. All the ingredients were well balanced and complemented each other. Would love to try their pasta soon.
Review №10
2018-12-07The sandwich was good, but it was missing meat! The chicken was fresh and had enough of it(not the thickest cut) the speck(smoked prosciutto) was too little of it. If they had put more meat in the sandwich I would’ve given it 5stars. The bread was really hard for my taste including the inside part of it. For the price I expect to get more!