Kerbside pickup
Yes
Siena Pizza in New York
Categories
Location on the map
New York, New York County, New York, US
Service options
No-contact delivery
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Mask required
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Payments
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Phone: +1 212-406-0918
Site: http://www.sienapizzanyc.com/
Site: http://www.sienapizzanyc.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–11PM
- Tuesday:11AM–11PM
- Wednesday:11AM–11PM
- Thursday:11AM–12AM
- Friday:11AM–12AM
- Saturday:12PM–12AM
- Sunday:Closed
Siena Pizza in other cities:
Comments (186)
This place has excellent pizza!The bottom is nice and crunchy, toppings are just enough and balanced.
Out of all the pizza places I visited in New York this is the only place that reheats their pizza for you in their pizza oven. Their pizza isnt oily/greasy which is good and their crust is even betterThe hot honey slice was my favorite and I highly recommend it.
This place is at the perfect location, next to my hotel, its really nice to know that even late I cab get a slice of that delicious pizza, the vodka was by far my favorite, I definitely recommend to try this, and they even have desserts, a slice is enough to fulfill your expectations but if you need more, be brave
Delicious delicious pizza! A little overpriced but I didnt mind paying it to show my boyfriends daughter what NY pizza is supposed to taste like. Clean space, not mush seating but we enjoyed eating at the bar facing the street - free advertisement for the joint.
Honestly, the best pizza I had during my stay in NYC. And not just because it was right around my hotel. The crust is thin, but firm and crispy. Its cheap and delicious. The staff gets your pizza quick, so youre never waiting for long. Over a 7 day period I got a slice 4 times here. Worth a visit, even if youre staying somewhere uptown.
Great little pizza place that was conveniently right next to our hotel. We went here multiple times, got a variety of flavors. I prefer the thin crust over the deep dish, but both were good! Totally had that solid crispy and soft crust thing I came for!
The first thing I notice was the delicious smell in the air that hits you right as you open the door. then display caught my eye. In the glass display you can see all different pizza pies. I asked what was the freshest. He said they were only a few minutes apart. I believe him because all looked fresh. Pizza looks dry when it has been sitting. This made it so difficult to pick. I settled for the margarita slice. We also got the Chiken parmesan sandwich. The food was super fresh. I got motazarella sticks. It was crunchy on the outside and deliciously googy looked at picture anside. The pizza was niece and thin and savory and delicious. So good am smiling thinking about it. Each bite was experience in my mouth. The sandwich was so big I could not open my mouth wide enough to bite it. The sandwich was very very good. But the pizza was beyond amazing. I also had a cannoli . I decide to try the white chocolate and raspberry filling. I recommend 100% . The outer chell was niece and crispy.Not many places left in New Your that serve this quality of pizza. The place was uber clean too.The service was great.Siena is on Rector street right of the 1 and 9 train. Only a few blocks away from the world Traid Center Memorial so if you In the area go visit.
One of the best NY pizza joints on the lower side. Fast and respectful, as well as the pie tasting top notch. Had my 3 kids with me and it was a wonderful experience. They even ate their crusts!
We were only in NYC for two days, but stopped here twice! The pizza was fresh and tasty, service was fast and friendly, and the cannolis were amazing!
Sooo good! Tried the Buffalo chicken and bacon ranch, nice and crunchy!
Some of the best pizza Ive ever had!! The thin ones and the square were both great! Add some of their hot honey for a good flavor addition! Place was clean and service was fast!
Pizza could have been so good, but person manning the oven was in too much of a rush. All the pieces our party of four received were still cold, especially the thick slices, but even the thin were barely warm. To packed to complain, just dont think well be back.
Got a slice to go like 10minutes ago. I should have walked out instead. When I entered the guys at the counter ignored us. Didnt say hello or acknowledge us. The one guy finally said hello and asked what we wanted. He had an attitude. He finally took our order. Got to our room to eat. The pizza was okay. Had better.
Damon and met the owner Ari, had a great conversation.Came back for lunche and dinner the next 2 days because he was such a nice guy and their pizza was so amazing.We especially enjoyed the hot honey baby deep dish!
The Pepperoni Squares are absolutely immaculate. It is one of my most favorite pizzas ever. So stupidly crisp. Those pepperonis sliced my mouth to shreds and I said thank you and immediately bought another.
Great place to grab a quick slice. I enjoy the upside down and vodka slices most. Havent had neopolitan there, just Sicilian. Will be back to get freshly prepared canolis
Absolutely delicious! Staff are friendly and the food was great.
We love ❤️ Siena Pizza!! Great quality. Friendly service. Great environment. The canolis are always fresh and perfectly sweet too!!
Such a delicious pizza and affordable, would totally recommend
This is the most amazing pizza we’ve EVER had! We tried the buffalo chicken pizza and the quality was out of this world! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!!
A solid option to grab a pie or cannoli. They offer equal kinds of regular slice and sicilian style square pizza. The later was the crispy, not the soft type of crust. The seasoning is a bit sweet in general. The cannoli is home style not overly fancy. Overall a nice place to get a quick meal or sweet.
Excellent choice for a quick “on the go” meal but they also have inside seating available. The pizza is very fresh and tasty!
Really excellent pizza at a reasonable price, the toppings selection on deep dish slices is simply phenomenal
We each ordered a slice of pepperoni and a slice of Buffalo Cicken pizza. Both were delicious the staff were also super nice and friendly. The price is completely ok and the pizza was nice and warm we will be back
I have eaten here a few times and always had great pizza. Can get a little pricey, but its to be expected being in the city. Worth the cost though.
Great taste pizza crunchy - Italian sausages w/broccoli rabe thin crust!! Only $5/ slice
Best Pizza around. Cozy sit down area. Amazing pepperoni slice and Buffalo chicken slice. Definitely recommend this place.
Most incredible pizza I’ve EVER had!! There are no words for that cannoli pure LOVE!!!
Excellent pizza! I had the nonnas and the regular pepperoni. 5 minute wait time from in the door to pizza in hand.
Hands down, then best pizza slice around. If you haven’t had the hot honey slice you are missing out!
New York style pizza by the slice. Best garlic knots ever!! Huge slices for a great price.
Went there during the memorial day weekend. Was bit expensive than what we thought, but pizza was fairly decent. We tried honey and barbecue chicken pizzas. I am keeping it to 3 stars since it wasnt as delicious as other pizzas we tried in NYC. Also the crust was thick and soft - we would have preferred the thin crispy crust.Customer service was good. Both the employees were attentive and were able to help with the choices. If you are going to spend $5 per slice, there are better pizza places in the city.
One of my favorite pizza places downtown especially the hot honey square slice.
The variety of pizzas and other menu items was great. The pizza was crispy on the bottom and soft through out. Flavorful. The wings were big and delicious. This is NOT YOUR AVERAGE PIZZERIA. o highly recommend it. Will return definitely. By the way, price was reasonable
Extremely good pizza with nice sitting areas. The best!
Oh man, what a pizza!!! Delicious, toppings to the right proportion on the square pizza and good music.
Their garlic knots with marinara sauce and their square pepperoni slice is amazing...my regular go to order
Ok to grab a quick bite to eat, but we had better for less money.
Absolutely the best!Im from the west coast and Sienna Pizza was the first place that I tasted NY Pizza!I got a simple cheese slice and was happy from the first crunchy bite! My kids got deep dish pepperoni, and my husband got chicken and ranch, I believe!Place was nice and clean. Staff was very friendly!Covid protocols in place including request for Vax card. We also enjoyed a cupped tiramisu.
Good pizza and the cannolis omg so good! Outstanding onwers! you guys make 6 stars now on!
Delicious pizza & great service.
Delicious pizza. Fast service. Reasonable pricing.
Below average pizza. Tasted super bland and rude workers. Garlic knots were super cold.
Great pizza, great salads, great cannolis! 10/10 definitely recommend.
Some of the best pizza Ive ever had. The quality is perfect and absolutely delicious. The staff are upbeat, kind, and easy to communicate with. The crunch with pizza will have you coming back quickly. This is a must visit when you are nearby.
Delicious pizza but wished they could do better at customer service one guy was very patient the other had a terrible mood.
Stayed near this place when visited NYC, first food we got and was AMAZING,,, must have visited three or four times more in our short stay
Perfect New York style Pizza!
Good pizza, very pleasantly surprised. There are tons of pizza joints in the neighborhood, many of them quite average, so it can be hard to pick out the good ones. This place is clearly different, with a garlicky sauce that isnt too sweet like the other guys and pepperoni with that nice roni cup look, taste, and char. A new go-to, very happy that theyre here.
Limited but amazing options. Great pizza to-go or sit-in.
Just moved in around the corner and came in here when I needed a quick dinner. I am so surprised and delighted by how good this pizza is!!! I had the square pepperoni which was a bit pricier than a regular slice but worth it since they are quite thick and very filling. It seems like a new spot, as I don’t remember it being here when I worked around the corner pre-covid. It’s a cute, clean little place. Highly recommend! This is my new go-to for picking up a slice/ordering pizza.
Great slices of pizza! The staff is very welcoming and offers tasty recommendations!
Phenomenal pizza and definitely my go to spot. Give the sausage slice a try, you won’t regret it.
Restaurant is very clean, the style is a comforting combination of old-fashioned counter service with a fashionable and modern design! I’m very impressed by their check in form for customers who choose to dine indoors - they checked my temperature using a contactless thermometer and had me sign in with the date, time, my name and contact info. Great set up for contact tracing if needed. $3 feels like too much for a slice, but good value for the service provided. I’m glad I work nearby 😋🍕
Very nice interior, the display of food is amazing. Even my colleague ordered another slice because of the presentation of one of the slices (forgot the name). Taste and quality is amazing, no complaints.
We got the cheese pizza, the pepperoni square and the cacio e Pepe they were all amazing!!!! I would highly recommend this if you are looking for great pizza! The cannoli we weren’t fans of but the pizza made it so worth it.
This place is a find. The selection isnt massive, but they make up for it in quality. Crust is just perfect--never over done. Service is speedy as well. Highly recommend, as its not just an average pizza joint.
Highly recommend the wings they aren’t breaded but they are really good. The Buffalo sauce you can actually see the spices it in. The pizza was also good too!
Really high quality pizzas. Unique specialty slices. The cannolis are so good too! Ohhh and the chicken parm on focaccia is out of the world.
This place is amazing. I loved their pizza especially the birria pizza.
Great pizza! The hot honey slice with sopressata and provolone ($5 + tax) is tasty. The roni cup slice also looks good.
Best pizza we had during our trip. They use high quality ingredients. Definitely get the canoli, the limoncello was delicious.
Tasty pizza and pleasant service. I thought it was funny when my friend asked if that was spinach and they replied yes. It was actually rappini. Italian type of broccoli. Delicious but an acquired taste. Worked for me because she gave all her rappini to me. In my defense it was a delayed realization of the conversation. I wasnt trying to score more rappini.
Quick service, friendly staff. Customers outside telling us how good the pizza is, and it didnt disappoint.
Good toppings (fresh mushrooms and flavorful crumbled sausage), sauce ( vodka pizza), and cheese - but the crust is unexpectedly thick and bland. Do they normally add salt to the dough and forgot this time?
Delicious place! My husband and I are visiting from the Bay Area. Best pizza Ive ever had ( The vodka pizza). Highly recommend and reasonably priced.
Literally the best pizza I’ve ever eaten in my life. Such creative flavor combinations. Following them on Instagram so I am never without.
Friendly staff and and amazing pizza. Very clean in here, going to be our new go-to pizza spot down town
Came here after seeing it Dave Portnoy Barstool Sports. Dave’s rating of 6.4 is about accurate. 8.5 from the community seems a bit high. I was hoping for better but it’s definitely a good pizza.
Amazing pizza! Would have loved a beer/wine if available.
My husband and I came to NYC for a week on vacation. The pizza is amazing and the cannolis are out of this world. I think we’ve eaten here4 times this week.
Quality Pizza For GREAT Prices! During Our Stay In The NY, We Went There Three Times! No Other Pizza Place Near By Compares. I Enjoyed Every Bite Of The Pizza!
One of the best pizza places Ive tried in the city so far. Definitely recommend eating here.
Amazing pizza, a must try !
Really good Pizza! The hot honey slice is amazing.
A little overpriced but tastes great
The pizza was ok, you cant customize a slice or two. You have to order a whole pie if you want say chicken and bacon as toppings.
Best pizza ever!! definitely try it out if you’re in the area! would totally go back again!
Great pizza and the best cannolis. Makes such a difference to have freshly filled cannolis and not pre-made.
It was alright could do better one of the things that definitely stood out and was really good was the honey pizza.
Very nice pizza place! Opens until late hours!Fast good service, well priced
It serves one of the most delicious chicken pizza in town!!! Though the place wasnt too clean and hygienic.
Amazing freshly made Pizza!
Maybe I don’t like NYC pizza, but being from NC, I expected more… no better than Dominos or Marcos
Tried the pepperoni square - delicious!
Amazing pizza! Place had a nice chill vibe and looked clean. Bathrooms available
Delicious pizza, good prices...walking distance to the 9/11 Memorial.
Amazing food. Best pizza downtown. Very nice owner.
Great staff, great food, my favorite place to go when I want pizza.
Big slices for a big price. The Sicilian slices are crazy expensive.
Really good pizza for a very reasonable price! I quite like the indoor seating too!
I didnt try the pizza but the fresh made cannoli was excellent
Best pizza Ive had in my life. Reasonably priced
Good pizza if you want a fast meal. Ask for Mikes hot honey.
Best slice in new york!
No Masks and OD white pepper on the Vodka and Caccio e Pepe. Do not recommend
Buffalo chicken pizza is amazing
NYC pizza. Good to stop on a trip around Battery Park. The Nonna”s is recommended.
I AGREE WITH ALL WHO SAY ITS THE BEST PIZZA THEY EVER HAD...THE GUY WHO COMPLAINED ABOUT MASKS PEES SITTING DOWN...DONT MIND HIM.
Very good place! Cozy and very good pizza!
First time to NYC, first slice of pizza. Did not disappoint!
Great pizza and service
Love coming here, our favorite local spot
Pizza looked yummy, but we ate the cannolis. To die for!!!
Pizza vet decent. Service was excellent.
They have the best pepperoni and the pizza is so delicious.
Very good canolis.
Amazing New York style pizza! Delicious
Great pizza for low cost
Great crew and good pizza
Best New York pizza
Restaurant is clean. Food is good. Vibe is good.
Broccoli rabe sausage!
Amazing pizza in Wall Street Neighborhood!
Great pizza and atmosphere!
Awesome pizza super friendly service!!!!
Amazing pizza
Perfect pizza, very cheesy ❤
Great pizza & cannoli
Amazing taste and its a bang for the buck!
The best service ever!
Pizza is very good
Really amazing
Good
Very good
Nice place to have a pizza 🍕
The best pizza in NY
Extremely good cannoli and pizza
Pizza was great!
Best Pizza!
Great taste!
Great pizza!!!
Rude customer service
Yum
Scrumptious
Pretty good
Great pizza
Excellent!
Delicious!
Great Pizza
This place is delicious. Love the place and the recipes. Hot, quick, delicious, and New York.
Small pizzeria with a nice collection of pizza and salad. The Mozzarella sticks were the best we ever had.
Very good pizza and friendly staff. Fresh pizza is available at any time of the day. To take away or to eat there. Ambiance is clean and tidy
Very nice bistro with delicious food. I ordered 2 pieces of pizza and garlic buns. The portions are really big, so I didnt even eat it for once. Packing one was also great. Fast service. Great
Very tasty pizza. The service is good, the place is clean and they have good customer service, the pizza price is good, it is good price and it is close to the memorial of the twin towers.
Great pizza, nice service, atmosphere fits. PRICES TOP for the quality
Deplorable service, the employees make no effort to help the tourists that we are. The pizzas are not particularly good (extremely peppery)All the prices are not displayed, they dont give the ticket without asking me if I want it, in short, go your way!
Outstanding pizza, I sincerely recommend it. Two delicious pieces for $ 10 :)
The best cannolis Ive ever eaten and exotic and delicious pizzas 😋
Very good pizza, hardly any waiting time. Manhattan usual prices.
The place is clean, the food and prices good. They attend quickly. The only bad thing is that the time I was there, many people were looking for the bathroom. They would just have to put a sign on the door so people dont ask where it is.
Excellent, very good quality and diversity of pizzas
The pizza is not good.I didnt like the dough, the sauce or the cheese.The attention was mediocre.
Pizzas were always ok, you cant moan!
Super tasty pizza.
The pizzas are too delicious 🍕 🤤 I loved it
Excellent pizza. And good music.
The cheese does not taste good and it does not have wifi service
Very tasty pizza from the stone oven at a fair price. Really worth a visit!
Very good pizza. You can buy whole or pieces. Good prices.
Was ok for a bite in between
Excellent food excellent attention exquisite flavors adequate prices thank you very much I will be back
Delicious pizza. Friendly staff and clean place.
Greasy pizza and the boxed one is rude. If you want to avoid a bad time, I did not enter this place
Very varied, there is a bakery inside the premises, you can eat everything.
Delicious pizzas in the heart of historic NYC
Excellent place good attentions
Good place in Fi-Di
So we didnt like it that much.
The pizza was very good.
Delicious
Rich and handy
Excellent pizza 🍕
Very tasty, and friendly staff
Excellent !!!
Good attention and rich food!
Total reviews rating 4.5
186 Reviews for Siena Pizza 2023:
Review №1
2022-05-19Delicious pizza! Stopped by for a quick lunch order and ordered a pepperoni square slice and an upside down slice. Both slices were great! Service was fast, efficient and attentive. Ample seating if you plan on dining in for lunch or a business meeting. Definitely recommended!
Review №2
2022-05-12Excellent pizza. I had the Buffalo chicken and the cheese and they are both really good. The red sauce on the cheese was perfect and the crust had the right crunch to chew ratio. We also had cannolis, one classic and one tiramisu. They were also very tasty. Definitely try this place out if you’re in the area.
Review №3
2022-05-22Clean, fast, great! The pizza is great! One of the best NY style cheese slices I had!The place is super clean, which you not always expect from a slice pizza shop.Totally recommended!
Review №4
2022-05-03Ran into this place on accident & gladly I did! Would definitely return for multiple reasons. I got a regular cheese as a rule of thumb for always trying a new location. A solid slice all around. Love the well done bottom as well as the crisp flavor of cheese.The other slice I bought was the vodka square. This one wasnt to my liking. What I disliked most other than the taste was the sesame seed bottom. Too much for me Im sorry.The reasons why I said Id gladly come back were to try the Canolis mainly. Id also like to give some specialty slices a try.
Review №5
2022-05-27Stumbled across this place and Im glad I did! The Square pepperoni pizza is sooooo good! Highly recommended if you like curl / cup pepperoni. Very clean inside, lots of seats, friendly staff and great quality pizza. Well done.
Review №6
2021-11-22Really delicious wood-fired pizzas! So crispy and buttery yet so light! Minimum or no grease. That’s how NY pizza is supposed to taste like. I’d recommend the pizza squares. Pizza by the slice is like $3-6. It fills you up! I didn’t try the cannolis but they look delicious!
Review №7
2021-09-13Great food and kind people! We bought two cannolis, and they were amazing. We got the Nutella flavour and the chocolate chip flavour, and my wife loved both of them (she likes cannolis more than I do). The pizza also looked phenomenal, but we didnt buy any. Prices seem pretty reasonable, especially for what you get. I wouldnt call them a bargain, but I also wouldnt say that they are overpriced. The food seems pretty authentic with all fresh ingredients, so you cant go wrong with it. We would definitely go again!
Review №8
2022-04-23Absolutely delicious!! 😭🍕 the pepperoni slice is perfect - wood fired, non greasy, a little spice to the pepp., a generous amount of cheese & crunchy goodness! The place is clean, staff is friendly & they have the cutest decor - perfect for any cute date night/late night (closes 11pm) foodie photo op!
Review №9
2022-05-16This restaurant was conveniently located next to our hotel. The pizza was pretty good. The staff was friendly and the service was quick. We’d come again.
Review №10
2022-03-04Excellent cheese slice for 3.50. Better than most dollar slice places. One of the few places where you can find an egg creme.Close to wall st/ bowling green and the charging bull. Among all the places around FiDi for a quick bite, you cant go wrong with this one. They also have a wood burning stone stove instead of electric/gas.