St Lukes Thrift Shop in New York

Review №1

2022-07-27

Here are the general prices for women’s clothes:Shorts: $22 and upBlouses: $25 and upDresses: $40 and upBlazers: $50 and upShoes: most didnt have price tags, so just assume you can’t afford themPurses: $40 and upCostume jewelry: $5 and upHigh end designer rack: $150 and upIt’s a nice clean store, but if you want deals on designer clothes you’re better off shopping on eBay or poshmark which will have better selection. They price their clothes the same as online resellers. They also have no changing room, so there isn’t a benefit to shopping in person here. The cashiers will watch you like hawks the entire time you’re in the store. Every customer a thief until proven otherwise. I guess you could say it’s good that the shop is nonprofit, but does a church sitting on $100 million in west village real estate and paying no property taxes really need your help??

Review №2

2021-12-05

Dont waste your time! Massive disappointment. Are they people who wrote good reviews just not coming on a Saturday? The store employees were rude, unwelcoming and snooty...Cherry picking from donations seems like their dream job why not be pleasant while you are covering yourself in all those rings? Guarantee this store makes double if you kick those two self serving old loafers out. The prices are so high for stuff that is used and damaged. A church thrift shop should be affordable for the community but everything is even more expensive than an antique store why so greedy employees...do these two make a commission?! Is that why prices are so high?

Review №3

2020-10-30

Ive been partaking of this superb thrift shop for many years and it never ceases to enchant. The cozy, small space always has a phenomenal, eclectic selection of things high to low end in great condition and thoughtfully priced to be reasonable deals and absolute steals. Ive gotten many beautiful and useful things there full of charm and character. Whoever does the purchasing for this shop has a great, discernible eye. And do visit and relax in the St. Lukes Garden next door - it is like an exquisite little secret garden and not to be missed.

Review №4

2021-09-15

Don’t expect thrift store prices as there are a lot of special antiques in this shop. Clothing is overpriced for my taste, but I love how much the employees care— it shows and I find that endearing.

Review №5

2017-08-26

Great thrift shop. Huge variety of clothes. This is a nice neighborhood and the clothes they have are gifted by the neighbors. Its all very high quality with a lot of brand names floating around for super cheap prices. The proprietor is incredibly friendly and knows her shop like the back of her hand. Its organized very well and doesnt feel cramped like a lot of NY shops do. Theres no reason not to pop your head in!

Review №6

2020-09-24

Such a nice experience! The ladies in the shop were so nice, and the deals they were offering were right up my cheap alley. Would 10/10 recommend.

Review №7

2021-06-16

So glad to see it open.Curated with an eye towards Designer with a whimsical flair that is in recent and vintage items.

Review №8

2021-05-15

Got the cutest outfit for $20! Super sweet lady working there as well.

Review №9

2018-12-10

Excellent finds abd more fun when they have their brown bag event. I just love the shop even just to browse.

Review №10

2019-01-04

Just a note, great place but has been closed for over 6 months. Last time I walked by (Jan 2019) it was entirely gutted. No idea when they will open again.