Delivery
Yes
Stanleys Bakery in East Islip
Categories
Location on the map
East Islip, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
In-store pick-up
Yes
In-store shopping
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
No
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Dining options
Breakfast
Yes
Planning
Quick visit
Yes
Phone: +1 631-581-1230
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:6AM–6PM
- Wednesday:6AM–6PM
- Thursday:6AM–6PM
- Friday:6AM–6PM
- Saturday:6AM–6PM
- Sunday:6AM–5PM
Comments (199)
My Wedding Cake was made from here almost 38 years ago and still amazing after all this time, my personal favorite is there cinnamon raisin bread besides all there items they sell!!!!
A fantastic, aromatic bakery. Open as early as 6am. Perfect for a quick cup of coffee and hot bread. They have delicious pastries, bread and cookies. My wife is partial to the glazed rolls and cannolis. Fresh french baguettes and Italian bread. Hearty Pumpernickel with or without raisins. If your in the area, highly recommend to stop by and pick up a pie.
Best bakery in the area. Been around for over 40 year. Service is great big selection and never disdpoints
Been going there for over 45 years. Great bakery
I went there for the first time, I got a pound of Italian cookies. They were stale and tasted like cardboard. What a waste of $14. I will never go there again.
The most inconsistant bakery in the past few months, different prices when i go in their alot of times as i was just in their today telling them that i was charged a lower price days ago and the clerk was extremely rude and should have honored that price as i have been a long time customer ( over 20 years ) Their prices have skyrocketed since theyve changed hands. The girls behind the counter are generally nice but the older woman with the short dark hair is one of the rudest people ive ever came across, shes the one that i almost got into an argument with. They lost me as long time customer. While i was there waiting to place an order, i overheard her speaking to a customer and when she hung up with the customer she was saying things under her breath that didnt seem very nice. Goodbye Stanly or who ever the new owner is, I recommend Pats Market down the road, prices and quality are better as well as attitudes or if your willing to take the drive, A & G Bakery in North Babylon, They are and have always been a great bakery, its worth the drive! Unfortunately i am unable to respond to your response so i will do it here. The price that i had told the rude clerk i was charged should have been honered but instead she decided to act the way she did. I was a 20 year plus customer of ur bakery. It wasnt the money which was about $1.50 additional, obviously which i paid, its the rudeness i will not put up with and being told to have a happy new year in a condescending way was not the way to handle it as i was walking out the door!...Let me also say that after my wife was informed of what happened, she will no longer be stopping by on Fridays to drop about 20 to 30 bucks to pick up donuts and rolls for our office!. As a business owners let me assure you, that older woman who works their, whether she is an owner or an employee, she is definitely not an asset to your business, thats not the way to treat loyal customers. Good luck to you.
I cant say enough good things about this bakery! I usually stop here to pick up dessert when I visit with my brothers family and its always a hit. Desserts are fresh and theres a pretty big variety. Last time I got the chocolate cream pie and everyone loved it!
Excellent service, excellent baked goods.Cheese cake is great!
Awesome jelly donuts, not only larger than others but filled generously with jelly and tasty. Great price as well. Have to acknowledge the pretzels as well, takes me back to the ball games when they were sold in the parking lots, the real true pretzels
Been enjoying Stanleys since 1964. The rolls did get smaller over the years but the quality didnt change. Wish they had social distance. The set up is everybody on top of you and no line. Same way as back then . the register area is cramped and 3 people are on top of you paying at the same register. Dont go on Sunday. Due to crowds. But delicious baked goods
Best buns around! I moved and request this spread at every visit to Long Island.
New owners.. Yes, still long lines. Employee helpful. Miss the smell of baking going on. Pastries didnt have the same freshness and taste to them.
Best jelly donuts anywhere! I travel over 30 miles to get them and make extra special trips. Worth the drive! Also love the Irish Soda Bread. Everything is always fresh abd everyone is always pleasant.
Absolute greatest bakery on the island! From the crumb cake to the raspberry jelly donuts down to the breakfast sandwiches and the amazing sliced and iced Irish soda bread🙃 Neverending goodies 🥲
Love their seeded rye weekly and everything else from cakes to rolls. So fortunate to have this bakery in town.
Best bakery around. . New owners have new delicious recipes.. definitely stop and try a snack here. More changes.. yummy coffee cakes
Usually a great bakery, but they recently pulled a fast one and gave my senior Dad a burnt cherry crumb pie. He was embarrassed when he brought it to a lunch he was invited to. When I convinced him to bring it back, they exchanged it for him, but no apologies. Very disappointed.
Lots of choices. Easter-themwd cookies. Very reasonably priced
A favorite whenever we travel from FL to EI.
Great place everything is fresh and deliciousEnjoy
Was a great visit but didn’t receive jelly donuts as we ordered my father was disappointed
Ive always loved the jelly donuts ,and have always recommended them to family and friends as the best anywhere. However theyve changed the recipe big time including the jelly.If you want a better one shoprite is now your best bet. The rest of their cakes and pastries as far as I can tell remain the same. Perhaps they changed bakers?
Everyone knows this bakery and how fabulous it is . Always fresh! Staff is friendly.
This bakery came through for my family when everyone else was booked up for graduation. The cake they made for us far exceeded our expectations and we also bought a French cheesecake that was amazing as well. For the 1st time in history we did not have a single dessert left over from our party. Not a crumb. My next visit to NY I will have to make my way over to my new friends at Stanleys Bakery. A Very Big Thank You to you all!!!!
Since I live out of state now we stop here whenever we are back to bring treats home with us. Love everything about this bakery!!
Donuts were good customer service fair
Delicious crumb buns, apple turnovers and jelly doughnuts
I love this bakery the food is always great and very fresh!! They have the best Boston cream and jelly donuts. Breakfast is delicious and their cakes are to die for. The staff here is awesome you can’t go wrong going to this bakery!
Its Stanleys!! Perfect. Always is!! When back on the Island, its a must stop. Cheese Danish, Sugar Jelly Donuts , just the best. Same recipe for years. Im in my 50s, and still the same since I can remember as a kid!! Just love it!! If they have it , get a poppy seed coffee cake ring/ strudel/ cake. Yummy!!
My entire family has loved them for years! Pastries are always fresh. ALWAYS DELICIOUS! Theyre so good. Staff is friendly. Place is clean. Prices are reasonable. Not a better bakery anywhere. We turn our noses at anything that isnt from Stanleys.
Stanley’s is one of those local bakery’s that people drive further than normal (for Long Island Drivers) to get to. It’s always fresh, with long but quick lines on the weekends.If you haven’t been, be sure to take a trip ASAP!
Ordered a Wedding cake. It was delicious. Great customer service. Rolls and bread baked fresh daily.
Went here fo many years. But the products have changed. No cheese in the danish and the donuts dont taste the same. Ordered a carrot cake last year and it was so dry that no one ate it.Also getting very expensive which I wouldnt mind if it tasted good.
One of few Bakery that people wait outside inline (full of people inside the shop). The cake is not too sweet.
Amazing cake for my mother in laws birthday
Great bakery. Been around a long time. Soon old school places like this will disappear. But not this one. I only gave it three stars because everytime I go back home and visit I order lots of stuff as a to go order to bring back where I live now. Every time they screw it up and give sub quality goods compared to what is on the shelves.That being said I will continue to patronize Stanleys. It is still the best in the area for miles around. I recommend the horseshoe cookies.
Who dosent love a good bakery? Pumpernickel bread, croissants ,tea biscuits and a very good jelly donut. Hard to get that combo but its all here at Stanleys.
There are no words for Staley’s the owner is the nicest person. The pastries are drop dead deliciousWell just a few words. Old style bakery. The best just like Brooklyn I’d say better.
All the buns are delicious specially jelly and creme buns. I ordered a carrot cake for my wife birthday party to my surprise it wasnt fresh. I return it and the bakery refuse to refund me..so i settled for another cake and they charged me 5 dollars more. I had no choice but to pay. Im very unhappy with the customer service. Im a long time customer.
Visiting from Florida, missed n.y. bakery brought back bagels to Florida put each one in a sandwich bag pre-cut & froze them, 1 minute in microwave & its the best
Best spot for those who loves sweets🍪
One of my favorite places to go get a egg and cheese on a roll. Those rolls taste and feel fresh, they way it just comes together with the egg and cheese seals that moment of deliciousness in your mouth. Always come here when visiting Long Island.
Great selection and couldnt believe how fresh everything was. Would recommend this bakery to anyone. Beads and cookies done fresh on site. Nice change of pace from the other bakeries Ive been to. Good job
Best bakery on Long Island. My family and I have been going for years. The carrot cake is AMAZING!!! Very friendly staff. Everything they make is always fresh and amazing
Fat mans delight (fat womans delight also). The pastries are freshly baked and tasty. Serious assortment of baked goods to choose from. It smells tasty inside as well.
The baked goods are to die for, the cakes are simply scrumptious. Been perusing this bakery many years and will continue to peruse for many more.
Ordered a Communion cake last week, the cake was incredibly delicious, the staff was extremely helpful and polite! Will definitely use again!
Its our once a week stop for seeded rye bread and birthday cakes or cookies when needed. Very nice efficient staff takes are phone orders and safe virus procedures.
They have the best 6 grain bread. Everyone at this bakery are friendly and very helpful. I truly enjoy going to stanleys for all my baked good. Thanks guys you are the best.😘💖💖💖💖💖
Ive been coming to this bakery my entire life. My grandpa used to walk me up here when i was a kid. It has always been the best bakery in town. I look forward to coming back every time we are in town.
Stanleys is the absolute best bakery. I live 45 minutes away but used to work nearby. Miss the place. RYE bread is incredible. No bakery on long island compares to Stanleys.
Love getting up early on holidays and waiting on line for Stanleys to open. Fresh baked goods, pastries, pies and cakes. Something for everyone. Love the Jelly Doughnut and canoli cake they made for my daughters 10bday.
Every single time I am in Long Island visiting I have to stop in. The staff is always friendly and some of the best cookies anywhere. This place got me drinking coffee again when i visited (trying to cut down) and caught me in a moment of self reflection where I wondered if I was visiting Long Island to see my family or Stanleys.
Everything was GREAT. Do not go in there hungry. One of the best things about New York are EXCELLENT bakeries. Highly recommended.
Always fresh and delicious. Staff is awesome. But...... BRING BACK THE OLD JELLY DOUGHNUTS!!!! Never a bad experience. Go once, youll go back.
The best cinnamon jelly doughnuts EVER ! The only jelly doughnut i will eat. Unfortunately if u dont get there in the am they are sold out
I love it ,delicious pastries and excellent dog treats
Best home town bakery. Great food, great staff.
I absolutely think Stanleys is the best bakery on Long Island always pleasantly staffed and the cleanliness I would recommend Stanleys to everyone I know and even people I do not just by conversion with people a must go to make it your own establishment 2 thumbs up
Excellent, delicious baked goods that you want to eat again. 🍰
Or something best bakery longtime mainstay they gave us free oatmeal cookies to try☺
Everything is fresh baked everyday. Stanleys has a big selection of cakes, pastrys, donuts, bread and rolls. Great coffee and breakfast to go also.
Amazing confections all around. May want to avoid if you get buyers remorse, if not, SPEND ALL THE MONEY! Seriously recommend the linzer tortes...... 😍
Long lines, and if you pre-order they have you wait in line with people who are ordering from the showcase. Normally there is a line to the left of the store for pre-orders, but none today (03-11-18). And then the entire order was not filed and I was told everything was there.
Everything they make is top notch
Always fresh backed goods
Like this bakery good choices always fresh goodies good service have been there a few times cookies bread cupcakes good stuff
Many choices. Nice staff.
Yummy desserts and breads , extended hours, friendly staff
Best bread in town. I am not a big fan of their cookies and cakes but I prefer German style baked goids.
Not so good. Cannoli shells not so good.
The best bakery! I grew up on baked good from Stanleys. 30 years later, and its still the best!
Been going here for years, BEST cakes in Town
Consistently, The best around.
Cant find many good bakeries like this anymore. Good selection of delicious baked goods.
The best bakery ! Everything that is made is delicious!Cakes. Rolls. Pastries. Fruit tarts
This bakery is amazing. Get their bread. You wont be disappointed.
Cakes pastries coffee and everything else is nice and fresh and employees treat you as a customer and good prices
Great treats and cakes. Always one of my favorite places to stop by and grab something sweet to eat.
Best jelly donuts on LI. & 3 layer cookies. Absolute best.
Love the cakes from stanleys bakery....so rich & delicious,every year I ordered cakes for birthdays and wedding anniversaries.
Best breakfast in town plus old school bakery no dunkin donuts here
Only good bakery around on the South Shore Drive all the way from North Babylon to East Islip to get rolls and bakery stuff
Stopped in for donuts, very fresh and inexpensive. Very good donuts. I would visit again.
Cakes are excellent and fresh rye bread is delicious!
I would have given 5 stars but they were out of Italian bread my last 3 visits.
Good selection and everything has been very tasty. Friendly staff.
Best bakery located in E. Islip. All item reasonably priced and always fresh
Nice variety of baked goods, fresh and beautifully decorated. Staff is helpful and prices are competitive.
Famous bakery with all the classics. Been around forever. Definitely worth stopping by
Then going there for their apple turnovers cream puffs 4 decades even before when we saw on Islip Avenue across from Pathmark
Best bakery around and they make a good egg sandwich as well.
I bought several things from here and every one was amazing. They are also super helpful and friendly.
Great place, awesome danishes, pastrys, donuts and not to mention cakes and pies.
Amazing bakery with everything from egg sandwiches to rainbow cookie cakes. Love it!
I have been here many times - Love the jelly donuts!
Best bakery I have ever been to...bar none. Cakes are amazing!
Eveyone there is very helpful and always smiling! !have been going there for years. Everything is delicious! !
My wedding cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious thank you so much🎂
We go there for the cheese cakes chocolate ship good and creamy when fresh.
This Bakery is Awesome, Great selelections, Excellent service.
Consistently good baked treats, this place is the best around for decades!
The Pastries are so good. So is the breakfast ,very inexpensive but good.
Delicious tasting cakes At reasonably priced The best jelly donuts
The ONLY bakery you should ever go to. Old school and amazing.
Cake was horrible they are doing remodeling wanted to bring it back see if they will eat it
Great fresh baked goods. Breakfast is Awesome
Pastries are good but I can do without the attitude from the girls behind the counter.
Best crumb buns around and great service!
Dont like that it has to be cash only.
Always a good choice for cake and fresh baked breads
The bakery is amazing I can’t wait for him to come the Sayville.
Best bakery on Long Island! Call ahead for Irish Soda Bread!
The BEST buns, esp jelly donuts, hard rolls but prices are getting out of hand.
The cake was good, the employees and management, not so much.
The jelly donuts are filled to the limit and their Boston creme donuts are second to none
Fresh delicious bakery items. I love their donuts!
Great cakes and baked goodies and friendly service
Awesome baked goods with a very friendly staff
Not very happy when you are in from Florida and they dont up date there website that there closed on Monday bye putting a sign in the window
Best Boston Cream I’ve ever had
Not consisant received cakes that were not fresh.I like the eye bread though
Great bakery been there forever!
Best bakery on long island, no doubt about it.
Great food and staff. They even serve breakfast!!
Love Stanley egg sandwichs and rolls best around
Very good
Excellent selection. Great service
Yummy and delicious
Hottest coffee in town try the Miami roll with your next egg sandwich
Stanleys always has very good pastries .
The bakery I always went to/ate from growing up and still go to when visiting my hometown.
Best ever
Love this place. My family has been going here for generations.
Best jelly doughnuts and coffee in town
Awesome doughnuts and egg samiches
Friendly n cake n cookies are fresh n delicious
Delicious pastries, rye bread, and rolls.
Everything here is delicious. You literally cant go wrong.
Love #Stanleys Best Jelly donuts in town!!!
The best tasting bakery in town
Great bakery
Great bakery. Good service
Excellent egg sandwiches and baked goods.
Love the jelly donuts and crumb buns
Great old school German bakery
Best Bakery hands down!
Hands down, the best bakery in the area.
Great bakery. Fresh and delicious.
Crispy and delicious cookie. that is exactly what i looking for
Everything is delicious and omg the jelly donuts!!!!!
Wonderful bakery wonderful staff
Always great service and food.
A local favorite for Sunday morning treats.
Just a great place always good going there
Every time Im visiting from NC, I come here!!
Nothing is fresh. Its all brought in
Great selection of treats
Wish we had one these at home!
A great selection of fancy cakes
Who doesnt like a jelly donut from Stanley
Great cakes .... great service
Behind the counter service is courteous and fast.
Best hard rolls
Excellent bakery a must try
Best jelly donuts on the planet
Rainbow cookies, the best.
They have a great selection.......
Best pastries and cakes in town
Best cookies pies and cakes
Best hard rolls around
Good but smells bad
Great jelly donuts
People drive from all around to go to Stanleys
Great place!
Over price breakfast was horrible
❤️
Good selection and price
Delicious as usual.
Everything that is good is created here!
The best bakery by far
Always the best.
All good
Love the rye bread
Who doesnt like Stanleys.
The BEST
Best pastries EVERRRR
There great
The cookies are fantastic
Total reviews rating 4.5
199 Reviews for Stanleys Bakery 2023:
Review №1
2022-07-08This was our first time trying this bakery for a cake order. I was so pleased that we were able to get the cake order in for July 3rd. A lot of bakeries werent accepting cake orders because of the holiday. The detail that went into the cake was amazing! Everyone at the party LOVED the cake! I couldnt stop eating it 🤭 we ordered a chocolate cake with chocolate mousse filling and buttercream icing. The icing is quite sweet, but we have a sweet tooth in this family, so we didnt mind it. Definitely ordering more cakes in the future!
Review №2
2022-03-15Absolutely loved the cake pops for my bridal shower. They were fresh, larger than most cake pops and got so many compliments. Gave very little instruction but they came out beautiful!
Review №3
2022-06-17On Easter someone brought five Saint Josephs cakes to share . They were fabulous ( I had never had them before ) . I was wondering if you sell them all th time or is it j ust an Easter treat.Anyway , they were fantastic .
Review №4
2022-06-08Food/drink*The Stanley Cup (Two eggs/scrambled, sausage patty, and two pieces of bacon on a roll) - Good; comes with complimentary orange juice*Crumb cake - Good; maintains consistency so it doesnt fall apart but can taste the difference in each layer/texture*Pecan Danish Ring - very good
Review №5
2022-05-06There was a large selection of cakes, cookies, pastries and breads. I purchased some treats for a friend and got a small loaf of seeded rye. Staff was nice and boxed everything nicely.
Review №6
2020-10-30Absolutely love this place. Many different options, a great breakfast sandwich, and the best jelly donuts I have tasted. Beyond that the staff was friendly even notice that one of the staff workers saw an older gentleman drop his item outside and she ran out in the rain to replace it. You cant beat that type of service.
Review №7
2021-03-14What’s not to love about a great bakery.... fresh baked goods, delicious fragrances and wonderful treats! Been going to Stanley’s for years and years. Never disappointed!
Review №8
2021-12-16Used to be undeniably the best bakery I’ve ever been to, but in the mid 2010s they changed their cake recipe and they have never been as good. The worst part is they deny having changed anything. They changed their jelly donut recipe as well - although that they actually admitted to doing. I was also sad to see they no longer sell their character cookies with the sugar heads. Nothing quite like eating one of those. Some products - although different - are still good, like the yogurt muffins, but as more things continue to change I get closer to considering other bakeries. It’s a shame because the place has so much charm and could be so great. Should be an easy fix…
Review №9
2020-12-17I called ahead for a rainbow cake for a friends bd. It was all ready when I arrived to pay and pick up. Social distancing measures are in place to give you the warm fuzzy and the cake? It was delightful! So moist. The right proportion of cake to filling. The chocolate was not overwhelming. In a word, decadent.
Review №10
2022-07-01Everything looks delicious, unless you know what you want your going to look at everything that they have to offer and the pricing is great 👍😊