Delivery
Yes
Sweet Polly in Brooklyn
Categories
Location on the map
Brooklyn, Kings County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Great cocktails
Yes
Great wine list
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible car park
No
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Cocktails
Yes
Food
Yes
Food at bar
Yes
Happy-hour drinks
Yes
Happy-hour food
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Cosy
Yes
Upmarket
Yes
Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly
Yes
Transgender safe space
Yes
Planning
Accepts reservations
Yes
Phone: +1 718-484-9600
Site: http://www.sweetpollynyc.com/
Site: http://www.sweetpollynyc.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:4PM–12AM
- Tuesday:4PM–12AM
- Wednesday:4PM–12AM
- Thursday:4PM–1AM
- Friday:4PM–2AM
- Saturday:2PM–2AM
- Sunday:2PM–12AM
Comments (145)
Great Experience, very sweet ambiance and the service was great! We stopped in for a drink and oysters on our last night in town, and would return on our next visit. Thank You!
Sweet Polly is one of my fav spots to go for a well made cocktail and some delightful light plates of food. Love the happy hour oyster special!
The shrimp cocktail was amaaaaaazing. Then the cocktails came. My only regret is not having enough alcohol tolerance to be able to taste their whole menu. Will 1000% be coming back and you should too
The cheese and charcuterie platter was embarrassing, with only a few slices of chorizo and 2 miniature portions of cheeses (and beer nuts of all things). Preposterously priced at $25 I think its the worst such platter Ive ever had. Their wine options were slim and not good at all either. If I ever go back itll be for the cocktails as Im told they are good. Theyd need to be to keep this place in business.
Exceptional drinks! Amazing service! Expensive but totally worth it!
Lush interior with antebellum and/or Victorian vibe, even better at night with low light and cushiony, dense crowd. Cocktails are top flight in all senses, making it good for dates, celebrations, and impressivity. Be patient with the table service. Negroni on tap. Beers and wine also available. Super close to Barclays/Atlantic. Go ready to spend, if not to sip. Bill comes in a book.
This place is so fun! I loved the 2000s jams and the general atmosphere. Obsessed with the logo-ed ice cubes. Ill be back.
Sweet Polly is a great addition to the area. The space is cozy and romantic for couples yet can accolade smaller groups for a nice hang. The food was very good and the mixologist concocted some really nice drinks. The only issue I had was with our mixologist, although the drinks were good, he had a slight tude or maybe just lacked personality. Would certainly go back!
Great cocktails in downtown Brooklyn!You have to try the Velour Tracksuit!
Really nice little cocktail spot. They have an inventive, yet approachable list of house cocktails in addition to the classics. There is also beer and wine, but we let the bartender make us something delicious. We had the “Southern Belle” and the “Swing Revival”. Both were well made and tasted great. I’ll come back next time I’m in the area.
Drinks look interesting and the atmosphere outside generally seems chill for Flatbush. Was looking forward to spending an evening here but we left before being seated. The hostess was rude from the start and ruined the experience for us. It’s a shame as so many bars in the neighborhood offer excellent drinks with friendly service.
This is a super chill place. The atmosphere was relaxed. The decor was on point. We got the grilled cheese and it was delicious. The drinks were a bit pricey but tasted great.
Great little cocktail bar! Came in the evening and love the dim, warm lighting. Drinks are tasty albeit a bit on the pricey side. Worth it though!
The drink was too sweet. I asked the waiter if he have any recommendations for a drink thats a little sweet but not too sweet so he recommended the Fro-Quito. My friend and I order the same thing. As for food we got the chicken Liver mousse. Its like a paste like texture. Kinda salty but it goes with the bread I guess. I would come back here again.
Sweet Polly has some of the most charismatic and lovely bartenders Ive ever met and the Venus is my favorite drink so far! I look forward to every time I get to stop by this awesome place and highly recommend everyone to come by for a drink or two. The atmosphere is absolutely on point for being able to enjoy drinks with friends and the food is SO enjoyable and comforting. 10/10 will keep coming back
Amazing craft cocktails. I also had the grilled cheese which was delicious. My husband and I enjoyed the ambiance and the great service from the bartenders Jojo & Blair. Jojo really took the time to explain the drinks and made you feel welcomed. We will definitely return to this gem in Brooklyn.Until next timeJulia & Kendall ( Chicago couple )
The single large ice-cube was crystal clear, which already says a lot about how they prepare their cocktails, which are well done. The interior is enjoyable to be within especially in the late afternoon hours when daylight is waning for the last few hours of the day.
Came here with my girlfriend and her father visiting from England on friday night to celebrate her birthday before having dinner close by.Hostess was extremely rude from the beginning. Someone needs to remind her and the rest of the staff that they work at a bar, and not the pentagon.When your establishment is half empty and you’re forcing new customers to “move out of the way” or have drinks outside in 40 degree weather (with no heat lamps) just because one person “might” join us for a toast at some point is just ridiculous.To make a long story short- because of her passive aggressiveness and rudeness we didn’t even bother to go in and order a drink. And won’t ever again. We went to a bar close by (Weather up) instead and had a wonderful experience there. I highly suggest itSweet polly.. just another place in Brooklyn who think they’re the only ones who do what they do. Complete joke
Very tasty cocktails. Pricy. Cute date spot for drinks.
One of my go to cocktail bars In Brooklyn. Try the jungle bird. Their food menu is surprisingly delicious. You wouldnt expect such an eclectic food offering at a craft cocktail bar.
Cocktails are great! Price point a little high for the neighborhood but I appreciate the design and atmosphere. Cauliflower Tikka Masala was pretty tasty. Overall, a convenient location and great pre or post dinner spot!
Cute cocktail bar, servers and hosts were accommodating. The drinks were good and the options made it hard to choose. Don’t get the the charcuterie plate. $16 for a few slices of salami, a little pile of prosciutto and some gross haggis looking slice. Texture was too weird and unwanted. Finished with overly crisp bread and some sour pickled cauliflower. Get apps elsewhere.
I have a very good friend whos been telling me about this place since I met her. Its her favorite place for number of different reasons. We only ate a little bit we had these incredible pickled eggs that are very small and theyre and pickled in beet juice. Are topped with an amazing sea salt its a very very interesting flavor something I really think anybody that can get to this place should try. The other item we shared was a grilled cheese sandwich with tomato bisque both of which were surprisingly tasty for something as simple as a comfort food such as that combination. I commented to my partner that the only time I see that on the menu is at a traditional Diner which anybody who read my reviews knows Im a big fan of traditional diners however this is a different rest on it and the cheese and bread are fabulous and the soup the bisque really is super duper sick . These were really really great items . The cocktails are very fancy and original and I tried two different ones cant remember what theyre called but they were both very different. We sat outside but I did manage to make it into the dining room to check it out and its very sleek. Theres some very interesting art including a rendering of the Hieronymous Bosch triptych from the what they believe is around the year 1500 called The Garden of Earthly Delights. Just like the original which is in The Prado in Madrid it is painted on three wooden panels and Ill bet you just bet you theyre the exact same size. I remember seeing this painting when I was last in Spain and its very memorable. Look it up if you havent seen it before. Its worth it to go into this place just to see this painting however I would highly recommend you have at least a cocktail while youre there...The service is extremely professional however I may have experienced The Best of the Best because I was with a hyper regular. Theyre fashionable and fun. The outdoor seating arrangement is actually very cool because of this location theres just a ton of good people watching so sitting out side is the way to go.Those of you who know me and read my reviews know that I eat in a lot of restaurants all over the place and I only review those that I find to be exceptional. Sweet Polly hits pretty much every touchpoint I can think of in terms of a deserving of 5-star rating from me. As I work through the rest of the menu at this place Ill update this review and post some pictures so you can see what Im talking about. But if youre in this part of town or anywhere close do not hesitate to get there. I was very cold and they even gave us blankets with the restaurants logo on them they were very warm and cozy. My good friend who I was with like them so much she said she was probably going to buy one.
Friendly people, fun drinks, great atmosphere. Get the hummus!
Came here with a buddy after work. Staff was very rude! Bartender was too busy to help me select a drink. Cocktails were so overpriced you’d think the service would match.
Been to this place twice and it is a nice speakeasy to say the least. The ambiance is very nice and the drinks are great. Its as if this place gave you luxury quality for an affordable price. Great place to impress a date and the location allows for options after chopping it up over a some spirits. The wine choices are good and the selection of cocktails are a nice variety.
We came here for a cocktail to check out a new spot. We stayed because the service was personal and lovely. We were blown away by the creativity and execution behind the bar and Im beside myself about the food. Youll come here, as you should, and enjoy many fine libations, as you should. But, the hidden gem at this Cocktail Bar is pure glory that is being plated from this extremely talented and seasoned kitchen. We had basically the whole food menu (except dessert) and we were so, so, so impressed dish after dish and we ordered more, more, and more. This place is the real deal on so many levels. Bravo chef and Cheers to the Sweet Polly Team.
Fantastic cocktail bar with good small plates. Negronis on tap and a happy hour menu that’s decent. Bartenders are pros and the best drinks are probably off menu or bartender’s choice. Lovely atmosphere so great for a quiet drink or date.
Best oyster happy hour anywhere, always a new selection of oysters to experience and expand the breadth of my palate. The drinks are expertly crafted and the setting is supper chill and cozy. Check it out, you wont regret
Enjoyed their brunch menu a lot! We had the French toast, eggs and bacon and I thoroughly enjoyed everything I ate! I like the ambiance and decor, I went on a Sunday afternoon at 1pm and it was quiet. Pricey but would go back for drinks or brunch again
Nice little bar with crafted cocktails. They make classy cocktails with a twist and their own special cocktails, which are very good. The interior is cozy and the place has a relaxing vibe. The service was good as well.
Dont be intimidated by the classy interior as this place is a great neighborhood spot that welcomes any walk-ins. The bartenders are extremely knowledgeable about the cocktails they sling but I was delightfully surprised by the food offerings. My favorite was the scallops. It can end up being a pretty pricey evening at this spot but worth checking out if you happen to be in the area.
Loved our first visit here, exciting cocktail menu full of old classics and creative inventions. The bar tender was wonderfully fun. The atmosphere is fantastic with an upscale decor matched to local illustrators artwork. They also have a variety of tiki inspired drinks on the menu with the mugs to match. While more pricey than a simple bar, the homemade ingredients and stylings make it worth it.
I love this place, great bar! amazing food! wonderful service! The place has amazing attitude! Still remember my favorite caipirinha
Fantastic spot to grab a drink and a bite, I had oysters, grilled cheese with tomato soup, and some cocktails and everything was spectacular. Knowledgeable staff and a beautiful space both inside and outdoors.
My girlfriend and I love this place. Great cocktails. Great staff. Great ambiance. We drink than we eat, but the queso fundito is amazing. Weve never made it for oyster happy hour, but you should!
Came here for a quick drink at a weird hour on a Saturday afternoon and really enjoyed the sunshine and quiet atmosphere. Interesting cocktail list, but I ended up ordering a Paloma. It was really good! Great service as well.
Drink was good, but expensive. Bartender was exceptionally rude over a minor miscommunication. Everyone has a bad day, but wouldn’t come back as it was really over the top and drawn out. Ambiance is nice otherwise and similar to that of many manhattan speakeasies. I’ve only written 5 star reviews prior to this one...
This is a very cute place, I love the ambiance. I like to come here for drinks and small plates. But I do know people who have ordered food and have said that it’s pretty good. The bartenders are usually really cool. If you don’t come for happy hour it can get a little pricey.
Really nice spot with great ambience, good range of classic and crafted cocktails, offered with fresh, tasty seafood dishes, charcuterie, and cheeses. Service is great. Only wish they had more comfortable seating.. if you cant score a bench, youre on a stool at small tables or the bar.
Best spot in Brooklyn for cocktails, space is beautiful, drinks are great and service is spot on. Couldnt ask for anything more
This is a great place to grab a unique and delicious cocktail. We were in town for a wedding and stayed at the Hotel Beresford nearby and decided to check this place out. Really nice vibe here, cool decor, attentive bartenders, and like I said - really good cocktails. If I lived in the area, this would be my hangout.
Good although not great. Conveniently located near Barclays for a post event drink. They were out of certain cocktails. Busy and cool atmosphere, although the wait for a seat on a sat night was > 60min. You can book in advance.
Most gorgeous Charcuterie platter, gorgeous salads, and home made Sweet Polly sauces makes this a divine experience. Packed at 3pm on a Saturday. The service is fantastic. Every part of this experience made me feel like I was in a high end Sweet Polly in Italy.Sweet Polly
Oh boy... we booked this place for a Sunday brunch with family because there were 8 of us and knew we needed a res somewhere. We show up and order drinks, or at least try to, two of the 3 of us got our drinks right away, but the third drink took 20 minutes to get. It was NOT busy at all, at we put in our food order right away: eggs and salads, stuff that should take 15 minutes max. An hour later, we are still waiting for food, Im on my 2nd aperol spritz, and the waitress makes an excuse about how the kitchen is in the basement... ok. The food was only so-so, the truffled eggs were very good, but the side salad was grossly over-dressed. All in all, the experience was toooo much time spent waiting for simple food that was only OK. Everytime I looked up the only waitress in the whole place was on her phone and barely paying attention. If youre going to drink, it seems like a good place, but would absolutely not recommend for food.
Great cocktails, but server added extra tip to my bill. Im one of those people who matches up my receipts with the line items on my credit card statement, and my Sweet Polly bill was $1.50 more than what Id written down. I dug a little further, and this place has some pretty outrageous suggested tips on their receipts. Instead of the standard NYC 18%/20%/22%, their suggestions are 25%/30%/35%. So someone upgraded my $9 tip [on a $45 check] to the $10.50 suggested minimum. Bottom line: if you patronize this place, pay cash.
Stopped by Sweet Polly to have a drink before an event at Barclays. The waiter was charming and easy to get along with. The drinks were so good! I ordered a Paloma and was not disappointed.
Theyre nice until you leave a $5 tip. Then they ask if the service was good.
Great drinks! Great outdoor seating! Very upbeat service. Our server Nicole made our experience very smooth and enjoyable.
Ive only been here a couple of times and never tried the food but normally were the bartenders friendly, funny and had a good attitude but their drinks w ere tasty. The drinks are a touch on the expensive side though and the few times I went, the place was packed.
Not sure I like this one. The menu options were a little strange, but the outdoor eating option was great
UPDATE AUG 2019: This is my favorite spot in all of Park Slope. You don’t know me, but a review as glowing as that is as rare as it comes. And I mean every word.———————————Great drinks, great vibe, great service. 5 stars!
Amazing - kind of crazy I’ve waited so long to go. Super chill place and ambiance with great drinks / food.Also incredible service, aside from the staff being very fun and friendly - they offered us a free round of drinks and were ever so polite / apologetic because the food took a little long to come out.
Very cosy place. Maybe a bit too cosy with the tables a bit close together. The decor was very tastefully done though and the bar area is really impressive. The staff were pleasant and helpful. Food was a bit disappointing as the flavors were a bit bland in the small plates. Was expecting a bit more from this place.
Fun, smart staff. Excellent cocktails, stellar food. You cannot go wrong when you eat and drink.here. The bar is 100% tiki friendly. Its a win win.
Overall the place is ok.I wish I could go there everyday— but it is more of a date spot. The drinks are great, but not at a price where you could go very often & the food looks really good, but is smaller portions and again priced just right for a date, but too much for the daily.
Little cocktail bar hidden right off of Flatbush Avenue. Seating is somewhat limited but cocktails were very good and the service was top notch.
By the time my friend and I hit Sweet Polly we had already abandoned 2 nearby resturants (333 grill/bar + Piquant resturant/bar) because they didnt acknowledge us.Within seconds of entering Sweet Polly we were warmly greeted and seated. The space was hip and classy. They played jazz music and had Heironymus Bosch paintings on the wall. The service was attentive and detailed (think salt bae). The clientle was diverse and chic (felt like I was in an Anne Hathaway movie).The menu consisted of oysters, cheese plates, well drinks, cocktails, and fancy finger foods. The bathroom downstairs was minimalistic and spotless (two of my favorite things)!!!Everything had an upscale but accessible/welcoming vibe. Costlier then other local options (in my opinion) BUT it was worth the customer service experience and warm atmosphere!!! I will return/recommend.
Can’t say enough good things about this cocktail bar. Vibe is great and drinks are perfect. Grab a table, order some drinks, and chill.
Jordan is a cocktail genius. Whether you order cocktails off the menu or ask him to make you something special, you will always be pleasantly surprised. Queso fundito is to die for.
Nice bar
They take a little time making the drinks, but thats because they require careful assembly/preparation. I like the Bad Hombre cocktail, mostly because it comes in a shark head.
The menu and images online are old. They no longer serve food.... Which is unfortunate because the food looked amazing. The Drinks however are awesome nice ambiance inside..,
One of the best places to chill in Brooklyn! Cocktails are just great! Highly recommend!
For starters I want to say shout out to the amazing staff .I would like to personally thank the chef and his staff for making my 34 year Anniversary Dinner the best ever.
Incredible atmosphere (try and get seated by the window), delicious cocktails and a great oyster deal!
Some of the best mixology in Brooklyn, Sweet Polly has a robust menu, great staff and cool vibes.
Great atmosphere & cocktails, fun glasses
Cute spot! Great cocktails and decent food and love the dimly lit vibe. Good for a date.
Lovely neighborhood spot. Great place to meet for a drink and a bite to eat. Try the Brussel Sprout salad it is a must have!
Incredible cocktails...truly...and the playlist?! SOOO GOOD!!!! Whoever put together the playlist 👌👌
Very good atmosphere, delicious cocktails and food. I very highly recommend for a date
Super classy bar with great food and cocktails, nothing like this in the neighborhood until now and a much needed addition.
Top notch cocktail bar. If you want an elevated beverage, this is the place to go.
Amazing cocktail bar in BK!! Delicious small bites and great service!!
Pretty expensive and often crowded but good drinks. Nice place to go before or after a Barclay’s event.
Love their cocktails! Happy hour is the best here.
Fun bar/ gathering place. The bartenders put on a terrific display of their art. Good music.
This place is perfect. Cocktails are phenomenal. Staff is sexy ;)
The best
Went on a date. Drinks are $$. Food was good, also a little pricey. Service was a little slow.
Excellent cocktails and friendly staff. Absolutely nothing to complain about.
Great place for drinks...
One of the best cocktail0places in Brooklyn. And the food is delicious.
Good quality food, small portions, seating limited. Low lights. Bar with limited menu.
Best cocktails Ive had in Brooklyn.
Fantastic craft cocktails. Oysters were fresh.
Beautiful ambiance. Good cocktail and wine list
Excellent cocktails and the charcuterie plate is spectacular!!!
Great nigronis on tap get there early for wonderful $1 oysters.
WOW. The drinks are spectacular, just spectacular!
Wonderful humans, drinks, and decor. Polished!
Sweet Polly is the standard for drinks in Brooklyn.
Nice hidden gem. Great drinks, great staff.
Two blocks from my apt and Im spent. Best neighborhood spot for days. And gin.
Doesnt stand up to other new York cocktail bars - especially with the prices
Excellent environment. Good chairs.
Is a small place, music is to toooooooo loud❗❗❗❗❗ that if you talk to someone you have to scream terrible experience!!!
Very crowded and loud, happy hour was only $1 off of wine.
Amazing drinks and ambiance
Nice atmospere! Food:good service:good
I love the drinks and ambiance. Enough said 😀
Very strong and inventive drinks!
Great cocktails and food is delicious.
Awesome spot with interesting drinks and great staff!
Underrated cocktails and great snacks
Great cocktails, oysters too!
Great place for cocktails and light apps.
Ceviche was great. Service was fast
Ok, decent drinks, expensive, bartender was a jerk.
Awesome music, awesome drinks, awesome staff.
Waiter excellent. Small share dishes.
Brilliant service and great cocktails
Rude to me at the bar
Great place to wind down with a glass of wine!
Awesome, friendly and knowledgable staff. Love going here :)
Mixologist bar tenders, beautiful environment
Sucha great place! Very recommended!
Great atmosphere
Stunning decor & the very best 🍷🍸🍹🥃
Great cocktails
Sexy sweet and strong cocktails
Great cocktails.
Best cocktail program
Hey. Good cocktails.
Cozy cool and great service
Great cocktails!!!!
Stunning
Best bar ever
Cozy and strong cocktail
Get the Brooklyn Gin
Cool trendy place.
The place is nice.
Sweet Polly!
Very good
Total reviews rating 4.6
145 Reviews for Sweet Polly 2023:
Review №1
2022-06-14Delicious cocktails, food and love the design inside. There’s a pretty plant wall that’s simple but adds a lot in terms of mood and ambiance. Went for Happy Hour the other day for the first time. Had a great time and loved my drink. We also ordered some nibbles to go along with our drinks and everything was delish. I think we had the beet salad and hummus? I forgot. But remember loving the flavors. Can’t wait to try it again.
Review №2
2022-04-03Excellent customer service. Great cocktails and delicious small plates. Awesome vibe. Crème Brûlée tastes soo good.
Review №3
2022-01-13We went twice on our holiday to NY we loved it so much, our server Vanessa was so amazing and the cocktails were divine! Highly recommend this place for a cool spot away from the hustle and bustle.
Review №4
2022-02-14Drinks were delicious with a lot of variety. Food was okay, but I would go elsewhere in the future for food. With that said its a cocktail bar so great food is not a criteria
Review №5
2021-12-11Great ambiance and very friendly staff - packed on the weekends so you may need a reservation if you want a table inside.As someone who loves gin cocktails I was a bit surprised by the lack of diversity in the menu, with only one gin cocktail available “on tap.” Perhaps it is just their winter menu, but many of the cocktails also used almond or walnut liquors, which were off the table for me with an allergy. If you’re looking for a selection of vodka cocktails, you’re not going to find it here either - predominately dark liquors, rum and mezcal.I’m willing to give it another try in the spring or summer season, overall a nice experience but not exactly what I was expecting from a cocktail bar.
Review №6
2022-05-23One of my biggest pet peeves is a bartender who fails to acknowledge a customer standing right in front of them. It to me is one of the most disrespectful acts in the service industry. I visited here on Friday evening, and was greeted warmly by the hostess. The bar was less than packed. I then proceeded to order drinks for myself and a friend, so I went to stand at the bar placing my hand on the bar and looking dead into the bartenders eyes to acknowledge I wanted to place an order. As I tend to respect a bartenders craft when they are making drinks and not bark at them, I waited. The bartender then went on to turn his back, continue shaking his shaker, turn back around, and do everything it seemed in his power to avoid eye contact and take my order. I stood there for over 7 minutes, fixed on him waiting for him to give the slightest acknowledgment as he proceeded to make other drinks, til it became so apparent that I was annoyed, that the other bartender standing at the far end of the bar came over to take my order. I then proceeded to give her my drink order, but then thought to myself, nah, im good. I wouldnt want to give my money and have tips pooled with such a poor excuse for service bartender. If its not your night, call out, go home. But if youre on the clock, have the decency to acknowledge a customer standing directly in front of you. If you prefer customers to bark at you, thats fair. Just wear a sign next time.
Review №7
2022-04-17Great drinks. We found service a little slow given there was just few table occupied. I wouldnt say its good for brunch, since it has only appetizers.
Review №8
2020-11-15Hello!!! Visiting from south florida we found this golden bar far away from tourist new york city areas where they are still learning how to treat customers.We had a table inside (25% capacity) by the plant wall close to the window... Ordered two orders of empanadas (3 per order) which were very tasty.Drinks by killer bartender NAZ were top notch, no words can describe the style and dedication. Just look at the pics people!!!See yall soon on my next trip!!!
Review №9
2021-06-12Excellent little cocktail bar on the edge of Prospect Heights behind Barclays Center. Cocktails were creative and delicious as was the queso fundido. Waitress was super nice and extra friendly. Great experience overall and will definitely be back. EDIT: Staff here have ALWAYS been super nice! And the cocktails are consistently tasty!
Review №10
2019-08-27I really liked it here! At first I thought it was too noisy but I realized I was just being silly. Its a very cozy environment to bring your partner or some friends to chat and have some drinks. Our waiter was very friendly and very attentive. I originally was going to eat anything but then I decided to order the grilled cheese and Im really glad I did. The bread was pretty crunchy but overall it was really good and it was great with the pesto sauce on the side. Would definitely recommend coming here! The drinks were pretty pricey but overall good.