Identifies as women-owned
Yes
Sweet Surrender Bake House in Levittown
Categories
Location on the map
Levittown, Nassau County, New York, US
From the business
Service options
Delivery
Yes
In-store pick-up
Yes
In-store shopping
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Same-day delivery
Yes
Dine-in
No
Health and safety
Staff wear masks
Yes
Staff get temperature checks
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Safety dividers at checkout
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly
Yes
Planning
Quick visit
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 516-731-2424
Site: http://www.sweetsurrenderbakehou...
Site: http://www.sweetsurrenderbakehou...
Opening hours
- Monday:7AM–7PM
- Tuesday:7AM–7PM
- Wednesday:7AM–7PM
- Thursday:7AM–7PM
- Friday:6AM–7PM
- Saturday:6AM–7PM
- Sunday:6AM–6PM
Comments (199)
Went to this place on a whim not expecting anything. The traditional slice of cheesecake was the best I ever had! No idea what was in it but don’t change the recipe ever.
They have the best donuts I’ve ever had!!! So fresh! My family always gets them.
Delicious custom cakes to order. The staff is always very friendly and provide a consistent product.
First time here and had high expectations, $18 for 6 donuts and they all tasted stale, specialty donuts with cereal on top costs $5 each and couldnt even take more than one bite because the cereal was bad
The crumb cake with the cracker, raspberry and crumb cake was amazing. I will have to inquire about all the other bakes as well.Thanks!
Had a custom bday cake. Looked great and tasted amazing
Great place has my favorite candy and great sodas nothing bad to say going back to get nerds and Reeses soon
The most helpful, and kind girls behind the counter plus a beautiful cake we ordered.A bit pricey for the sweets.
Great bakery and friendly staff. Its soo great that they have sugar free options as well!
Very good place the buttercream cakes are amazing.
Can I buy everything? Many delicious baked treats to choose from. Great customer service and delicious baked goods.
Everything was fresh and tasty the doughnuts were fluffy and fresh had a ring shaped cake with crumble and chocolate drizzle that was outstanding prices were very fair and the two young ladies behind the counter were very nice
If you are into sweets, this is your place! They also offer coffee in the mornings and carry a variety of baked goods, including assortment of bread loafs.
This bakery is legit - my ALL time favorite on Long Island! Everything fresh ALWAYS! Staff is super friendly and helpful. Prices are affordable. Bakery is clean and clearly follows social distancing rules. But the best part? Every single thing Ive ever purchased from SS is delicious - from their sugar free blueberry muffins, cookies, cakes and pies to their St. Josephs pastry (got the LAST one late this morning)! Its endless!Please try them out if you have not already! I will always continue to support our local businesses through these tough times and if you agree, then Sweet Surrender should definitely be on your list!🎂🍩🧁🥧🍪
They have the best baked goods. Bread is delicious, their cakes are as good as they look. Will keep supporting them.
Me and my family typically love this bakery. All the desserts are quality and delicious but this time really put a bad taste in my mouth. The Staff was extremely rude and tried to rush us out of the store. Also I understand because of the mandates that there can only be 2 people in at a the store at a time but when I went to go look on the other side of the store to see what cakes and pies there were on the other side of the showcase, we were told to stay on our side of the counter. How are we supposed to see all of the desserts you offer? We even tried to purchase more things and ask a question about a pie a the girl behind the counter was very impatient and gave us a snarky face. I think if you want to have returning customers then maybe teach your staff some customer service skills.
I was excited to see how the cakes look on the website! However to my disappointment they did not executed my order the way I wanted. I even sent a picture of another cake...all they had to do is follow the pic and I specifically said call me if you have any questions... This place is not a bake house, they are only good for cookies and cupcakes. AND They still charge me full price. Smh.
Wow I have had the best jelly doughnut in over 50 years since I was a teenager in Wyckoff Heights Brooklyn. Webbers bakery was an old fashion German bakery on Wyckoff Ave and every Friday there was a line down the block . I would stand in a line for Sweet Surrenders Jelly doughnuts. Theyre just as good if not better than Webbers. I moved away from NY to a suburb in Kansas City. I came for visit. If you have plans to expand make KC your for city Ill be your biggest customer and promoter.Len R. From KC
Alive with Deliciousness!! 💘🍩🍰 Bakery that seduces your senses with its fragrant aroma and diet common sense momentarily waltzes out the door and you find yourself craving sweetstuff like a crannoli: Flakey, moist, and just the right level of sweetness topped with cannoli shell pieces. The perfect something with my Tea..☕While there, I picked a raspberry crumb donut and it was OUT OF THIS WORLD. It was Sooo Tasty, 💋 and incredibly moist, fantastic crumble, and awesome surprise layer of jelly. Could eat a dozen of them! Thank goodness my common sense returned and out we walked to the car with my Crumby donut and crannoli. LOL!! ☕🎂🍩🍰 Update: 2-16 Thank you for responding! I cannot wait to try your new flavors, will def stop in!!
Our doughnuts and pastries were amazing and fresh. High variety of different baked goods.
Love, love their rainbow cookie cheesecake. Their cakes are always fresh and fairly priced. My go to bakery. Friendly and helpful staff as well.
Awesome bakery in Levittown. Unfortunately, they no longer offer the Crannoli, which was my favorite, but every time i walk in i want to ask for one of everything, please! Walked in there today and spent $50. Thanks Sweet Surrender!
This bakery is 17 minutes from my house, but well worth the trip. Everything is delicious. Prices are amazing. They have a pound cake that has raspberry coating and crumbs on the outside. OMG!
I have been going to this bakery for over 30 years since it was called the levittown bakery. They definitely cleaned it up with the new ownership. They always had the best jelly and Boston cream doughnuts. Recently, they changed the jelly in their doughnuts, when I brought them to our last family gathering everyone agreed the Jelly is not what it used to be. The Boston cream is still very good. We also get their rolls often. I had gotten a cake there once (dont remember under what ownership) and it was so dry inside I never got another one again. They do have other good things in there that they bake fresh daily. I do recommend going there to give it a try.
I ordered a cake for my coworker who is moving to a new state for grad school but when I got there I was told the order was never put in so I had to wait for them to make it. At first I was extremely disappointed because I would now be late to the going away party but the ladies working there were extremely nice about it! They made sure I didn’t have to wait in the long line again and even offered me a complimentary cake pop for the wait. The amazing customer service paired with their delicious cake has guaranteed my loyalty to them for all future pastry purchases!!
I went to place an order for a tres leches birthday cake. the lady took my order for a pick up the next day.1. So i called the next day to tell them that i would be picking up the cake at 6pm instead of 4 pm. they asked for my order and i told them it was a tres leches cake. THEY COULD NOT LOCATE MY ORDER because instead of tres leches cake they had VANILLA CAKE on my order.2. i asked them to change it to tres leches. they said it will be $5 extra for tres leches and i agreed to pay.3. i went to pick up the cake and paid for everything, only to realize later that they gave me a VANILLA CAKE instead of TRES LECHES.i was very disappointed by this and the birthday cake was ruined. bad business & bad servicing.
Great pastries at reasonable prices. I have not tried the cakes, but they look great! Update - I tried the cakes and they are amazing as well!
Best donuts in the area. They are unique and fresh. Prices are great and the staff is super friendly. The Italian pastries are delicious too. Haven’t had the cakes yet but they look amazing.
This is a gem of a bakery in Levittown. From the fresh donuts and pasties this place is a delight.They do custom cakes for any occasion. Just make sure you order ahead of time.A must try is their awesome donuts chock full of jelly or filling if you like Boston Cream.Once you go, youll be back again and again.
My first time at this bakery & it would not be my last. Everything I bought the Raisin bread & the cookies was Absolutely Delicious!!!Great customer service!
We purchased a cake for my bridal shower and it was AMAZING. Definitely the talk of the party. The staff was so kind and generous while helping us pick out what flavors. We ended up going with one layer of vanilla and one layer of chocolate cake, with a layer of raspberry filling and a layer of chocolate mousse. The raspberry filling was to die for! They also delivered the cake right to the party so we didnt have to worry about picking it up. Thank you Sweet Surrender!!
Their apple strudel is fantastic. I try not to eat too many sweets but thats my new bakery. Friendly, clean, and fantastic products.
They have a large selection of delicious cakes and pastries. The staff were very polite. This is my go to bakery.
Baked goods were pretty good. Black and White cookie was a little cake-y but the rainbow bar and brownie were pretty tasty and not too expensive. Nice little place, staff wasnt friendly but the place was clean and I didnt wait on line, so no complaints. Selection is fair. Not the best, but recommended.
Enjoyed their jam-covered Bundt cake many times till finally I caught an opportunity to visit myself and salivate over all the goodies. The fact that they like to play and innovate amongst old staples tells me the bakers enjoy their craft. The goods show for it and the happy counter crew sends the place into 5-star territory.
Great bakery. Order a specialty cake for a surprise birthday party. The cake came out amazing and tasted great. Got alot of compliments. They really did an amazing job.
I used to love this bakery- have been going to it my whole life! I don’t understand, but for some god awful reason they recently changed the jelly they use in their donuts :/ they used to be THE BEST and now they’re almost inedible. Very disappointing!
Favorite bakery in the area!! The donuts are to die for as well as the Crannoli. Everything else is just as good. I used to go in here twice a week then realized how much weight I was gaining. Now I reduced it to every other week. But, i miss all thos wonderful baked goods!!!
This place is amazing. Fresh pastries/bread. Staff is courteous and friendly. Always pleasant going into this bakery. Wouldn’t go anywhere else.
Ive been going here for many years ( I think theyve been in business for decades) - Great french crullers, which most bakeries dont have - cinnamon raison buns too. I love the powered crullers and egg rolls. When I get a cake, the Mocha cake is the one - its wonderful. My favorite bakery .
Twice in last month I went to Bakery around noon to get favorite items, the cheese and crumb buns. Both times found them stale, very disappointed. Yesterday my beef was with the server whose attitude was also stale as she snapped responses. Not pleasant. What is happening at Sweet Surrender?
First time there and bought lots of stuff for the office. Woman who helped me was very nice and even helped me to my car. Everyone enjoyed all items I bought especially the rainbow cake!
This place was awesome! They go above and beyond to make sure you are satisfied! Not only did they deliver a beautiful and great tasting cake to my boyfriends office for his birthday when I was out of town, but they also printed out the card that I emailed them and delivered it with the cake! All with under 12 hours notice!
ProThe staff was friendly.ConsI bought a cake very dry and stale! Only cut a few slices the day of the event and the rest of the cake(4/5th) was thrown in the garbage. The other items I purchased was not horrible but would not go to the bakery again.
Very nice! Pastries are well made and great! Maybe consider Ralph’s Italian Ices. Doesn’t look in the best condition, but definitely will blow your mind because it is so good.
Best cheesecake on Long Island! I love how the people that work there are helpful & friendly. I also admire how creative the delicious cakes & treats are. I highly recommend this bakery.
Excellent bakery my personal favorite. I will pass 3 other bakeries to go here
DELICIOUS, best cake ever. We tried an amazing cake, it was a rainbow cheesecake....So good and first time Ive ever had it. It was a big hit. WORTH the calories
So far I had two cakes made from here and both times they were amazing. They were just what I wanted and tasted moist and scrumptious. I finally found a place I love!!!
Overall a very good spot. Tried their famous crannoli. While it was good, maybe my expectations were a little too high because of its reputation as I didnt think think it was great. For my taste the crannoli cream kind of overpowered the rest of the cronnoli, so it was like a bready cannoli. I tried some other donuts there as well and they were very fresh and tasty.
Stopped here after a doctors appointment a d tbe bakery items were plentiful and very fresh. We will be going back here again
The desserts are aesthetically pleasing. I found it a bit too thick and sweet for my liking. Not as great as some of the other bakeries nearby.
YUMMMMMMY! Love the Pennsylvania Dutch pound cake, the cup desserts . They have BETTER Italian semolina bread then the Italian bakeries and stores in Wantagh, Bellmore.
First time going here today. Made a good impression. Large selection of cookies, and other baked goods. Everything was fresh and tasted good. Clean bakery, i will be back for more!
Amazing they made a customCherry Shortcake no BUTTERCREAM IT WAS AMAZING! GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE! VERY CLEAN VERY NICE.
This was a quick stop to pick up something to bring to a friends house. I have driven past here many times and Im glad I stopped in. Very nice selection, warm and friendly service and the cupcakes were delicious.
Amazing desserts. Customer Service was excellent. I would go there everyday if I lived here.
I ordered a Communion cake here. It was amazing. Probably the best cake I ever had. Everyone loved it
Has great gluten free coconut chocolate dipped macaroons and other almond gluten free products.
Onion pocket rolls are the best Ive ever eaten..and the Chocolate custard donuts are super tasty! Top notch for over 50 years.
The bakery makes a great custard crumb. The jelly donuts are pretty good also.
This is the only bakery I go to. I wont eat a red velvet cake from anywhere else because theirs is too tier.
Pastries and baked goodies are always great here. Have brought cupcakes from Sweet Surrender for coworkers birthdays on a few occasions and theyre always a big hit.
I surrender! This place has the best Donuts and cupcakes anywhere.
Everything was super delicious
Best Baked Goods in Nassau County ive found. Cardinalis used to be it when i was a teen and Dortonis was their replacement.Well now, Sweet Surrender has raised the bar with tastier traditionals and more original selections. Plus, 1000% friendlier counter staff. No snobby self entitled little twits that are upset that they need to work at Sweet Surrender. Just friendly personable ladies that have a just right attitude. This goes for the owners too.Always a pleasant experience here. Keep up the GREAT WORK ladies.
Went there once, no plans of returning. I felt stop and shops bakery items were just as good for less money. No need to go out of my way for it.
Rudest people! “We stopped receiving orders for thanksgiving on Monday”. “That’s it! “next year you know honey” never bothering coming back to this place ever again.
This bakery is fantastic I have not gotten anything that is not great love jelly donuts apple horn and buns they give Dortonis a run for their money.
Im a repeat customer and I can assure you that you will not be disappointed. The rainbow cheesecake, bread pudding cake and cranolies are delicious.
Apparently has the same baker/recipe, when my father was a little boy in Levittown 50 years ago. It is still that good. Enjoy it while you can!
Have never had a bad experience!!
Nice bakery, very clean and good selection of items. Their Danish, turnovers and doughnuts are very good.
Cakes are ok staff is for some strange reasom place is not really that welcoming dieant rrally lool clean inside either .last time i ever go there .the bakery in shop rite is just as good and the baker actual talks to you i give this place a 5 overall
Friendly service. Good variety (and tasty) of sugar-free baked goods not easily found elsewhere👍👍👍
They have the best donuts and pastries. Love the powdered custard donut
Love this bakery but they dont have pumpernickel bread😔
Wrong cake. took extra money from me and gave a wrong cake.bad servicing. bad business. bad service!!
Best seven layer cake anywhere. Crannolis are also a great treat.
Everything is fresh and amazing!
The staff are great, helpful, make suggestions when you dont know exactly what to get, oh and lets not forget the baked goods are great too, Cranolis!!!
They have the best creme brule and cannoli on long island the staff are so friendly the girls in there always smile n polite
This bakery is amazing they have everything and then some.The staff are friendly and helpful.
Great bakery! Friendly service! Good coronavirus policy and protection!
ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! cheesecake and Italian cookies were outrageous 👍🏼
A great bakery, good prices and beautifulChoices.
AHHH TEA BISCUTS,BOSTON CREME DOUGHNUTS,AND EGG SHAPED ROOLS WHAT CAN BE BETTER THAN THIS. ALL BAKED FRESH . DELICIOUS AND THERE PIES AND CAKES ARE GOOD TOO.
Awesome small-town bakery. The cronnolli is legit. Breads are well-made and tasty.
Great friendly customer service and incredible Oreo cake.
The fresh made donuts are always very good and are far better than the generic donut from Dunkin donuts!
All very good and no insane lines like the crazy place!
Pastries a alright, a little overpriced, thats my only reason for giving it 4 stars, try the cranoly! Its a heavenly doughnut
Fresh and strong coffee, fresh tasty pastry. Friendly staff. Joice and Sara we love you.
This is our favorite bakery. We love their cakes!
Best bakery around
A seven-layer cake is out of this world the best I found on Long Island
Fantastic donuts, fantastic staff!Cant wait to dig in!⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Good stuff here, staff friendly, but expensive. I recommend it specialty if you have a sweet teeth. I know ill be back.
Always fresh..Always good. The BEST rye bread you ever tasted!!
Great raspberry Crum cake.very helpful staffs.
Lovely pastries. Owner very pleasant, helpful and accommodating with event services.
The Greek owner has customized several beautiful and scrumptious cakes for me!!!
Excellent cookies, pastries, breads, cannolis. Great service.
I had a delicious black and white cookie. Nice people too
Came in just before they closed doors at 6pm. They served me and l bought what was left including a few rolls.
My go-to bakery. The staff here is so sweet and the food is such a treat.
Great service, great staff, great selection and wonderful cakes.
Really great service. Their products are so fresh and taste delicious!
Homemade sweets.. sweet fresh bakery aroma the moment we walked in.
Good places and so good pastry there make it
Great bakery. Some items can be pricey.
BEST JELLY AND BOSTON CREAMS HANDS DOWN....COOKIES, PASTRY, CAKE, COOKIES, BREAD..THE BEST!!
Apple pie is delicious....service is great..staff is cordial and helpful
Best cinnamon sugar donuts youve ever had!
Love this place. Delicious baked goods and polite employees
Great treats & delicious desserts!
Love this place. Fresh and amazing plus service is outstanding!!
Great pastries and cake. Fast service
If you have a sweet tooth this is definitely the place to go!
Everything they make is delicious
Best jelly doughnuts anywhere 👍
Quality has gone down over the last year .
Best bakery on Long Island 😊
Great bread pudding! Very friendly staff!
I love the donuts from there
Yummy cakes...Great service
Their crannolis are out of this world amazing! They should be illegal. ; )
Most delicious baked goods around!
Always visit when I am in town. Amazing selection!
Havent had anything that wasnt delicious from them!
Beat bakery around. All there stuff is awesome.
Love this bakery. Never disappointed.
Best pastries great prices
Hands down THE BEST bread pudding.
Girls are very nice, products are delicious
Delicious bakery on par with Dortoni.
Best bakery in Nassau!
Very good neighborhood bakery
Love the rainbow cheesecake 😍
They have Pies!!!
Great donuts and cakes.
Love the mini carrot cake
Love the custard crumb and napoleons!!
Always great!! Love them
So good, I have to restrain myself.
Best bakery ever!
Love their bakery
My wife favorite place.
Best bakery in the neighborhood
Best bakery in the USA
Amazing prices and great products
The best bakery around
Best Bakery around
Everything is delicious.
Linzer tarts done right!
Great old school bakery
OMG Soooooo good!!!!
Nice bakery
Everything is the delicious!
Very good baked goods
Great selections for all
Great Bakery
Great cakes & cookies
Very good selection
Good Italian pasty
Great service and treats
Fresh and good..
Great
The crannolis are amazing!
Great dessert
Great bakery
Great bakery
Its the best around
Wonderful, as always!
Nice
Excellent
Excellent service
Extra yummy, Extra Friendly
Nice selection
Excellent products
Yum
Delicious pastries
One word...Crannoli!
Awesome Crannoli
Delicious cranolli
This place makes me ☺
One word- yum
Love this place
To expensive
Total reviews rating 4.6
199 Reviews for Sweet Surrender Bake House 2023:
Review №1
2022-05-30My daughter ordered a Rainbow cake, cupcakes & filled pastries for her dad & my Anniversary.I’m not a lover of rainbow cookies etc but your cake was sensational as were the creamy cupcakes and pastries!My other daughter & son-in-law raved about everything as well!We will be ordering from you whenever we need desserts.Congratulations on your wonderful desserts!
Review №2
2022-02-15Everything at Sweet Surrender is fresh and delicious. They have the best jelly donuts! And the pecan coffee ring is teriffic. Other favorites are black and white cake, rainbow cake and bread pudding. You cant go wrong getting fresh breads and rolls as well. The staff is very helpful, making sure you get what you want.
Review №3
2022-05-02I ordered my daughters Communion cake from Sweet Surrender. Not only did they do a beautiful job decorating it, it was also so fresh and delicious. My guests could not stop talking about it. Cannot recommend this bakery enough.
Review №4
2021-08-31It’s so nice to find a good bakery!We needed a treat for my niece, she loved the cookies with sprinkles.
Review №5
2022-03-11I love this bakery. They never disappoint with there cakes. The strawberry shortcake is my favorite both the cake and individual cake cup. The cakes are fresh and the bakery uses fresh fruit. Trust you wont be disappointed in taste, visual appeal, price or anything.
Review №6
2021-07-30Would love to give this place ZERO stars.Ordered a strawberry short cake for a birthday party. Strawberries had MOLD on them when we opened the box!!! Seriously?!It was disgusting Next stop Better Business Bureau
Review №7
2022-06-30DO NOT USE!!! What a horror-show! I ordered cookie favors for 6$ each. This came to 216$ for 36. I went to pick up the cookies and the writing/ icing is all smeared. Looks like a pre-schooler decorated them. The bakery told me there is no time to remake them. When I offered to give them back in exchange for my money. I was only offered 25$. I was told the owner would call me but no one has! What a joke.
Review №8
2022-03-23Great place since I moved to Nassau I have tried other bakeries but this one is the best overall. Fresh everything and their custom cakes are amazing.
Review №9
2021-07-23We ordered a cake for my daughters 2nd birthday. The cake looked so beautiful and tasted amazing! We couldn’t have been any happier. It was so easy to place an order and they made sure to write down the details I wanted for the cake.
Review №10
2018-02-17If you havent had a crannoli, you have to try it! Its a cronut (croissant donut) with cannoli filling and topped with cannoli chips. The strawberry Cheesecake cronnoli is absolitely delicious! Their cakes are beautiful and whimsical. The staff is very friendly and helpful. The prices are fair for what you receive.The is street parking in the front, and theres a small parking lots inbetween the pizzeria and south of the border restaurant.