The Carnegie Hotel in New York
This is my second time staying at the Carnegie Hotel and it was as wonderful as the first time. Beautiful room, wine at 5 pm, breakfast, fantastic service as well. A gem.
I really don’t want to leave a review and give away how good this place is. If you’re looking for a really well designed and simple, clean, and convenient hotel in Lincoln Square, this is it. The design is beautiful and so efficient - whoever did it knew what they were doing. The rooms aren’t big, but they’re actually fairly big for NYC. The drawer fridge is brand new and amazing! This hotel has all the little perks you don’t find anymore - including cushy slippers and bathrobes. They take note of your arrival time, and I had no problem checking in early. There’s a cute breakfast/snack bar in the lobby with everything you could need. And did I mention this place is clean, clean, clean? Love! 😍
Its very well located and offers a good value for the price. Very disappointed with the breakfast offered during covid, early 2022, almost all the packed pastries were stale
Wonderful stay here; probably the best experience Ive had to date in Manhattan. Excellent location - just a ten minute walk to either Central Park or Times Square. Very nice and clean hotel and rooms. We stayed in a room with a king bed and had enough space for our daughters pack-n-play, and had a nice view of the street from the window. The staff were incredibly friendly and accommodating. The included breakfast and adjacent parking garage were additional perks. Would definitely stay here again.
Hidden charges of $30/nt that they deduct from incidental hold. The room was paid for but they charge extra without pre-notification when you book.
Lovely place and staff. Clean room, an amazing location, and free snacks 24/7🙃
Because of a rise in covid, Canceled my 4 rooms booked about 12 hours before we were supposed to check in. Policy says one night charge for such a late cancel but I wasnt charged anything. Much appreciated. Will stay here when covid calms down again
My boyfriend and I stayed here a few nights ago and were so impressed! Such a cute boutique hotel, everything was spotless and clean which is always a must when searching for a hotel. Complimentary tea, juice and coffee no matter what time of day or night!
So very impressed .. and havent arrived for my stay yet! Alexandra.. front desk manager I believe.. so polite/professional and sincere with pre-arrival enquiries. Very apologetic for the short wait on hold. After which, a refreshing grounded sense of ... I will definitely do what I can to make your stay perfect. A pleasure... more to come...
Really good hotel, with small and compact but efficient room. Comfortable showers, comfortable beds. The breakfast was mostly cereals and bagels.
Nice staff, great room & even though they said no housekeeping, our bed was made & fresh towns were given daily. The snacks, breakfast & happy hour were fabulous.
This is NOT a four stars hotel. There is no variety of facilities. There is no restaurant in the hotel. There is small corner for guests to chill with tables— but with more than 8 ppl in the room you can feel it’s already packed “ especially during the COVID” you need more space and a better ventilation in the area. NOT good for families or with young children.The room is way too small for the price. The bed measurements is FULL size bed NOT queen size. It’s a bit disappointing when I expected and paid for queen size bed but got the full size bed. I talked to the front desk about it but she claimed everything is in queen sizes. So I said the measurements are not lied. Please go measure it. Then she said our bed sheets are ordered in queen size. So I said” yes which can also fitted to the full size bed”.You can expect this hotel as a 3 stars hotel. It’s simple, clean and compact in a good location. It’s good for tourists who are travel lights ( no space), looking for a place to rest after a long day of touring, good location and near subways.They have free light breakfast for you as a perk. Some yogurt, muffins banana and coffees. Also a happy hour 5-6pm for wine and snacks.There are better hotel options with the same price if it’s not your last minute booking.
Excellent stay! Staff was friendly and accommodating. I was given an unexpected room upgrade for my birthday! The hotel is very clean and modern. I would recommend to a friend.
The room was very modern and clean. Breakfast and afternoon snacks were great. Its in Manhattan where you can walk to central park and Times Square.
Let me acknowledge that the staff is AMAZING!!My room specifically was less than decent, tv had to addressed everyday and breakfast options were better at a Hilton.
I had a great stay. It was a little pricey though. The staff was friendly and I enjoyed the free wine from 5pm to 6pm. Everything was clean and in order. The location was excellent with so much within walking distance. The rooms had blackout sheets you could control for privacy.
We stayed for 2 nights in March 2018 in Room 1104.FANTASTIC for a few days in the city. VERY SMALL room, but VERY WELL DONE.Plenty of shelf space to put things, newly done rooms overall, very cute shower with overhead rain faucet. Bed felt new, and everything was very clean. Plenty of drawers if you wanted to unpack. I also liked that for a small space, the fridge was a pull-out drawer style so you don’t have to squat down to look inside that fridge.Really well designed room.We had room 1104. The view from the window was the brick wall of the next building, which is GOOD so we don’t have to hear traffic. We had a very nice quiet night’s rest.Carnegie Hotel offers a complimentary happy hour with wine. We took part in that happy hour the first night, and found that people were not mingling mainly with the people they were with instead of networking with new people, but we still enjoyed our time there. The wine and food offered was fine, though, and it was a nice gesture from the hotel.At any given time, there is free snacks and coffee and beverages in that lobby.Given the location, room cleanliness and general newness of that hotel, we WOULD stay here again!
I had good night sleep and a great shower. However, the view of the inner court is only for HVAC enthusiasts. Then again I dont know if the views from the rooms on the other side would be any better.
Modern, clean rooms with a great rock and roll theme. Staff were polite and accommodating and the location was great! Room was surprisingly quiet for the area.
Convenient for most any mid-town business. The staff are friendly & accommodating, the rooms are well appointed if a bit small, but this is mid-town! They offer a better than usual complementary breakfast, and a nice happy hour every afternoon. Solid value and, did I mention how conveniently located they are!?! Give them a try on your next trip, you wont regret it!
I cant say enough good about this place, its clean, great location, friendly staff, good layout, great price... We especially enjoyed the wine hour from 5:00 - 6:00 PM...although we only went once its still a great service to offer. The rooms themselves are not large, but its a boutique hotel so I wasnt expecting large rooms. The shower did have a rainfall shower head and they booked us in a few hours early after holding our bags for the morning. For the wine hour and breakfast they encourage you to take glasses and plates to your room, which is a nice touch. Also, I was able to use wine glasses and a cork screw when I arrived late one night with my own bottle of wine. We came from the Marquis Marriott which is where we spent the first two nights of our trip and I would take a room at The Carnegie Hotel any day over the Marquis. Also, they had nice bath robes!
Very clean, fairly sized room and quiet. Loved the size of the shower, could fit 2 people in.Also helpful staff. Loved the wine and cheese hour and the snacks and drinks whenever we wanted them- super helpful for tourists who are in and out of the hotel sight seeing. I would definitely go back!
Very nice place! Clean, modern, well appointed rooms.... the staff is very friendly and efficient and the snacks are really great...breakfast is included..and coffee/other drinks are available 24 hours....no penny pinching here; thanks so much..
Lovely little hotel in a great location. The rooms are small, but clean & modern. Very quiet, floors only have 4 or so rooms on them so you don’t have to listen to other people coming and going constantly.
For the price the location, rooms and staff is a great deal! Staff were very attentive and stride to help us on our long trip from Toronto. Rooms are super clean and close to new.Hard and expensive parking if you’re driving.Will definitely return.
The hotel was beautiful and the staff was very friendly and helpful. The beds were very comfortable and the bathrooms are beautiful! The one thing I loved the most is the location. Its right next to Carnegie Hall and not a far walk from both Central Park and Times Square. Overall I am very pleased with my stay and will definitely be coming back next time Im in NY.
Excellent stay! They have free breakfast and a happy hour with cheese and wine 👌🏼 snacks and drinks all day for guests. The staff was incredibly polite and friendly. Will definitely be coming back.
I did not have the best experience during my stay here. We stated prior it was our anniversary/my birthday and nothing was done. We have stayed at other nyc hotels that made it much more of a special experience. Also the breakfast had no cream cheese for the bagels which was odd. I would not recommend this hotel unfortunately. Also we called around 1pm and were told the room was ready and when we got back to check in had to sit and wait.
An absolutely delightful little gem.The staff here have been so great and accommodating. The room is cute, very clean, and pint-sized. The location is great, and I could not be happier with my choice in where to stay for our NYC explore and have fun trip.
Great hotel! Conveniently located in Midtown, super close to Central Park, Soho, the 5th avenue. The staff was very friendly (except for the lady at breakfast, she was always moody). Check in was super fast, so was check out. Loved the fact that they offer continental breakfast (7-10 am) and cheese, crackers, and wine daily from 5-6 pm. They also have 24 hr service of snacks, coffee, water, and tea. They offer two bottles of water in every room. Rooms are small but they are very comfortable. Bed and linens were good. TV and cable at every room. Wifi works perfectly. They charge a 30 USD extra daily fee but if you take advantage of breakfast and the already mentioned food offerings, its worth it. A great budget hotel (at least in low season) and an excellent option to stay at NYC.
Nice, cozy, clean place. No surcharges. Breakfast included. All day coffe and tea with cookies. Wine hour from 5 to 6pm. Bathrobe, sleepers and small fridge in the room. Nice street view. Very very clean and contemporary. Best choice for those who perform or just vist Carnegie Hall. 3 nights cost us $1080 but we had just a great time there. Check out at 12 pm, you can leave your bags for free at their storage if you want to go for a walk after check out. Loved this place , will stay there again!
Small, but beautifully formed! Rooms very well designed and appointed, and providing free drinks/snacks is a great idea for visitors to such a busy city. Staff were courteous and efficient. Would love to return!
While the rooms are small, they are very nicely done, modern, well appointed, functional, and tastfull. The free breakfast, snacks, water, and evening wine and cheese are a very nice touch. Would definitely return!
The hotel is a tucked away gem right across from The Carnegie Hall. They offer free breakfast, wine and cheese hour, and a room with different snacks, coffee, drinks and cookies.The ambience is very nice, the rooms are small yet comfortable, and the decor is updated and modern. They provide you with slippers in the bathroom, a robe in the closet, and sub outlets.There is a parking garage adjacent to the hotel that is reasonably priced and its walking distance from Times Square yet quiet enough to not hear the bustle.
Clean place to stay with a great location. Service was 5 stars. The rooms were clean. Only slightly negative comment is that when staying on the top floor you hearing a constant pipe banging sound. Its not noticable during the day, but at night you hear it.
This hotel is wonderfully located, the rooms are efficient, the service impeccable. Do yourself a favor and stay here. Snacks all day, wine between 5-6, breakfast in the morning. I’ll never stay anywhere else when in New York.
I had a wonderful stay at this hotel.My room was very clean and comfortable.The staff is friendly and caring.Vetiola and Alexandra at the front desk were fabulous!!!!!! I will definitely stay at this hotel in the future!!!!!
This is a new or newly renovated clean hotel with the amenities you appreciate but not the ones you don’t need. The location is great - easy access to most subway lines and perfectly situated between Central Park and the Theatre district while being quiet and peaceful. 24hr healthy(ish) snacks are appreciated- fruit, cookies and chips including baked lays. The price is on point- at the time of writing it is about 10% less than other premium hotels in the area but of course you don’t get the perks of luxury and other premier hotels- mainly room size and adequate breakfast. I’d like boiled eggs or charcuterie during breakfast as I limit carbs- not available here. TIP- there are two things that are weird in the rooms — one the closet- it opens opposite to how it looks like it will. The door in not the side with the cutout handle but the one next to the cutout which looks like a handle. A quick fix for the hotel would be to install a handle/knob on the opening side to save the sanity of your staff and a bad first impression. Two the shower is tight and turns on counter clockwise on the bottom faucet to turn on. Let it run as the temperature can vary at the same position shower to shower. The top switches the flow from hose to rainshower. The desk gets tonnes if calls about this too. Overall for the price it’s like an 6/5 star but if it were prices to other equivalent hotels in the area I’d give it a 4. Perfect as a safe area for solo travel if you are here for plays.
For the last 10 days we called The Carnegie Hotel home and it really felt like home.The staff were great and always friendly, the room wasnt big but it wasnt small either compared to other hotels I have stayed in, in New York. Ultra modern room with a great bathroom and the shower was large, the room was super clean and the bed was comfortable.Coffee and snacks available 24/7 for all guests.....if I had one issue its breafest time, make sure you have it early or late cause it is a small area and when its full it can become an obstacle course with all the guest filling up the room. Every day in the afternoon between 5 and 6 the hotel treats their guests to wine and snacks.The location is great and situated between Time Square and Central Park and the subway is just around the corner.I would highly recommend this hotel and being that this is my 4th time to New York I would definitely be coming back to The Carnegie Hotel.Great work guys, Im sure you will keep it up.
This is a smaller hotel with 4 rooms per floor. Great location between Central Park and the theater district. Very clean! The standard Queen room is tiny but beautiful, and things like the slide-out fridge and glass bathroom pocket door make perfect use of the space. The decor is great. And again, very clean. Bed is comfortable. Bathroom is spotless. Shower has handheld and a Grohe rain shower. Snacks and drinks (coffee, tea, juice) are in the lobby 24hrs. Wi-Fi is solid (150Mb/s), and plenty of free on-demand HD content on the Samsung flat screen. We had a rear-facing room but staff still managed to get us somewhat of a view from the 18th floor.Overall experience: no frills, but a clean modern room at a great value. Would stay again. A+
Chose Carnegie Hotel based on the reviews online and it was a great choice. We just needed a conveniently located modern and clean place to sleep inbetween events with friends and this fit the bill. Boutique style facility with limited number of rooms. Like most NYC hotels, rooms are small but efficiently designed. Clean, contemporary finishes. Great wifi, nice snacks and beverages available in lobby. Easy walk to the park, nearby theatres, Times Square, etc. Our friends all stayed at the Wellington on the same block and had a very disappointing experience so we are glad we broke from the herd.
Very tiny hotel, tiny breakfast area, and even tinier rooms. Good location. No fitness center, which I had no idea about. Free breakfast and snacks throughout the day. Not bad if you’re ONE person staying there for a few days.
Staying 1 night. Mainly to sleep. June 9-10. So I know there are tons of reviews on line, I like to keep things simple. Obviously, small rooms dont let that throw you off (its new York) my room 1004, view of another building so keep blinds closed. Everything modern, up to date. New from changing stations for your devices to bathroom toilet. Space is limited so dont bring tons with you. 10 min (real) walk to time square and just far away from 7th Ave that its no bother to walk. Maybe something that should be mentioned on other reviews is that there is a really inexpensive parking garage next to the hotel so dont have to go crazy finding parking. Final thought..I for one like newer/updated hotels, specially in a major city. You want classics rustic or even nice hotel go to maine or something like that. In a major city in 2018 thinks should be new, clean and more improtant moder. I expect it and I will pay for it. I really think this hotel highloghts all the right things at the right price point in a major city full of over priced stuff near the tourists capital of the world (other than Disney)
Very nice hotel. Staff was super friendly rooms was clean.
Although the room size is small, the environment is good. Breakfast is relatively simple. The traffic is more convenient.
Friendly service. It was great to have the little snacks and food options to tide you over after travelling. Sound was not an issue. Rooms are compact but plenty of space for a visit and to relax
Hidden fee of $28.69 for coffee and a very lacklustre breakfast. Was not informed of this charge, nor was I given a receipt.
Great Hotel. Three excellent restaurants near by, Souvlaki GR at the entrance is awesome. Great Greek food. Rooms are clean, business attire. $199 a night. I highly recommend it.
Beautiful room. Polite staff.
No Heat! Fire Alarm!Stayed in a Junior Suite this hotel for 4 nights. First night NO HEAT! Second Night NO HEAT - when we asked for help the staff told us that they ALREADY knew our room had no heat and the gave us a tiny heater?! Third day was complete panic when our rooms fire alarm went off!! The elevator doors automatically locked (and we were on the 18th floor). We were stopped in the stairwell by an employee and told the alarm was tripped due to someone working in the building. However, 2 different employees showed up at our room and informed us that it was our specific room that had caused the alarm! Firefighters arrived at the hotel, people came and went from our room! Only after this was our heat finally fixed - just in time to check out. No one on staff apologized for the fiasco or for putting us in a room that they knew had no heat! When we arrived home we saw the following post on Trip Advisor... (proof that the hotel staff knowingly put us in a room with no heat!Holli K...La Quinta, California...Reviewed 2 days agoNo heat and noise but nice staffWe were scheduled to stay six nights. When we checked in, there was no heat in our room. Staff immediately checked into it, providing us with a small floor heater and attempting to fix the problem. After three days and nights of being cold and interrupted sleep from the noise of workmen outside our room, we checked out. The hotel did not charge us for the remaining nights. Also, our room was incredibly small and did not resemble the photos on the website.
Sometimes location is everything—especially if Carnegie Hall is your reason to be in the city. But this hotel also offers clean, modern rooms and friendly staff. If you want all that, but don’t want to pay for a big lobby and bellman, then Carnegie Hotel is for you. I plan to make it my regular landing place on annual trips here. It sure beats walking up and down 7th AV in a cold breeze.Update: Carnegie now charges double what I paid on my first visit. Therefore, I lower my rating from 4 stars to 3 stars. Value for money is not what it used to be.
It’s was simply perfect. We arrived early. We were immediately checked in & were upgraded. No issues whatsoever the staff is very professional and was friendly. It was a perfect birthday getaway.
Rooms are really tiny, but the bathrooms have rainfall shower and a desk for business purposes so thats really nice. Beds are super comfy.
The name of this hotel should Carnegie “no coffee in the room” Hotel. These guys have a coffee machine in the first floor lobby - and NOTHING in the room. Excuse? “We don’t have enough space in the room!” Well that’s smart (NOT!).I can’t say anything else. It’s like, you don’t have coffee machine in the room? Really? What planet are you on?It’s like saying “we don’t have a shower in the room, it’s in the nearby gym next block”.GET IT TOGETHER GUYS. GET IT TOGETHER.
Great staff. Very accommodating. Clean rooms. Very comfortable bed
Possibly a tad overpriced, breakfast was a disappointment, and beware of the concept of paying for a view. That aside - clean, lovely rooms, comfortable bed, fridge in your room to keep your beer that you find around the city chilly , and friendly staff. Id stay again.
The location is excellent, the rooms are somewhat small but still very clean and modern, everything works and the staff is very nice and helpful, they dont charge for mail, so thats actually very nice for someone not from the US
Absolutely loved my stay couldnt fault the hotel at all! Staff always pleasant and helpful and the breakfast and snacks available were perfect
Great place, awesome bathrooms, amazing location, really nice amenities
Great location and friendly staff.Hotel is clean and quiet.Breakfast and wine and cheese are not free as advertised.You will be charged an extra $30 per day for this whether you use it or not.Nothing in NY is free !!
Easy everything. Terrific staff and quiet rooms...at the back. The shared dining room is cute and a great place for a chat with fellow guests.
Nice hotel, small rooms but they have breakfast, snacks throughout the day and wine and cheese in the eve
Beautiful hotel in a great location for a great price. Will definitely book again
Clean, very small room, if you sleep with open window you will love the AC unit noise all around !!! Nice staff.
Great place. Room was clean and the wine and cheese was excellent - view from our room of Carnigie Hall awesome.
European style hotel. Very clean, cozy and great location. Superb for business travelers!
Awesome boutique hotel in a great location. Staff are friendly, informative and very helpful. Would recommend this hotel to anyone
Great little hotel close to the action.
Free snacks and the complimentary wine and cheese was a nice touch. Clean rooms and bathroom.
Clean, quiet boutique hotel in the midst of hectic midtown. I enjoyed my stay here.
Great service 👍, the room waited for us when we came although the check in hour was 4 hours later.
0xFe046dA5acF45B2f484C7Acda50FAbca5B45639BCome here
Convenient location, friendly staff, quiet, clean, medium sized, well laid out rooms
Nice. Practical and straight forward. Excelent for business travel. Good location. Friendly staff.
Staff could not be more helpful. Roo.s are clean and modern but small as you would expect in NYC
Super clean rooms, great location and kind staff. Highly recommended
Best and cleanest hotel in the city. Staff is amazing
Great location but the rooms are a bit tight!
Excellent location, friendly stuff. I liked having yogurts, bananas and other snacks around the clock.
Small cozy hotel. Modern, clean and well maintained.
Very nice small rooms good breakfast
Great staff. Nice room and a perfect location.
I installed the air conditioning in the lobby great looking Hotel but too expensive for me
Nice room, good price, would stay again.
Beautiful place, great location, rooms on the small side
Very helpful staff, neat rooms and excelent location.
Great service, nice rooms, great location
Room 1601 is fantastic, lovely bed and plenty of space!
Centrally located. Great staff. Clean and quiet
Very nice european style modern hotel
Excellent! Well done! Stylish, contemporary. All around perfection!
Simple nice place no frills or fuss but solid
Nice New hôtel, in a perfect area for visiting NY
Very nice. Warm, quite and clean.
Great location. Very clean. Great service
Excellent little hotel across from Carnegie Hall.
Affordable and super close to everything. Will stay again.
Convenient location, free wine hour and snacks.
Great hotel with nice people.
Great hotel great location great staff.
Great bed and great location.
Modern place, stuff very friendly.
Very nice boutique hotel.
Staffs are friendly and very cost efficient
Wonderful staff. Love the atmosphere
The best
When is a suite not a suite and a breakfast not a breakfast?
Great location and service
Very nice
Great service, in a great spot
Worst experience of my life.
Room 804
Friendly helpful staff
Really helpful staff
I just love this place
Super!
Good
Clean & cozy!
Good place
Solid boutique hotel with quiet rooms in a very good location... they would be getting five stars except for the fact my TV barely worked.Check-in experience was terrific - thank you Delia.
Excellent hotel - conveniently located for attractions and on a direct metro line from JFK Airport. Purely. Good cosmetics, textiles. Breakfasts (like almost everywhere else in the USA) are modest, but quite enough to start the day. Particularly pleased with the snacks and drinks in the lobby, and the wine hour 😋
Super well placed, pleasant and very clean room, friendly staff especially the woman who often worked in the evening, I do not have her name but very pleasant and super jovial, we have excellent memories, photo to follow
Cute. It was an excellent decision. Super well located close to central park and time square. Small but well decorated room. Super clean very nice. ❤ The price The best in the area at the end of the year.
Nearby subway station. Central Park. Market. The surrounding environment is good, such as restaurants. But the room space is small
Stayed for 4 days in NYC alone.A small hotel just off Carnegie Hall in Manhattan.The hotel is modern, monotone, calm yet stylish, clean and functional and nice.The staff is kind and the environment is quiet despite being a big city. There is no noise because it is not the type that stays in a large group.The location is great, so its the best place to set up as a sightseeing base in Manhattan.Light meals and drinks are free in the lobby, so its a good idea to have some.
Very satisfactory hotel!I made a reservation knowing that the room was small, but the first time I entered the room, I was a little embarrassed. However, the cleaning conditions such as beds and bathrooms are very good, and convenience facilities such as drawers/refrigerators are very convenient. The bathroom is the cleanest among the hotels Ive been to so far!!!The staff are friendly (especially the girls are really friendly) and the breakfast is pretty good.This is my third visit to New York, and I had the most quiet sleep at night. (This part seems to be different depending on the location of the room~ When checking in, when we arrived earlier than the official check-in time, we said, The room you can enter right now is noisy at night. I can give you a quiet room later. I got it, but it was a really quiet and sleepy room!!)There is no glitz like a large chain hotel, but I am very satisfied with the quiet and pleasant hotel, and I will return without hesitation the next time I visit New York. Thank you Canegi Hotel!
Hotel a stones throw from Time Square and Central Park is still very quiet. Clean and new room. Bath products stocked every day. Breakfast only sweet but varied and plentiful including snacks and fruit. Room with drink and cookie dispenser always available. The afternoon aperitif is excellent with cheese, peanuts, grapes and wine. Very friendly and helpful staff
Very good hotel in a central location, yet quiet (by New York standards). Nice staff and very modern and clean rooms with a modern bathroom (rainforest shower). A good price / performance ratio.Breakfast without hot food but perfectly adequate (toast, bagel, sweet pastries, jam, fruit, cornflakes, fully automatic coffee machine). It is also always replenished.Happy hour at 5 p.m. is also a good offer, and the flat rate has to be paid for this too. WiFi very fast. You can leave your suitcase free of charge on the day of departure.Good supermarket and deli is around the corner on the other side of Carnegie Hall.I can only say about the often criticized points: the breakfast room is small, but if you get up a little earlier, for example, 8 am, there is little going on. Disposable tableware is no longer available here. The rooms are a bit small but still comfortable compared to other hotels.
Are you world travelers? I highly recommend this hotel in New York. Central, brand new, breakfast included, hard to find here in the big apple, super clean, helpful staff and ready to meet you if you have difficulty with any problem Michael at the reception proved to be a great help. I highly recommend it
This carnegie hotel is a small but stylish but tasteful hotel just off the Carnegie Hall.Some of the residents seemed to be concerned with Carnegie Hall, and while the language of each country was flying, the topic seemed to be music-related. As a preference for smaller hotels than large ones, this interiorThe atmosphere of intelligence, and the harmony of soothing monotone and graish wood are very nice like NY.Both hardware and staff are reliable hotels!
Hotel in a great location, a few hundred meters from Central Park, very near to the metro. Continental breakfasts, so-so. 24-hour access to coffee, tea, cakes, fruit. Free wine tasting from 17-18 daily. Small rooms.
Very good, it is a small hotel but with excellent service. The rooms very clean and modern. Its location is perfect, two subway stations nearby, restaurants, central park. The food area is small but with breakfast included, with snacks service all day and with the wine hour in the afternoon, the truth is its size goes to a second term.Its very helpful staff, with flexibility to store our luggage before check-in and after check-out, while leaving our plane. In addition to its recommendation where to eat, places to visit, use of the subway, etc ...
Perfect location, excellent cleanliness, well stocked continental breakfast. Team friendly and attentive. OThey wound the final wine of the day. Complimentary juice, coffee and water at any time. I recommend it and I will be back.
Good location, small but clean rooms. Friendly service. Breakfast is very simple, but should not be offered on plastic dishes. Here a more ecological solution would be desirable.
Small, very modern hotel in the heart of Manhattan. Great bathroom but small room. For New York City but perfectly fine.Snacks and drinks are free throughout the day.
Very clean!!! A small hotel very well located !!!! Not bad for its 4 years of opening !!!
Excellent breakfast (a pity about the plastic plates), beautiful location, very neat room, nice that there is an afternoon wine with cheese ready, very very friendly and helpful staff
Nice new clean and comfortable, not cheap price though. The breakfast, which is included and could justify the price, is however minimal and of not excellent quality.
A great little hotel, quiet and discreet but very well placed. Room clean and smartly appointed. Very nice staff
Excellent and innovative room, rain shower, very kind staff, very intimate and quiet hotel, no problems of hot water / slow lifts (as there are in the big hotels), breakfast (partially kosher) which includes breads and pastries, delicacies, fruits, snacks, cornflakes, jams , Juices and more. Also during the day there is light drinking, snacks, and free fruit.Highly recommend.
Breakfast is not enough with 1 cheese type only until 10 am.Recommended place close to the Times. All day long you had coffee and a light drink and some treats. Excellent cleanliness. Large, comfortable bed. It is recommended to book a large room. The reception staff is courteous and very helpful.
Excellent place to stay a few days. Details of care and courtesy. Good attention. Excellent location.
A hotel very well located !!Good attention !!Very clean !!What more could you ask?Breakfast is very good
Hotel clean and quite new. There is not much variety in the breakfasts. I would go back without hesitation
Hotel very well located for visiting Manhattan. Good benefits and very quiet room.
This is a very modern boutique hotel. Location near the park and near a number of underground stations. A courteous staff. Breakfast. In the afternoon there is light refreshments and free wine in the lobby.
My favorite hotel !!!Close to everything and very good service !!!
Hotel very new and clean, very cool rooms! Hot drinks all day, the best!
A clean hotel with spacious rooms, but no more
A spectacular hotel. There is a good quality price relation. The unbeatable location
Very good attention. Cuatos a little small but clean and everything works. Excellent location
Rich, cozy and very central. Very close to the subway and only blocks from Times Square and Central Park
Beautiful and clean but very small room and breakfast without something salty. ..Great breakfast in general!
Great location, nice coffee and happy hour, helpful staff
Very good service and location. It is reduced in terms of space, but very nice and functional
Not bad. I thought better. High price. Small rooms. revisable
I expected more ((. Not enough normal breakfast in a comfortable room.
All very well except the dining room that is small
I would like to visit him 😘.
Fantastic hotel with great location.
A little small, but clean and nice
Well decorated. Friendly staff
Good location
Very good
Location, cleanliness
Total reviews rating
175 Reviews for The Carnegie Hotel 2023:
Review №1
2022-06-12The first hotel we stayed in for our honeymoon. The service is really good, so friendly and respectful. The rooms are really clean and have a calming ambience to them. They included a wine and cheese tasting everyday in the afternoon, and the breakfast they included was good enough if you are not planning on eating somewhere else in the morning. The amenities are on point, we got two really rainy days and they had umbrellas for us, always giving a have a nice day! or welcome back! as you leave and return to the hotel.
Review №2
2022-04-22I stayed here last month and it was wonderful. I usually stay at the Concord but decided to give this hotel a try. Definitely will be back. Next week in fact. The beds and shower are what really impressed me. The bed is so comfortable and the shower is amazing. Great views with giant windows, that also have shades to block out light. Very quiet too. Everyone was very friendly and helpful. Cant wait to stay there again.
Review №3
2021-12-10So disappointing. The room was beyond tiny, not at all like the website portrays. The bed was supposed to be a queen, it wasnt. I have a queen at home, I know how big a queen bed is. This wasnt a queen. Their answer to me was These are the queen size beds at this hotel. Our room wasnt cleaned or serviced in any way, even AFTER we specifically asked and were told it would be. Ive stayed in some bad hotels over the years, they at least made the bed. When I asked about it the next day, the answer was If someone had an accident on the bed, we would change the sheets, otherwise we dont. This was supposed to be a nice getaway weekend. Im fully aware that what you get for your money in New York City (at Xmas time, no less) is much less and much smaller than what youd get for the same amount elsewhere. But this was unacceptable. When I brought my concerns to the staff, they were nothing short of rude. Stay at a Sheraton, Marriott, Hilton, etc. Same price, much nicer, and Im sure the customer service is better. It couldnt possibly be worse.
Review №4
2022-01-10Hotel rooms were lovely - small but super cosy and location was really lovely. Right next to Central Park and only a walk away from Times Square.However, we found some of the staff to be quite rude (not all of them, some were lovely but others were really unhelpful and unwelcoming). We stayed for 4 nights but didn’t get the room cleaned at all which I wasn’t too happy about considering we were still paying a considerable amount for the stay. Had to go to reception and ask for new towels because they were so wet and not enough space to dry them - this should have been something cleaning services were changing. Also found room service food to be mediocre for what New York has to offer but definitely charging New York prices!I would stay again but staff need a bit more training in customer service before I do
Review №5
2022-03-16We had a great stay at the Carnegie hotel. Delia at checkin was friendly and helpful and we were able to check in 3 hours early. When a problem with the a/c occurred the staff quickly attended our needs and moved us to another room. When we had difficulties with the tv Jose was patient and helpful and resolved the situation. The complimentary breakfast, snacks, and wine and cheese were a nice addition to our stay. Additionally, the location made it easy to grab some food or walk to Times Square. I would highly recommend this hotel to anyone.
Review №6
2022-03-16It was our first time in New York and our stay was WONDERFUL! Staff was extremely helpful, we enjoyed wine hour and loved our room! Cleaning service always had our room cleaned also. Great experience!!
Review №7
2022-06-06Very centrally located. Friendly staff. Offers a nice breakfast and complimentary wine from 4 to 5 pm. Would stay here again!
Review №8
2021-10-05A+ across the board. Friendly and accommodating staff. Clean and simple rooms with comfortable bed and floor to ceiling windows with a small one that opens. The bathroom has a waterfall feature in shower!! They have a free breakfast in the morning with various pastries, cereals and hit beverages. I was a fan of their cocktail reception from 5-6pm with free wine and cheese/crackers, a great way to kick off the evening. One of the reasons I booked this hotel was location, its 2 blocks from central park and less than a 10 min walk to Radio City. Definitely staying here again!
Review №9
2021-12-02We loved this hotel and would stay here again in a heartbeat. The staff was exceptional and went above and beyond. The happy hour was really lovely and we also enjoyed the breakfast offerings. The 24 hour coffee was much appreciated. Great location!
Review №10
2021-08-11I wish I could give this hotel more stars. Everything was amazing. The staff was extremely helpful and kind, there was more free amenities than I could count, and the cleanliness of the room was outstanding; not to mention the shower was PERFECT. I will be going back and recommend this place to everyone. One note is the rooms are a bit small but it didnt bother me. Alexandra, the lovely front desk woman, deserves a raise!