Outdoor seating
Yes
The Old Mill Inn in Alfred Station
Categories
Location on the map
Alfred Station, Allegany County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Delivery
No
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Sport
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Cocktails
Yes
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Spirits
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Planning
Accepts reservations
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 607-587-9060
Site: http://www.onedepotstreet.com/
Site: http://www.onedepotstreet.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–10PM
- Tuesday:11AM–10PM
- Wednesday:11AM–10PM
- Thursday:11AM–10PM
- Friday:11AM–10PM
- Saturday:11AM–10PM
- Sunday:11AM–10PM
Comments (68)
Got their ribs. Had gotten before and were really good. Not so much this time, had just been cooked too long so meat was mushy. Will do them again hoping for a return to the former quality.
Delicious food everytime!!
Great food and drinks. Very friendly staff. A fun place to hang out and get the flavor of Alfred Station NY!
We like going there on the wing nights. The wings are definitely a good size and definitely worth the money and for the eat-in price special Its great. They place has taken a turn for the good recently and we enjoy the drink specials and varieties of food. Check it out
Most amazing bar in town!! So many friendly people and great atmosphere! The food is sooo good and the drinks always satisfy!
Only the best at The Old Mill. Great people, great food. Kids night ❤ is Monday dont miss it! Tuesday WINGS!! Wednesday you better order your ribs early if you want them these guys have nailed the recipe!! Thursday PASTA Friday FISH. Enjoy the weekend at The Old Mill with cold drinks and more amazing food! Take my kids here weekly they love it.
We enjoyed our meal at The Old Mill Inn, our food arrived quickly and was super hot. We had a pepperoni pizza, a chicken wing pizza, and a dozen wings with Carolina Gold sauce. All were delicious and definitely home made pizzas. Wings were seriously jumbo. We will look forward to eating at The Old Mill Inn again.
Awesome bar just outside of the village of Alfred. Great selection of food. The wings are awesome!
Chicken wings are very delicious now service on the other hand not so professional
As a totally unbiased individual I would highly recommend this establishment. Food is great and staff is friendly!!Update: This is still by far the best place to eat or drink in ALL of Alfred Station! If you havent tried it you are missing out!!!
Our pizzas and wings were perfect. We frequent the Old Mill often. We had a going away party and a large order. It was on time, hot and very tasty. A big thank you goes out to Noah and the gang. A+++++
So, this Place! Noah, Aaron and Rich were in the spot when it turned over. Noah created a smokey-mustard-pepper dry rub for chicken wings that rivals Anchor Bar! Sorry, Buffalo, as with most things a creative force has taken you over. They have a huge beer selection and full service bar. Kids get free rootbeer!~need I say anything more? Booka large reservations!
Updated Review:Had an issue with an order and the owner contacted me and made it right! Love the wings here and the atmosphere!
The food was great and service was great,it was just very cold in there. But will definitely go again.
Great food! Great service! Great people! Definitely recommend!
First the bad, it was very loud, the soda tasted like rum, and it took 25 minutes to get our food. Now the good, the workers where friendly the food was good priced and tasted good. I understand it is a bar that serves food and you have to expect the bar atmosphere but it was totally uncomfortable for me to be there, I spent almost $50 just to take my food home because it was so uncomfortable, which by time I got home everything was cold. If I stayed I would have likely would have spent more. I always go back to places I like and spend alot of money and tip well, which I will never go back to this place.
We had a great meal here! Very friendly staff and quick service. Very attentive. 😁 super yummy wings and creative sauces. Check out their General tois sauced wings! Delish.
Love The Old Mill! The owners and workers are friendly and welcoming. Its cozy and casual and the food is awesome! We have had fish fry, pizza [today the beef on weck pizza 😋] and burgers. Its all good!
Excellent wings. Love the atmosphere
Place is awesome. Great food and service. Pool table and family friendly at least during the day when we went.
I really appreciate the captain and ginger. It’s cheap, delicious, and never stops flowing! Best chicken tenders around, screw those other guys. Can’t stop eating here.... and I’m fat, so that’s saying something😀
Love the wings and the owner is really nice to everyone
The food is always amazing. A welcoming bar with a good variety of drinks.
Great food and better bartenders. My favorite spot to play pool and eat wings
Ive been here several times. Its a decent place to go for a meal. Staff is friendly and accommodating, and I will definitely be a returning customer.
The perfect kind of Pub. That you can sit back and drink your Blues Away! And with a very entertaining bar staff! A little hole in the wall, that you would never expect so much fun from! I encourage you to visit the Old Mill family.
Great place bartender Jack was the Man!
The food and drinks are incresible and the bartender is exceptionally handsome, what more could you ask for??
Love the food and service! Very large selection of drinks as well.
Great food and large drink selection
Good food and home town feel ,u need 2 stop in and have fun.
A fun place and great wings!
Great wings and pizza! Will come back again
Food is great. Beer is great. Go here.
Great beers. Great atmosphere. Super staff.
Great burger and excellent customer service!
Love the food! SOOOOOOO GOOOOOOD! Make sure to try the soft pretzels
Fries were awesome they tasted like fair fries!! Hot dogs were good!!
Very good place good food and everybodys gets along
Fries are okay. Great atmosphere
Great food. Great staff
Excellent service!! Wonderful place for family and friends to gather.
Best burger in town, Hands Down
Fun fried food reminds me of going to the fair!
Nice place to go owner very pleasant, could not as for a better guy
Great place to go
Excellent food and service!
Excellent..
Fries are freshly made and delicious!
This place is the bomb try the food its awesome
Very friendly bartender.
Very good food here
Very good reasonable priced
Great food, great service
We love Oney! Best service ever.
Wings are SO good!
Need air conditioner
Their wings are the best!!
Total reviews rating 4.7
68 Reviews for The Old Mill Inn 2023:
Review №1
2022-05-31Great place - excellent wings, awesome burgers and real french fries. You can tell that the chicken and beef come from local farms. The wings were some of the meatiest and largest I have ever had. The burgers were fresh and lean. Great selection of beer! Looking forward to the addition and hope to get back soon!
Review №2
2022-04-20Im all about family friendly places. The Owner & Bar tender where very nice to my girls. The food was definitely worth the stop. I will be stopping in again if in the area.
Review №3
2022-03-29Ive lived in this area most of my life, and this place is the best kept secret Ive ever had the pleasure of stumbling on! Food is very reasonably priced and portions are good sized! Service was exceptional! Atmosphere was fun and friendly! Thank you Mr. Bartender man for a great dining experience!!! We will DEFINITELY be making this a monthly stop at the very least! I would absolutely recommend dining here!
Review №4
2022-06-16I had a great experience at Old Mill. Their Old Mill spice wings (dry rub) were the best! The French fries were hand cut and perfectly fried. I couldn’t resist ordering the fried Oreos. They were a delicious surprise. They are wrapped in their handmade pizza dough and fried. We ordered ours dropped in chocolate syrup. They were not too sweet and not greasy — simply delectable! I highly recommend the Old Mill. Funky decor, gigantic bar, great vibe.
Review №5
2022-06-27I love the Mill! The wings here are my favorite in the area. They’re large, delicious, crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside. There’s a huge variety of sauces and rubs to choose from and a dozen is only $13!! Great price for great wings.The pizzas and calzones are made fresh every day and it shows. The fresh dough is soft, yet lightly crispy, and simply delicious.The Mill has great specials and its a nice place to hang out and have some great food.
Review №6
2022-03-12Great little bar with a variety of beer, liquor, and food. I’ve become quite the regular. The pizza, wings and fish fry have been excellent each time! Noah and his crew are very friendly and welcoming! Will most definitely be going back!
Review №7
2022-06-27Awesome meal, amazing staff!
Review №8
2022-04-22Excellent food. We had the best pizza and wings ever!!They were packed. There was a big party there, but we were still well taken care of!!We will be back
Review №9
2022-06-26We ve tried this place twice and are giving up on it. First the place needs a good cleaning . The bathroom door has a hole in it. It has a nice decor that could look nice if cleaned up. The outdoor dining is in the entrance drive so it gets dusty.There s a lot of weird food items on the menu. We think they should just concentrate on making less options but good.Ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and it only had 7 pieces of chicken on it. Burgers werent cooked. A few items tasted canned or frozenTried again and got the pepperoni pizza which tasted frozen and lacked everything.It has a really nice looking bar and plenty of parking.
Review №10
2022-05-06This is by far the friendliest bar I have ever been in (been in a lot)! Not just the bartenders, but the patrons were also nice as hell! I really enjoyed the enchiladas on Cinco de Mayo. Next time in the area I will definitely return.