Delivery
Yes
The Pizza Shop in Warrensburg
Categories
Location on the map
Warrensburg, Warren County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Salad bar
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Counter service
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Groups
Yes
LGBTQ+ friendly
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Transgender safe space
Yes
University students
Yes
Phone: +1 518-623-3070
Site: http://www.thepizzashopwarrensbu...
Site: http://www.thepizzashopwarrensbu...
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–9PM
- Saturday:11AM–9PM
- Sunday:Closed
The Pizza Shop in other cities:
Comments (169)
Best pizza in upstate! (And we live in nyc) Two thumbs up. We ordered 2 pies for pick upToday and they did not disappoint. No grease! Fresh ingredients and amazing taste. What a gem. Great staff too. Looking forward to regularly eating here when we come to the Adirondacks. Bravo!
Always, always a great pie. Best in the region!
Great crust! I liked the supreme and husband liked the white veggie though I thought it was a bit bland compared to other great white pizzas weve had throughout the years. Wouldnt order garlic knots again - too dense and not a strong enough garlic flavor for me. But I would definitely order here again as the crust really was fantastically crunchy and brown and flavorful and perfect!
Best Pizza Ever!!!! Simple, Clean, balanced, perfection. Would rival Any NYC slice and its in upstate Warrensburg NY. Hidden gem huge understatement!!
Great pizza and very friendly staff.
Wonderful food and staff beyond compare. They are always right on he ball
Love stopping in for a couple slices on the way home from Glen Falls. They dont seem to have the five or six varieties to choose from like pre-pandemic, but I guess thats understandable. Love the Mediterranean and White veggie!
This was darn good pizza. We had the white veggie and it was delicious.
We stopped here on our way back from Gore, and now its our favorite pizza place in the area. They offer excellent crust, fresh ingredients, good prices, and I love the wall murals inside. Parking is in the bag, and there is a restroom inside. It has won best in the region 3 years in a row, and Id be surprised if it didnt win again in 2020!
Best gluten free pizza I have had since being diagnosed with celiac 6 years ago! I was pleasantly surprised to find out they had gf pizza when I stopped to pick up a regular mushroom pizza for my husband. I ordered a gf mushroom pie and thoroughly enjoyed it. My 16 year old grandson just stopped by and I reheated it and he thought it was really good too.
We were on a long drive home and looking for good pizza. We read all the reviews and went out of our way to stop here. It was so worth it. The customer service was excellent and the food was delicious. The lasagna pizza is a must try and hit the spot. If were in the area again we will absolutely stop in again.
Pizza was good but this was what i got for an XL pizza. Feel a bit ripped off.
My family and I had an excellent dinner here. The pizza was out of this world and we really enjoyed the fresh and delicious salads. Service was friendly and fast despite how busy they were. All around amazing!
I just order a calzone and it taste real bad only 2 pieces of pepperoni in it never go there again my 5 year old can make food better then this place
One of the best pizzas Ive had in a while. The prosciutto and arugula will knock your socks off. Thin crust with excellent flavor. Totally worth it.
Excellent pizza prepared by wonderful young, friendly staff and owners. It’s a regular stop for lunch and a welcome treat for dinner when working late. Tasty, thin crust with decent selection ny the slice during lunchtime hours.
Friendly service, food was excellent. We had A pepperoni Stromboli and a two cheese calzone. Very clean. Thank you will definitely stop again!
The food was insane. We had a Hawaiian pizza (fight me...) and it was superb. Artwork on the walls was also fantastic and shows the kind of care that the owners and staff put into their work.
We love the pizza shop they have a nice variety of pizzas and other dishes. Always on point!
Gilbert and Mariella were incredibly helpful and beyond accommodating. Ideal examples of what customer service should be like. So thankful for the insanely delicious pizza and the amazing people that work there. If you know whats good for ya youll order Vitos Pizza!
Stopped at The Pizza Shop for lunch after Oscar’s Smokehouse. When had xlg half cheese and half mushroom pizza. The crust perfect, nice and thin. The sauce, cheese and mushrooms were also delicious and perfectly balanced. The crew behind the counter were friendly as on previous visits here.
I really like this place but I love thin crust pizza. My grandparents disagree and feel the crust is too thin. Very good flavorful calzone but a bit on the pricey side for the size. Everything Ive tried has been great, not a bad meal yet.
This place is awesome. My coworker got pizza from here and I loved it so much that I had to come myself! Pizza is super yummy and their prices and affordable and Im my opinion Cheap. Workers are really nice . I 100% recommend this place
We ate at The Pizza Shop during our vacation in Lake George. Best pizza ever! We are from NYC and have so many pizza places to choose from. By far The Pizza Shop tops them all!! Can’t wait to go back!! Had the Lasagna pizza - definitely must to try!
Best pizza in town. Hands down.The eggplant lover, buffalo chicken, and arugula & prosciuttopizzas are deliciouuusTheir wings are good too, and my friend tried the calzone and said it was the best calzone shes ever hadThe actual store location is nice too, ate there a couple times. Nice place with cool people!
We ordered for the first time from here. I had a Calzone and my wife had a wrap. This will not be our last time ordering from you !!!! It was fantastic !!!! Best calzone I have ever. had !!! Whatever you are doing, keep it up !!!!
First I will tell you that they have great pizza and garlic knots. Secondly I will tell you that we had delivery twice from them and the third time we called they said they dont deliver here and to call somewhere else. I advised them they delivered here twice before, they said that was a mistake. Way to appreciate your customers! PS. We are 5 miles from the pizza shop.
Great NY Pizza!! Nice thin crust that doesnt flop when you pick it up. Good cheese to sauce ratio, and tasty crust! 👌
Treated myself to a slice - WOW! May have been the best Pizza I have ever eaten.Service was both prompt and friendly.Restaurant is clean - big plus after visiting others in town.Did I mention how good the Pizza is? The best!
Conning from long island, true good pizza is hard to come by when youre upstate. However, since i found the pizza shop it is always an easy choice where to order from. Great food, great people.
Really great pizza. On time and delicious. Happy to have found them and have already ordered from them three times in two weeks. Love the green pepper and onion! Ingredients are fresh and it makes all the difference in the world.
Honestly the best Pizza in Lake George/Warrensburg area. Giovanni is strait from Sicily and makes a beautiful and extremely tasty pizza pie! Also try their cinnamon sweet sticks. Great portion sizes and also extremely friendly staff. Love the owners of this family business!
I’ve always enjoyed their pizza and the Rainbow Cake was delicious!
Love this place- I just moved to Warrensburg and have been 4 times already lol. One of the owners (wife) is local and the other (husband) is from Italy. Locally owned pizza shop with someone from the motherland spinning dough daily? I rest my case...
A wonderful couple from Italy own the shop, make the pizza, and provide superb service. The pizza is good and fresh, while the owners are nice and refreshing. So, overall, no doubt, anyone should go here, weather locally, traveling through, or taking out.
Best thin crust NY Style pie in the North Country. Friendly attentive staff. Usual selection of Pies, Subs, Salads, Stromboli, Calzones etc. I have sampled most of their offerings in the past 6 months. Everything Ive ordered has met or exceeded my expectations. Give them a try - you wont be sorry!
Good food and a very nice place. Staff was super helpful. Excellent rolls. Got a hot sausage parmesan that was just awesome.
If you are looking for New York City style pizza, this is a great place. Super nice people with a nice large menu. Everything I’ve had has been great.
Pizza OK, Wings worst ever, heavily breaded. Sausage parm hero edible, prices HIGHNot going back
Opened within the last 10 days or so and the pizza is very good. Classic, thin crust pizza. I had a couple slices on my first visit. $5- gets you 2 generously sized slices and a drink. The menu includes the usual...subs; hot and cold, calzones, strombolis, salads, platters which are dinners with bread and a nice selection of creative pizza types for those who dont want to build their own. Notably, they say they bake their own bread and rolls daily. Ill definitely go back soon. No apparent website yet. This is the best of the pizza places in Warrensburg...Ive tried them all.
Best food in the area by far and the employees are wonderful. They always make their orders perfectly and in the rare occurrence that they mess it up are perfectly willing to do what it takes to ensure you leave happy and ready to come back another time.
The best Pizza in Warrensburg. Owned and run by a husband and wife team. The white veggie Pizza with ricotta and red peppers is a must try. Any choice will satisfy. The lunch specials are very good and inexpensive.
WE LOVE THIS PLACE! We order from here about once a week- always go for the eggplant or arugula pizza and have never been disappointed. Great food, friendly service, and accurate price!
Great pizza! I stopped on a whim, and was not disappointed. Great chewy crust, and perfect amounts of sauce, cheese, and toppings. Try them, you wont be sorry.
We asked a few different locals where to get the best pizza and they all sent us here. Boy were they right. Excellent pizza!!
Simply amazing. The best pizza around here. Staff is wicked friendly and always have a smile on their face. Nice calm restaurant environment for eating in.
Awesome pizza! Great customer service, very busy spot putting out some great quality food!!
Just stopped in from the cold to get some slices from the best pizza place around great pricing and friendly staff along with excellent service highly recommend you stop in and try it you won’t regret it
We love it here! Best pizza in the Lake George area. The owners are great people!
Great, authentic Italian pizza. Loved the Tesla artwork on the wall. Happy 5 Years to The Pizza Shop!
Decent pizza! Garlic knots were disappointing however
The Pizza Shop is, without question, the best pizza in the area. Youd have to travel to New York City or Italy to find pizza anywhere near this good. I highly recommend the white pizza.
Friendly staff and quick service. The cheesy bread was very tasty.
Wonderful quality of food exceptional customer service and a warm feeling of care and respect every single time I enter this family business.
Great staff, cozy atmosphere, and clean too. As for the food, DELICIOUS!!! And pizza reminds me of NYC pizza, very close. Only pizza or Italian food I eat . Really should try this place!!
The pizzas great - Im from Philly so I think I have a basis from which to judge. I patronize this place regularly. I just discovered the cannoli - order a cannoli - hand-filled and delicious.
I’m from downstate and was so impressed with how fantastic the pizza here is! Definitely will be back when passing through again.
Love this place!! My family and I had an amazing meal here, the kids would not stop talking about how much they loved the pizza!
I have used The Pizza Shop for both personal and company use. Their food is amazing and the service is incredible! Very satisfied!
This place is the best ever I eat here at least a couple times a week thats how good it is thanks pizza shop for making good pizza plus they make it nice to have a slice on the go when you dont want a whole pizza plus the blue cheese is to die for I cant get enough of it
I had the salad and it was perfect! Great service and a local owner who cares about his pie.
Just a good pizza place with food that doesnt disappoint. Hard to find pizza in that area where the food is consistently good.
If you are looking for great pizza and service this is the place. Their pizza is awesome and they are some of the nicest people you will find.
Fabulous Pizza!Incredibly friendly and amazing service!The best Pizza in the North country for sure.
Very satisfied with Giovanni the owner..very caring and understanding and fixed a issue at no cost..thank you so much!...if you want great food and great customer service I recommend you go here first before anywhere else!!!!
I used The Pizza Shop to cater for a company party & was absolutely satisfied with their food and service!! Highly recommended.
Ordered 2 pizzas at 7:22pm for delivery. An hour later we called and they said driver was on his way. Manager Timothy said you want your MOFO pizza or not! How professional!.
I will plan ahead when ordering on a weekend next time as they are very popular because they make very good thin crust pizza.
Been in the area for years and this is for sure the best pizza in the north country! Keep up the excellent work
This is by far the best of the pizzarias in Warrensburg. A large plain pizza is $13.50 and well worth the price.
Food not worth the money thin pizza with barely anything on it and want 17 to 30 bucks
Great pizza, wonderful dough, pleasant service.
Great pizza with a a gluten free option.
Delicious authentic italian pizza owned and operated by a lovely married couple Great atmosphere and awesome staff and food, Cant be beat!
The pizza place in Warrensburg. Calzones are out of this world. Chicken wings are 4 stars though.
Great pizza!! We will definitely be back!
Great slices to go.
Nicest owners in Warrensburg and the best food in town for a long time highly recommend you stop by if you never have before very positive environment great for the family
Most authentic Italian pizza that Ive found here! Definitely a place to check out!
Really good pizza! Plan ahead as it does take a while for pickup at peak times.
Excellent pizza! Friendly staff.
This shop is the real deal if you’re looking for delicious, thin crust NYC style pizza.
I have had a couple pies form here that were about a 7 out of ten. had two cheese slices yesterday that were perfect 10 out of ten.
I have ordered 2 calzones at different times and both make me become Ill. I wouldnt recommend them
Cant wait to try it today have searched for NY style pie since Ive moved here from Brooklyn three yrs.ago
If you are looking for New York City style pizza this is the place the sides are excellent too.
Another one if our favorites near Lake George
Decent pizza. Tasty toppings. The crust is a bit bland.
Its the best pizza around.love the atmosphere
Seriously the best pizza I’ve ever had!
I love the pizza shop! Best pizza in Warrensburg. Even best pizza in the area hands down!!
Great friendly service. Great pizza crispy bottom. I will stop by when in area.
The best pizza shop in the area! Great group of staff members and the owners are fantastic!
The best Pizza in town by far! If you are planning to travel in this area, you have got to stop.
Definitely the best pizza I have found in all of upstate New York.
Love this place good food. Only place around that makes gluten free pizza.
The pizza is excellent here and the service is the best.
Loved the Stromboli! Will have to try a pie next time!
Everything we’ve gotten from here is delicious! (And we are picky) The staff is also super sweet and helpful
Best pizza anywhere around here. Always my first choice!
Xl buffalo chicken pizza took only 15 min to get and only 5 min to devour
Definitely a contender in the LG/Warrensburg area! Great service. Great pizza.
Good service, not all loved sauce, crust was good, parking, no flop
Great food, reasonably priced.
This is the only pizza in the capital district that reminds me of where I grew up in Brooklyn. True NYC style pizza
Love the pizza hear it is a great spot for lunch when you are in warrenburg
Thin pizza. OkCan soda, $1Two liter,$2 , prices very reasonable..
Good pizza but debit card machine wasnt working they swiped my card and then asked for cash because it spit out an error
Great pizza, great people. Best in area!
Very good “italian pizza” 🍕, good staff and place 👍🏻
Really good pizza ... nice staff awesome place to get pizza
Good pizza, but not very consistent.
Best pizza Ive ever had!
Love this place.best pizza in Queensbury. Ny
Delicious! Have great calzones. Definitely stoping here again!
Best in the Adirondacks
One of the best pies we’ve ever had
Great fresh pizza, best in the region!
Yummy pizza, lots of options, good service
Great NY style pizza with great crust.
Best pizza in Warren County!!
Best sub I have ever had in my life.
Delicious food! Everything seemed to be made from scratch.
Great food as always!
Great pizza quick service
Love the Bianca with bacon and pineapple 😍
Perfectly crispy pizza. Great service.
Delicious pizza and cool artwork!
Really good slices!
Very good very clean. Bangin foods and desserts...
Always 5 star
Best pizza and service ever!
Best pizza in New York
Very very good highly recommended
Great NY-style pizza
Awesome slice of pie! Thank you!
Great staff especially the delivery driver
Made with love.Conistently great
Best pizza in the area.
Great pizza and service.
If Jesus made pizza this would be it
Above average plain pie
Pizza And salads fast!
Cant wait to try it.
Its the best... around
The best pizza in town!
Best pizza around
Great Place
Its not digorno.
Delicious, and quick
Best pizza around!!!
Fantastic pizza!!
Great pizza!
As always fabulous!!
Always delicious!
Amazing
Pizza were good
It was good
Good place to eat
Total reviews rating 4.7
169 Reviews for The Pizza Shop 2023:
Review №1
2022-03-13Tried the pizza and wings Friday night based on good reviews. Service was polite but harried. The pizza was tasteless and was like cardboard as it cooled. The wings were over done and small and again had very little taste in the sauce. We were very disappointed based on the glowing reviews. Hopefully they can turn things around to the better.
Review №2
2021-01-01Pizza was excellent, fresh and perfect for a cold winter day. The homemade red sauce that goes with the mini garlic knots is a must. Staff was extremely nice too.
Review №3
2020-07-21Good pizza and good chicken wings. The cheese pizza was good. If you are looking for a pizza place this is worth a try. The chicken wings are not bad either. The place is clean.
Review №4
2020-03-05Omg!! Had to redo my review!! The local favorite with the pickles omg amazing!!! Its my new favorite pizza EVER!! Since my last review i got wings again asked for extra sauce an the wings were perfect!! The garlic knots are to die for!!!
Review №5
2022-06-28Got wings and there hot sauce is awesome could have been touch hotter but really tasty.cooked the way I ordered them.
Review №6
2019-08-28The best pizza i have ever had. Giovanni is a master of his craft. nyc pizza can learn from this guy! amazing food and an amazing price... a true hidden jem!
Review №7
2021-12-08The people that work here do a great job of making you feel welcome. The food was great, way better than we had hoped for! The owner was making the pizza, I asked for a special thick crust, and he blew it out of the park!
Review №8
2016-08-20Perfect pizza place for family on a budget. Its absolutely delicious! Cheesy bread was awesome too! Drinks are a buck. Cant beat it! They are all so polite and helpful! Why spend tons of money for pizza when this place is truly Italian pizza! THANK YOU The pizza shop we will see you again next year when we return to Lake George!😀
Review №9
2021-08-22A diamond in the rough!!!! Pizza was great. They closed at 9:00 pm and with our late arrival around 8:30, we were prepared for a limited menu and possibly being rushed out. None of the above. Our pizza order was Hot and fresh. Owner was accommodating and friendly. We loved the simplicity of the inside. Clean and well kept. Definitely our new place for pizza. Just goes to show you that fancy lights and tables outside doesn’t always mean a great experience. Thank you for a wonderful meal.
Review №10
2021-09-19Fastest delivery! Told 45 mins. It was there in 30. The “local flavor” was the best. The only reason for 4 stars is the acidic red sauce/marinara that caused intense heartburn. I’d definitely get the cheese bread, a white based pizza, and the cinnamon sticks again.