Outdoor seating
Yes
Tillys Table in Brewster
Categories
Location on the map
Brewster, Putnam County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Delivery
No
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Great coffee
Yes
Great dessert
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Happy-hour food
Yes
Healthy options
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
High chairs
Yes
Atmosphere
Cosy
Yes
Historic
Yes
Romantic
Yes
Upmarket
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Yes
Accepts reservations
Yes
Phone: +1 845-808-1840
Site: https://www.tillystablerestauran...
Site: https://www.tillystablerestauran...
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:Closed
- Wednesday:Closed
- Thursday:5–9PM
- Friday:5–9PM
- Saturday:5–9PM
- Sunday:11AM–3PM
Comments (130)
Always have a great meal at Tillys Table! I also just love the atmosphere in the restaurant. They also have a top notch brunch with so many options, whats not to love? Highly recommend!
Went to Tillys with a group of Friends to the Sunday Brunch and we all loved it. Had a great time and the food was delicious. They had great menu choices and a large buffet of baked items items to explore. Nummies!! Afterwards we walked the spacious grounds seeing all the different farm animals and beautiful horses. They also had a nice gift shop on the property. Thank you Tilleys for the wonderful afternoon!
Went for Comedy Night, 2 fantastic comedians. Included show, buffet dinner, coffee & dessert. Cash bar. Well worth it in a great ambiance.
I will come back here and actually eat at the restaurant soon. I had to contribute the pictures I took of beautiful grounds and animals. This place was a favorite stop in when our family visited parents just 15 minutes from here in Lake Carmel. There used to be horses and now there are alpacas, miniature horses, chickens and hogs. This is a valley landscape with barn and some art installation in front which is the perfect addition to this property. The giant Sunflowers are color candy. Great location.
Love this farm especially the horses and every single meal I’ve had here has been absolutely delicious. Exquisite! Have been coming as often as possible. At sunset it’s glorious. And don’t forget to visit the black beauties!
Great food in a nice atmosphere. Linguini with Clams was huge. Burgers were great as well. Full bar and wine list
Always GREAT food and the staff is very friendly. Highly recommend
SO HAPPY WE FINALLY CHECKED IT OUT!! The place is soo beautiful inside and out, when we arrived, we saw 3 white tail deer running around on the open grounds, so awesome to see.... sat at the beautifully lit and decorated bar then sat inside by the fireplace, in eye sight of the hugh windows for an AWESOME meal!!! DELICIOUS!! Service was great... we will soon be regulars Cant wait for the weather to warm up and spend an evening on the deck ..... 💝
Such a beautiful place and very tasty food. Could have been a better night if we were given a little more info and attention
The most overcooked chicken I’ve ever had. It was like the Grizwald Christmas Turkey. It was featured on the menu: Farm to Table “Market Price”. The waiter never came back to refill our drinks. Save your money.
Went for a wedding brunch. It was very good. Definitely will come back on my own.
Great service. Good food. Good drinks. Cant wait for them to fully open with their full menu.
We had my daughters shower on Sunday at Tillys. The event was held in the barn and it was beautiful. The staff was very attentive n helped out whenever needed. The food was delicious n plentiful.I would recommend Tillys with 5 stars
Staff was wonderful. Food was excellent. I really did enjoy the inside atmosphere and will definitely return in the summer when we can enjoy the outside seating.
I was there for a friends baby shower. The food was absolutely delicious and the portions were very generous! The staff was so helpful with setting up for the event. I will definitely be returning to enjoy dinner there with family and friends!
Food was amazing. Great atmosphere. The bartender Cyndi was amazing! Drinks were great and service was better! Will be coming back here regularly!
Amazing Landscape, Delicious food and incredible service .Definitely a Must!
I had a wonderful Valentines dinner there! I received a rose when we entered. I had pesce de mar, which was delicious. They had gluten free pasta for me. My husband had the prime rib special. Both entrees were generous and served hot by friendly staff. Social distancing was comfortable. The atmosphere was very relaxing to me. Thanks, Tillys Table!
We spent the evening at their comedy night. The food was great and the show awesome. We really enjoyed our night.
Good night at Tilly with good food and music, provided by Satisfaction a Rolling Stones cover band. Two hours of Rolling Stones music cant beat that.
Very nice, great food...
Great food. Nice place. Can be a little loud.
Food was exceptional. Service was slow and needed polish. Server was very personable and outgoing and made up for the rest of the service. Needs host at door to say goodnight, wall hangings to dampen sound. Bus persons to clear the table periodically. More attention to small details and the place would truly be beyond. Needs to be clearer about mission. Limited menu seafood centered. We marked our online reservation form that it was our Anniversary, however nothing was done with this information, so why ask? Even so we had an excellent time.
Just moved to patterson ny and saw this place. It looked majestic and really thought might be a farm to table restaurant. My son in law and daughter had helped us in the move and I wanted to take them someplace nice. The place looked like a home run. The parking lot was full, the decor and atmosphere looked great. Missing was the smell of burning wood on this cold day and the smell of cooking.We had reservations and we seemed to have surprised them because it took a while for us to be acknowledged. Make a long story short I have had better tasting food at Cracker Barrel and higher quality. Everything was bland. The brunch promotes breads and pastries both of which were not there at 1:15 it was completely gone. The mimosas were good and the servers and helpers were pleasant. I feel they tried their best with what they had. I have no desire to return its a one and done for me.
We’ve gone here for comedy shows with dinner included for a reasonable price.Tonight was only for dinner.The food tasted good but was WAY overpriced.Menu was VERY limited - we should have been told this when we made reservations$18.00 for calamari appetizer$24.00 for chicken entree- no bread/ salad$10.00 for Common store type cheese cake or chocolate cake- neither were excellent - ridiculous!
The food and service were top shelf. The business was very clean and well maintained. There was ample parking.
Comedy night on June 18th 2021. First getting the food was horrible long wait and kept running out of food and having to wait 5 to 10 mins for salad or hot entree to be replaced.WORST part was the last comedian. I understand comedian s push the limits but this guy just kept going on about killing his wife. 2 jokes about it ok move on but 1/2 his time was about killing his wife.Also very warm in the barn. AC was on but couldn’t handle that size crowd. Best part of the night. LEAVING !!!!!!
My experience was underwhelming to say the least.Was really impressed with the decor and place where there restaurant sits....Our experience with everything else was the underwhelming part.We were sat and waited a good 10 minutes before our waiter greeted us or asked for our drink orders. I was very hungry so I decided to indulge in the Buffett.Boy was I disappointed... one bagel, one muffin.. didn’t refill it the rest of the time I was there. Everything else on the Buffett was pretty tasty.I ordered the crab cakes and they were decent, but the potatoes that came with them were cold and flavorless. The others I was with got the spaghetti and the steak and eggs. The spaghetti was very bland and the steak and eggs were good.Mimosas were the best part of it, very good.Overall not as great of an experience as was expected.
Literally the best food in Putnam County. Calista, Colleen, Corey, Kayleigh and Nick are all the best people. I love how the Chef will come out and meet people throughout the night. Their food and service is beyond 5 Stars but thats all I can give! Check this place out if youre looking for real fine dining in the Brewster area!
Great food & service. Cory was our server & he was excellent. Nice atmosphere with wood burning fireplace. Good size bar. Would definitely go back. Farm to table. From Apps to desert great.
Sunday brunch was very nice. Colleen, Sean and staff were welcoming and attentive. The location is charming, overlooking the horse farm and educational farm. The atmosphere is Sunday casual, good for family or brunch for two. We look forward to trying the restaurant and bar, and entertainment.
Sunday brunch is a real treat at Tillys Table. Reservations required 11:30am - 3pm. For starters there is a self service buffet of an assortment of both breakfast and lunch items to choose from. Additionally, you are given a menu to choose from 8 delicious choices. The Belgium Waffle with fresh cream, strawberries and blueberries is fantastic, so is the steak and eggs any style.Every entree is accompanied by crisp bacon & home fries. Farm fresh to table, bountiful and scrumptious food. Rustic decor, splendid vistas, the farm is a wonderful place to visit for an enjoyable day. All you can drink mimosa, coffee, tea and dessert. The menu is ever changing based on the whim of the chef, a pleasant surprise. The cost is $29.00 for adults, $15.00 for children under 12, free for children under 4 years of age. Dinner is served Thursday thru Sunday evening. The service is friendly and attentive. A must see, a must do.
Fun happy place with friendly staff and fantastic food.
We had an event in the top area of the barn and not in the restaurant. Really nice place. Intricate wood working on the roof. I think you get your own caterer so I wont hold the lack of dessert for my fat body on Tillys!
One of my favorite places. Appetizers are great. And the Filet Mignon and jalapeño mashed potatoes combo is INCREDIBLE. I would give this place 6 stars if Google let me...
Filet mignon was terrible. Service was incredibly slow. Would not go back. Drinks were very watered down.
Hudson valley restaurant week menu was more expensive than it’s supposed to be. Service was great though
Been there three times for Brunch. Food is always fresh and tasty!! Service is excellent. Great place to take the family as you can view the farm animals after youve had your fill.
I loved this place. Attended for a comedy show and everything was spectacular. Wonderful atmosphere, delicious food, drinks were great and the 3 comedians on stand were hilarious. Im dying to visit again!
This was such a lovely place for an event. We previously didnt know what was offered at Tillys Table, but we do now! We will be back for dinner, too!
Beautiful venue. Excellent food. Helpful staff. Tillys Table was the perfect spot to celebrate my birthday. Meagan was awesome to work with as well as the staff.
I went to a concert here, I didnt go in for a normal dinner inside. The show was great but the food was very disappointing. The food was very bland, and both types of sausage they were offering were pretty much the same, and they just tasted like overgrown hotdogs. But the over all experience was very enjoyable.
150-200 of us came for my uncles funeral. It was well organized, stocked the whole time, and kept clean as we were going. The bartenders were very nice and attentive. Thank you so much, Tillys Table, for a beautiful luncheon.
I am so disappointed with this resturant. The only good thing about it is the happy hour. 2 for 1. The food is awful! $16 for a frozen piece of meat! With frozen french fries. Very very over priced. To top it of. When we asked for more ketchup they gave us packets as if we were at McDonalds. Ordered fried shrimp as an appetizer. Guess what! Also frozen food. Its so sad because the place is nice. But not worth the money. If they are go to charge prices like that the food MUST be fresh and made from scratch! I was at the village social yesterday in Mount Kisco and it was fantastic and cheaper! Very very disappointed. Hopefully someone reads this and makes some changes.
You’ve gotta check this gem out. A horse farm turned farm-to-table restaurant. Talk about pivoting and reimagined vision. The views from the oversized windows are of the rambling hills of a white fenced horse-ranch with a few horses in the distance and alpacas you can touch. The farm has a walking trail that guests are welcomed to trot along to see several other farm animals living their best life. Cozy, and country-sophisticated ambiance in the restaurant make it a great space for family meals and occasions, date night and boys or girl nights out. Updated, stylish and super clean bathrooms. Very friendly staff. Excellent plating and presentation of farm fresh foods. You literally taste the difference. I was so intrigued by my first visit with a friend last Saturday for dinner that I went back and took my grown sons just 5 days after. Try the muscles in marinara sauce .... simply delish!! That fresh tomatoey sauce is impossible not to sop up with their warm bread rolls. Hope this review helped you decide. Give it a thumbs up, and check out my other honest reviews.
Beautiful hidden gem. I never knew it existed. Love the beautiful wood interior. Great food and friendly staff. Went for a school gathering. The homemade mac and cheese was out of this world!
Holiday party buffet style dinner. Food was very good.
45 minute wait for 2 lobster roll dinners and 2 burgers. Chef..a lobster roll that looks like tuna salad, all that mayo, is NOT A LOBSTER ROLL. 1 lobster roll perfectly prepared is 100 times better then 2 imitation lobster rolls on a plate. 3rd visit, last visit, not good.
Great place for gathering. Nice bar in the front and open dining room in back. Beautiful spot. Food was pretty good. Parking is a bit up on a small hill and walk down to restaurant. There is handicap parking right in the front.
Visited for first time. They sat us outside. Except for some road noise. It was great food was amazing. Steven our server was the best
Ordered take out, food was ready in 20 minutes & traveled great. It was fresh & delicious. Highly recommend!
Did not expect such great tasting food. 😄Very satisfied... Cant wait to come back.
Went there for the beer fest. Was better than the year before. They keep improving. Shilelagh law there this year was great.The county legislator (Joe Castelano) was even walking around asking how things were and if there were any improvements we think they could make....
Excellent food, friendly staff with great service. Little pricey but definitely worth it. Would highly recommend.
This place is awesome. We were looking for a place to have a drink during the pandemic. It was super clean with a amazing county vibe.
If I could give no stars I would. We were in the neighborhood last night and decided to check this place out. Went online to look for hours and they said they had reservations open at 9:15 and 9:30. Since we were less than a minute away we drove there rather than book online. When we arrived a rude host told us they had decided they were no longer taking people and closing early. It was 9 oclock on Saturday night and your website says your open for reservations but it didnt matter. Maybe if you sat people on a Saturday evening more regularly you wouldnt be in the position to be closing early.
Great service and great atmosphere. Loved it
Great food and something to satisfy any palate. Extremely nice and courteous staff.
The food and service was great.
Great food, roomy dining room, good service. We took advantage of Thursday evening special for $29. Our group of 8 left raving about the food.
Food was very good. Pork belly was delicious. The bowl of mussels was bigger than my head. 50? 60 mussels?
First time here. Nice people good food. Great show sal was great.
Cozy and very calm ambianceGreat view outsideDelicious food and great service
Had brunch there. Food was amazing. Service was excellent. It was a little loud but otherwise a great afternoon.
Great atmosphere and services is very friendly.
Great atmosphere. Food was delicious. Didnt mind the wait for main course since it was so good.
Very Nice! Great place for Brunch! Kaylee was our server and she was excellent! Thanks for the great experience!
Was actually at Tilly Fosters banquet hall. An old converted barn, staff was friendly and pleasant.
Staff was friendly and food was delicious. Place was warm and welcoming. Will definitely return
Really a nice place , try the Sunday brunch its great. Very cool bar to hangout. Craft beers , very good service.
Assaulted in the bathroom by an apparent employee.Sheriff had to drive my friend and I home (thanks Sheriff)..Need to get rid of that guy who works there.
First time here, absolutely amazing. Beautiful atmosphere, attentive staff, delicious food. I highly recommend it.
Happy hour 2 for 1 🍺. Thursdays price fix menu is very good. $25 for a complete meal, cant be beat!
Really nice restaurant and it has a cute farm ...definitely worth a visit.
Wonderful service, great food and cocktails. Friendly staff.Definitely going back.
WILL NEVER GO THERE AGAIN , WENT TO SUNDAY BRUNCH AND LET ME TELL YOU 1ST ITS IMPOSSIBLE TO GET INTOUCH WITH SOMEONE ON THE PHONE AND 2ND IT IS SO UNORGANIZED FROM WHEN YOU WALK IN THE RESTURANT TO THE TIME YOU SIT DOWN TO THE TIME YOU LEAVE.NEVER AGAIN
Average at best..If you want me to be honest..Took forever for food to come out..most of it was cold..Had ordered Pork chip apple braised and got pork chop stuffed with prosciutto and cheese,ate it anyway was ok....
Really good food and really good food service
Great food and great vibes ! Will definitely be coming back
Love Tillys. Amazing staff. Kayleigh, Colleen and Corey are the best. Love the horse, King and Charlie.
Great place I love it!
Food and service is fantastic. Fresh farm to table deliciousness!
Food was amazing!!! Great service!!
Food was great, nice ambient excellent service.
Great food lovely ambiance beautiful view of the farm
Food,service and outdoor views were all great!!
Loved the whole evening! Food atmosphere and staff outstanding.
Service was meh, food was good, big portions.
Food was bomb diggity but the wait staff was MIA like Bergdahl.
Way too noisy when there is a party upstairs.
Good food, excellent staff!!
Great views, large portions.
When I went it was very good, but now after I sent friends their and received a poor report I am not so sure now
Great service, good food and drinks.
Food was good service was great
Great atmosphere and service. Fine food and drink.
What an amazing Place absolutely beautiful friendly food was delicious
Good food good people. 5 stars easy.
Food was delicious and the service was excellent.
Good food good drinks good people great renovation of an Old Farm
Beautiful placeWorking farmEducational as well
Great food and great service!
Great car show and great car show too.
Was at the Travis tritt concert here and had a good time
Difficult to get in touch with the party organizer. Call a few times, never call me back.
Excellent location,excellent food and service.
Great Sunday brunch. Great price.
Must Visit Tillys Table
Food was not on par with price
Great restaurant!!
Comedy show was a hit.
Excellent food and service
Good food and good service
Attended a concert
Beautiful venue!
Very satisfied!!
Great food
Loved it!!
It was great
Delicious!!!!
Total reviews rating 4.5
130 Reviews for Tillys Table 2023:
Review №1
2021-11-29Tillys Table is a beautiful restaurant on Tilly Foster Farm in Brewster. It has the perfect rustic charm and was beautifully decorated for the holidays. We were the only people there at 5 PM on a Sunday, but a few other parties showed throughout the night. We had a lovely table right in front of a warm fireplace. The waiter was very friendly, answered all of our questions, and never made us feel rushed. We were expecting the portions to be small, but we were pleasantly surprised with how large the portions were! The food was delicious and the wait staff were attentive. We had a great time and will definitely be back - maybe next time to try their brunch! Thank you for a great experience.
Review №2
2022-06-01Went here a fun little festival. Lovely place with a lovely gift shop that also holds classes. The bar/restaurant looks terrific, with beautiful outdoor seating. In the summer they have Saturday night concerts on the green..... check the website for details.
Review №3
2022-03-21Fantastic Sunday brunch. Pleasant service, delicious options, and beautiful setting. The farmers table starts you off with a variety of options like bagels, lox, fruit, salad, cheese, etc. Entree selection includes steak/eggs, crab cake florentine, stuffed French toast and Belgian waffles.plus bottomless mimosas! Well definitely return!
Review №4
2022-02-25Beautiful Restaurant - Food to Die For !Best linguine and clam sauce ever, surf and turf was excellent; we started with the pork belly which was fantastic - the sauce paired so well with the pork !!!Can’t wait to come back!!!
Review №5
2022-05-02Tilly’s did an outstanding job for our wedding reception. The space is gorgeous, the staff is so accommodating and kind, and the food is incredible. We got lots of comments that this was the best wedding food that any of our guests had ever experienced. It was a spectacular night.
Review №6
2021-11-15First time trying the restaurant. We went in for restaurant week and had braised ribs and crab cakes. They were great but the pork chops and pork belly was little over cooked. I had good enough experience to go back and try them again in the near future.
Review №7
2021-07-301st time here for dinner and will definitely go back. I had the Chicken Milanese. Crunchy on the outside tender on inside. The Arugula salad it came on was excellent as was the light vinaigrette.Garlic mashed potatoes were great.My wife had Branzino and liked it a lot. Only issue she had was getting g skin off the fish which took away from the meal a little bit.She had Tiramisu for dessert I had triple layer chocolate cake..Very good with a creaminess with no sugary aftertaste.Pricing very reasonable and meals were large enough for leftovers.My only complaint was all the appetizers were seafood based and only 1 red meat choice for entrees.With a farm to table motto and not near the ocean I was hoping for some more farm to table appetizersGreat vibe inside.Staff was attentive and smiles everywhereDef going back.Reservations required
Review №8
2022-05-08Great mothers day brunch. Many items to choose from , all well prepared except one, the bacon was undercooked , almost raw. That one item should not take away from an otherwise wonderful brunch. Everything else was excellent .
Review №9
2022-06-20This is a beautiful place! They have indoor and outdoor dining. They do have live music on some nights. It would be a great venue for dates or families. The staff were very friendly and the food prices are reasonable. I would highly recommend and will return soon.
Review №10
2021-05-21Nice local restaurant! Servers are always friendly and helpful! Last time we ordered beef tenderloin and surf and turf and both were great! Tasty and done just as requested! Also their mussels are one of the best we ever tried. Looking forward to dining here again.