Outdoor seating
Yes
T.J. Finleys in Bay Shore
Categories
Location on the map
Bay Shore, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Kerbside pickup
Yes
No-contact delivery
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Great bar food
Yes
Great beer selection
Yes
Great cocktails
Yes
Sport
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Cocktails
Yes
Food
Yes
Food at bar
Yes
Happy-hour drinks
Yes
Happy-hour food
Yes
Spirits
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Toilets
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
LGBTQ+ friendly
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Transgender safe space
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 631-647-4856
Site: http://www.tjfinleys.com/
Site: http://www.tjfinleys.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:12PM–4AM
- Tuesday:12PM–4AM
- Wednesday:12PM–4AM
- Thursday:12PM–4AM
- Friday:12PM–4AM
- Saturday:11AM–4AM
- Sunday:11AM–4AM
T.J. Finleys in other cities:
Comments (160)
Spent $10 on a pint of beer that I could have gotten much cheaper at the brewery. I wont make that mistake again
Pretty nice place!Stopped in for a Guinness and a burger. The bartender was very nice and took really good care of us. We shared the shrimp tacos with jalapeño slaw. They were EXCELLENT! The sauce had a little spice and the shrimp was deep fried perfectly. My burger was cooked to order and the fries were hot and well done.My son had the hanger steak sandwich and thought it was great. He asked for a side of gravy which came in a little to go container and cost $1.00. I hate the nickel and dime stuff!Only negative comment is that there was a funny smell in the place, like cleaning disinfectant or something but the front windows were opened to the outside and it was a great night.
They have a Great beer selection but doesnt everyone? The food and atmosphere separate these guys from their peers. Service with a smile. More bar tenders needed for Tuesday Trivia nights. Well be back for more tacos and wings.
Like this place, go once a month. Excellent revolving beer selection. Excellent apps
The Nachos with chili are fresh crispy and extraordinary
Good beer selection, friendly and attentive bartender, heat lamps on the back deck were most appreciated. Someone clearly had some digestive issues on the lone mens room toilet (and I do mean ON the toilet... and floor), and it looked like it had been there a while. Dont know if they were waiting for a hazmat crew to come clean it up, but it was not welcoming. Aside from that, a decent dive for a few weeknight brews.
I just moved to Bayshore and started researching neighborhood bars. This one came up so I came here and have been here ever since. Great food and drinks with reasonable prices. Shawn the bartender is my M’F’m man! He’s absolutely awesome as well as all the other staff This is now “my bar” no doubt! !
So Ive had 2 meals through door dash from here and I dont know what to think. First time was a burger, cooked exactly how I wanted it. Most recently I went for the pulled pork but boy was that a mistake. The meat was like dried jerky, tough and leathery with the slaw and pickles doing their best to carry the sandwich. Both times I have ordered the pretzel trio and both times they have been a little underwhelming as well. Fries are tasty though.
See, heres the thing - I like beer. Like, alot. And, well, T.J. Finleys doesnt just have beer, theyve got some of the best taps on Long Island! Ive been there a few times now and everytime is something different, almost all from local breweries ans the service has been on point each time.Theyve got a great popcorn machine, which they gladly give you some of when youre at the bar (careful, its addictive) and TVs so that you can watch the games, or chive TV (love that network) and relax while still being able to follow your team.Theres also a back outdoor heated patio during these winter months. Parking in bay shore can be tricky, but its well worth solving the riddle to hang here.
What amazing top notch customer service. I placed an order through uber eats and the order got mixed up when it was delivered. I contacted TJ Finleys and the manager, Zack was exceptional & beyond accommodating... he personally made sure the order was redone and personally delivered it to my door. I truly appreciate the service and I will gladly go back, its not every day that you get such awesome customer service and great food. I highly recommend this spot.
Food was good. Definitely try the truffle fries. Large selection of beers plus they have cocktails for those who dont like beer. Service was quick. Cozy atmosphere.
Great selection of beers and friendly bartenders.
It use to be better. The place cannot control the inside temperature to the point of being very uncomfortable. The beer selection used to be more balanced between different styles, but not any more.
Didnt hate the place. Didnt want a to go dish frisbeed at me either by a bartender while she eavesdropped on someone else convo. But I still said thank you and have a good night.
Amazing beer selection. Their bloody Marys can be a meal. Perfect spot for beer lovers before you catch a ferry or just want a fun pub to hang out in.
My new favorite place! Nice selection on tap, well prepared and different selection of food, descent pricing, relaxing atmosphere! Very friendly staff, attentive! Went back 3 times, will keep going!
Excited to see live music is back on Thursdays🎼💕
Great bar with great food. They have beer from all around the world and if you drink around the world you get your name on the bar and a t-shirt. It can get crowded on a weekend and If a big game is on but other wise you can get a place to sit most of the time.
Bartender was friendly enough, but stopped to text before she served each drink. Fried pickles are pickle spears, so that was a bit of a disappointment. Good beer selection, though, and internet jukebox.
In Bay Shore, no one does craft beer like TJ Finleys. With a large selection on tap and at least one brew on cask, there is a variety not passed by anyone else on Main Street. During the summer, the back deck is always a fun place to hang out and drink into the night. Staff are always courteous and will get you your drink lightning fast even with a packed bar. Finleys is a great spot close to home for most, and it keeps its regulars close. Ask them about their beer passport program! A great establishment on pretty much every front.
Great burgers N tots with an extensive beer selection makes this place a must try!!!
They have got a great beer selections but it cant save them from the just OK staff and terrible people that go here. Its not as douchey as Changing Times but its almost there. Be warned.
We were able to hangout ....as a group...at a table... green beer... good conversation... attentive staff...thank you...
Just ordered wings and fries from here because I live close by. The chicken was old and they just put sauce on it and reheated it. The fries were soggy. The food was not edible. A definite waste of $25.
Nice little bar with an awesome beer selection and pretty good food.
Get some of the best wings on long island, ask for them double cooked, you wont regret it. All the food is good and the beer selection is fantastic, if youre a beer drinker you need to come here
Great atmosphere and rocking music if you like that type of bar. Plenty of beers on tap including seasonal and local brews.
What a awesome place to get good beer and good food. It is a really good atmosphere and the staff 8s really friendly
They make a Philly Cheese steak that will knock your socks off, I dont even drink, the food is awesome!
Good food, good drink prices & excellent staff.
Great staff, great atmosphere. The beer selection is plentiful, and unlike most other beer bars, its not all IPAs.
Great beer selection with knowledgeable staff and some of the best bar food Ive ever had. Highly recommended.
Take out wings Warren is good as usual usually go to for take out wings.
One of my favorite local bars. A great selection of constantly rotating great craft beers and a really excellent bar food menu.
Happy St. Patricks Day
Good beer selection, typical bar food but does get crowded on weekends and during sporting events
I went here after volleyball and the staff remembered us from the year prior! Great service as usual and of course very good food.
Awesome place to hangout with friends. Staff is really nice and friendly. The food is amazing, the environment is good. Highly recommended
One of my favorite bars to go to when looking for a new beer to try, food is very tasty too.
Awesome food, great environment, attentive staff. All around great place for a bite to eat and a great drink.
Food and beer was great. Nice and clean and friendly staff.
Just average, wont rush back
Great food girls behind the bar were fun outgoing and on top of things had a great experience there
One of my favorite spots. Cool bartenders, good food and great beers.
Exceptional cocktails, great beer and great food. Melanie is an excellent bartender, and makes the experience even better!
Had a beer and two soft pretzels perfect snack/small meal.
Great beer, pretty good bar food, and a fun atmosphere, and theres never a cover!
Clean and good beer selection. However the beer prices were 8 or 9 dollars per pint.
Went for lunch. Friendly service, good beer selection, good food.
Great beer selection and surprisingly extensive food menu.
If youre looking for alcohol, this is your spot. Dont expect much more than that though.. Crummy music, cool seating arrangement but thats about it
The blue cheese burger was awesome!! Best Irish coffee in town!.
Great place for beer. Good food, better beer.
Great food, great beer selection and the bartenders are awesome.
Recently went there. Nice crowd
Cool place , they take care of cleaning ,distance rules and make it a good time 🤠✌️
Great tap beer selection and wonderful environment cheerful staff
Great beers and relaxed atmosphere. We regularly travel 20 minutes to wind down here.
Good bar apps and nice beer selection. Good daily specials too!
This place is perfect for drinks eats and get togethers! Never disappointed! Wings are KILLER!
Great staff, awesome food and stellar beer and mixed drinks.
I love this place, they deliver alcohol thru doordash
Great tap list, great servers!
They have really good food! steak sandwhich is my go to!
I didnt even get to go in.there was a huge fight with what looked like two groups of people.
My wife and I had great burgers in a friendly atmosphere.
Awesome beer selection, can get crowded with the younger crowd on weekends. Always new beers on tap
Great food great beer
Great burgers french fries and beers! And Melanies a great bartender!
Awesome low key bar. Great place to hang with friends
Great Beers and Pub fare
Door dashed mild wings. Came with no sauce. Told me to just drive over and pick it up. Waste of $40 bucks.
Love the beer detection and food. Never enough seats available.
Nice place, delicious chicken wings, and wonderful place to watch football.
Good wings, great selection of beer.
Good food, staff be and drinks.
Excellent
Good place to hang out. They start ignoring you when it gets busy though...
Great beer and cocktails. Great bartenders.
Made the wall took me long enough but so happy I did it
My favorite Wednesday spot, food is great too!
Great food. And a great vibe to the place
Great beer selection. Great burgers
Great beer selection. Great food.
The food is very good for the right price
Cool bar lots of taps, heated outdoor areas.
Im here right now with some people and its a good time. Good people.
Really good atmosphere had a good time
Very nice
Reliably good cocktails at a fair price.
Great atmosphere, friendly patrons & staff.
Great food. Great service.
I dont remember 😂
Great weekday deals, nice people. Good times.
Nice vibe
Played the first 11 seconds of Mambo number five then skipped it. Wack.
Very nice place , enjoyed it very much
Great tap selection, love the sweet potato tots
The best bar on Long Island period.
Very good service. Good food.
Guess I just came on a bad night. Staff sucked and last called by like 2...on Friday night!!!
Great food, great atmosphere
Great beer and food!
I won 1300 dollars from here its awesome
Nice bar. Friendly service.
Always a great hangout spot!
It is a pub with good food, good $.
Good place to have a drink with friends
First time there had a great time
Great food and drinks
Awsome food service and environment
Great place to hang out!
Fun bar good food
Somehow always end up here after a night in Bay Shore!
Good place for craft beers
Really chill and cool vibe
Great football crowd!
Great beer and food
Music too loud with no one dancing.
Nice beer selection
Just like the places right around it...
They have heieken 0.0
Pretty cool little spot
Nice place for a beer
Nothing special in my opinion
The beers are cold.
Good place
Nice place
Excellent service.
Excellent wings
Great music
Good place to go!!!
Oktoberfest
Worst bartender
Never a bad time
Always a blast
Good wings
Not so much
Horrible bartender
Good vibes
Great staff
Good place.
Sick sliders
Love this place
A very nice place with a variety of beers, only the food lacked a bit of seasoning, but the lady who attends is very friendly and attentive
The food is delicious they always have something new ... it is very good atmosphere
I have no idea how soft I dont know what place is that Ive never been there
Lindo lugar
Very well
Hi, Kayla
Total reviews rating 4.4
160 Reviews for T.J. Finleys 2023:
Review №1
2022-03-13Very popular and busy establishment. Great food and cozy atmosphere. Back outside heated bar and beirgarten allows for more room. Staff was pleasant. Parking is close with municipal lots and on street pay parking as well.
Review №2
2022-04-11They had Chimay...enough said! But they also loved our dog and gave him water, a great time in the village!
Review №3
2022-06-02Pretty much my go-to in Bay Shore. Friendly staff, great bar food options. Yummy cocktails and good beer selection.
Review №4
2022-06-09This is one of my go-to bars in Bay Shore. They have trivia night on Tuesdays around 8/8:15 - bring your A-team as it’s competitive!
Review №5
2021-07-12For this Boston Irishman this pub is fabulous! The dry rub wings are outstanding; beer selection top notch; and, the bartender professional and friendly.
Review №6
2022-02-05I mean, come on, its T.J. Finelys. What more do you need. One of the best bars in Bay Shore, if not the island. This place needs no introduction. Great beers on tap! Taps are always clean and the beer fresh. A great selection of bottles and cans. Cocktails are always on point. Also, dont sleep on their food! Always great! Really, you cant go wrong at Finelys!
Review №7
2018-07-14This pub style bar is right in the heart of downtown Bayshore and serves up a pretty decent selection of tap beer and bottled beer as well. The food is classic pub fare and will do the trick if you get hungry but it may be best to eat beforehand if you want a more varied menu. Overall a good spot to grab a fresh brew. Cheers!
Review №8
2021-10-19Went for pumpkin fest. The place had a great vibe and plenty of seating. Would recommend for a fun night out.
Review №9
2022-05-06Nice beer selection, friendly staff and delicious pub food! Finely crafted cocktails! Frequent exciting and fun events.
Review №10
2017-03-29Great bar, Tuesday night trivia is a good time. Lots of beers from which to choose. Im with Matt Quedens.