Outdoor seating
Yes
Tommy Guns Pizzeria in Warrensburg
Categories
Location on the map
Warrensburg, Warren County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Phone: +1 518-696-6500
Site: https://tommygunspizzeria.com/
Site: https://tommygunspizzeria.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–9PM
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–9PM
- Saturday:11AM–9PM
- Sunday:11AM–8PM
Comments (145)
We ordered pizza rolls and pies for a family get-together last summer. The food was hot and ready to be picked up, and fabulous!
Really good pizza and great friendly staff. go to pizza place in the area.
Great pizza! Would recommend for their awesome variety of pizzas
Came in after a day of skiing and grabbed a few slices. Did NOT disappoint! Pizza was a good, fair prices and staff was super friendly. I will definitely come back.
Delicious. very pleasant staff and we love the desert knots and garlic bread 10/10 very cheesy
I’m well acquainted with pizza. Family from Jersey: Tomato Pie. Family from Brooklyn: classic by the slice. My own restaurant, wood fired Neopolitan. This pizza is legit. Good people, good service, clean. Check it out.
Tommy Guns Pizzeria has delicious pizza plus an amazing selection of additional foods that will satisfy any craving for excellent Italian food. Staff is very friendly and restaurant is clean!!!
I have gone here for months food has been excellent today ordered a ceaser salad wit crispy chicken the chickens gotta be 2/3 days old can barely chew our pizza is ice cold wow not happy at all
Wow! Totally exceeded my expectations! The best bruschetta I’ve had in 49 years, chicken parm was tasty too. Jameson & Anthony we’re great with my downstate special requests in the back room speakeasy, & I am particular. What a surprise and treat this venue is, our first time here, this will be our regular place for sure. Whole staff was welcoming and friendly. I can see why we were recommended here.
My family and I got a large pizza and there was a tiny hole in there handmade dough and they gave us two extra slices! That on top of the wonderful staff 5 stars without a doubt. Also the pizza (and fris) are so good!
Great food. And great patron
It is great atmosphere and great food at a great price take out eat in at the bar in the back
Hard to find a pizza worth eating in this area but Tommy Guns is top notch!!!!!!!! Great pies and great prices
So this is one of the few reviews where my negative is really a positive so lets get started.The people: They are extremely friendly and helpful and willing to make suggestions (when asked) when you cant quite decide what to get. They work well and fast under pressure and still have that friendly attitude.The food: Let me start by saying: I would contemplate doing illegal things for the Bang Bang sauce. Their pizza is top notch and the Bang Bang sauce is amazing. The only negative is that some of the new stuff isnt great BUT to have a place that is willing to experiment is Awesome!. I will gladly try some food that I dont like for the chance to try new things. The best part about this place is they rarely miss the mark with their experiments.Overall its a 5 star place. Good food, good people, and decent prices.
Alfredo pasta 10/10.The rest was good too.
Tommy Guns is our go-to for pizza when we stay at Diamond Point. The woman that answers the phone is genuinely the nicest, most patient person Ive ever placed a pizza or takeout order with.If you are intrigued by the bang bang chicken pizza, you have to try it and wont be disappointed. When we order for the beach we always get an extra one of these because everyone tries it and then eats twice as much as they said they would, (Dad and Chris!).Pro tip: if you are impatient NY/NJ-ians, order before the evening rush like around 5 or 530 the latest for the fastest delivery time (45+/-), even if you arent going to eat until around 7.Anytime after 6-630 all bets are off. Does not warrant less stars because lets be honest, everyone on the lake is calling for pizza at 630-7.
Went to Tommy Guns tonight for the first time based upon a reccomend from a freind. It was excellent. Sat at the bar, Jameson was the bartender. Had a few drinks and ordered our pizza to go. Super friendly and personable place. He even had a good play list going.We a got treated to an order of garlic balls that were out of this world delicious. Once we got home and enjoyed our sausage and pepper pizza it too was outstanding! I think the best in the entire area.This is a great little unknown place that should be on your list of must dos. I am so looking forward to going back for a meal. Everything coming out of the kitchen looked great. A must!
Brittany does an amazing job! Best Pizza around. we wish that they lived closer to us!!
Thank you so much definitely best pizza in town keep up the good work
Pizza was cold when I got it, the delivery guy dropped the order of garlic knots on the ground, they didnt have more so wanted us to wait until next day and still wanted us to pay full price. Will never order from them again. Prices are not worth the food I made better by the the time I was 15 yrs old Stewarts has better food
Absolutely love their bang bang pizza and the garlic knots are my go to side. They have amazing staff and reasonable prices. They are quick and haven’t had any issues with any of the orders I have gotten from here
Great food atmosphere was awesome will definitely go there again
First impressions! Yikes. Not impressed at all. No one acknowledged us when we walked in. Music in bar so loud we couldn’t hear ourselves. Bartender didn’t look up. All employees looked “harried”. Wasn’t well organized or welcoming. Shame. We thought we’d found a diamond in the rough. Went down the street.
I had the bang bang shrimp salad. It was fantastic! The owners are incredibly welcoming. Nice atmosphere...new bar opened in the back. Highly recommended if you are in Warrensburg
I ordered chicken wings, I got chicken nuggets in hot sauce. Normally pizza is good cold, but I got sick from it. I will NEVER eat there again.
Terrible communication, said they came to deliver and knocked, never heard a thing and we didn’t get our food.
They are excellent. I love pizza, but not just any pizza, good quality pizza. And for that reason, I can reassure you that Tommy Guns is really good. They have a thin crust style of dough with a generous helping of cheese. They have a plethora of great topping options, plus a restaurant environment that is cool and relaxing with friendly people who work there.
Every time we go the staff is great and the food even better. Love the bang bang shrimp
Please try there turkey bacon sub its one of a kind!
Im a Philly native that relocated to the north country. Tommy Guns has the best Philly cheesteak this far north of the City of Brotherly Love! Pizza is fantastic, fries are perfect! Will definitely get a lot of business from this Philly family.
This pizza is SO GOOD! even when I get it delivered it still tastes super fresh. I recommend it to everyone who comes into the area.
Really good pizza and the best eggplant sub on their homemade bread. Our bartender Jamison was very attentive.
Greaf food!! Love when we go upstate and get to eat here.
Definitely need more help or someone who can estimate order time. Was told 45 minutes and upon my arrival, pizzas were just going in the oven. Pizzas then sat on top of the oven while I waited for my wing order. By the time, we get the wings it was an hour and half from order time and our pizzas were cold. This is the 3rd and last time for us.
The ordering process is fairly simplistic, but the execution is not smooth. Dully understanding that this is a small town local pizza shop that at this point only offers pickup or delivery only. You have to call 1 number to order and another different number to notify the pizzeria when youve arrived. After trying their order number for 30 minutes and getting a mixture of busy signals or the numbet doesnt work we drove down to see if we can order in person which we were told with attitude no call the number.Attitude aside the pizza is actually very good. The sauce that is on the pie is not acidic, the lumberjack is a meat eaters dream come true. If the ordering process werent ridiculous I would have gotten pizza here more than once during my recent visit to the area.
Ceaser salad was huge and delicious. My husband pizza was on point. Great Decor.
Tommy Guns has amazing food! The ingredients are fresh & all food is made to order. They use Boars Head brand meats & cheeses exclusively on their subs, wraps, stromboli, calzones, pizza & salads plus Oscars Smokehouse bacon as well as their famous More Than Mustard (& I believe they use their horseradish mayo). Their salad dressings are also made in house & are delicious. Another thing that puts their subs over the top is the out of this world Italian sub rolls that they bake fresh in-house every morning! The homemade pizza crust is perfection, the pies are huge & they certainly dont skimp on the toppings or the cheese! Highly recommend!
We ordered three pizza .They were all great.I was exceptionally happy with the veggie gluten free option I had.Really good gf crust is hard to find.This was delicious. Great prices and good customer service. Definitely will be returning when we are in town .
Girl put me on hold and didnt come back. Busy place still went and got there pizza. worth it
I’ve been a local for 22 years, and this is the worst pizza shop that has ever been in town. 45 minutes turned into two and a half hour wait for my food. When I got my food it was cold and, they messed up my order. Service was trash. Also the food was nothing special either. WOULD NOT RECOMMEND !
Fantastic pastas, salads, and garlic bread!But the pizza itself.....not so much.Weve ordered pizza 4-5 times, and every time we cant even finish it. and usually we feel kinda sick for a while after.. even the regular ol pepperoni pizza wasnt great. The wings are usually overcooked and dry as well.I kinda feel like they should have been more of an italian restaurant rather than a pizza place specifically? because again, the pasta, bread and salad is superb. But as for the pizza, Im not sure well bother trying it again.
NJ visitors’ stamp of approval! We had the 3 sisters and lumberjack pie - both were great. You MUST order the garlic knots if you go here, so good!!
Knowing that they where open on the off season made us go in the first place. When we fo found it there was cars lined up along the r. This is definitely a hot spot for the town! And for good reason to. At first I was like why wouldn’t they put the sauce on the wings, when I had themi figured out why. They hash a perfect crunch to them. Amazing! And they do not skip out on toppings for the pizzas! There was so much meat and cheese! Just the way you wanna make it at home!Definitely worth the money!!!
Delicious pizza!!! Great beer selection in the back room!
With out a doubt good food great pizza... my only complaint is the time and estimate of how long... 2 times now I have been given an hour till pick up and when I show up its literally just getting put in the oven
Just got food there because the pizza shop is closed on Monday or I would of went there..and the pizza I got is horrible and so thin..cant believe they charged me $17..picture tells it all..very Disappointed
We really liked the Pizza here. We stopped by for lunch here while coming back from White water rafting. The chicken Pizza and three sister veggie pizza is really awesome. People are very friendly and helpful too.
Tommy Guns Pizzeria is the top ten pizza place in the world. I like Grimaldi pizza from Brooklyn, but now my No1 Pizza place is Tommy Guns Pizzeria. Staff is so friendly and courteous and dont miss the chance to have a fantastic lunch or dinner.
Went to this place twice this week! Pizza is great, so is the meatball hero.
Just ordered as i always do large pepperoni with xtra cheese. Of course no xtra cheese again and im all for thin crust pizza but u could actually see thru crust. Please when i say and pay for xtra cheese i i wt xtra cheese!!!!
Pizza is amazing! Sub rolls are super hearty and can’t go wrong with Boar’s Head meat. Staff is very friendly and they have the BEST chocolate milk around!
Best pizza around! Only place for real NY style pizza and they have a gluten free option too :)
Just walked into Tommy Guns pizza shop and was blown away by there pizza. Service was great place was clean and neat. Highly recommend if your in the area!!
Excellent as always. The walk up window is tough but we are compliant . Had time to Visit the liquor store next door .
We are outside & the food was huge portions very reasonable price & waitress was nice.
Fantastic... The Warrensburg pizza is out of this world good!!!! Great energetic employees... Great music outside patio!!!
I ordered my pizza I was told it would be 45 minutes it was well over an hour and a half and I called a couple times after checking on the status of my order and the woman who answered the phone actually hung up on me. The food is good the customer service is horrible
Pizza was good but after 45 minutes and a call ahead our was still not in the oven when we got there. Would go again when in town but not call ahead.
Delicious food with a neighborhood atmosphere. Love the new bar area.
Wonderful staff and amazing food! Cant wait to go back!
Awesome pizza but im always told 30 -45 minutes but its always longer and pizza comes almost cold to where you have to microwave it. Like tonight i ordered it took over an hour to come
Have ordered numerous times and the last FOUR times its either wrong or they forgot something DONT DO DELIVERY GUARENTEED TO SCREW UP
Great pizza staff was very friendly loved the firepit
I went there with my friend to try. Service was ok, decent pricing, and quick making and the food was actually alright. However, the next day, me and my friend were throwing up, having stomachaches, etc.
Great food, alot of selectoons, pizza was justvthe way I like it and great pasta very good cooks, awesome customer service.......
Excellent pizza and pinwheels! Highly recommended!
By far the best pizza I have had in years. Looking forward to going back
Ordered a gluten free pizza, one buffalo chicken salad, and one plain chicken salad. Got two buffalo chicken salads. Girlfriend was not happy.
Delivery guy walked in with no mask on, waitress walked out the door to bring me a salad with her mask on her lower lip. Not ever going back.
Fresh, delicious, huge antipasto salad. My son liked the pizza and my hubby his mixed italian sub A LOT!
Best pizza in Warrensburg ny. Very friendly. Finally good pizza in town. All food is great. Thank you Tommy guns.
Best pizza outside nyc will most definitely be going back again
I live over an hour plus away. Was out there to visit friend. Food service and cost gets an A+
We really enjoy their pizza, wings and garlic knots. Friendly service with great prices.
Tommy Guns is the best pizza hands down the owners are great people and the staff is great I honestly eat there around 3 days a week.
Super good pizza! Perfectly cooked. Just like NYC. Will be returning, often.
Very good. Great menu. Fast service
Pizza was very good. Best Ive had in the ADK.
Been here for 45 minutes and still no food , table came in after us and is eating pizza ?????
This was the best pizza I ever had will be back and tell everyone I know
Excellent pizza! Friendly people. Will definitely come back
Good pizza, better than others in the area and friendly staff
Great place, great family restaurant. VERY GENEROUS WITH TOPPINGS
Great and no masks!
A good slice of cheese, warm & just like I would find in similar NYC hangouts
Great place!! Quite the hidden gem!
This place is awesome! Highly recommend! Great food ! Great staff
Great food , great service , and in an amazing town. Thank u
Best white pizza around!
All of the food was a new York city style and taste, well done
Love this place I have never had a bad meal recommend highly
The best pizzeria in the area! I definitely recommend it!!
Pretty good, Id eat their pie again.
A bit pricy but great food!
Amazing spaghetti and meatballs. Great quantities and superb quality
Thank you Tommy guns... You deffinietly made my night.... My all time favorite puzza by far.
Very good pizza super friendly staff
I love this place good food and service.
Best subs in town and you have to try the bang bang sauce !!
My favorite pizza around
Great pizza and fresh made daily subs
Good food and the employes are really friendly
Sauce had no flavor was like a piece of bread with some cheese.
Best pizza in the ADKs!
Professional and courteous staff
Very bad customer service food ok
Great pizza and beer.
Very tasty pizza and wings!
ABSOLUTELY The Best Pizza around!!
They always make great food.
Great food, friendly staff
Great service and food.
Great pizza great prices
Great Food, Love the Crack Knots!
Called 3 times and no answer
Great food great people
Good food and good people
Good pizza and Italian food.
Good pizza!!
Best pizza around!!
Great service and food
The food is great unbelievable
Love the food there.
Great owners and food!!!
Wings usually over cooked
Perfect place to eat
Really good pizza
The best in Warrensburg!
Great pizza
Great wings
Great food
Great pizza
PIZZA ROCKS !
A local pizza house in a small town. It is delicious when I eat it with the red pepper powder which the cheese pizza is gawaku and together.Dow is a thin American dow.Chicken tenders are large in size, but they do not taste very good.
Thanks to
Total reviews rating 4.4
145 Reviews for Tommy Guns Pizzeria 2023:
Review №1
2022-02-04Pizza is 5 stars, dough is homemade and as good as it gets. The margarita’s tomatoes, cheese and basil are fresh. The meatballs are homemade and really tasty. I highly recommend eating here.
Review №2
2022-06-22I’ve tried all the chicken parmigiana Heros (subs) in warrensburg. This is the best and would be exceptional anywhere. The bread is nicely toasted with a nice flavor to the sauce and chicken and the hero was not too dry. I’ve been working (physical labor) all day and I honestly couldn’t finish the entire thing. I’ll be coming back probably every time I’m near Town. It’s totally worth it.
Review №3
2021-10-21Good service on a busy weekend night and tasty garlic knots, but sadly disappointed by the quality of their pizza. I won’t be back due the underwhelming pizza, it’s just not good. Literally down the road you’ll get a significantly better pizza from The Pizza Shop, go there instead if you’re looking for pizza.
Review №4
2021-10-01Ate here several times during our stay in town. Food was great! Had lunch here twice and dinner on the patio once. Very friendly staff and excellent food!
Review №5
2022-04-30I stopped by this place yesterday for the first time. It is one of the best pizzas I have ever had! The staff are very friendly too. I highly recommend this place to anyone who enjoys this type of food!
Review №6
2022-02-11Great crew great bartenderGood laughsAnthony the chef did awesome
Review №7
2022-02-28My son had a birthday party. I ask what pizza shop he wanted . He said tommy guns pizza. My kid who is very picky loves the taste and Everyone that work there is very friendly. I love there gluten free pizza it taste so good. i will always order from there. Everything about tommy guns pizzeria. Make it a family friendly place to take your child. I have extreme social anxiety and they made me feel welcome.
Review №8
2021-05-25We walked in ready to order food and beer.. They direcred us to their new speakeasy.. Pizza was good. Hot garlic parm paired well with the frog Alley sour we got on tap. We were able to do a flight. Our favorite was Artisanal beer works beer that they have in cans. Very 20s vibe.
Review №9
2022-05-20I called another pizza shop in town they did not serve breaded deep fried mushrooms and Tommy guns did very good Ill definitely go back nice atmosphere great food
Review №10
2019-06-14Love their unique twist on pizza plus the classics. Delicious! The garlic knots were really GARLICY! Timely and friendly service Typical price. Two sizes of pizza available.