Top Of The Bay Tex Mex Bar and Bistro in Alexandria Bay
Categories
Location on the map
Alexandria Bay, Jefferson County, New York, US
Service options
Health and safety
Highlights
Popular for
Offerings
Dining options
Amenities
Atmosphere
Crowd
Payments
The BBQ is good. Really good, and thats coming from a southerner. I order the pulled BBQ pork quesadilla almost every visit. For $8.99, you cant go wrong. Its an impressive portion, and I always have leftovers. The other BBQ dishes, bang bang shrimp, and mussels are excellent. Ive enjoyed most of the food tried here. So, thats the good. Now for the needs improvement category. The interior hasnt changed over the years even as the name and owners have changed, but its functional. As others have noted, the outdoor areas have seen more improvement. The staff is friendly, although not that attentive. Locals definitely receive priority attention at the bar. The beer selection is minimalist for drafts, but the cocktails are decent. Prices are fair. All in all, Top of the Bay is surprising for the quality of the food and the impressive BBQ.
I was just reading reviews and noticed something deeply disturbing. One review from a Danielle Pierone (aka KAREN) decide to bash this small business and try to ruin an theyβre image over a water bottle that she couldnβt bring in. SO, with that being said. I canβt wait to give this place more of my business as long as we can keep entitled trash like her out. This business handled that review so well and people like her are the reason why you canβt bring in the water bottle. Honey, We know itβs vodka in so take your sorry story on how you are trying to recycle somewhere else. I wanna stress i have no affiliation with business but Iβve worked in the hospitality industry that Iβve had enough of it. Also, food and atmosphere are great!
We wanted to try this place for lunch, not they dont allow anyone under 18 in! Thought this was a bit excessive considering it was the early afternoon. We were disappointed, Tex Mex sounded good and there werent any other Mexican options. Too bad they lost our business just because we had children with us.
Total reviews rating 4.2
70 Reviews for Top Of The Bay Tex Mex Bar and Bistro 2023:
Review β1
2021-09-27Excellent customer service by the young man with black hair. He did everything on his tablet faster than I see most servers use pen and paper! The food came out fast and delicious! We all got something different from tacos to bowls to burritos and it was all very good! The beer is actually reasonably priced here too πΊ The restaurant sits on a rooftop over looking the bay and has shaded seating its a wonderful spot to bring tourists!
Review β2
2022-07-04Food: Mexican cuisine. Small menu, which is how I like it. Everything we ordered was delicious.Ambience: On the terrace, with a sectioned area under a tent. Great views. Live music on Sundays. It can be windy,Service: was very good. Consistent follow-up to see if everything was okay.Time: we were approached immediately and consistently taken care of. We spent more time enjoying the view into the bay and the food.
Review β3
2019-07-22Nice little place over the water. Small menu, but decent food. Drinks were good but small. Wait staff was great!Note that this place is only upstairs, and is on a outdoor patio. Not fun during wind and storms!I recommend a try.
Review β4
2021-08-07Got here at 9:45 and the kitchen closes at 10. The waitresses were 10/10 (thanks Tini). They were motivated to get our order in vs being annoyed because of our tardiness. Weβre from the city and realized a little late everything closed at 10. Did I mention the tasty burritos and generous tacos? Plus the margaritas are on point. Not too sweet. Yes please!
Review β5
2022-07-02Great Mexican! The brisket tacos were fantastic.
Review β6
2021-06-22I normally never leave a review but our appetizers came out with our dinner. Bartender made us wait until she was done on her phone and having a conversation with three men, before taking a drink order. Our dinner was not as ordered. Before finishing we were brought the check. This place makes you feel like youβre inconveniencing them.
Review β7
2020-09-10Atmosphere is very nice, staff is amazing. They have live music most of the time. Although it is on the pricey side.Ive tried the chicken burrito twice now and each time Ive had it, it was either warm and cold in the center or just barely warm. For the price of the food you would expect it to be well cooked.
Review β8
2021-08-28Good place in Alex bay area.. it is bummer that we could not get our 19yo son in due to age restriction.Staff and chef accommodated with Vegan Burrito! Happy
Review β9
2021-08-29An outdoor bar upstairs offers a great view of the public docks and other venues. Drinks seem a bit pricey at first until you realize the pours are heavy.
Review β10
2021-11-19Love stopping here to watch friends play live music. Great margaritas, nice beer selection, tex mex food is delicious, staff is always friendly.