Two Brothers Pizza & Pasta Restaurant in Levittown
Categories
Location on the map
Levittown, Nassau County, New York, US
Site: https://www.twobrotherspizzaandp...
- Monday:11AM–10PM
- Tuesday:11AM–10PM
- Wednesday:11AM–10PM
- Thursday:11AM–10PM
- Friday:11AM–11PM
- Saturday:11AM–11PM
- Sunday:11AM–10PM
Been going there since I was a baby in the early 80s with my family. My dad was one of their first customers when they first opened. Whenever I come up to visit from Florida, this is ALWAYS one of my first dinners when I come back home. Never had a bad pizza in over 40 years of eating there!!
I grew up down the block from this pizzeria and watched it grow. Usually love their pizza and never had a problem until today. When I was told they wouldn’t take a phone order and payment for 7 slices of pizza bc it wasn’t an order for the kitchen. I had my two small children with me and it is easier to not have them waiting for pizza with a crowd. Some places are even offering curbside. I didnt think placing the order was too much to ask-I just wanted to quickly go in and grab my order. When I went in and asked about why they wouldn’t take order I was told it is busy and slices go quick ( which I still don’t understand if I paid for it over the phone). To top it off the pizza was not even hot.
OUTRAGEOUS PRICESPlaced an order for 2 spinach slices, 1 chicken roll, 1 ziti slice and 1 order of French fries. The order we 28.65. I find this to be outrageous . They charge $4.00 per spinach slice, chicken roll was $8.00. Ziti Slice $6.00 and the French fries were also $6.00. On top of their exorbitant prices the taxes are not included in the prices. My family and I have been loyal customers of Two Brothers, but after tonight outrageous prices we will be looking for a more reasonably price pizzeria. Shame on the extreme over pricing.
I grew up close by and have been going here since they opened. I really do love this pizza, but some of the people behind the counter can just be down right rude. Would it hurt for them to at least say thank you when ordering over the phone or in person? Like, should we be honored to be eating their food?Like I said, love the food, the owners are always there making food and staying involved, just need the counter kids to be a little nicer.
Located in a Shopping Center on Levittown Parkway. Relocated a few stores down. Bigger and nicer. Super busy with takeout orders. Impressive during COVID19 Restrictions. Food is good. But the Sicilian Pizza is the Star 🌟. On the pricey side. Credit cards accepted. The Staff is OK. Many locals patronize this place. We will definitely be going back.
Big fan of carbonara. This place was highly recommended for the food, so when I called to ask if carbonara was on the menu, I had to try it. Well apparently at Two Brothers all you gotta do to make a carbonara is sprinkle some bacon and peas on your fettuccini alfredo and voila, alfredonara. Wouldve been ok with the peas being in there... Wouldve even let the bacon slide in place of pancetta or guanciale... But ALFREDO sauce!?!?! Cmon!!!! If you dont know what youre cooking google/youtube it. Hint eggs (with extra yolk) & pecorino are a must. Get it together.
Twice I’ve ordered salads and twice my order was wrong. So annoying to order a salad with grilled chicken and not get the grilled chicken or order Caesar salad and you don’t get the Caesar dressing. I do like the food but they have to get a better system in place to make sure the order is correct. Two stars for being so unorganized!
I like the food here. Nothing crazy just good wholesome food. They have a wide selection. The pizzas pretty good I especially like the Vodka slices. The star of the show for me is the pinwheels they have meat and vegetable pinwheels and theyre both equally as good. My only problem with this place is the parking. Decent-sized Lots but there are a lot of businesses there and it gets pretty crowded. If you go off peak you should find plenty of parking. Well at least you know all the stores there are good since theres no parking LOL
Pizza has been okay. The staff has been rude one day and pleasant the next. Ordered a few trays for new years and everyone said it was good but a bit salty. Im running out of patience for this place.Update after 3 years and the staff are still miserable. Domenicos and Marios of Levittown it is.
I use to love two brothers, to some extent still do. The food is great but with the renovations its lost that neighborhood pizzeria feel. Its too fancy, the service is far to slow. Waited 45 min to get a simple meal when being seated. The waiter is less than friendly. The guys behind the counter are awesome pleasant and chipper. Its a very conflicting dynamic between a pizzeria and an Italian restaurant. Its lucky they had a great establishment people know before the move...hopefully in time it gets better
A grilled chicken salad is very good Also chicken parm hero’s and meatball heroes. One complaint is that they very rarely have enough regular pizza there is always a regular pie coming out in five minutes. ( because no one waits five minutes). Which makes you buy the more exotic pizzaWhich is more. $$
This place has a beautiful dining area, and it’s located in a very convenient place. I have ordered out, I have also dined in, and the one thing that I can say for sure is that no matter what you decide to do, you will be very happy with the quality of the food, and the fact that their staff is incredibly helpful and courteous. Every single time I have eaten in this place it has always been clean and a good time I highly recommend this place.
They cut the pies into six slices so they are particularly large slices when you order by slice. Quick service. Spacious and clean eating area. Not sure if there is card minimum but they took my card when my margherita and Buffalo chicken slice with bottled Coke came out to $11.30
THIS IS THE BEST PIZZA PLACE IVE EVER BEEN TOO! I am from NJ but my mom is from Long Island so every time I go to visit my granny I have to get two brothers pizza. In my opinion the Sicilian there is the best! I am young and picky about my pizza so me saying this is the best is worth a lot. Sometimes when we leave Long Island we stop by two brothers to bring a pie home to put in the fridge to heat up for later! I have never had a bad experience here.
This is one of the oddest pizza joints Ive ever seen. I ordered a slice and 2 rice balls. The girl behind the counter went to put the rice balls in the microwave and when I asked her not to, she made a face like I had just asked her to cut a finger off. What pizza place microwaves food when there is an array of pizza ovens right next to you?! The sauce was very salty and the pizza was cold. I work all over Long Island. Ive been to more pizza places than I care to admit. This place definitely IS NOT a 4.x star shop. After reading some of the other comments here about staff issues, I think the owner needs to train their staff better, stop hiring teens that only seem to care about a pay check, or both.
Pizza to my liking!! Im a lifetime NYC pizza eater and have been looking for pizza in Nassau that meets the flavor profile I like in pizzas. I had my first pizza from Two Brothers tonight, and it fit the bill. Looking forward to having more. Workers were friendly. The restaurant is nice and clean. Pizza oven area is bright. Parking is ample.
This isnt just a pizza joint! There is a lot to choose from down to deserts and alcohol. Food is tasty, decor is nice, service was good for when we went. It was obviously slow but food came out right away. I liked that they told us ahead of time it would take ~15 mins for a fresh pie. We were hangry and ordered individual slices instead. Which equated to about a whole pie.
This place is everything youd expect from a neighborhood pizza place. Everything is good, personally I think the pasta dishes are a little better than the pizza.Its not the best pizza Ive ever had in my life but it is the place I go in the neighborhood when I feel like pizza. My only complaint is that its a little on the pricier side, but its not outrageous.
I got a regular pie with extra cheese and 6 mozzarella sticks and it came out to 33 dollars, ok that’s overpriced for the quality of food they gave me. Mozzarella sticks were undercooked and weren’t even that good. It was like they rolled a string cheese in breading and put it In the microwave for 16 seconds and said here ya go sir. Pizza was a salty undercooked mess. I don’t get why so many people go here that they got to build a new place does anyone realize there is so many places a mile or less that is so much better than this place? Calda blows the doors off this place. Probably giving the rest of the pizza to my dog really tasted like cardboard not even exaggerating.
The focaccia bread here is the BEST focaccia bread I’ve had at any restaurant. Sometimes my son specifically asks me to go here just to pick up that bread for him. I love the cheese pizza though, along with my husband. We find ourselves coming here several times per week.
Food was great but I need to complain about the service. If the service was close to acceptable I would have given a 5 star. It was not busy when I ordered and I still waited while a blonde with a tattoo on her right forearm sat there flirting which I didnt mind but she gave me attitude firstly I guess because I interrupted her. She then proceeded to put the pizza in the oven while they made a hero. The pizza ended up burnt and COLD by the time I got it. And I waited for the hero which sat waiting for 4 minutes before she gave it to me. On top of that she tried to give me warm soda and when I asked for a cold one I got attitude. I dont usually do this but she deserves to be reprimanded it made me want to get her fired. Do your job leave your personal life at home.
I overheard one of the waiters talking to the owners saying something EXTREAMLY Racist about an Asian Family eating dinner.(Something about how he hates Dealing white Chinese customers and other things) I had already paid for my Pizza Pie or else I would’ve walked out . . . I will NOT be going back to this organization!
Idk, Ive been living in the area for over 7yrs, found this place around the corner and thought great - love bagels on the weekend - but everytime I go there its a bad experience. Theres always a rediculous wait - seems oddly coincident that they never have bagels I want (egg, poppy, specialty) cause they fail to properly predict the demand... Today I walked out because again, no egg & no cin-raisin... Last time, the bagels were hard and over cooked (funny cause I had to get plain cause they didnt have egg that time either) time before, same thing... Never warm, always hard outside and frankly, I cant even say I remember the flavor even being any good... Honestly, just frustrating... I want to like this place but its just not happening for me...
I like Two Brothers Pizza, but where are the spicy entrees n coal fired pizza with spicy salsiccia piccante? theres nothing spicy on the menu, thats whats making this a 4 Not 5 for me and my family. The gelato is over priced for what you get. Did I hear Italian pop music playing in the background? -- thats a plus! Lets keep the Italian in pizzeria.
I have lived near 2 brothers for past 10 yrs, it used to be fantastic despite they do not deliver. In the past 1-2years it has gone so downhill, its such a shame. You are told your order will be ready in 15-20 min and your order is never ready despite there was no one in there, the order is wrong so they have to remake it while the rest of your order is sitting on top of ovens, When you ask for a calzone well done...it never is. Or the chix roll is burned with hardly any chix in it....all bread. The pizzas are mediocre, used to be delicious. The kids that are behind the counter sometimes are cluless. It is really a shame because it is so close but I will never order from there again and we used to order a huge order....like at least over $30.00 and up. The only thing that is still just ok is their meatball parm heros.The owner should really take note of this!!!
OMGOSH, this is my go to place if you want the best pizza in Town, especially there salad slices and Brushetta !!! I cant say enough good things about Two Brothers Restaurant. From their food to their staff they are 100% amazing !!! The only thing missing is that they dont deliver...WHY??
Total reviews rating 4.4
199 Reviews for Two Brothers Pizza & Pasta Restaurant 2023:
Review №1
2022-02-13We was very excited to hunt something thing different than our usual places for Italian restaurant we been all amazing place in Long Island from east meadow to copique to east you name it finally we end up today Two brothers from all the out east first off No customer service like any restaurant.Waitstaff only one guy serving few tables all alone.Food not one expect.Poorest service ever. god bless two brothers and my best wishes are grow up like anything but customer service means a lots!!!!!Beautiful restaurant but.Good luck
Review №2
2022-01-21Great pizza when its actually cooked properly, just dont understand why every single girl that works there has a b*tch of an attitude. Theres one girl with black hair, short and quiet that Ive never had a problem with and it the only one Ill tip.
Review №3
2022-01-29Excellent pizza, heros and entrees. The service is very good as well. My favorite is the Sicilian pizza and chicken parm hero.
Review №4
2022-02-13Super friendly staff, delicious food and spacious dining area. We order delivery all the time but decided to stop in for dinner. Their bread basket consisted of a soft garlic and tomato on top a lightly toasted bottom bread (my favorite), adults shared a brick oven buffalo chicken pizza, salad and kids had mozzarella sticks and two slices. We all left super satisfied.
Review №5
2022-05-23My friend lives in senior housing a few blocks away and thats how I was introduced to it. I have been hoping here for several years, w friends and on my own. The place is bigger inside than out, and there are many tables for customers. The food has great flavor. There is a woman server there that is so polite and friendly. She acts as server at times when it is a serve yourself.There are many seniors who visit there.Also I enjoy the old supermarket there, Key Food. I enjoy goingthere for cases of water, that are very reasonable priced and miscellaneous items.
Review №6
2022-07-10This place used to be absolutely fantastic before they moved, before the pandemic, it used to be an incredible place to grab a pie after the baseball game. Im not sure what changed internally with the business but externally it looks like its being milked for every penny before they close up shop. The product is no longer worth the price and the staff seems to be giving up, likely a reflection of management. Regardless, whatevers going on, I wish you guys well but 15+ years customer here and its no longer what this place once was.
Review №7
2022-05-22I ordered a slice of cake. They sent me a paper thick slice. I know inflation affects us all, but this is ridiculous.
Review №8
2022-05-19Okay so second time I am trying 2 brothers. First time really not good. Second time well not good at all. I asked for 2 slices and a ch8cken and three knots. Everything was given quickly and I was impressed. I asked if the slices were hot and the girl behind the counter said the pie was pretty fresh. Please take not I got the chicken roll for later so that didnt have to be prepped. The cold knots I will let slide . However the pizza which I was having at that moment was said to be fresh after I asked if the slices where hot. I should have check further into it cause they were cold too. So how did the pizza taste. Not really good at all I dont know how they maintain 4.4 stars the pizza is horrid. Dont with this place.
Review №9
2022-05-15The food, especially the sauce is exactly as I remember it 20 years ago. Amazing to be so consistent after all this time, really incredible! Thank you for so many years of wonderful food!
Review №10
2022-03-01Ever since the Internet began, we have all become accustomed to individuals posting phony reviews for whatever reason. It’s quite easy to determine which ones are phony because of the bad grammar, the making a big deal over very minor issues, the recounting of things that occurred that sound like they came out of Alice In Wonderland, etc.But the phony reviews here win the prize for the stupidest ones I’ve ever seen. Anyone who has actually used Two Brothers knows how unlikely to be true what’s written in these insulting postsCouldn’t those of you who I’m speaking about even use a dictionary, spell check, or make any effort to invent a plausible lie that at least would sound like it might be true ?I and my family have patronized Two Brothers for decades and neither myself or anyone with me had any of the experiences that you babble aboutThe food is always good, service is quick and friendly, my takeout always arrives steaming hot, and they’re always willing to accept requests as to the food preparationMy personal favorites are the sausage and pepper heroes and the Sicilian piesTo the objects of my little rant here :Get A Life