Umbertos Pizzeria in Huntington
Categories
Location on the map
Huntington, Suffolk County, New York, US
Site: https://www.umbertoshuntington.com/
- Monday:11AM–9PM
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–9:30PM
- Saturday:11AM–9:30PM
- Sunday:11AM–9PM
Umbertos Pizzeria in other cities:
Excellent food. Delicious pizza and pasta dishes. Accuracy of your order is come and go, depending on whether manager is on top of things, especially double-checking take-out orders. But when they get everything right, the food is superb.Update: errors on my delivery orders at least three times now. Manager is not on top of delivery orders...and counter guy does not follow directions on orders properly to give to chefs. Sometimes no manager is on-site at all, after calls in to complain. Reducing review down to 3 stars until operation at this restaurant is improved back up to previous standards.
Insanely fresh, authentic Italian at VERY reasonable prices. Such great classics offered. The small salad was so great I wished Id gotten the large. Salad had a few fantastic olives and the creamy balsamic dressing was heavenly. As we dined, I noticed many locals carrying takeout orders of many pizza pies and pasta dinners. I see why. This place is amazing. Great service, too. The bread they brought out to start with was fresh, hot, perfect. We had the chicken parm hero and the ziti eggplant siciliana. Both were delicious and both were such huge portions we each had doggie bags.
I ordered a Sicilian pie to go. the crust was raw, it didnt have enough cheese on it and it was definitely under cooked.They should train the staff better I couldnt communicate with them because they didnt speak english and didnt seem concerned.I would pass on the Sicilian pie if you thinking about going in there
Eh, I had high hopes thanks to the legends you hear about how good their food is, and all I was given was really lacklustre food at best. Beyond bland tasting for any of the slices that I ordered. If you want good pizza in the area, drive the extra 3 miles down to Huntington village and hit up portofino or rosas. Soooooooo much better. The best that I can say about this place, its food and it will not make you gag or ill. Just make you wish that you went elsewhere for better za
Im from New Jersey and was in Huntington visiting a friend so we stopped by to try this place. The cheese pizza we had was SO TASTY. Ive got to say I would definitely consider moving to NY after trying this pizzeria. The staff was really friendly and our pizza was hot and ready quickly. The cheese, the sauce and the texture of each slice was perfection. I will definitely be back. Even if I have to drive 2 hours to get here. Keep it up, Umbertos!
Been to plenty Umberto pizzerias and this has to be the worst one. Ordered a Buffalo chicken slice and regular slice. Regular slice was very thin and pretty much fell apart as I picked it up. Smh. Buffalo chicken slice was square and didn’t taste like Buffalo chicken at all, tasted like alla vodka. Staff seemed like they didn’t care or want to speak to you, I asked the guy behind the counter if he gave me the right slice and he said yes it’s a Buffalo chicken... I had to get hot sauce to pour on it. Gave it the two stars because seating was nice. That’s it. Go to the other umbertos, not coming here again.
UPDATE. Ordered for labor day weekend. 2) 3 ft heroes. The Italian hero was very good. The grilled chicken with roasted peppers and mozzarella not so much.. the grilled chicken hero was missing the mozzarella. I Called and they brought me some but the chicken and the roasted peppers had a weird taste. Like what youd think lighter fluid would taste like. No one would eat it.Ordered 2 half pans of pasta on the $29 special. The baked ziti was not worth it. The pan was only half full of pasta and hardly any ricotta cheese or mozzarella. I almost didnt have enough food. Very disappointing especially since it doesnt cost much to make. Will not order it again. The spaghetti and meatballs was better. The garlic knots were tough and no garlic flavor. Last week I ordered a half pan of Chicken Tuscano. It was very good. Im on the fence about ordering there again.
The Pizza was very tasty but the Cold Antipasta was poor mostly lettuce small amount of peppers ,olives ,tomatoes and the meat and cheese was very skimpy we had to request more meat and cheese. We told the waitress that it was not up to standards. We go there frequently and we have had better quality before than we did this trip
I had the greatest experience at the Huntington location here on a Thursday Night. The manager Antonio and the waitress Karen went out of their way to make my group comfortable. They managed to accommodate 8 people even though most tables were empty. They honestly made my night. 100/10 !
Food always excellent but take out service was poor. Kid at register was not sharp. I think the staff lost my phone order as it took a very long time for my dinner to come out of kitchen. It was not super busy and at least 5 others were served before me and I was promised dinner ready in 20 minutes. It was close to 50 minutes actually. To make matters worse they left out the bread.
I stopped by here last weekend on a friends recommendation after a trip to the pumpkin farm. The pizza here was really good. I’m not a big pizza fan but I had 3 slices. The grandma pizza and the margarita pizza was really good. Highly recommended place. Please visit if you’re in the area and hungry.
Easy to see right off of Jericho Turnpike servicing West Hills and the adjoining areas of Suffolk County. Small parking lot. Moderately clean facilities. Public Restroom. Reasonably priced. Credit cards accepted. Nice staff. We will most likely be going back. Great Sicilian Pizza. Give it a try and you decide.
This is our go-to for italian food in the Huntington area..... we live in Greenlawn, but this is always worth the drive. Takeout is good, but the food tastes better when eaten at their tables.... we always tell company to meet us there and it never disappoints. Their lasagna is to DIE FOR!! Waitresses awesome, takeout workers friendly, portions HUGE and delicious.... what more could you ask for!!
Not like me to write reviews online but after last night i had to. place was packed the whole time we were there but staff accomodated us pretty quick. waitresses and staff were all so nice to wife and i and food was really good. wife had baked ziti and i had a hero. huge portions we both finished. our waitress gave us mini cannolis and we didnt have room but we ate them anyway and they were the best cannolis ive ever had. i can see why the place was so busy. well definitely be back
Pizza is good, not great, by NYC standards. Prices on the expensive side, again compared to Manhattan. The biggest issue I have with this place is they don’t wear gloves during the pandemic, despite having them right in front of their noses. When I called it out, they became defensive and talked gibberish. This is inexcusable. I’m a medical doctor.
When I first moved to Huntington I fell in love with this location. As time went on it went down hill. It caused me to inquire and I was told they had a change in staff. None of the dishes are consistent in how they are made. The deliverys are always screwed up. And the pizza is inconsistent too. I hope another change is in store as I love the sauce there.
I been going there for so long in New Hyde Park. And when they open in Huntington, I was so Happy! But today is a big disappointment! And the guy in the register try to lie and tell me that the pizza he gave me was a brick stone oven pizza. I live in Italy for 3 yrs in Sicily and I always order brick oven. And the fact I saw that the pie came from the regular oven. I paid $30. That’s a rip off. I try to tell me that’s only the name. That’s it ! That’s the last time I gonna but from the branch!!
Definitely a bad experience. The waitress was overwhelmed, despite the fact that she told another table that she sent home the other server because she could handle the whole restaurant herself... Except she couldnt. She forgot to bring multiple items including waters for quite some time. Disappeared behind her station to have a chat with every other employee possible. The kitchen ran out of bread while we were there and didnt have any fresh cheese. The pasta dishes we ordered were two drastically different sauces on the menu yet looked and tasted exactly the same upon arrival. There was spaghetti mixed into my penne leading me to question the cleanliness of the kitchen and I wish that I had noticed it earlier. One dish was so oily it was inedible. The caprese starter was served with a balsamic emulsion instead of plain balsamic and had roasted red peppers all over it instead of the correct number of tomatoes to go with the slices of mozzarella. It was almost as though they were out of those too. One family sitting behind us had half their meal entirely forgotten for over 45 minutes. Will not go back. What a train wreck.
Chicken cutlet on the chicken parm hero was thing and dry, barley any sauce. Buffalo chicken slice had zero spice to it. Grandma slice had barley any sauce on it was all crust. Garlic knots were just doused in oil. Will say I’m very disappointed and I will not be going back
Called in my order, showed up 5 mins later, sat there for 5 mins with nobody on line in front of the counter with the counter people just glancing at me... was finally asked if i needed help and i said i called in an order 10 mins ago. He then rushed the slices into the oven. Why did i bother calling in my order to save time. pizza is good though, only reason for 3 stars.
This restaurant is affiliated (same owner) with Mama Sbarros in Deer Park (where we eat -- no exaggeration -- 5-6 times per week).We decided to stop in because one of our favorite waitresses (Maria) is now working at this location.Its a little smaller than Mamas in Deer Park but decorated very nicely. It was a warm/cozy feeling about it.Pleasant atmosphere. Nicely decorated. Very clean.Now ... the Manager on Duty (Patrick) is a friend of mine so he made me a special dish. Although it doesnt have an actual name I can tell you that it consisted of gemelli pasta, vegetables (carrots, red and green peppers, spinach), and grilled chicken in a light sauce (sort of a garlic and oil with a touch of tomato and a touch of pesto).It was not good ... it was GREAT!! Seriously. One of the best pasta dishes Ive ever had.Of course the service was excellent!! Maria is exceptionally friendly and attentive.We didnt have room for dessert -- but Im sure a cappuccino and a freshly-filled canola would have hit the spot!If youre in the area (Huntington, Huntington Station, Melville, Syosset, Woodbury) and you want some really good pizza or pasta, be sure to visit Umbertos!!If Patrick is there, ask him to surprise you!! :-)
Very disappointed! I had always enjoyed Umbertos, they had been my favorite Italian restaurant for many many years. A few weeks back I ordered food and noticed their portions had become smaller. I thought it was a fluke thing. Today I ordered again and yet again the portions are still smaller but they also screwed up my order. I called to let them know but I didnt want to wait another hour for delivery again so I proceeded to just deal with it. Unfortunately though the chicken was very dry even though it was swimming in sauce. Sorry Umbertos but thats it for my family! Maybe hire another chef?
So sorry Umberto’s but I’ve been a customer for a long time & something has changed! I ordered eggplant parm tonight & received pieces of breaded eggplant on top of linguini with red sauce topped with mozzarella! Eggplant parm is a separate dish layered with eggplant & cheese baked in the oven with several cheeses. If you are going to cook Italian on LI you have to do better with your recipes. Please take pride in your cooking!
Beware those with Celiac or GF needs from sensitivities. They dont take Gluten Free Needs seriously even though every time, they go out of their way to say they do.Great food so this is a shame. I waited for a personal GF pie which was taken out by the same metal server that was used on regular pies and then witnessed my GF pie being cut by main roller used on all regular pies as well.When I called this to the gentleman she attention,I was still charged full price and given an attitude.Having celiac is hard enough, people really need to take this illness seriously. Ive been getting sick, and now I finally know why...
Placed simple order 1 pie 1/2 tray of manicotti an 12 garlic knots an large soda so pie is overcooked I can live with that but instead of the manicotti I get a half tray of ziti that was horrible called them at umbertos an was told it was the same price an there was no effort to make it right said that’s ziti was on order ticket double checked my order an I did order the manicotti an by the way garlic knots with no garlic an burnt well at least they got the soda right it will be awhile till I order thru site an or dine there againUpdated review must say after posting the above review There Manger Shawn call an offered to make it right was very impressed on how well he handled the situation an his mannerism In handling it
I ordered online on Valentine’s Day for my kids. Email confirmed delivery in 45 min. Over two hours later still no pizza. They claim online system isn’t theirs but it’s on their website! I waited 20 minutes on hold to sort it out only to be hung up on. Do NOT order from here! It’s a disaster.
The place was not busy tonight but the service was so bad , we had to wait about 30 minutes to set after she set two customers a had of us came after us every thing we did order was wrong and the waitress seam she did not like us at all and tried very hard to make sure we will not come back to this place again .This place only for certain group of people any ones not look the same as them get tread bad so not to come again .I wish I can give them less than one star
On Friday at 12:45pm on July 27 2012 we went for lunch at Umbertos Res. Jericho Tpke - (The NY Giants oder pizza there for the Super Ball) well hear this - I didnt believed my eyes - we were 20 persons - in the meddle of our meal a member of the family was not feeling well - we call the Hospital - the Police and Drs. were at the Res. in 4mm - Thank God took him away to the Hospital/OR - we stop eating - i ask for the bill - they charge us the full amount - FINE BUT ! - sorry one person did not eat his food he went to the Hospital - i ask to talk to the manger please - came back and said to bad his dish is here for you to take home - WE DID NOT TAKE THE FOOD HOME - i been in customer services for 40 years - NYC - i can not said more about Umbertos -
After watching the blonde pizza girl touch all the garlic knots with her bare hands after collecting money I should have left but I didnt because I was hungry good mozzarella things was gross and so was pizza I used to love this place and lately it sucks will not ever be going there again
The service was slow I did not like the house salad loaded what up with peppers and onions and everything else they said well thats the house salad well okay they didnt take it back my eggplant Parmesan was black burnt Ive lived in this town for 25 years I used to like Umbertos but now its really going downhill make that a zero not a one
Total reviews rating 4.3
199 Reviews for Umbertos Pizzeria 2023:
Review №1
2022-06-01We ordered Umbertos trays of pasta, eggplant Parm, sausage, meatballs, chicken Francese and Caesar salad for a birthday party. it was great! Everything was delicious and hot when delivered. They included all the utensils, ton of plates (and not the thin paper ones but durable ones), and napkins. And even though we had our own, it still was very handy to have. On the side note, we have gotten pizza with garlic knots on numerous occasions before, and they were really really good. Highly recommend them!
Review №2
2022-06-09Of all the Umberto on long island this is the best of them. I drive occasionally way out of my way to go here. I used to live close but now I drive 30 minutes to get a good pie.They are clean and just top notch all around.
Review №3
2022-06-09Ordered cauliflower margherita pizza, it was delicious. Delivery service was even a bit earlier than expected. Well recommend
Review №4
2021-10-10Absolutely excellent pizza, so flavorful and the best crust I have ever tasted. Was immediately greeted by a very pleasant young man today. He was friendly and professional. I ordered a pepperoni slice and a grandma slice and they were DELICIOUS !! This place had a huge variety of pizzas it was very clean, which has is always important and now more then ever during these crazy times. I 100% recommend this place.
Review №5
2022-02-28Great food, great and fast service, nice atmosphere for a pizza place. A bit on the expensive side.Eggplant parmigiana is very good. Try it.
Review №6
2022-01-08Gave me wrong order. Tried calling to fix my order but they didn’t want to do anything about it…. I called at least three times and they hung up the first two times, and left me on hold for the third time. The owner needs to know who to hire. Employees were rude and manager also hanged up. Been a customer for years but this was unacceptable. Never going to buy from here again…. 1-7-22- Today (1-8-22) the ACTUAL manager called to apologize for what had happened yesterday. He said he was very sorry for the inconvenience and would do all possible to fix this from happening again. He understood the assignment and apologized (and it wasn’t even his fault)…. He wasn’t there yesterday so the employees never actually passed me the manager. I am grateful for the generosity of the manager. Thank you verymuch
Review №7
2018-10-15Great ‘real’ New York pizza! By the slice or whole pie and sooooo delish!!! Did we mention dessert was good too.
Review №8
2021-10-25Great local pizzeria with a wide variety of traditional and grandma pizzas. Staff is always really polite and accommodating . The place is great for wother takeout or dining in. They remember their regulars and make sure they are taken care of. Go there before closing and theyll throw in some extra garlic knots if you’re lucky!
Review №9
2021-12-19Umbertos has amazing Food, They have an amazing team. The Assistant Manager Siavash took the time today to help me provide a gift of Food to the team that cares for my mom. Siavash helped me create a menu that they would all enjoy. Thank you Siavash for helping me to deliver a special Christmas to my mothers Rehabilitation Facility
Review №10
2021-12-10The pizza in all their varieties are always excellent and consistent. Quality products produce quality food. Dine in menu is also excellent. Friendly serv6and always clean.