Outdoor seating
Yes
Zegarellis Restaurant Bar Pizza & Catering in Brewster
Categories
Location on the map
Brewster, Putnam County, New York, US
Service options
Kerbside pickup
Yes
No-contact delivery
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff get temperature checks
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fireplace
Yes
Great coffee
Yes
Great dessert
Yes
Live music
Yes
Sport
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Cocktails
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Happy-hour drinks
Yes
Happy-hour food
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Spirits
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Bar on site
Yes
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Groups
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 845-278-7174
Site: https://zegarellis.com/
Site: https://zegarellis.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:12–9PM
- Wednesday:12–9PM
- Thursday:12–9PM
- Friday:12–10PM
- Saturday:12–10PM
- Sunday:12–9PM
Comments (125)
Great pizza! Love the variety of specialty slices!
I’ve VERY frequently ordered food, drank and ate at this establishment, consistently supporting this business even though there are much better Italian restaurants in the area. The quality of the food varies each time, but if there’s one thing that is always consistent is the shortness and rudeness of the owners wife. HER customer service is below satisfactory. God forbid a customer has a question about what comes on a sandwich, but change your mind because you decide maybe something else would be better... you may just get a nasty response such as “oh my god!” I’ve worked in customer service and in the restaurant industry all my life and NEVER have I once reacted to a question in this manner. Zegarellis, you should be grateful for the people who are still ordering from your place in this time, not treating them as if they are a nuisance to you. I feel sorry for your employees, they deserve better employers. You officially lost ANOTHER consistent customer. Will not be back.
Great atmosphere! Great service! Great food...
This place has an amazingly friendly staff. They also have fantastic specialty pizzas. However the personal pies are a little large for my taste, they probably run about 10 to 12 inches across. The food is good and the beer selection is nice. You can always find one or two craft brews on tap. Overall, this is a good pizza place with a great neighborhood vibe.
Friendly. Good food. Reasonably priced. Their calzone is amazing.
Nice bar, good food but way, way too much sauce on both pasta and chicken parm..... oof.
Yummy food, good prices, friendly staff... Neat little local place, full of personality inside and out. We ate in this time, but have also picked up pizza, and the bar looks nice.
The best pizza ! Very reasonably priced. Beautiful grounds, spacious inside and awesome music. You got to try their Buffalo Ranch pizza. Youll love it.Very personable owner.
I love pizza and its always great to eat it, especially at Zegarellis. There is such a friendly staff whether its a familiar server or a new one, they always stay professional and hospitable. After 4 years at their new location, their service is still just as humble as ever. This will always be my go to place for pizza, wedges, appetizers or a drink to cap off my night!!
The food was, as it always is, excellent. Service was good, personable without being obtrusive. The specials menu was loaded with seasonal choices (tonight featured pumpkin chili soup, pumpkin ravioli and a salad with pepitas and cranberries). Everything we had was delicious.
This is a nice little place to dine. Been there several times and plan on going back in the future. Never had their pizza but the food is wonderful. Id recommend it.
Weekly specials are our favorite ! Friendly staff and love the atmosphere. Fair prices and great portions . Always a hit !
Casual place with a wide menu of very good Italian food. It can be noisy with a full room but its a family run business that will work to make sure you have a good experience. There is a dining room as well as a separate bar area (that you can also get food at). Very limited beer and wine menu but thats not why youre going there.
Been a customer for many years, even when they were across the street in the smaller location. Food and service has always been great.My only critique is that the parking lot is gravel, not paved, which could make it difficult for disabled or elderly people.
Zegarellis has been my favorite pizza place for about the past 15 years. Since I could ride a bike I was getting slices at their original location across the street from the current spot. I have never been disappointed. My favorite pizza is a shrimp and clam with a red sauce but any of theirs pies are some of the best pizza I have ever had. Other things on the menu are also great but I find the pizza so mouth watering that I rarely deviate to the rest of the menu. The famous New Haven pizza joints dont even come close to Zegarellis in my opinion. I look forward to getting a pie whenever Im heading back to the area.
Ive given this place numerous screw ups before writing a review due to the fact that I liked the owner but im just about done with these people. Beware of your online orders, you will order food like every other website. Except they will charge your card more money after the point of sale. I recieved an email from my bank stating that they took an additional 20.00 after my order was placed. Once I questioned it, I was given the run around as to why i just paid 60.00 for a pasta dish and some garlic bread. The prices are already crazy expensive. Also thats called theft when you charge someones account without their approval. If my bank hadnt sent the email it would never had been mentioned. Tonight I placed an order, it was confirmed to be picked up at 5:59 pm. I got there at exactly 5:59 pm. And there was no order to be picked up. They didnt see it. And blamed it on the website company. I called the online company and zegs clearly got the order.. so zegs, thanks for ruining my sunday night dinner. Along with other screw ups on orders and billing ive had it. The food is a 7 out of 10. And not worth the b.s.. the attitude from the staff is uncalled for. I was given an attitude because they screwed up my order. Get it together.
Placed an order over the phone got a calzone and a burger with fresh mozzarella cheese and when I pulled the bun off the burger there was a 2x4 melted piece of Saran Wrap. Called the restaurant to see if they would fix their mistake and I would go get the new one. Who ever answered was the rudest person ever. Said they would remake it so I went back. Found out the owner was the one who answered the call swore at me because he said it wasn’t his fault and he’s not responsible. It was his meat guys fault. And that I should call them. Never going back. I could have forgot about the Saran Wrap things happen I have worked in a kitchen but take responsibility for your employees mistakes and don’t be rude!
Company gathered for drinks and dinnerGreat bartender made a perfect mule. Appetizers were great. Buffet was very nice. Bathroom was spotless. Bus girl was cute and pleasant.
The 4 adults in my group were very pleased with the drinjs, appetizers, entrées, desserts, and service. The food was delicious and our server was friendly. Well definitely be going back to Zegarellis.
Mainstay of local restaurants. Consistent, quality food preparation. Excellent, quality pizza and entrees. Gluten free options are also available. Great parking access.
Nice place... Have driven past it many times... So glad we stopped... We will be back. Good food and service. Simple wine list with decent selections at reasonable prices.
We have been enjoying Zegarellis for years. And I am a tomato soup fan, so to say that i just had the best bowl of tomato soup is honestly a RAVE. Better than I have made. Then again, everything we have ever ordered here has been consistently delish!
New location as of 2013. Ample parking, larger sit down area. In fact, you sit outside during warm weather. New Bar/Grill area in front... with nice large screen TV. Like their Hawaiian pizza and they ranch dressing slices.
Manager/owner kept glaring at our table through the service window. Food and server were great but the higher ups made it a very uncomfortable experience.
Decent restaurant. Felt clean. Unfortunately we found a fly in our pizza. Maybe it was a one time occurrence. Therefore I will not post a pic. Prices are on the higher side.
I have frequented this establishment for many years and will always make a stop whenever Im back in town... I live about an hour away but come to the area often. The Zegarelli special wedge is always a favorite but Im yet to find one dish I dont like from these guys! Joe is the best!!!
Nice cozy place great service great food in the middle in the middle of Brewster
Met friends for lunch and drinks. Ate outside on a beautiful day. Food was all good including dessert.
Zegarellis is the best in this area. Food is plentiful and prices are very reasonable. Bobby the bar tender works Tuesdays through Fridays and is always quick to see if you need a refill and offer you the latest house special that Angelo and Joe create in the BOH.Worth the trip ..
Delicious food!! Great bar and dining room. Friendly staff and specials are great every week !
Ordered take out. The food was hot and delicious. Staff was friendly. I would definitely recommend this restaurant.
The make the best salad pizza anywhere. The bar is fully loaded as well. Love eating and drinking there.
Best food and nicest people. I used to live close by them but now I moved 30 min away but I still order from them. Thank you
Good pizza and salad.
Food would be a lot better if management wasn’t so terrible. Lazy manager.
Great food! Great drinks! Very clean and a very great staff. Always on top of everything. Zegarellis never disappoints.
Nice happy hour
Great place! Food & atmosphere both fantastic
Great food friendly atmosphere and courteous staff.
Havent been here in awhile, so was pleasantly surprised by outdoor seating, lively crowd, and diverse menu.
This place has great food and drinks the owners and staff are top notch check this place out you won’t be disappointed this is ur local CHEERS
Lovely dinners several times. Great service, pretty & intimate dining room, food was out of this world!
Great place to eat the wait staff is great and the bartender is the best in the area he can make a great drink
Delicious food, clean modern dining room, waitstaff were so nice!
Food pretty good. Quality of meats are very low. Otherwise clean and enjoyable place
Food literally made us sick and owner couldnt care less. We go out of our way, twice as far just to avoid eating here!
Great quality take out food. My go to when I do want to cook. A local who is grateful Zegarellis is there
I have never had a bad meal here. There pizza is top notch
A great local place in Putnam lake, Patterson NY. Good food and a fair price. Always friendly staff and the food is good. I recommend this place
Great food service and atmosphere with fantastic people
Very convenient, great for pizza but pickup only. Havent eaten in but once years ago.
The food is very delicious and you guys have great service
Joe was very nice to my friend and I. The pepperoni pizza was my favorite!
Pizza is very good. Sandwiches are very good too.
Love it
Wish I knew it was here years ago. Excellent staff and great foodTry it out!
Great pizza. Had spaghetti and shells and all good.
Always good Italian food. Pizzas very good. Clans Bianco a favorite.
The place is local hangout. Great bar and great food. Try the steak sandwich
Very friendly atmosphere nice bar
Always a good time. Great food & waitstaff and friendly clientele.
The new place looks great and the food is never a disappointment its a must go to place.
The food here has gotten better and better over the decades. Friendly staff too.
My favorite restaurant. Best food anywhere
Go to pizza place. Cozy bar with limited tap selection but they try.
The food was terrific, and the service was great.
Nice local restaurant with good food and friendly service
Great food, good drinks, and awesome people!
Great food. Clams Casino white is amazing!
Great pizza place to get a slice and a beer.
The best pizza I have ever eaten!!!wow!
Not much I liked here, from the food to the service.
Fryed pickles were good waiter was nice
Poor service waiting 15 minutes for service with a empty house. Order drinks got no refills 😔
Best food and staff in the area!
Nice family restaurant with delicious food.
Pizza was dry with almost zero sauce!
Food is authentic and full of flavor.
Great food and great people.
Good good. Restaurant a bit small.
Best pizza of all time.
Great Italian food with a countrified flare
Good food prices o.k.
Love their pizza and bar
Great place for a quick bite!
Good pasta, friendly staff.
Great place, environment and food
Delicious food.
Sausage Parm was good.
2nd time and lovin it still. :)
Joe is a great bartender
Good food
Excellent food and service
Great food
Good food
Good subs
Good happy hour
Very good as usual.
Good pizza!!!
Excellent as always!
Needs another try...
Excellent food
The best pizza
Great
Angelo is the best
Good pizza
Best place around!!!!!
Amazing food
Delicious 🍕
Best in town
Great place
I like it because they prepare very good drinks
Good will
Nll
Dxzs
Total reviews rating 4.4
125 Reviews for Zegarellis Restaurant Bar Pizza & Catering 2023:
Review №1
2022-02-25I simply love this cozy bar/restaurant, plenty of parking on the side and front of the restaurant, additional parking across the street, food is definitely delicious. If you like your dish spicy like me, make sure you let them know.
Review №2
2022-03-16My wife and I went there today for an early dinner. Best Italian food I have had in a long time. The sauces in our meals where sensational. The owner Angelo came to our table for a small chat. Very friendly and personal. Made us feel like family. We will definitely be going back for some more great food.If you want a great Italian meal you have to check out Zegarelli’s,
Review №3
2021-11-10Great local restaurant to enjoy some quality food and drinks. Friendly attentive staff contribute to your enjoyment! Seems to be a favorite hangout for the locals. Definitely a good spot to enjoy some food & drinks....and worth a try!!
Review №4
2021-10-24Great food, service and friendly staff. Crab cakes and calamari are good appetizers. Had linguini and clam sauce, chicken san marine for main courses.
Review №5
2022-04-30I only give reviews that are positive. Great vibes in the bar area. Friendly and welcoming atmosphere means a lot. Zeg special hero is one of a kind and amazing. Scoured the earth for something similar and never happened. Peace xo
Review №6
2017-12-09Still a 5 star rating! My favorite dish is the spinach salad. Enormous enough to take some home and have for breakfast. Yes breakfast yum!!
Review №7
2021-12-17Great food, fast service and reasonable prices. We have them cater events for us too and they do a great job. Try the eggplant parm!
Review №8
2021-08-23Truly a hidden gem!If your in the greater Danbury CT, New Fairfield CT, Brewster, NY. Area You have to give the place a try.I had the Chicken Parm. My friend had the Veal Parm. Both were excellent!The desserts were awesome too.Fair prices and our server was so nice.Definitely going back soon.😊Only one negative...my bottle of beer was served with a warm beer glass not chilled.
Review №9
2021-07-07For last months.. I think the chef is not familiar with the menu, Tuesday the food doesnt taste same like others days. eggplant or chicken wegde are chopped up, the chicken francese taste horrible. its only on Tuesdays.. figure out what is going on please
Review №10
2021-03-21I had high hopes but they were dashed pretty quickly. Ordered takeout and they forgot the garlic bread. My entree had absolutely NO flavor. Oily spaghetti with not a hint of garlic or really any type of seasoning. Everything we ordered was unappetizing. Never going back